BBC's Gaza film has issues, but we should be allowed to see it
No matter how much small print is added to the contracts between broadcasters and producers, nothing works in factual programming without trust. Factual programmes throw up myriads of unforeseen problems that must be resolved between the film-makers and the broadcaster. But having resolved them and made the appropriate editorial changes, including adding missing information, these programmes were then broadcast without further issue.
Unless there is some unresolvable issue with it, Gaza – How to Survive a War Zone must be put back on BBC iPlayer, with appropriate changes, as soon as possible so we can all see it and judge it for ourselves.Peter GrimsdaleFormer commissioner, BBC and Channel 4
Last summer I was Save the Children's interim response team leader in Gaza. I watched Gaza: How to Survive a War Zone when it was still on BBC iPlayer. In many respects, it accurately portrayed what it was like to be in Gaza during active hostilities. In 20 years of humanitarian work, it was the hardest response to which I have been deployed.
The documentary centred on three children who were clearly affected by what they were experiencing, and who showed courage and resilience in the face of horror. But the film gave a misleading impression, as the situation depicted for two of them was more privileged than that of the great majority I met. It gave the impression that the lives children were facing in Gaza were better than they actually were.
The controversy around the film distracts attention from the plight of hundreds of thousands of children suffering harm in Gaza.David SkinnerSevenoaks, Kent
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
4 minutes ago
- NBC News
Columbia agrees to pay $200 million to restore funding cut by Trump administration
Columbia University will pay $200 million to the federal government to restore the majority of funding that was cut by the Trump administration over allegations it violated anti-discrimination laws. "This agreement marks an important step forward after a period of sustained federal scrutiny and institutional uncertainty," acting university President Claire Shipman said in a statement. The Trump administration in March said it was canceling $400 million in grants to the school, accusing it of 'inaction in the face of persistent harassment of Jewish students.' Columbia then agreed to a list of demands by the Trump administration, which some critics saw as a capitulation by the private university. Columbia said in the Wednesday statement that under the agreement 'a vast majority of the federal grants which were terminated or paused in March 2025 — will be reinstated and Columbia's access to billions of dollars in current and future grants will be restored.' 'This includes the reinstatement of the majority of grants previously terminated by the National Institutes of Health and the Department of Health and Human Services, renewal of non-competitive grants, the release of overdue payments on active, non-terminated grants, and Columbia's restored eligibility to apply for new federal research funding in the ordinary course,' the university said. Columbia and other universities have been targeted by the Trump administration over student protests over the war in Gaza, which some Republicans have said were antisemitic. "While Columbia does not admit to wrongdoing with this resolution agreement, the institution's leaders have recognized, repeatedly, that Jewish students and faculty have experienced painful, unacceptable incidents, and that reform was and is needed," the university said in Wednesday's statement. Columbia said the agreement will establish a "a jointly selected independent monitor who will assess the implementation of the resolution." The $200 million, termed a settlement by the university, will be paid to the government over three years. It will also pay $21 million to settle investigations by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the university said. Student protests over the war in Gaza, which Israel launched after the surprise terrorist attack by Hamas on Oct. 7, 2023, took place on college campuses across the U.S., including at Columbia. President Donald Trump campaigned on attacking those protests, and since taking office his administration has sought to deport some students who took part in pro-Palestinian demonstrations by accusing them of sympathizing with Hamas.
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
How the wife of Hamas leader 'The Butcher' fled Gaza on a fake passport after his assassination - and then remarried in Turkey
The wife of the architect of the October 7 terror attacks has been dramatically smuggled out of Gaza and is now living a new life in Turkey with a new husband, according to explosive reports from Israel. Samar Muhammad Abu Zamar, widow of Yahya Sinwar, the Hamas military commander who was killed by IDF forces in October 2024, allegedly escaped the war-torn enclave using a fake passport and carrying 'significant sums of cash'. Sources in Gaza told Israeli news site Ynet that Abu Zamar remarried in Turkey just months after Sinwar's death, in a wedding and relocation operation overseen by Hamas political bureau member Fathi Hammad, long linked to smuggling fighters and their families out of the Strip. The claims come as footage from 2024 resurfaced showing Abu Zamar walking through a Hamas tunnel just hours before the October 7 massacre - carrying what appeared to be a designer handbag. Although officially unconfirmed, the story has been widely reported in Israel. An Israeli security official told Ynet that Abu Zamar, along with Najwa Sinwar, the wife of Mohmmed Sinwar - who succeeded his brother as Hamas chief after his death - both crossed into Egypt through the Rafah crossing using forged documents. 'She's no longer here - she crossed through the Rafah border using a fake passport,' a source said of Abu Zamar, saying the escape required 'high-level coordination, logistical support, and large sums of money that regular Gazans don't have'. The revelations have sparked fresh outrage among ordinary Palestinians, many of whom remain trapped in Gaza after 19 months of relentless war, while the families of senior Hamas figures reportedly live in comfort abroad. 'They send their children to study in Turkey and Qatar – and send ours to the grave,' one Gazan civilian said. 'What makes them different from any corrupt ruler in the Arab world? They only look after themselves'. Hamas, which styles itself as the vanguard of Palestinian resistance, has long been accused of exploiting the suffering of its own people while sheltering its leadership and their families overseas. The Islamist group's military network has been shattered since the October 7 attacks, with only one senior commander, Izz al-Din al-Haddad, believed to still be alive. Abu Zamar's former husband, Yahya Sinwar, was assassinated in October last year after being hunted by intelligence services and the Israeli Defence Forces for over a year. Ultimately, his assassination was seemingly by chance, with the group of trainee soldiers responsible for the Hamas chief's death not knowing his true identity at the time, according to reports. Israeli officials have said the 61-year-old - who has long been dubbed the Butcher of Khan Younis - was killed after he emerged from the underground tunnel network where he had been hiding. A unit from the IDF's 828th Bislamach Brigade was patrolling Tal al-Sultan, an area of Rafah, when it came across a group of three Hamas fighters in the street and engaged them in a firefight. The terrorists were 'on the run' moving from house to house, the IDF said, and became split up. One of them, since identified as Sinwar, 'ran alone into one of the buildings'. He went up to the second floor, and troops responded by firing a tank shell in his direction. The unit, made up of trainee infantry commanders and reservists, then began to sweep the area, according to Israeli reports from the time. Two grenades were thrown at them, one of which exploded while the other failed to go off. The troops decided it was too dangerous to proceed and pulled back, sending in a mini drone to trace the fleeing fighter instead. Dramatic footage released by the IDF showed the bloodied Sinwar, his face concealed by a scarf, throwing a stick in a final attempt to defend himself against the drone just seconds before he was assassinated. Two 120mm tank shells slammed into the building, as well as a surface-to-surface Matador missile, with shrapnel scything across the upper floors and killing Sinwar. Unaware they had taken out Israel's prime target, the soldiers did not return to the site until the following morning, when soldiers from the 450th Infantry Battalion were sent in to get a closer look. As they inspected the dead, they realised one bore a striking resemblance to the Hamas leader. Graphic images emerged of his corpse lying on the rubble surrounded by Israeli soldiers, while close ups showed a catastrophic head wound and multiple injuries. He was found with a weapon, a flak jacket and 40,000 shekels (£8,250). 'Yahya Sinouar had a lot of cash and fake passports on him, he was ready to flee,' Israeli army spokesman Colonel Olivier Rafowicz told French outlet CNEWS. He claimed that the items Sinwar had on him, which allegedly also included a card from UNRWA, the UN aid for Palestinian refugees, 'may show that he was ready to flee and leave Gaza and his men behind.' Booby traps around the area meant the corpse had to be left in place, but part of one of his fingers was removed and sent for testing. Confirmation of his death took several hours, with multiple tests carried out, and his identity eventually confirmed with dental records and fingerprints. Four hours after it confirmed it was investigating whether the Hamas leader had been killed, the military issued a simple message on social media: 'Eliminated: Yahya Sinwar.' Pictures show Israeli troops carrying a body, believed to be Sinwar's, out of the destroyed building on a stretcher. Recently, hostage talks have stalled, reportedly due to the difficulty of even reaching Hamas's scattered leadership in Gaza. But despite occasional deadly ambushes on Israeli troops, Hamas is no longer capable of large-scale coordinated operations, analysts have said.
Reuters
34 minutes ago
- Reuters
Canada calls for immediate resumption of UN-led aid in Gaza
OTTAWA, July 23 (Reuters) - The Canadian government said on Wednesday that Israeli military operations against civilians and aid workers in Gaza were unacceptable, and called for the immediate resumption of U.N.-led aid distribution in the war-torn enclave. "Israeli military operations against WHO staff and facilities, World Food Programme aid convoys, & the ongoing killing of Palestinians seeking urgently needed food and water are unacceptable," the Canadian foreign ministry said on X. "Hunger in Gaza has reached catastrophic levels ... Canada calls for the immediate resumption at scale of UN-led aid," the ministry added.
