SC allows Delhi BJP govt to withdraw cases against Centre, L-G filed under AAP regime
The Supreme Court on Friday permitted the Rekha Gupta-led Delhi government to withdraw cases filed by the former AAP administration against the Centre and the Lieutenant Governor.
A bench of Chief Justice of India B R Gavai and Justice Augustine George Masih allowed this after Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, appearing for the BJP-led government, said that 'these matters should not trouble this court anymore'.
The law officer pointed out that the seven cases filed by the then Arvind Kejriwal government included one on the control of services in Delhi, the authority of L-G in committees, including solid waste management and Yamuna River cleaning, and against the validity of some Acts and ordinances issued by the Centre.
The battle for control over services had resulted in a judgment by a five-judge constitution bench of the court on May 11, 2023. Giving control over services — excluding police, public order and land — to the Delhi government, the SC said the National Capital Territory administration is unlike other Union Territories and has been accorded a 'sui generis' (unique) status by the Constitution and that an elected government needs to have control over bureaucrats, failing which the principle of collective responsibility will be adversely affected.
In an apparent bid to overcome this, the Centre on May 19, 2023, promulgated the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023, to set up a National Capital Civil Service Authority for the transfer and posting of Group-A officers in Delhi.
The then AAP government challenged this before the SC, and the matter has been pending since.
Another such dispute between the Delhi government and the L-G was over the January 19, 2023, National Green Tribunal order, which said the L-G would head a high-level committee for Yamuna rejuvenation. On a challenge by the AAP government, the SC had stayed the order.
The two sides were also caught in litigation over the alleged non-release of funds for the Delhi Jal Board for 2023-2025 and the appointment of the Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission (DERC) chairperson.
Earlier, cases filed by the AAP government against officers were also withdrawn from the Delhi High Court.
The AAP-led Delhi government had protested against the Ordinance and said it was behind the emboldening of bureaucrats who, it alleged, stopped following ministers' orders and attending meetings called by them.
AAP ministers and then Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal had said the amended Act was a way to challenge the SC's verdict and had led officers to defy directions from the elected government, thereby stalling work in Delhi.
Some examples given by party leaders was the stalled work on water and sewer pipelines and repair of broken roads. Many ministers had also written to the L-G seeking action against officers and claimed the officers were only following the L-G's directions.
The allegations were denied by the L-G office.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
37 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Multi-party delegation meets Jaishankar after 4-nation tour on Operation Sindoor
External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Tuesday met members of a multi-party delegation and received feedback from them on how they exposed Pakistan in various countries over its support to terrorism. The delegation led by BJP leader Baijayant Panda met Jaishankar at his office here after the key diplomatic tour and presented their report. The delegation returned home Tuesday morning after visiting Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Bahrain and Algeria. In these countries, the delegation members met foreign dignitaries and Indian diaspora during a series of meetings and exposed Pakistan's support to terrorism in the wake of Pahalgam terror attack and subsequent Operation Sindoor. "It was a very good meeting, and we gave External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar our feedback. All members of the delegation provided their inputs and shared their views with him," said delegation member Harsh V Shringla, a former foreign secretary. Asked what the minister told them, he said, "He (Jaishankar) told us that our objectives were fulfilled and congratulated the delegation and its leader". Panda told reporters that their visit abroad was successful where they could explain India's "new normal" against Pakistan over terrorism. He said the delegation members were united and gave a very strong message to the countries they travelled. "A successful four-nation tour — Bahrain, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Algeria. All four countries have taken clear steps against terrorism and understand India's principled stand...," he said in a post on X. Panda said the countries they visited understand India and its history has been such that "we don't need to give any justification". "We are a country of non-violence and have provided shelter to people from several countries. We had wanted to give the message of India and the new normal that we will retaliate terrorist violence. We ave also imposed economic sanctions and our goal is that Pakistan should stop its policy of supporting terrorism," he told reporters. Panda also said that the countries they visited are supporting India, not just in economic growth but also against terrorism. Other delegation members who met the external affairs minister included former Jammu and Kashmir chief minister Ghulam Nabi Azad, Phangnon Konyak, Rekha Sharma and Satnam Singh Sandhu. Other members of the eight-member delegation included Nishikant Dubey and Asaduddin Owaisi.
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
After 11 years, Pankaja & Dhananjay come together on Gopinath Munde's death anniversary
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar: After a gap of 11 years, the Munde cousins — minister Pankaja and former minister Dhananjay Munde — came together on Tuesday at Gopinathgad, in Beed's Parli Vaijnath, during the death anniversary observance of BJP politician Gopinath Munde . Earlier, the cousins used to visit Gopinathgad separately each year, avoiding interaction due to their political differences. Tuesday's occasion, featuring a religious ceremony and blood donation drive, garnered significant attention across Maharashtra, both for its political importance and the public reunion of the Munde cousins at the annual commemorative event. While Dhananjay Munde remained silent during the event, Pankaja Munde addressed the gathering and shared memories of her father. Before the event, Pankaja had said, "The NCP is now our ally, so we invited all functionaries from the party, including Dhananjay Munde. He is my cousin, and I am certain he will attend the function." The cousins, feeling politically isolated, have shown solidarity at public events throughout the past year, having resolved their differences before the previous year's elections. During her Gopinathgad speech, Pankaja said Dhananjay requested her to speak for the family. "He (Dhananjay) told me, 'You speak for all of us.' I am grateful to everyone who stood by me over the years as I found my footing in politics. This is a family, and every year, we wonder what we can do to keep Gopinath Munde's memory alive," she said. The BJP minister in the Devendra Fadnavis cabinet highlighted her father's public service. "If people knew how wounded he was, there would have been a wave of blood donations across the country. Today, we conduct health and blood donation camps to honour his legacy. He lives on through his ideals and the love of the people," she said. Referencing spiritual matters, Pankaja added, "Even Lord Ram and the Pandavas faced exile. I heard in the keertan today — greatness comes with pain." Additionally, Pankaja discussed her recent accommodation allocation. "I was finally given the Ramtek bungalow, which I requested back in 2014. At the time, it was occupied by a senior minister. Today, it feels like a great honour and a rare moment in history that I received this bungalow after Munde Saheb. This is not just a residence; it symbolises responsibility and commitment," she said.
United News of India
an hour ago
- United News of India
'One Nation, one Husband?' Mann's dig at 'Sindoor' draws flak
Chandigarh, June 3 (UNI) "One nation, one husband?", Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Singh Mann's dig at BJP's "Ghar-Ghar Sindoor abhiyan" drew flak on Tuesday, especially from BJP leaders who alleged that Mann had mocked Operation Sindoor. Mann, in a press conference, was asked by a journalist about Sindoor being sent to Ludhiana. He quipped, "What is this scheme? One nation, one husband??" He termed the BJP's so-called scheme a joke. He alleged that the BJP was trying to seek votes over Sindoor. Bye-elections for Ludhiana West assembly seat are scheduled for June 19. Meanwhile, taking exception to Mann's jibe, Union Minister of State for Railways Ravneet Singh Bittu said that the nation won't forgive Mann for the words he has used for the PM. Haryana Minister and BJP leader Anil Vij, reacting to Mann's comment, said that Mann, who was a comedian earlier, was "doing comedy in politics". He said that one should not make comments without grasping the depth of an issue.
