Latest news with #FriendsofOceanBeachPark
CBS News
16-03-2025
- Politics
- CBS News
New mural vandalized day after Great Highway shut down to cars
After just one day of the Great Highway shutting down to cars, a new mural was vandalized overnight. The community group, Friends of Ocean Beach Park, and the artist say they won't let it discourage them and they will repair it. People who frequent the area, like Jim Kirk, noticed the tagging. "I actually used to go to Playland when I was a little boy," Kirk said while looking at the mural of Playland by the Sea. "It's just beautiful, she portrayed the whole thing, the cliff house, and someone came and graffitied over the whole thing." Kirk has spent his life in San Francisco, the new mural reminded him of his childhood. "Playland was where the Safeway was down there that whole thing was all Playland," Kirk said. "It was like the Santa Cruz Beach Boardwalk." It closed in 1972, but the mural brought it back to life. Kirk says he saw the artist, Emily Fromm, paint it and he was disheartened to see it had been tagged. "That's my first thought," Kirk said. "Maybe it's someone against the park but regardless it's just uncalled for." Friday was the first day a two-mile stretch of the Great Highway was closed down to cars for good. Crews have already started the transition of the space between Lincoln Avenue and Sloat Boulevard into the city's newest park. Back in November of 2024, 55% of San Franciscans voted "Yes" on Proposition K to transition the space, but many people who live nearby didn't support the proposition, including Kirk. "I'm not really for the park either myself," said Kirk. "I lived here my whole life and I like having the Great Highway to drive on. I feel like we need it for the traffic and for the emergency workers, firetrucks, ambulances, the coastguard uses it if somebody needs help out on the beach. I feel like we need the highway." Sunset Resident Seth Rosenblatt disagrees with Kirk. He still rides his bike with a sign of his support for Prop K. "People keep forgetting that although two-thirds of The Sunset voted against K that means a third of us voted for it," said Rosenblatt about the closure of the Great Highway. "This is really going to be an incredible thing, not just for recreation but people are going to come out here in a way that they haven't since we had Playland at the beach. It's going to be an economic engine that people are not expecting." Rosenblatt stopped to take a picture of the vandalism. He says it's disappointing, but he doesn't think it was in defiance of the park. "I would be surprised if it was related," said Rosenblatt. "The people who have turned their 'No on K' support into recalling Joel Engardio have been using what I call fact-free arguments but I don't think they would tag something like this." Kirk believes there should be a middle ground between having only a park, or only a highway. "My thought is that they could have both," said Kirk. "They have enough room up here where they could have two lanes of traffic and then they could create a park on the west side. I think that would be a good comprise." The organization Friends of Ocean Beach Park and the artist plan to restore the mural and put a protective coating on it so that if it gets vandalized again, it can be cleaned off more easily. "While I do not know why the mural was vandalized, since the markings were random and unspecific, it is likely tied to the conversion of the Great Highway into a park, a very divisive change which took effect the day of the defacement," Fromm said in a statement. "However, the mural is intended as a gift for the community, regardless of that change, and defacing my art has no bearing on this voter-approved measure. "
Yahoo
16-03-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
Mural ‘heavily vandalized' on Great Highway after road closure: ‘It just doesn't make sense'
SAN FRANCISCO (KRON) — A Bay Area artist who created a mural on San Francisco's Great Highway is getting support by community leaders after her artwork was 'heavily vandalized' — one day after the road was closed to cars to make way for a new oceanfront park. Thursday is last day to drive along SF's Great Highway The mural by Emily Fromm that is located at the Judah bathroom on the Great Highway was targeted by vandals Friday night (see photo below). In November, 55 percent of San Franciscans voted yes on Proposition K to permanently ban vehicles from a two-mile stretch of the coastal highway and convert it into a park. On Thursday, the road was closed to vehicles so that the area could be transformed and readied for its opening on April 12. 'It's painful to see something meant to uplift the community and celebrate our history be treated with disrespect,' said muralist Emily Fromm in a news release. 'Public art is vulnerable by nature, because it exists out in the open for everyone to enjoy. But vandalism like this doesn't just damage a mural, it undermines the spirit of community that this project is all about.' Officials with the park said a report was filed with park rangers on Saturday to investigate the incident. Anyone who witnessed the event or has information on the vandalism is urged to contact their nearest law enforcement agency. 'Vandalizing a beautiful mural to protest a park is a bit like slashing your own tires to complain about traffic. It just doesn't make sense,' said Phil Ginsburg, the general manager of the San Francisco Recreation and Park Department. 'The new oceanfront park belongs to all San Franciscans, regardless of how they voted on Prop K. These murals are beautifying public restrooms and celebrating the history and natural beauty of Ocean Beach,' added Lucas Lux, president of Friends of Ocean Beach Park. It is not clear what led to the incident. Fromm has said that she and other artists had previously faced verbal harassment several times from opponents of the park. 'This kind of vandalism and harassment has no place in San Francisco,' said Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco). 'Turning the Great Highway into a public park is a visionary project that reflects our city's values: access to open space, community, and imagination. Attacking artists and volunteers who are bringing this vision to life is shameful.' KRON4 reached out to the San Francisco Police Department for comment but did not hear back in time for this report. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Axios
13-03-2025
- Politics
- Axios
"Unlawful" Great Highway park faces legal challenge
Weeks before the Upper Great Highway is set to open as a park, opponents of the contentious measure authorizing the roadway closure are fighting back with a legal challenge. Driving the news: Earlier this week, Proposition K opponents filed a lawsuit against San Francisco questioning the legality of the measure and how it was placed on the ballot. Why it matters: The lawsuit is the latest escalation in the fight over the planned park set to open next month. It has split voters on the city's east and west sides over " the war on cars" and sparked a recall campaign against District 4 Supervisor Joel Engardio who led the effort to put it on the ballot. Catch up quick: Proposition K asked voters whether to permanently ban cars along a 2-mile stretch of the highway and turn it into an oceanfront park. While the measure passed with 54% approval, voters in the Sunset and Richmond districts largely opposed the plan due to concerns over traffic and longer commutes, in sharp contrast to the approval it gained from voters in the city's eastern districts. Between the lines: The plaintiffs in the case, including Matthew Boschetto, a former Board Supervisor candidate and leader of the " No on K" campaign, contend that voters do not have the right to approve the street closure and that the park proposal should be subject to the state's environmental review law. The suit claims the defendants — Engardio, Supervisors Myrna Melgar, Rafael Mandelman, Matt Dorsey and former Supervisor Dean Preston — "ignored the state's plenary authority over traffic control and roads and unlawfully placed a measure before San Francisco voters," according to the lawsuit. What they're saying: Boschetto argued that the ballot measure should be voided and that the park conversion should go through the legislative process with community input rather than being decided upon by voters. "I don't have a complete prohibition to any park being there, but if we're going to do this, there's a right way to do it and it's been done the completely wrong way," he told Axios Wednesday. The other side: Lucas Lux, president of Friends of Ocean Beach Park, said he doesn't believe the "lawsuit has any merit" and feels confident that it will be dismissed. "If you buy their argument, you can't have JFK promenade anymore. You can't have the car-free road through McLaren park. You can't have this new Ocean Beach park. The consequences are so broad and sweeping and out-of-step with the intent of the state legislation," Lux said, adding that such projects have already been granted exemptions from environmental reviews. "We want everyone's voices to be at the table, but the way to solve problems is not through lawsuits, it's through working together," he added. What's next: The plaintiffs are seeking a court injunction to block this Friday's scheduled closure to vehicles and the park's opening on April 12.
CBS News
12-03-2025
- Politics
- CBS News
Lawsuit filed against City of San Francisco to prevent Great Highway from becoming a park
SAN FRANCISCO — In just a few days, the Great Highway on the west side of San Francisco is scheduled to be closed to car traffic. It comes after voters decided to turn the area into a park with Prop K on the November ballot. Almost 55% of voters in San Francisco agreed the section of highway from Lincoln Way to Sloat Boulevard should be re-purposed into a beachfront park. Now one group of neighbors filed a lawsuit Tuesday saying Proposition K was not legal and should be reversed. "I get worried about safety. When the upper highway, Great Highway is closed, traffic flows into the neighborhoods," says Matt Boschetto. His family has lived on the west side for 5 generations, and he is also a small business owner. That's why he decided to get into the fight over the planned park, literally on the Great Highway. "San Francisco is the most democratic city in the U.S. It used to be a city about people power. It used to be a city that had very, very inclusive processes, and this is the absolute opposite," Boschetto said. Matt is helping to lead "Livable SF," the group that held a rally Tuesday to announce a lawsuit suing the city saying passing Prop K was not legal. The idea to close the Great Highway was met with opposition since the start. Residents in the Sunset neighborhoods said by closing the highway there would be more traffic in the neighborhoods, making the streets less safe for families. They also argued it would be harder for people to get to the commercial corridors, which would then hurt small business. Those in favor of the park say there are work arounds to those concerns. "We have extended multiple invites to the leaders of the no on K folks to work together on neighborhood improvements including addressing their concerns on traffic. Their answer is filing lawsuits to try to undo the democratic will of San Franciscan's," says Lucas Lux, president of the Friends of Ocean Beach Park, a group that's supported Prop K. But as many have pointed out, the people most impacted on the west side of San Francisco voted overwhelmingly against closing the Great Highway - where as the people living on the other side of the city generally voted for it. "We all live in a city together. We all vote together, and we honor the democratic outcome," says Lux. Opponents, like Matt, say they fought it before voters approved it and they will continue to fight it now. "I think there's little we can do to stop the closure at this point, but I do think it is a very strong argument and if we do win in the court of law, the ballot measure will be null and void," says Boschetto. This has all gotten so contentious, the group against the park has even started a recall effort for the San Francisco supervisor who represents this district, Joel Enguardio. He released a statement today saying he believes the measure was legal and the lawsuit has no merit. CBS Bay Area also reached out to the San Francisco Mayor's office and the city attorney's office for comment.
