Indonesia's flip-flops and indecision stall investment say analysts, after LG pulls out of $11b nickel project
Indonesia's flip-flops and indecision stall investment say analysts, after LG pulls out of $11b nickel project
JAKARTA -- The decision by South Korean company LG to exit a US$8.45 billion (S$11.1 billion) plan to build an electric vehicle battery supply chain in Indonesia has sparked debate over Jakarta's inconsistent policies and slow decision-making .
LG Energy Solution, the world's third largest EV battery maker, disclosed its decision on April 21, citing 'market conditions and investment environment'.
LG led the consortium that was meant to develop a nickel mine, build smelters and construct a battery cell plant in Karawang, West Java, under a memorandum of understanding signed with Indonesia in Dec 2020. Indonesia holds the world's largest nickel reserves.
Some industry observers have described LG's move as a setback to Indonesia's plans to build an EV ecosystem, and its ambitions to develop downstream industries around its mineral resources.
But the government has insisted the mega project is on track.
On April 23, Energy and Mineral Resources Minister Bahlil Lahadalia said development and production would continue as planned, with China's Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt as the new lead company.
'There is no change in our plan to make Indonesia a global EV production base,' Mr Bahlil said.
On the same day , Investment Minister Rosan Roeslani said that it was the Indonesian government who had decided to terminate the partnership with LG on Jan 31, after years of stalled negotiations.
Questions have arisen over the surprise entry of Huayou, and whether LG pulled out or was ejected by the government.
Industry analyst Fabby Tumiwa said the Indonesian government should explain what had really happened behind the scenes, and its reasons for selecting Huayou, which makes EV battery raw materials.
'For the sake of public accountability and transparency… we need to know what really was going on and what basis was used to go with Huayou, after spending long years of negotiation with a different party,' Mr Fabby told The Straits Times.
At a forum in Parliament on April 24, economist Drajad Wibowo explained that five years ago, LG and its partners were invited by the government to invest in the EV battery project. This was in anticipation of South Korean carmaker Hyundai launching its Ioniq EV, which uses nickel-based batteries and is produced locally, in 2022.
But the government unexpectedly introduced a new policy in early 2024 that exempted imported EVs from tariffs for two years. This led to the quick entry of other EV brands, including China's BYD, which ate up the market share of Hyundai and others that had invested in building assembly plants in Indonesia.
BYD cars use batteries powered by cheaper iron phosphate, a mineral that is not abundant in Indonesia.
The Indonesian government had also offered BYD reductions on luxury goods tax normally imposed on vehicles with a high price tag , said Mr Drajad.
'With the same specifications, the price of an Ioniq car is about 50 to 60 per cent above the BYD car here,' Mr Drajad told the forum, pointing out that the Ioniq's market share in Indonesia has been on the decline.
Data from Indonesia's automaker association showed that EVs comprised 12.46 per cent of Indonesia's total new vehicle sales of 70,892 for March. BYD had the lion's share of sales that month at 54 per cent, followed by other Chinese makes Wuling (13.6 per cent) and Cherry (11.2 per cent). Hyundai falls outside the top five selling brands, with just 3 per cent of total EV sales.
Analysts also point the finger at slow processes and indecision at Indonesia's state-owned enterprises, which usually partner with foreign investors and take a stake in these projects.
Such management indecision is partly caused by previous cases in which SOE executives have been prosecuted for losses arising from the usual course of business, and received sentences akin to those meted out for fraud, financial mismanagement or abuse of power. The law was only amended in February to shield directors from personal liability for decisions 'made in good faith and with reasonable care'.
On the heels of the LG decision, the world's largest battery maker CATL was reported to be scaling back on its Indonesian EV battery project. It will slash more than half of its planned US$6 billion investment due to weak global demand and shifting market projections, according to an April 23 report by Bisnis.com.
CATL was allowed to buy about a half of a large nickel mine in North Maluku province in December 2023, on condition it invests in building processing facilities to turn nickel ore into intermediate products and EV battery cells. CATL has started building a battery cell plant in Karawang and expects to complete it by mid- 2026 .
Mr Nurul Ichwan, a deputy minister in charge of promotions at the Investment Ministry, told Bisnis.com that the government and CATL are discussing how the Chinese company should adjust its funding, taking into account how many years it will take to recover its investment.
'We understand, the new calculations (investment spending) would remain promising,' Mr Ichwan said, adding that latest developments showed global EV demand is not as strong as expected.
Wahyudi Soeriaatmadja has been Indonesia correspondent at The Straits Times since 2008, and is based in Jakarta
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
13 minutes ago
- Business Times
Meta to share AI infrastructure costs via US$2 billion asset sale
[NEW YORK] Meta Platforms is pressing ahead with efforts to bring in outside partners to help fund the massive infrastructure needed to power artificial intelligence (AI), disclosing plans in a filing on Thursday (Jul 31) to offload US$2 billion in data centre assets as part of that strategy. The strategy reflects a broader shift among tech giants, long known for self-funding growth, as they grapple with the soaring cost of building and powering data centres to support generative AI. The social media giant said earlier this week that it was exploring ways to work with financial partners to co-develop data centres to help finance its massive capital outlay for next year. 'We are exploring ways to work with financial partners to co-develop data centres,' Meta chief finance officer Susan Li said on a post-earnings conference call on Wednesday. While the company still expects to fund much of its capital spending internally, some projects could attract 'significant external financing' and offer more flexibility if infrastructure needs shift over time, Li said. The company did not have any finalised transactions to announce, she said. The disclosure in Meta's quarterly filing, however, signals that plans are firming up. In its quarterly filing on Thursday, Meta said it had approved a plan in June to dispose of certain data centre assets and reclassified US$2.04 billion worth of land and construction-in-progress as 'held-for-sale'. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up These assets were expected to be contributed to a third party within the next twelve months for co-developing data centres. Meta did not record a loss on the reclassification, which values the assets at the lower of their carrying amounts or fair value less costs to sell. As at Jun 30, total held-for-sale assets stood at US$3.26 billion, according to the filing. Meta declined to comment for this story. CEO Mark Zuckerberg has laid out plans to invest hundreds of billions of dollars into constructing AI data centre 'superclusters' for superintelligence. 'Just one of these covers a significant part of the footprint of Manhattan,' he said. The Instagram and WhatsApp owner on Wednesday raised the bottom end of its annual capital expenditures forecast by US$2 billion, to US$66 billion to US$72 billion. It reported stronger-than-expected ad sales, boosted by AI-driven improvements to targeting and content delivery. Executives said that those gains were helping offset rising infrastructure costs tied to its long-term AI push. REUTERS
Business Times
43 minutes ago
- Business Times
Shopee tightens grip on South-east Asia's sellers as take rates climb
IZA, a seller of customised bags and keychains on Shopee Philippines, used to earn 240,000 pesos (S$5,354) a month across her three shops on the platform. But that was before Shopee began raising its commission fees in the second half of 2024. Since then, the total fees Shopee deducts, including shipping and transaction charges, can climb as high as 25 per cent of her sales. 'These days, I only take home around 70,000 to 90,000 pesos a month,' Iza tells Tech in Asia. Over the past year, Shopee has gradually increased seller fees across its markets. While other platforms have also raised their fees, Shopee's rates generally remain the highest. And that's not all, the company recently introduced additional flat fees per transaction in certain markets. In response, a growing number of sellers are starting to speak out. But a Shopee spokesperson points out that the fees will be 'reinvested to benefit buyers, whether through shipping perks or payment benefits.' BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up 'We hope to continue supporting purchasing power and domestic consumption, which will in turn stimulate economic activity and benefit our sellers,' the spokesperson added. Pressure builds Rezky, an e-commerce specialist at an FMCG brand in Indonesia, echoes Iza's complaints. With rising fees and newly introduced charges, his product margins have dropped by around 3 to 5 per cent. This has forced his store to raise product prices as well as cut back on marketing spend, limiting the shop to run campaigns that have already proven effective. 'We can't afford trial and error in marketing this year,' he says. While his store's revenue is still growing, the pace has slowed year on year, Rezky admits. The new flat fees, at 1,250 rupiah (S$0.10) in Indonesia, 3,000 dong (S$0.15) in Vietnam, and RM0.54 (US$0.17) in Malaysia, are hitting low-priced items the hardest. Sellers may even choose to bundle such products rather than sell them individually. This move has also been followed by Lazada, where the platform will implement similar flat fees, with the same amount, starting Aug 1 in Indonesia. Daisuke Mori, CEO of ecommerce marketing agency Feedforce Vietnam, said that the firm is likely gearing itself towards 'larger, higher-margin brands' in the long run. But it's not just the fees. Sellers have also started feeling the squeeze from other policies, such as stricter delivery timelines and return options that include 'change of mind'. Since last year, sellers are required to ship orders placed in the morning within the same day. Those coming in after noon can be fulfilled the following day. Rezky said that his shop has no issue with the new delivery policy, thanks to a well-equipped operations team, and he believes the policy benefits consumers. However, he acknowledges that it could pose challenges for smaller sellers who lack similar resources. Returns are another story. Rezky notes that his shop has received returned orders because buyers changed their minds. While the volume is not yet alarming, fewer than 10 returns per month, he admits that it's an issue. Shopee has begun tightening its return policy in response to complaints from sellers. That said, both Lazada and TikTok Shop also allow such returns. While TikTok Shop does not offer returns for a 'change of mind', it does permit them under the label of 'no longer needed', provided certain conditions are met. Maintaining profitability Shopee is clearly working to boost its take rate as part of its push towards profitability. In 2024, it posted its first full-year positive adjusted Ebitda. The marketplace's typical take rate now falls between 9 per cent and 13 per cent, including commissions, payment fees, and other mandatory selling costs, according to Simon Torring, co-founder of insights firm Cube Asia. However, that figure can climb much higher when factoring in marketing and logistics co-investments. Sellers often have to shoulder part of the shipping cost to offer free delivery to buyers. As a result, total selling expenses for many merchants can reach 20 to 25 per cent of post-discount sales. While it's clear that Shopee raised its take rates to maintain profitability, the higher fees also give the company more room to reinvest in subsidies and marketing efforts aimed at attracting buyers. In turn, consumers enjoy more frequent promotions and discounts. These incentives help boost sales on the platform and allow Shopee to defend its market share against TikTok Shop. In 2024, Shopee reported a 21 per cent year-on-year increase in gross merchandise value (GMV) to US$66.8 billion, a faster pace compared to 2023's 15 per cent growth, according to the latest report from Momentum Works. Meanwhile, TikTok Shop posted a 38 per cent GMV increase over the same period. That GMV growth has translated into revenue gains. Shopee's revenue rose 38 per cent year on year in 2024, driven by growth in advertising and seller commissions. Its income from commission fees alone jumped 41 per cent year on year in Q4 2024. Le Tuan Anh, former country head of Vietnam at Leap Commerce, says that Shopee appears to be defending its position by prioritising buyers through perks – even if it comes at the cost of small merchants. Cube Asia's Torring notes that most sellers are frustrated with the changes. But they have also tolerated them, mainly because the increased take rates are being reinvested into promotions that help drive traffic and sales. 'Most sellers are facing rising costs, but their sales are going up as well,' he points out. No better options In Vietnam, more than 88,000 sellers closed their stores on Shopee last year, according to local media reports. Feedforce's Mori attributes this in large part to rising fees, a sign of just how much pressure sellers are facing across the region. As Shopee's ecosystem becomes more centralised, sellers are gradually losing their bargaining power. Leap Commerce's Anh notes that merchants would have to 'play the game' to continue to succeed. 'This means using all the available tools in e-commerce, such as live selling, affiliates, and paid ads,' he added. Cube Asia's Torring likens the evolving dynamic to that between retail tenants and landlords. 'It's symbiotic but not overly friendly,' he explained. 'Both parties seek to extract maximum value from the partnership.' This shift has pushed some merchants to look at alternative sales channels. Without meaningful alternatives that can match Shopee's reach, it's hard for niche platforms to attract and retain a critical mass of sellers and buyers. PHOTO: SHOPEE Smaller sellers are testing 'guerilla' commerce strategies such as conversational selling on WhatsApp or Telegram, most of Vietnam's ecommerce transactions are still done on Facebook, Anh points out. For larger brands, Anh suggests exploring direct-to-consumer websites, affiliate marketing, and livestream-driven commerce. These models allow them more control over margins, customer data, and brand narrative. But scaling these alternatives remains challenging. Mori notes that many small sellers still rely on the traffic and infrastructure that platforms such as Shopee provide. Without meaningful alternatives that can match Shopee's reach, it's hard for niche platforms to attract and retain a critical mass of sellers and buyers. For Philippine gadget shop Kimstore, staying on Shopee is still worth it, for now. 'We are still getting very decent sales from the platforms,' said Kim Lato, CEO and co-founder of Kimstore. 'So the strategy now is to take advantage of platform campaigns and guide customers to whichever channel gives us the best deal.' FMCG brand seller Rezky also said that has started testing alternative channels such as WhatsApp. But Shopee and the stable sales it provides means it will still be a key focus.
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
Lessons from golf for the astute investor
On the surface, golf seems a world apart from financial markets. Not to stereotype, but many finance professionals enjoy a game of golf, and it's not hard to tell why. There are striking parallels that offer invaluable lessons for anyone building lasting wealth. The recent conclusion of the 153rd Open Championship, the oldest golf tournament in the world, on Jul 20 saw the final grouping consisting of world No 1 Scottie Scheffler against Li Haotong. It is a rare occurrence to see a Chinese golfer at a major tournament. Scheffler won by an impressive healthy margin, but what was more intriguing was that he went 32 holes bogey-free, demonstrating consistency and dominance under pressure. (For non-golfers, bogey-free means finishing all of those holes at par or better.) This got me looking into the compounded reward money for the last century. In 1926, the famous Bobby Jones – lawyer by trade, golfer by passion – won for the first time. As a career amateur, he wasn't entitled to any prize money, so the whopping £75 (US$364) was awarded to the runner-up. Fast forward to 2025, Scheffler took home US$3.1 million of the total US$17 million prize money, an increase of 8,500 times from a century prior (taking the US dollar exchange rate in 1926 of £1 to US$4.85). This growth seems mind-blowing and equates to a compounding growth rate of just 9.5 per cent, approximately the return of global stocks in the same period. Returning to golf with fresh eyes While I played competitively as a junior, I have had the good fortune of returning to the green with my kids reaching the age to start swinging. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Playing as an adult has brought a whole new appreciation for the mental side of the game – the risk-reward trade-offs, the need to make decisions and live with them, the pressure, the choice of equipment and so many other nuances draw parallels to evidence-based investing. Staying on course by taking appropriate amounts of risk for return In golf, you are constantly faced with choices. From tee to green, you need to pick the line, shot and trajectory, while taking into account bunkers, water, rough, wind, rain, emotions, your competitor's actions and the world around you. You could carry that water to try to get on the green in two, or lay up with a higher chance of making par. Investing presents similar choices. You could take on lots of risk for the chance of making a big short-term return, but you could also catch a bad swing and end up in a ditch. Astute investors begin by picking the right 'shot' for each of their goals. This isn't about chasing the latest market fad; it's about crafting a well-thought-out investment strategy and asset allocation that aligns with your unique goals, time horizon and risk tolerance. Do you need a conservative iron shot to lay up, or can you confidently unleash the driver for a long-term gain and take on the volatility? Understanding your personal 'course conditions' and making strategic choices before you swing is paramount to improving your probability for success, and knowing when to go for it or protect capital. Working backwards from the goal Visualisation is important in golf – and not just for the next shot. A good golfer visualises from the green and the hole, and works backwards to the optimal shot they want to play off the tee to put themselves in the best position. If I want to hit 120 yards into the green on a 350-yard hole, I should try to hit 230 yards off the tee. I don't have to take out the driver and put myself a more awkward 60 yards from the hole even if I strike it in the middle of the fairway. Scheffler's performance at the Open clearly showed he consistently made choices off the tee that set himself up for success. Investing is the same. We start with the life goal, and work backwards to how we allocate our assets today. Liabilities-driven asset allocation has long been the way institutions invest, and now with the power of access, advice, lower costs and technology to implement this method, individuals can do the same. Like golf gear, every investor needs a set of personalised strategies Golf is one of the few sports where your gear can become outdated every few months. Golfers have to comb through all the noise, find what suits them and select fourteen golf clubs, each with a distinct purpose. Similarly, to consciously build investment portfolios, we must assemble an efficient collection of strategies that complement each other. When combined, they must be suitable for our goals, and our ability to tolerate volatility and complexity. Ideally, you can do this in a cost-conscious way and with unbiased advice. It is probably fair to say most golfers spend more time thinking about and researching how to improve their set of clubs, combing through dozens of websites and consulting multiple experts and friends before making their choice. We can all apply the same discernment to how we grow and manage our hard-earned wealth. There is no undo button in golf or investing Golf can also be a uniquely unforgiving sport. In tennis, for example, if you hit a lousy shot, that particular game is far from over. Miss a two-foot putt, that shot is marked on your scorecard forever. Once you've hit a shot, you can never get it back. In investing, the past is gone forever, too. Time lost and hindsight are constant frustrations. The market does not care if you are below your cost. The market does not care if you doubled your money on that stock in the last month, or if you missed out by sitting out for the last year. You can only focus on your allocations today for your future. You are playing against yourself In golf, no one will move your ball. No one is moving the course. You are in total control of implementing your game. A good swing requires consistent practice, focus and discipline, so you can perform when the pressure is on and distractions are everywhere. Successful investing also demands disciplined execution. This means sticking to your investment plan through market ups and downs, resisting the urge to panic during downturns or chasing fleeting highs. It means regular rebalancing to maintain your asset allocation, to improve the probability of success. The true mastery in both pursuits comes from controlling your emotions, silencing the inner critic and maintaining a clear, long-term perspective. Patience, resilience and the ability to learn from every shot – good or bad – are the hallmarks of a champion, both on the course and in your financial life. So, was this more about golf teaching us about investing or investing teaching us about golf? Whichever way you see it, improving your probability of success in managing wealth or playing golf will certainly lead to greater enjoyment in life. The writer is chief executive officer and co-founder of Endowus
