‘Army Bowing at Modi ji's Feet': Why a Deputy CM's Gaffe Doesn't Bode Well
Menu
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
Politics
'Army Bowing at Modi ji's Feet': Why a Deputy CM's Gaffe Doesn't Bode Well
Badri Raina
5 minutes ago
As of now, India's armed forces swear allegiance to the constitution, not to any person or political authority.
Representative image. Prime Minister Narendra Modi meets armed forces personnel during a visit at the Adampur air base, in Jalandhar, Punjab, Tuesday, May 13, 2025. Photo: PTI
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Contribute now
When the then German president, Paul Von Hindenburg, died in August of 1934, Adolf Hitler combined the posts of president and chancellor.
He thus became Fuhrer, head of both the state and of the armed forces.
Until then, German soldiers were required to take the following oath:
'I swear loyalty to the Constitution and vow that I will protect the German nation and its lawful establishments as a brave soldier at any time and will be obedient to the President and my Superiors.'
Hitler now created a new oath:
'I swear by god this sacred oath that I will render unconditional obedience to Adolf Hitler, the Fuhrer of the German Reich and people, Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces, and will be ready as a brave soldier to risk my life at any time for this oath.'
Never mind that one fall out of this change was that German soldiers often excused whatever atrocities they committed as acts deriving from their oath of loyalty to the Fuhrer.
In our own time, Donald Trump was heard to say during his first term as president of the United States how he would like to have the same kind of loyalty from his Generals as Hitler had from his.
His subsequent denial that he had said so flew rather in the face of the fact on record.
Here at home, flush with the chastisement meted out to a terrorism-spawning Pakistan, the unending cacophony of braggadacio seems now to have culminated in a statement rather potentially ominous.
The honourable deputy chief minister of the BJP-ruled state of Madhya Pradesh, Jagdish Devda, has informed the nation how the armed forces are 'bowing at Modi ji's feet'.
Once again, subsequent sophistries on behalf of the minister have persuaded few.
To Modi ji's credit there is nothing on record thus far to say that he requires the sort of personal allegiance from the armed forces as has been alluded to by the minister.
Nor, on the other hand, has he taken any cognisance of the unconstitutional and degrading aspersion cast by the erring minister both on the armed forces and on him by default.
One imagines that had Jawaharlal Nehru been in his place, the said sycophant minister would have had his ears pulled pronto in public rebuke and rejection.
We recall that Nehru once wrote an anonymous article in The Modern Review, 1937, castigating himself for his dictatorial predilections.
Modi ji has of course often been heard to refer to himself in the third person, as royals were wont to do. Savour his frequently declared 'Modi ki guarantee' as a gold standard of credibility – rather like Caesar's pronouncement in Shakespeare's play Julius Caesar, 'When Caesar says do this, it is done.'
Nor has his tenure been above desiring executive sway (inevitably meaning his own) over institutional mechanisms, to the detriment of the Constitutional injunction about the separation of powers.
As to the army, he has in the past used such epithets as ' mere jawan (my soldiers)' even if as an expansive paternalistic metaphor.
The question that must worry the law-abiding citizen is whether the fawning deputy minister's hyperbole may go uncorrected.
As of now, India's armed forces swear allegiance to the constitution, not to any person or political authority. It is to be hoped that Modi ji will ensure that such allegiance continues to be the authorising legitimation of the life of our soldiers.
The deputy chief minister's gaffe is too serious a matter to be bypassed.
Badri Raina taught at Delhi University.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
'Nation's Army Bowing at Modi's Feet': BJP Leader Sparks Row With Remarks on Operation Sindoor
Row Over Operation Sindoor Message on Train Tickets: Opposition Says Govt 'Using War as Opportunity'
Gujarat Samachar Owner Held by ED, Congress Says Critical Writing Against Modi Govt Led to Arrest
National Unity Cannot Be Celebrated Merely As a Wartime Gimmick
'We May Not Accept Modiji Has Failed But People Are Comparing How Indiraji Stood Up to US Bullying in 1971'
Kharge Alleges Modi Cancelled J&K Visit Due to Intel Report Before Pahalgam Attack
Second Speech in 24 Hours, Modi Invokes Religious Figures But No Mention of Trump Mediation Claims
Anchored in an Unsustainable Plan, Modi's Speech Presented Old Ideas as New, Bold Thinking
Will the Modi Government Carry Out the Caste Census or Will it Remain an Eyewash?
View in Desktop Mode
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
12 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Bengal: 4 held after 8 cops injured, bike torched in Kolkata suburb shop clash
Kolkata: Four men were arrested after eight police personnel, including a woman constable, were injured in a clash between two groups over the opening of a shop in a Kolkata suburb on Wednesday, police said. Stones were pelted, police vehicles were damaged, and a two-wheeler was torched in the middle of the road, officers aware of the development said. The police had to resort to a lathi charge and fire tear gas shells to disperse the mob, following which prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) were imposed. 'Prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the BNSS have been issued. A few police personnel, including an IPS officer, sustained injuries after a mob pelted stones and bricks. Police had to resort to lathi charge and fire tear gas shells to disperse the mob,' a senior officer said. The clash took place close to the Rabindra Nagar police station. The police said that when a team of officers went to the spot to tackle the situation, they were attacked by a mob. 'They came in hundreds and were indiscriminately pelting stones and glass bottles. We were few in number. Many police personnel were injured. A brick hit my head,' a lady police constable said. A large police contingent and the Rapid Action Force (RAF) were deployed to bring the situation under control. 'The situation is now under control. Raids are going on to arrest those who attacked police personnel,' an officer said. Also Read: Bengal: 40-year-old slits wrist after stabbing wife, minor daughter in Hooghly The incident triggered a political row between the ruling Trinamool Congress (TMC) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). 'In Ward No. 7 of Maheshtala Municipality (Metiabruz Assembly), an illegal attempt was made to construct shops right in front of a Shiv temple near Rabindranagar Police Station. When local Hindu residents objected and built a small Tulsi Mandir instead, mobs launched violent attacks on Hindu homes and temples,' BJP's IT cell head Amit Malviya wrote on X. Kolkata's mayor Firhad Hakim said, 'Violence won't be tolerated. Police are doing their job. People of all religions live here peacefully. I am not bothered by what the BJP is saying. They incite communal violence. Strict actions will be taken against those who take law in their own hands.' Suvendu Adhikari, BJP legislator and leader of the opposition in the state legislative assembly, said that BJP legislators will protest in the ongoing assembly session on Thursday.
Time of India
34 minutes ago
- Time of India
Full India-US trade pact may take time; govt awaits clarity on Trump's policy
India-US trade deal (Representative AI image) NEW DELHI: While India and the US work towards finalising an "initial tranche" of the proposed trade deal before July 9, the full bilateral trade agreement may take a few months as the Trump administration is yet to spell out its policy on trade, beyond using tariffs to get countries on the negotiating table. A long-lasting agreement will require the US to move beyond a case-by-case approach, which can form the basis for a durable agreement, sources said. Besides, there are issues, such as how the tariff cuts committed by the US Trade Representative will be implemented, as there is no clarity on whether the reduction will need to be cleared by the US Congress. Already, the legal challenge to Trump's reciprocal tariffs has created some uncertainty on how the duties cuts will be negotiated. After a meeting between PM Modi and Trump in Feb, the two countries had agreed to negotiate a bilateral trade deal by Fall (Sept-Oct), before the US President decided to roll out reciprocal tariffs on April 2, only to suspend it later. Even the deal that the Trump administration has managed to negotiate with the UK and China are not final agreements but are in the nature of interim trade agreements, given the repeated flip-flops. These also include the American president focusing on certain sectors. For instance, while successive US administrations have made a case for lower duty for Harley Davidson (although it uses its Asia plant to ship superbikes), the push to lower duties for cars was seen in the context of Tesla boss Elon Musk's close ties with Trump, until the bitter fallout last week. While negotiating the agreement with the US, govt has some key factors in mind: One, it wants to secure the best possible deal for its businesses so that they can get market access in return for lower duties in India. Sources have argued that an agreement will give American companies access to a market of close to 1.5 billion people. Two, govt is keeping a close eye on how the tariffs are being reset for other countries as competitiveness is a key parameter for Indian exporters. Unlike some of the countries, which offer dollops of subsidy for their businesses, govt only provides refunds of actual taxes and duties. Three, govt is keen to ensure that its sensitivities in several segments, such as agriculture, in segments like staples are fully on board. In any case, the current negotiations are focused on goods trade, along with trade facilitation & customs and rules or origin, with India's interests in services not getting addressed at the moment.
Indian Express
36 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Delhi Confidential: Matching Barricades
After the new Parliament building was inaugurated in 2023, the Parliament House complex has seen a range of new features — from landscaping to relocation of statues to new uniforms for staff. Soon, visitors to the complex would get to see 'aesthetically pleasing' barricades in place of the usual ones placed by the security. The CPWD has designed the barricades to match the look of the new building, in the same red sandstone colour and cast iron design mimicking the jaalis inside. The triangular Parliament building will be displayed at the centre of it. Now that the government has announced that there is no special session to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the Emergency declaration, the BJP is considering a plan to conduct mock parliament sessions across the country. Party sources said there is a suggestion that mock sessions showing how Parliament passed the 42nd amendment of the Constitution — during the Emergency to centralise power and curtail judiciary — should be conducted in every district. The controversial remarks made during the debate, including the one made by Congress leader C M Stephen daring the courts to defy Parliament (he had said 'I don't know whether they (courts) will have the temerity to defy this Parliament. If they do it, we have our machinery) will be played in the mock parliament sessions.
