‘Neither central nor state forces allowed in assembly'
2
Kolkata: The advocate general, in his submission to Calcutta High Court, on Tuesday denied
BJP
's allegation of discrimination between central and state forces on the Bengal assembly precincts.
AG Kishore Datta pleaded that neither central nor state forces were allowed as security to MLAs. "However, there are some policemen deployed in the House, without arms, on the directions of the high court," Datta said.
He submitted that all other security personnel were made to wait in shelters. "The prayer made by the leader of opposition (Suvendu Adhikari) to allow central forces within the assembly precincts/House would result in an order of reverse discrimination," the AG said.
You Can Also Check:
Kolkata AQI
|
Weather in Kolkata
|
Bank Holidays in Kolkata
|
Public Holidays in Kolkata
Adhikari's counsel and BJP chief whip Jaydip Kar had earlier cited a notification issued by the assembly speaker on May 6, 2021, preventing central security forces accompanying BJP MLAs from entering the premises.
The AG urged the court of Justice Amrita Sinha to consider whether a direction to the legislature presided over by the speaker, who enjoys certain privileges and immunity under Articles 178, 194, 208, 212 and Entry 13 of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution, was preferable and how far the functions of the legislature could be brought under the purview of judicial review.
Senior counsel for Adhikari, Billwadal Bhattacharya, held that the point of the matter was whether constitutional provisions could be suspended by issuing an administrative letter from the speaker's office.
Justice Sinha adjourned the hearing till July 21.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
5 minutes ago
- Time of India
Malicious stonewalling: Randeep Surjewala slams EC over 'vote fraud' issue
Randeep Surjewala accuses the Election Commission of concealing voter fraud and offering weak excuses when confronted with evidence of manipulated voter rolls. This criticism follows the Haryana CEO's request for Rahul Gandhi to provide documentation supporting claims of electoral roll anomalies in the 2024 Haryana assembly polls. Surjewala asserts the EC is failing its duty to ensure fair elections. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Congress leader Randeep Singh Surjewala has lashed out at the Election Commission, accusing it of hiding "voter fraud" with its "lame duck excuses" when confronted with evidence of "mass manipulation" of voter remarks came after the Haryana chief electoral officer (CEO) on Saturday asked Congress leader Rahul Gandhi to furnish documents within 10 days in support of his claims about anomalies in electoral rolls in the 2024 State assembly Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha on August 7 claimed that the difference between winning and losing the Haryana elections for the Congress was 22,779 votes in the entire the EC communication to Gandhi on X, Surjewala said, "When confronted with evidence of mass manipulation of voter rolls, the Election Commission seeks to hide the 'voter fraud' with its lame duck excuses, puerile legalese and fake technicalities. No wonder that it is now named as 'Election Capture of India' - ECI."He said the "malicious stonewalling and obfuscation" of the Election Commission to address the issue of "vote theft" and hide behind excuses establishes its "fear of truth"."Not once has the ECI and BJP said that Rahul ji's assertion of vote theft is wrong," he said."The EC is not a passive clerk of electoral paperwork. It is a constitutional guardian of the level playing field and free and fair polls, the lifeblood of democracy," Surjewala said."To evade scrutiny in favour of procedural smoke screens is not neutrality. It is an abdication of duty that corrodes the very democracy it is meant to protect," Surjewala Congress leader alleged that it is nothing short of a "crime" against democracy and the Constitution and these notices will not dilute the unpardonable "sin" it is Haryana CEO's communication to Gandhi on Sunday stated, "This is to draw your kind attention to this office communication dated August 9, 2025, referring to the statements made by you during the press conference held on August 7, 2025, pertaining to the alleged inclusion of ineligible electors and exclusion of eligible electors in the electoral rolls of Haryana."Gandhi has been asked to furnish the particulars of the electors concerned, along with the "duly signed declaration/oath under Rule 20 (3) (b) of the Registration of Electors Rules, Congress leader had cited data from the 2024 Lok Sabha polls to also claim over 1 lakh votes were "stolen" through five types of manipulations in an assembly segment in Congress leaders amplifying the "vote theft" allegation of Gandhi, Election Commission officials on Saturday once again pressed the Leader of the Opposition to either sign a declaration to support his claims or apologise to the country for making "fake" charges.
Indian Express
5 minutes ago
- Indian Express
‘Vote chori' row: ‘lame duck excuses, puerile legalese', Congress hits back as Haryana CEO demands oath from Rahul Gandhi
Hours after the Haryana Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) wrote to Congress leader Rahul Gandhi Sunday regarding his allegations of the 'inclusion of ineligible voters' in the state—and requested a formal declaration under oath—Rajya Sabha MP and senior Congress leader Randeep Singh Surjewala hit back at the Election Commission of India, saying 'these notices will not dilute the unpardonable sin it is committing'. A Sreenivas, CEO, Haryana, sent the letter to Rahul Gandhi Sunday while referring to the allegations levelled by him in a press conference held on August 7. In his latest letter, the CEO said, 'It is requested that the signed declaration/oath may be returned to this office within ten (10) days, so that necessary proceedings may be initiated in accordance with the provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, and the Registration of Electoral Rules, 1960.' Tagging the CEO's letter on social media platform X, Surjewala said: 'When confronted with evidence of mass manipulation of voter rolls, the Election Commission seeks to hide the 'Voter Fraud' with its lame duck excuses, puerile legalese and fake technicalities. No wonder that it is now named as 'Election Capture of India' – ECI.' Surjewala alleged: 'The malicious stonewalling and obfuscation of Election Commission to address the issue of 'vote theft' and hide behind excuses establishes its 'fear of truth'. Not once has the ECI and BJP said that Rahul ji's assertion of vote theft is wrong.' Stating that EC 'is not a passive clerk of electoral paperwork', Surjewala said: 'It is a constitutional guardian of the level playing field and free and fair polls, the lifeblood of democracy.' 'To evade scrutiny in favour of procedural smokescreens is not neutrality. It is an abdication of duty that corrodes the very democracy it is meant to protect. It is nothing short of a crime against democracy and the Constitution and these notices will not dilute the unpardonable sin it is committing,' he added. The Haryana Assembly elections were held in October 2024, in which the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) won 48 seats while the Congress won 31 seats for the 90-member Vidhan Sabha.
The Hindu
5 minutes ago
- The Hindu
‘Voter fraud' allegations: Surjewala accuses Election Commission for ‘lame duck' excuses
Congress leader Randeep Singh Surjewala has lashed out at the Election Commission of India (ECI), accusing it of hiding "voter fraud" with its "lame duck excuses" when confronted with the evidence of "mass manipulation" of voter rolls. His remarks came after the Haryana Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) on Saturday (August 9, 2025) asked Congress leader Rahul Gandhi to furnish documents within 10 days in support of his claims about anomalies in electoral rolls in the 2024 State Assembly polls. The Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha on August 7 claimed that the difference between winning and losing the Haryana elections for the Congress was 22,779 votes in the entire State. On Election Commission fraud claims, BJP accuses Rahul Gandhi of 'selective outrage' Posting the EC communication to Mr. Gandhi on X, Mr. Surjewala said, "When confronted with evidence of mass manipulation of voter rolls, the Election Commission seeks to hide the 'voter fraud' with its lame duck excuses, puerile legalese and fake technicalities. No wonder that it is now named as 'Election Capture of India' - ECI." He said the "malicious stonewalling and obfuscation" of the Election Commission to address the issue of "vote theft" and hide behind excuses establishes its "fear of truth." "Not once has the ECI and the BJP said that Rahul ji's assertion of vote theft is wrong," he said. "The EC is not a passive clerk of electoral paperwork. It is a constitutional guardian of the level playing field and free and fair polls, the lifeblood of democracy," Mr. Surjewala said. "To evade scrutiny in favour of procedural smoke screens is not neutrality. It is an abdication of duty that corrodes the very democracy it is meant to protect," Mr. Surjewala charged. Elections stolen, alleges Rahul Gandhi; Election Commission of India demands proof 'under oath' The Congress leader alleged that it is nothing short of a "crime" against democracy and the Constitution and these notices will not dilute the unpardonable "sin" it is committing. The Haryana CEO's communication to Mr. Gandhi on Sunday (August 10, 2025) stated, "This is to draw your kind attention to this office communication dated August 9, 2025, referring to the statements made by you during the press conference held on August 7, 2025, pertaining to the alleged inclusion of ineligible electors and exclusion of eligible electors in the electoral rolls of Haryana." Mr. Gandhi has been asked to furnish the particulars of the electors concerned, along with the "duly signed declaration/oath under Rule 20(3)(b) of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. The Congress leader had cited data from the 2024 Lok Sabha polls to also claim more than one lakh votes were "stolen" through five types of manipulations in an Assembly segment in Karnataka. With Congress leaders amplifying the "vote theft" allegation of Mr. Gandhi, Election Commission officials on Saturday (August 9, 2025) once again pressed the Leader of the Opposition to either sign a declaration to support his claims or apologise to the country for making "fake" charges.
