Indonesia's flip-flops and indecision stall investment say analysts, after LG pulls out of $11b nickel project
Data from Indonesia's automaker association showed that EVs comprised 12.46 per cent of Indonesia's total new vehicle sales of 70,892 for March. PHOTO: AFP
Indonesia's flip-flops and indecision stall investment say analysts, after LG pulls out of $11b nickel project
JAKARTA -- The decision by South Korean company LG to exit a US$8.45 billion (S$11.1 billion) plan to build an electric vehicle battery supply chain in Indonesia has sparked debate over Jakarta's inconsistent policies and slow decision-making .
LG Energy Solution, the world's third largest EV battery maker, disclosed its decision on April 21, citing 'market conditions and investment environment'.
LG led the consortium that was meant to develop a nickel mine, build smelters and construct a battery cell plant in Karawang, West Java, under a memorandum of understanding signed with Indonesia in Dec 2020. Indonesia holds the world's largest nickel reserves.
Some industry observers have described LG's move as a setback to Indonesia's plans to build an EV ecosystem, and its ambitions to develop downstream industries around its mineral resources.
But the government has insisted the mega project is on track.
On April 23, Energy and Mineral Resources Minister Bahlil Lahadalia said development and production would continue as planned, with China's Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt as the new lead company.
'There is no change in our plan to make Indonesia a global EV production base,' Mr Bahlil said.
On the same day , Investment Minister Rosan Roeslani said that it was the Indonesian government who had decided to terminate the partnership with LG on Jan 31, after years of stalled negotiations.
Questions have arisen over the surprise entry of Huayou, and whether LG pulled out or was ejected by the government.
Industry analyst Fabby Tumiwa said the Indonesian government should explain what had really happened behind the scenes, and its reasons for selecting Huayou, which makes EV battery raw materials.
'For the sake of public accountability and transparency… we need to know what really was going on and what basis was used to go with Huayou, after spending long years of negotiation with a different party,' Mr Fabby told The Straits Times.
At a forum in Parliament on April 24, economist Drajad Wibowo explained that five years ago, LG and its partners were invited by the government to invest in the EV battery project. This was in anticipation of South Korean carmaker Hyundai launching its Ioniq EV, which uses nickel-based batteries and is produced locally, in 2022.
But the government unexpectedly introduced a new policy in early 2024 that exempted imported EVs from tariffs for two years. This led to the quick entry of other EV brands, including China's BYD, which ate up the market share of Hyundai and others that had invested in building assembly plants in Indonesia.
BYD cars use batteries powered by cheaper iron phosphate, a mineral that is not abundant in Indonesia.
The Indonesian government had also offered BYD reductions on luxury goods tax normally imposed on vehicles with a high price tag , said Mr Drajad.
'With the same specifications, the price of an Ioniq car is about 50 to 60 per cent above the BYD car here,' Mr Drajad told the forum, pointing out that the Ioniq's market share in Indonesia has been on the decline.
Data from Indonesia's automaker association showed that EVs comprised 12.46 per cent of Indonesia's total new vehicle sales of 70,892 for March. BYD had the lion's share of sales that month at 54 per cent, followed by other Chinese makes Wuling (13.6 per cent) and Cherry (11.2 per cent). Hyundai falls outside the top five selling brands, with just 3 per cent of total EV sales.
Analysts also point the finger at slow processes and indecision at Indonesia's state-owned enterprises, which usually partner with foreign investors and take a stake in these projects.
Such management indecision is partly caused by previous cases in which SOE executives have been prosecuted for losses arising from the usual course of business, and received sentences akin to those meted out for fraud, financial mismanagement or abuse of power. The law was only amended in February to shield directors from personal liability for decisions 'made in good faith and with reasonable care'.
On the heels of the LG decision, the world's largest battery maker CATL was reported to be scaling back on its Indonesian EV battery project. It will slash more than half of its planned US$6 billion investment due to weak global demand and shifting market projections, according to an April 23 report by Bisnis.com.
CATL was allowed to buy about a half of a large nickel mine in North Maluku province in December 2023, on condition it invests in building processing facilities to turn nickel ore into intermediate products and EV battery cells. CATL has started building a battery cell plant in Karawang and expects to complete it by mid- 2026 .
Mr Nurul Ichwan, a deputy minister in charge of promotions at the Investment Ministry, told Bisnis.com that the government and CATL are discussing how the Chinese company should adjust its funding, taking into account how many years it will take to recover its investment.
'We understand, the new calculations (investment spending) would remain promising,' Mr Ichwan said, adding that latest developments showed global EV demand is not as strong as expected.
Wahyudi Soeriaatmadja has been Indonesia correspondent at The Straits Times since 2008, and is based in Jakarta
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
36 minutes ago
- Business Times
South-east Asia's polymer production crisis worsens as US-China trade shift looms
[SINGAPORE] South-east Asia's petrochemical industry is facing a double whammy of weakening export demands and potential import surges, as trade tensions could redirect US polymer to the region's already-saturated market, sustaining pressure on production. Polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP), as crucial downstream segments, are encountering 'considerable challenges' in the region, noted commodity markets intelligence firm Argus. This is amid trade uncertainty exacerbated by a US federal appeals court ruling on Wednesday (Jun 11) that President Donald Trump's tariffs can remain in place while it reviews an earlier court decision to block them. The latest ruling complicates newly drafted US-China plans to ease trade tensions. Argus highlighted that additional US polymer supply is anticipated to enter South-east Asia as part of trade flow redirection, driven by cost-competitiveness and the low likelihood of countries in the region imposing retaliatory tariffs on US cargoes. The London-headquartered research firm found that some US producers and regular exporters had already begun sending their cargoes to Vietnam instead of China. 'However, the situation remains fluid, and any continued shift in trade flows could contribute to additional supply entering the South-east Asian market,' the research firm said. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Friday, 8.30 am Asean Business Business insights centering on South-east Asia's fast-growing economies. Sign Up Sign Up During the US-China trade war in Trump's first term in office, US polymer exports were redirected to countries in the Asia-Pacific. Specifically, US PE exports to Singapore and Malaysia rose by 328 per cent and 264 per cent, respectively, Argus noted in another report released on May 30. Plastic goods pressuring demand Meanwhile, trade uncertainty could prompt new trade routes for finished plastic goods, beyond the polymer trade. Chinese plastic products once bound for the US will likely seek alternative markets – including South-east Asia. This threatens to further strain the region's export-dependent finished goods sector, putting indirect downward pressure on polymer demand. In 2024, around 8 per cent of the US' imported finished plastic goods came from South-east Asian countries, which now see the risk of a significant fall in demand, noted Argus. Around 17 per cent of China's PE imports were from the US in 2024. The intelligence firm noted that South-east Asian countries could explore opportunities to increase run rates and export PE to China with low-cost feedstocks amid the trade tensions between the world's two largest economies. 'But this remains a challenge for the region, as it predominantly relies on naphtha as a feedstock, which is less cost-competitive than lighter options,' it added. It also said that limited upstream integration further disadvantages the region, compared with markets in the Middle East and North-east Asia, where more integrated supply chains enhance cost efficiency. China factor Other than trade uncertainty, China's expanding polymer production capacity also threatens to deepen South-east Asia's existing polymer production crisis, where some regional crackers had been in extended shutdowns since late 2024. Fumiko Dobashi, manager of Asia-Pacific chemicals price reporting at S&P Global, highlighted a trade dynamic between the US, China and Asia in a briefing on Jun 3: The US exports raw materials such as ethane, liquefied petroleum gas and polymers, while Asia ships back finished plastic products and rubber products. However, China has been expanding its polymer capacity, transforming itself into a net exporter from a net importer and adding to the polymer flood into nearby regions, said Dobashi. She noted that while the US remains a major polymer exporter, the trend of China becoming a significant player continues, with the country increasing its exports to Asean nations such as Vietnam. Declining operating rates Over the past five years, South-east Asia's PE and PP operating rates have declined by 25 per cent and 20 per cent, respectively, on average as exports fell and imports rose, Argus noted. Meanwhile, the region's PP net trade position has shifted from net exporter to net importer since 2022; as has its PE trade position since 2024, amid China's accelerated progress towards self-sufficiency and increasing exports. Specifically, China's PP exports into the region have trebled to 636,000 tonnes over the past five years, mainly to Vietnam and Indonesia. China's focus on self-sufficiency also significantly reduced South-east Asia's PE and PP exports by 1.8 million tonnes, or 37 per cent, over the same period, according to the research firm. It added that the region's polymer prices will be further depressed by shrinking downstream export demand and more supply entering the market.
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
Bessent emerging as a contender to succeed Fed's Powell
[NEW YORK] A growing chorus of advisers inside and outside the Trump administration are pushing another name to serve as the next chair of the Federal Reserve: Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. President Donald Trump said on Friday he would name a successor 'very soon' to replace Jerome Powell, whose term as Fed chair ends in May 2026. The small list of candidates under consideration has included Kevin Warsh, a former Fed official whom Trump interviewed for the Treasury secretary role in November, according to people familiar with the matter. But Bessent – who is leading Trump's effort to kickstart the US economy with sweeping changes to trade, taxes and regulation – is also now one of the contenders for the job, said the people, who requested anonymity to discuss private conversations. Formal interviews for the position have not begun, two of the people said. 'I have the best job in Washington,' Bessent said in response to a request for comment. 'The president will decide who's best for the economy and the American people.' A senior administration official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, disputed the reporting without providing further specifics. As Treasury chief, Bessent would traditionally play a key role in the search and interview process for the next Fed chair. It's unclear if he would recuse himself as Trump begins to make his decision. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up 'Given the amount of trust and confidence that the global financial community has in Scott Bessent, he's an obvious candidate,' said Tim Adams, president and CEO of the Institute of International Finance (IIF). 'He's a dark horse candidate,' Adams said, adding that Warsh – who served as a governor on the Fed board from 2006 to 2011 – would also be a good choice. Asked specifically about Warsh on Friday, Trump said: 'He's very highly thought of.' Bessent has been at the forefront of negotiations on a US-China trade deal, arguably the most important of the pacts the president is seeking to forge as part of his effort to reshape the global trade landscape. 'Scott Bessent proved he could implement President Trump's agenda during an incredibly turbulent first six months,' said Steve Bannon, former chief White House strategist and outside adviser to the president. 'He's not just the star of the cabinet, but a safe pair of hands for global capital markets.' The president, who first nominated Powell to the job in 2017, has regularly complained that the Fed chief has been too reluctant to cut borrowing costs. Trump pushed Powell to lower interest rates in a White House meeting last month. Powell and Fed officials have held interest rates steady in 2025, arguing a patient approach to policy is appropriate amid economic uncertainty caused by Trump's expanded and evolving use of tariffs. Fed policymakers have said they expect the announced tariffs to weigh on economic growth and boost inflation. Whoever the Senate confirms for the post will have to prove to the world that the Fed's independence from political meddling remains intact. Trump has said many times that Powell is making a mistake by not lowering rates, and has previously said that he should have a say on rate decisions, raising questions over whether markets would see the next pick as beholden to him. Bessent or Warsh 'would be given the benefit of the doubt from the financial community' that they would preserve the independence of the Fed's rate-setting authority, IIF's Adams said. Economist and Trump ally Arthur Laffer said Bessent 'is wonderful, but he already has a job. And his specialty is not monetary policy.' 'As I told the president, I think Kevin Warsh is just perfect for the job,' he said. Other candidates whose names have previously been floated for Fed chair include Kevin Hassett, the White House's National Economic Council director, Christopher Waller, a Fed governor, and former World Bank President David Malpass. BLOOMBERG
New Paper
3 hours ago
- New Paper
Maids set up illegal side hustle outside mall, draws ire from nearby business owners
To make some extra cash on their rest day, a number of Indonesian maids gathered to set up a small food market outside City Plaza in Paya Lebar, despite knowing it is illegal. "Many maids gather for a few hours, and some of them sell food and beverages, so the others will not come to patronise us," said a nearby shop owner. Every weekend, the group of Indonesian maids seize the opportunity for a side hustle by selling food such as chicken rice, fruits and drinks outside the mall. Shin Min Daily News reported that a group of women carried reusable bags containing food items while walking around the area. Business was decent, as occasionally, people would pay to buy the food. Another group with a different strategy was also spotted nearby. Rather than approaching the public, these women placed their offerings in the open space for passers-by to choose from. Some maids placed their foods in the open. PHOTO: SHIN MIN DAILY NEWS When offered a $3 cup of lemon tea by a vendor, the reporter attempted to ask about her business. However, the woman was unwilling to respond and quickly packed the food before leaving. A maid who wished to remain anonymous told the Chinese daily that she was from Indonesia and knew touting was illegal. Every fortnight, she would sell food she and her friends prepared. However, she admitted that her employer was not aware of her business. Maids would gather outside the mall on their rest day, and some would come prepared with food for sale. PHOTO: SHIN MIN DAILY NEWS A chicken rice stall owner said that even though the maids' food prices were slightly higher, people still bought from them. "Our business was affected by about 20 per cent." The Singapore Food Agency told Shin Min Daily News that the authorities had begun investigating the case and will take action against food vendors without a licence. Under the Environmental Public Health Act 1987, a person must not hawk for sale any food or goods in a public place without first obtaining a licence. A spokesperson said that unregulated street food hawking not only poses environmental problems, but also may pose risks to public health. Illegally sold food may be unsafe for consumption as it does not meet the safety requirements of SFA. SFA will take appropriate action against illegal hawkers, and those with financial difficulties will be referred to social service agencies for assistance. The public can report the unlicensed sale of food on
