Outlander's Catriona Balfe 'disappointing' in role of Claire Fraser compared to books according to fans
Outlander star Catriona Balfe has been widely praised for her role as Claire, however some book fans have highlighted the major differences from Diana Gabaldon's description of the leading star.
Outlander fans have divided opinion on how suitable the leading stars of the hit Starz show are in comparison to Diana Gabaldon's book franchise. It has opened the floor to debate on how the characters have transferred on-screen.
Sam Heughan and Catriona Balfe are famed for their roles of Claire and Jamie Fraser. The historical romance series has amassed a global fanbase, after bringing to life Diana Gabaldon's Outlander books.
However one fan has taken to discussion platform Reddit to question the suitability of Irish actress Balfe, as the role of Claire. It comes as the world war II nurse was described in the books as 'curvy' and having completely different coloured eyes, and height.
Sam Heughan has appeared to impress many though, with the Scottish actor being hailed as 'ideal' for the portrayal of Highland warrior Jamie Fraser.
"For Jamie, I feel like there aren't many differences, as I feel like Sam was born to play Jamie, with the subtle difference that he is 3cm shorter than his character. But in Claire we do see more differences between the one in the book and the one in the series?," one fan penned.
They continued, "That doesn't mean Cait doesn't play a great role, I adore her. But when I read, it's a different Claire. Although I have no references. Do you know any famous women that you use as a reference when you imagine Claire because you feel that she is much closer to the one in the books? Or are you just imagining Cait?"
Fans soon took to the forum to weigh in with their opinion, when many fans pointed out that although Balfe's acting is outstanding, her appearance is a far cry from how the books describe Claire Fraser.
One fan said, "I don't see Cait, no. Specially bc Jamie talks a lot about her big a** and hips and Cait... well, she is a very skinny legend supermodel with the longest legs ever. She is almost as tall as Sam."
Another echoed, "No I have a different image for Claire. She's supposed to her head in the middle of Jamie's chest when they stand or lay together. Cait is too tall to be Claire. And the eyes."
A fan quickly responded, "Yes! How many times does Diana write eyes the color of 'verra fine whiskey'?" Someone else said, I'll get downvoted for this, but you asked. I picture Cait, but it's disappointing that's she's so thin. I roll my eyes when I read the books and Jamie talks about her round a** lol."
"I don't picture Caitriona, I picture her as described. Book Claire looks nothing like Cait. The height, and especially the height difference with Jamie, her hair color is described as medium brown and Cait's is close to black, and of course the eyes and lack of curviness (particularly the plump arse) are totally different," added another.
One person suggested, "I always picture Jessica Raine, the actress who played Jenny Lee on Call the Midwife."
Meanwhile, some fans disagreed as they praised Catriona Balfe's portrayal. Many fans had ended up reading Gabaldon's books after watching the show, and could only imagine Cait as Claire.
One person wrote, "I love the way she's described in the books as quite curvy (because I can relate, lol, and it makes sense for Jamie's character to be attracted to a curvy woman esp in that time period) but I loved Cait's performance so much that I just picture her."
Someone else quipped, "I picture Caitriona as Claire, as I saw the show before I read the books. I don't mind her height as it's nice to see romantic character representation for tall women. As with the books and in rl, the tiny women generally get the tall guys."
"I see Cait because the show led me to the books, but my book Claire is so much more than show Claire," added another.
Another fan noted, "I have my own versions of all the characters in my mind when I read. Nothing against the actors. Most of them are fantastic. But the book characters are different people to me."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
23 minutes ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Sex, grief and debauchery: Belfast author on her blazing debut novel about millennial friendship
As post-Sally Rooney Irish lit is booming, the 32-year-old writer talks to Ellie Harrison about her tale of a group of Belfast women who are stumbling through life and loss as they wave goodbye to their 20s We've all got that friend. The one who plonks herself down at the pub table, overflowing with anecdotes about the night before. The one who has the whole group in thrall to her stories, each one a marmalade-dropper in its own right and delivered with panache and killer timing. Whether it's sexual escapades or a slice of office gossip, she's got the tea. It's always a joy hanging out with this friend. A rush. And that's what it feels like reading Thirst Trap, the debut novel from Belfast-born Gráinne O'Hare.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Jaffa Cake lovers have complaint at they admit 'something's changed'
McVities Jaffa Cakes first arrived on the scene almost 100 years ago but recent fans of the sweet treat have expressed their disappointment after sampling them and coming to the same conclusion Jaffa Cake fans have shared a common complaint after spotting a 'difference' in the sweet treat's overall taste. The popular McVities snack is a quintessential British favourite. They're made up of a sponge base with a layer of orange flavoured jam topped with dark chocolate. They were first concocted almost 100 years ago, with many supermarkets and stores up and down the country creating their own versions of Jaffa Cakes. For many though, only the original McVities Jaffa Cake will suffice. The trusty treat is often found in the biscuit aisle, though it is legally considered a cake after a 1991 VAT ruling. Recently, one Jaffa Cakes fan picked up a pack in the supermarket after a few years of not having indulged in one. On Reddit, they explained they didn't 'even wait to get home' before opening the box and tucking in. Sadly, they soon regretted their choice, branding them 'dry'. They explained: 'That 'spongey' bit? It's not the same spongey bit I remember growing up. It's like drywall. 'Well, drywall is a bit far, but it ain't no sponge. I had three, just to make sure I wasn't going crazy, and they were all the same.' Once they got home, they offered them out to friends who agreed with their assessment and 'all said the same thing', convinced they're 'just not the same'. They then asked their fellow Reddit users: 'Has something changed? Have false memories allowed me to remember an absolutely supreme experience whilst munching on these delights? Or have they just decided to change the whole recipe to save a few quid?' They added: 'P.S. The absolute kings of the knock-off Jaffas used to be M&S. I don't dare try them now in case they've followed suit and sucked all the moisture out of theirs as well.' In the comments section, people shared their thoughts - and it seems the majority agree. One Reddit user observed: 'I used to think as you get old your taste buds change or you grew bigger but no, they f***ed with the sizes & recipes.' Another claimed: 'Off-brand Jaffa cakes have been superior for a few years now. Aldi ones are pretty good, M&S too'. Someone else complained about the size of Jaffa Cakes: 'They used to be 12 but now 10 in a packet. They have shrunk as I can easily get one in my gob as 20 odd years ago I would struggle. So that's 10 mouthfuls for me.' And another lamented: 'I'm actually starting to get p***ed off with how literally everything in the shops is crap. McVities Jaffa Cakes are a premium brand, if I am buying them I want the premium quality that ought to come with the premium branding. 'But no, I'm paying a premium price for a fancy box containing a worse tasting and smaller product than Aldi own brand. Might try them again in a decade.'
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
90s Glasgow band back with new album of 'covers and collaborations'
'Being asked to tour Hungary as part of a Scottish contingent for the British Arts Council in 1996,' she says, 'and performing as part of a Creeping Bent Organisation label night at John Peel's Meltdown in 1998.' 'At the first, the audiences were pretty hard core, which The Seret Goldfish definitely is not. The trip is immortalised in the song 4 Excited People." She adds: 'The second was a spectacular night, which included performances by Adventures in Stereo, The Leopards and a brief appearance by Vic Godard, and it was brilliantly compered by the much missed poet, Jock Scot.' The Secret Goldfish will be launching their fourth album, Empty Holster, at a special showcase on June 21 in Glasgow's Glad Café. Ex-Orange Juice guitarist James Kirk will be performing with the band and The Cords will be appearing as special guests. The Secret Goldfish BBC presenter Nicola Meighan will be interviewing Katy about 30 years of The Secret Goldfish, her early music career with the Fizzbombs, and her memoir of music and family, Matilda in the Middle. Nicola will also be interviewing Katy's husband, the musician and songwriter Douglas MacIntyre, about three decades of running The Creeping Bent Organisation record label, which is closing down at the end of the year. Katy Lironi and her husband Douglas MacIntyre (Image: Colin Mearns/Newsquest) Empty Holster has been many years in the gestation, explains Katy, who has been collating songs by her favourite songwriters since 1996. The album tracks have been recorded sporadically over recent decades and were finally completed at Green Door studio in Glasgow and mastered by Samuel Joseph Smith. 'Why now? Well, this is the final year of operation for CBO and I am someone who needs a deadline,' she laughs. 'I guess the planets have just aligned and this is its moment.' It is a record of covers – Holiday Hymn by Subway Sect's Vic Godard, Get on Board by James Kirk and tracks by The Shop Assistants and The Beach Boys – and collaborations, including Adventures in Stereo's Jim Beattie and Davy Henderson of Fire Engines and The Sexual Objects fame. It includes an impressive array of musical guest appearances, including Mick Slaven of The Bluebells, Campbell Owens of Aztec Camera, Francis Macdonald of Teenage Fanclub and Katy and Douglas's daughter Amelia Lironi, of up-and-coming funk-popsters QUAD90. QUAD90 (Image: Chris Hogge) There is also a new song on the album, says Katy. 'Louche Life is a song we wrote with James Kirk and it seemed to fit with the overall spirit of collaboration of the album,' she explains. 'I love working with James because you never quite know what direction he'll take or what lyrics he'll sing. 'We appeared on Marc Riley's 6 Music show a few years ago and James rewrote a whole load of lyrics in the car on the way down to Manchester for the session.' Katy adds: 'Collaboration is the root of all the very best creativity and it also brings out the best in us. 'To have my absolutely favourite songwriters and artists on this album is magical - perfectly topped off by singing in tandem with my daughter Amelia, who was still space-dust when the earliest songs on the album were initially recorded. 'It's fairly surreal.' Katy's book, Matilda in the Middle, is a memoir of music and family. Choir 21 (Image: Ginger Horticulture) 'It's largely about how important music is the lives of many in the Downs syndrome community, my own daughter Matilda included,' she says. 'Bringing out the book has been a highlight of the last year for me and being able to take it to so many festivals has been an amazing experience. 'I've really enjoyed introducing the audiences to Choir 21, the Makaton choir of teens and adults with Ds that I run in my role with Downs syndrome Scotland. 'We took a small contingent from Choir 21 down to the DSS garden at the Chelsea flower show last month. 'We performed an original song, Our Chelsea Anthem, co-written with Douglas and Ken McCluskey of The Bluebells, who are our patrons.' She adds, smiling: 'It was an amazing experience for our young people and Chelsea didn't know what had hit it.' The release of the Empty Holster does not mark the end of The Secret Goldfish – far from it, says Katy. 'There's always another album in the making,' she says. 'And we are always open to touring. When CBO finally comes to a close, we expect to have loads of time between work and family, to fill with more musical adventures.' The Secret Goldfish are at the Glad Café on June 21.
