BJD steps up attack on ECI, says it will approach high court on discrepancies
BJD spokesperson Amar Patnaik said the party had submitted a memorandum to the Election Commission of India in December last year highlighting 'serious discrepancies' in the 2024 election data but hadn't received a satisfactory response.
'Eight months have passed, and the Election Commission has failed to address our concerns or provide satisfactory answers. We would soon move high court on these discrepancies,' said Patnaik.
The former Rajya Sabha MP stated that the BJD identified three major inconsistencies in the 2024 elections, based on their analysis of ECI data.
Across Odisha's 21 parliamentary constituencies, the number of votes counted exceeded those recorded in the Electronic Voting Machines. 'We cited a discrepancy of 682 votes in Booth No. 57 of the Phulbani assembly constituency and variations of 660 and 784 votes in booths of the Talsara assembly constituency. Similarly, the total votes in Lok Sabha constituencies did not align with the combined votes of their constituent assembly segments. There was a variation of 4,056 votes in Dhenkanal, 3,521 in Kandhamal, 2,701 in Bolangir, and 677 in Jajpur where the election was decided by a mere 2,000-vote margin,' said Patnaik.
BJD legislator Dhruba Sahoo said there had been a 'shocking' increase in voting percentages reported after the official close of polling, ranging from 7% to a high of 30%. 'In 50% of Odisha's assembly seats, this discrepancy was between 15% and 30%, with Keonjhar — where chief minister Mohan Charan Majhi contested — recording a 30.64% difference, the highest in the country,' he alleged.
Patnaik questioned how such variations could occur in an era of advanced EVMs and telecom networks, noting that discrepancies in 2004 elections were below 2%.
'If votes from mock polls were not deducted, as the ECI claims, that's a criminal offence,' he asserted, rejecting the commission's explanation that faulty EVMs or pending litigation in 28 constituencies prevented the release of Form 17C (a critical document recording votes polled).
'Even constituencies not under litigation have not received these forms,' he said, reiterating the BJD's demand for a comprehensive audit of the electoral process — from voter list preparation to vote counting — by independent auditors or the Comptroller and Auditor General.
BJD also called for 100% verification of Voter Verified Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) slips with EVM counts, instead of the current 5% mandate, and a 30-day deadline for providing Form 17C and VVPAT slips to citizens upon request. 'Such mechanisms exist in developed democracies. Why not in India?' Patnaik asked.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Lok Sabha approves updated I-T bill, to ease compliance burden
Lok Sabha NEW DELHI: Lok Sabha on Monday approved the Income Tax Bill 2025 - a key reform aimed at revamping the decades old income tax law for individuals and companies, making it simple for taxpayers and easing the compliance burden. Earlier, FM Nirmala Sitharaman introduced the revised and updated version of the I-T bill in Parliament, incorporating recommendations of the Select committee of Parliament. On Aug 8, FM had withdrawn the earlier bill, which was introduced in the house on Feb 13. The Select committee of the Lok Sabha headed by BJP's Baijayant Panda had examined the I-T Bill 2025 and adopted the report on the draft legislation last month. The parliamentary panel had suggested 285 recommendations on the draft legislation, aimed at simplifying and modernising the country's tax laws. "Almost all of the recommendations of the Select Committee have been accepted by govt. In addition, suggestions have been received from stakeholders about changes that would convey the proposed legal meaning more accurately," according to the statement of Objects and Reasons of the Income Tax (No.2) Bill. " For TDS correction statements, the time period for filing statements has been reduced to two years from six years in the Income-tax Act, 1961. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like listen now on spotify samy Listen Now Undo I-T department sources said this is expected to reduce the grievances of deductees significantly. Flexibility has been provided in the new I-T bill for allowing refund claims in cases where the return is not filed on time, a move which is expected to come as a major relief for taxpayers. Tax experts said the reforms are expected to ease compliance for individuals, companies, MSMEs and promote a stable, predictable and transparent tax system, key for sustaining domestic consumption, attracting foreign investment and supporting growth. "The withdrawal of the earlier I-T bill and the introduction of a revised version demonstrates govt's responsiveness to stakeholder feedback and the Select Parliamentary committee's recommendations," said Gouri Puri, partner, Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas and Co. Puri said the original draft raised concerns about ambiguities, particularly regarding house property taxation, pension deductions, and the refund process for delayed filings. "The revised bill addresses these gaps to simplify interpretation, reduce disputes and promote fairness," said Puri. The new I-T Bill also aims to eliminate redundant and repetitive provisions for better navigation, reorganising sections logically to facilitate case of reference. It has opted for simplified language to make the law more accessible and has removed obsolete and redundant provisions for greater clarity. Mandatory investment and deposit of deemed accumulated income of 15% of regular income in specified modes has been done away with. The word "profession" has been added after "business" in clause 187 to enable professionals with total receipts exceeding Rs 50 crore in a year the facility of prescribed electronic modes of payment. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays , public holidays , current gold rate and silver price .
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
New Income Tax Bill gets Lok Sabha nod
The Lok Sabha on Monday gave its nod to the new income tax bill, which does away with alternate minimum tax on limited liability partnership (LLP) firms and allows refund claims even if taxpayers do not file returns within the due date. ADVERTISEMENT The Income Tax (NO.2) Bill, which will replace the Income Tax Act, 1961 from the next financial year, was introduced by Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman and passed in the Lok Sabha amid din without a debate. It will now go to Rajya Sabha for its approval. The bill cuts down wordage and chapters by almost half and presents the clauses in simpler and easier to understand language. It does away with the confusing concepts of assessment year and previous year, replacing them with "tax year". The original Income Tax Bill, 2025, which was introduced in February, was withdrawn by the minister on Friday and the new bill incorporating "almost all recommendations" of the select committee, headed by parliamentarian Baijayant Panda, which had scrutinised the original bill, was bill has maintained status quo on loss carry forward provisions, exempted non-profit organisations from taxing anonymous donations received by purely religious trusts and tweaked the definition of MSMEs (micro, small and medium enterprises) in alignment with the MSME Act, which were part of the recommendations of the panel. ADVERTISEMENT It has also reintroduced deductions in respect of certain inter-corporate dividends for companies opting for concessional rate of taxes in line with the provisions of the existing Income-tax Act, 1961 and nil tax collected at source on Liberalised Remittance Scheme remittances for education purposes financed by any financial bill has added the term 'profession' alongside 'business' under electronic payment rules, which means professionals with income of more than ₹50 crore annually must use prescribed electronic modes of payment. ADVERTISEMENT The bill has also clearly defined deductions for commuted pension and gratuity received by family said some of the pain points have been removed. ADVERTISEMENT "The revised Income-tax Bill, 2025 demonstrates the government's receptiveness to parliamentary recommendations, incorporating targeted amendments to enhance clarity, ease of compliance and consistency with existing legislation," said Sandeep Jhunjhunwala, partner, Nangia Andersen LLP. "To give a few examples, the provisions of levying alternate minimum tax on LLPs has been done away with, the rigours placed on charitable trust have been removed, the provisions of transfer pricing and the definition of 'associated enterprise' to whom these provisions apply, have been relaxed," said Dinesh Kanabar, CEO, Dhruva Advisors. (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel)
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
Kamal Haasan Demands Machine-Readable Electoral Rolls, Slams Rahul Gandhi's Detention
Chennai: Actor-turned-politician Kamal Haasan launched a sharp attack on the Election Commission of India (ECI) today, raising what he called "grave questions" about the integrity of the country's electoral rolls. In a strongly worded letter to the people of India, the Makkal Needhi Maiam (MNM) founder asked why the ECI refused to publish rolls in machine-readable formats that allow independent verification and why it demanded a written oath from Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi when the evidence he cited came from the poll body's records itself. The Rajya Sabha MP's statement comes amid the ongoing controversy about bogus voters in the Mahadevapura assembly segment in Karnataka. Last week, Rahul Gandhi alleged the assembly segment of the Bangalore Central Parliamentary Constituency had more than 1,00,000 fake votes in the 2024 Lok Sabha polls. Mr Gandhi accused the BJP of benefiting from duplicate entries, fake and invalid addresses, bulk voters at single addresses, invalid photos, and misuse of Form 6 - allegations the BJP has dismissed as baseless and politically motivated. The ECI's insistence on complaints under oath and its reluctance to probe the issue have drawn criticism from legal experts and opposition leaders, who warn the episode has caused a major dent in the poll body's credibility. Citing suspicious additions to rolls in Karnataka and Maharashtra and mass deletions in Bihar's Special Intensive Revision exercise, Mr Haasan questioned whether "addition sometimes resembles subtraction." He demanded that the ECI rise to the standards set by former Chief Election Commissioner TN Seshan, "who was impartial, fearless and above partisan politics," and permit independent audits so that "people see the truth rather than be told to take comfort in authority's word." Mr Haasan also condemned the detention of Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc MPs while they were marching from Parliament to the ECI headquarters in Delhi to demand answers on alleged voter roll manipulation. "Detaining the people's elected voices for peacefully demanding answers for the people's rights is an assault on democracy itself. To arrest people's representatives for seeking transparency is to arrest democracy," Haasan wrote, warning that such actions "cannot stand in a free republic." Framing the issue as a national cause beyond party lines, Mr Haasan urged all political parties, including those in the NDA, to unite for transparency. "Defend the vote, and you defend the republic," he said, calling on citizens to take the demand for reform "from village to town, from town to city, to every corner of India." BJP spokesperson Sudhanshu Trivedi dismissed Mr Gandhi's claims as baseless and accused him of demeaning constitutional institutions. With many independent agencies exposing large-scale irregularities, building on the issue raised by Rahul Gandhi, the issue has turned into a huge embarrassment for the poll panel.
