Tribunal rejects Singaporean's tax refund claim due to jurisdiction issue
A SINGAPOREAN had his claim against an electrical appliances outlet dismissed by the Johor Consumer Claims Tribunal.
Claimant SB Koo had demanded the respondent refund customs tax paid by him, claiming the respondent had cheated him.
Respondent Izonic Electrical Sdn Bhd director Lim Chee Khoon said the company was willing to meet with Koo.
'We are willing to meet him to resolve the matter, but he refused,' Lim said outside the Johor Consumer Claims Tribunal at Menara Ansar, Johor Baru.
Lim said the claimant wrote a negative review of the company and this was picked up by a digital media portal on the island republic.
The respondent said the portal ran the story with the heading 'Singaporean man allegedly asked to pay S$268 for 'customs tax' after buying RM1,400 water filter in JB'.
Lim said the portal published the story on Feb 2 after the claimant made the purchase of the electrical items on Jan 17.
Lim, 37, said Koo, 61, went to the mall in Taman Abad, Johor Baru, with his wife.
The couple decided to buy home electrical appliances on display at the outlet.
The items were a water filter, Thermos pot, induction cooker, stainless-steel wok and a set of four ceramic bowls, totalling RM4,588.
'They were given a RM50 voucher which brought the bill down to RM4,538,' Lim said, adding that the claimant paid using a debit card.
Lim then sent the couple home to their Housing Development Board flat by car on Jan 17.
Lim claimed that he paid S$268 (RM888) in taxes on Koo's behalf at the Causeway and was later reimbursed.
Lim also made an appointment to instal the water filter on Jan 18, which the claimant agreed to.
'The claimant called our Singaporean representative on Jan 18 to inform him that he was busy and not at home,' said the respondent.
Lim said the representative called Koo many times to fix another appointment date but his calls went unanswered.
During the hearing, Tribunal president Hafez Zalkapli reminded both parties any decision made by the Tribunal could not be challenged.
Hafez dismissed Koo's claim, explaining that it was not the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to hear cases related to tax disputes as the case should be filed with the small claims court.
A small claims court is a specialised court handling civil disputes involving relatively small amounts of money, offering a faster and more affordable alternative to traditional litigation.
Those needing Tribunal assistance can call 07-227 1755 or 07-227 1766, or visit the Johor Consumer Claims Tribunal at Level 17, Menara Ansar, Jalan Trus, Johor Baru.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sinar Daily
2 hours ago
- Sinar Daily
Kota Madani, a misplaced priority amidst budget cuts, says Pas Youth
The youth wing's chief argued that such a project represents a misplaced priority at a time when Malaysia is grappling with subsidy reductions and a worsening fiscal deficit. By SINAR DAILY REPORTER 01 Jul 2025 08:18pm The initial phase of development, spanning 41.28 hectares in Precinct 19, is slated to commence in September 2025 and is projected for completion by the end of 2027. - Bernama photo SHAH ALAM – Pas Youth has slammed the Federal Government's ambitious "Kota Madani" development in Putrajaya, labelling it an "elitist" undertaking that could exacerbate the nation's financial woes. The youth wing's chief, Afnan Hamimi Taib Azamudden argued that such a project represents a misplaced priority at a time when Malaysia is grappling with subsidy reductions and a worsening fiscal deficit. The initial phase of development, spanning 41.28 hectares in Precinct 19, is slated to commence in September 2025 and is projected for completion by the end of 2027. - Bernama photo Afnan cautioned the government against pursuing what he termed "vanity symbols" for the Prime Minister, urging fiscal prudence instead of new commitments. He highlighted concerns that the project, despite an estimated cost of RM4 billion, could incur a substantially higher financial burden if funded through a private finance initiative (PFI). The PFI model, he noted, has historically drawn criticism for potentially masking a government's true debt obligations in official records. Afnan called on the administration to disclose the precise cost of the project, including annual commitments stretching over the next 20 to 25 years. "What tangible benefits can the people expect, especially the younger generation who will inherit the weight of this debt? "Why is such a extravagant project being prioritised when funding for education, healthcare, food security and social welfare continues to diminish?" Afnan questioned in a statement today. The Alor Setar MP also raised objections to the involvement of Putrajaya Holdings Sdn Bhd, a subsidiary of Petronas, as the project's primary driver. He pointed out that this comes at a time when the national oil and gas corporation faces declining profits, workforce reductions and increasing investment pressures across various sectors. "The government should be safeguarding Petronas, not transforming the company into a 'political ATM' to finance elitist projects that do not offer equitable commercial returns," Afnan added. Calling for an immediate halt to the Putrajaya government quarters project, Afnan demanded that a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis be presented in Parliament. "If the government insists on proceeding, it will become evident that the true purpose behind Kota Madani is not national advancement, but rather the pursuit of political ambition and the legacy of a particular individual," he concluded. On June 26, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim officially launched the Kota Madani project, conceived as a smart city initiative designed to be people-centric and environmentally sustainable. Reports indicate the project will operate on a build, lease, maintain and transfer model, meaning the government will not directly bear maintenance costs but will pay through a long-term lease arrangement. The initial phase of development, spanning 41.28 hectares in Precinct 19, is slated to commence in September 2025 and is projected for completion by the end of 2027. This phase will comprise 10,000 high-density vertical residential units, designed to accommodate over 30,000 residents.
The Sun
4 hours ago
- The Sun
Pertama Digital confident of returning to profitability after acquisition of two companies
KUALA LUMPUR: Government e-services provider Pertama Digital Bhd (PDB) expects to return to profitability after acquiring 80% stakes in two companies, D-Ron Singapore Pte Ltd (D-Ron SG) and D-Ron Malaysia Sdn Bhd (D-Ron MY) with a purchase agreement that includes RM32.4 million profit guarantee over two years. Pertama Digital Group CEO Lim Nasrul Halim said the profit guarantee offered by D-Ron is backed by an escrow arrangement to ensure the guarantee is fully realised. There is also a two-year service agreement with the current founders and leadership team of D-Ron as Lim said it was important for D-Ron to undergo a smooth transition into a Pertama Digital subsidiary. 'We are already slightly profitable according to last quarter's financial report, but it isn't good enough for us and our shareholders. 'We are confident about our profitability mainly because of our acquisition of D-Ron which will come with a profit guarantee of RM32.4 million,' he told reporters during a press conference at Pertama Digital's corporate headquarters today. Lim said the acquisition of D-Ron was not for the sake of profitability but because the companies, which specialise in information technology and surveillance hardware distribution, complemented well with others in the Pertama Digital group. 'We are not acquiring these companies for the sake of profitability. It's strategic and there's a bigger picture to it.' Pertama Digital plans to acquire D-Ron SG for RM101.14 million (S$30.41 million) and D-Ron MY for RM4.99 million from three vendors, bringing the total amount to RM106.13 million in cash. Recently, Pertama Digital received approval from Bursa Malaysia for an extension until Oct 31, 2025, to submit its regularisation plan. Lim said he was confident that the company will be able to submit the regularisation plan earlier than end October. 'We are working hard towards our due diligence process and D-Ron's leadership has been helpful in expediting the process of preparing the plan. Once we have shareholder approval we can submit the plan early.' Initially, Pertama Digital failed to submit a regularisation plan by the Feb 9, 2025 deadline as required by Bursa Malaysia. Its conditional acquisition of D-Ron forms the cornerstone of Pertama Digital's regularisation plan built on a series of high-impact deliverables. The deliverables include the completion of a major acquisition with strong earnings visibility, positioning Pertama Digital as a key player in digital infrastructure; the evolution of MyPay to strengthen its role as a trusted digital backbone for government transactions and public sector innovation; and a partnership with Infobip to enhance public sector's communication infrastructure and government-to-citizen engagement. Other ongoing projects include eJamin, a bail payment system that has processed over RM1 billion in transactions, and BizKecil, a platform supporting small enterprises. The company is also exploring a cybersecurity collaboration with Netsec Sdn Bhd for the public sector. Pertama Digital said these efforts form part of its plan to strengthen financial performance and operational viability. The company will now proceed with comprehensive due diligence on D-Ron Group and will convene an extraordinary general meeting to seek shareholder approval. Pertama Digital will also work closely with Bursa Malaysia to secure all necessary regulatory clearances.
New Straits Times
8 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Petrol, diesel smuggling slows as authorities clamp down at border
TUMPAT: Heightened enforcement by border security agencies along the Malaysia-Thailand border has led to a significant decline in petrol and diesel smuggling activities. A check at several petrol stations in the district revealed that the once-frequent activity of purchasing subsidised fuel for illegal cross-border trade has slowed noticeably, despite continued demand for fuel across the border. A source said many fuel smugglers have either temporarily suspended operations or shifted to alternative forms of smuggling following persistent enforcement efforts by agencies, especially the General Operations Force. "The enforcement presence is much tighter now. "Many regular smugglers have gone quiet. "Some are taking a break, others have moved on to smuggling different goods, and a few have quit the trade entirely," the source said. Checks also showed that only a handful of 4WD vehicles, commonly used by smugglers, were observed refuelling at stations near the border. "These are believed to be repeat buyers, who now make smaller purchases to avoid detection. "Those still active in smuggling are buying in small quantities per trip to reduce suspicion. "But overall, the volume of such activity has dropped," the source added. It is understood that while demand for Malaysian subsidised fuel remains high in neighbouring Thailand due to price differences, increased border patrols and roadblocks have made smuggling riskier and less lucrative. Meanwhile, Kelantan Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry director Azman Ismail confirmed the trend, attributing the decline to consistent enforcement actions under the Control of Supplies Act 1961. Last year alone, he said the ministry recorded 240 arrests, with the seizure of nearly 127,600 litres of petrol worth about RM276,400. Meanwhile, about 247,600 litres of diesel worth nearly RM600,000 were also seized, and 460 vehicles valued at RM4.25 million were confiscated last year. As of June this year, he said 102 arrests had been recorded, with the seizure of 25,781 litres of petrol valued at about RM55,365 and 21,353 litres of diesel worth RM61,180. "A total of 221 vehicles valued at about RM1.18 million were seized. "All cases are being investigated under the Act. "Some arrests were made based on referrals from other enforcement agencies, while others were initiated directly by the ministry. "The decrease in this activity is also due to the ban on illegal crossings enforced by the police effective from Dec 1 last year," said Azman.
