UGC to strengthen scrutiny on ‘Not Found Suitable' decisions in faculty hiring
The government is moving to tighten control over the controversial 'Not Found Suitable' (NFS) provision used in faculty recruitment across universities, according to a report by TOI.
A committee set up by the University Grants Commission (UGC) is expected to recommend that every instance of NFS be formally reported to the commission for review.
Universities will be required to justify each case where no suitable candidate is found, allowing the UGC to examine the reasons and offer corrective guidance or alternative recruitment options, TOI further reported.
Addressing misuse
This step comes amid concerns that the NFS clause has been misused to block candidates from Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBC) from securing academic positions.
The issue has also sparked political debates, with the BJP accusing the Congress of historically manipulating recruitments under the NFS pretext, while opposition parties argue that vacancies have surged under the current government. The UGC committee, formed on June 19, is tasked with investigating the extent and root causes of the problem. Early findings indicate that many vacancies in central universities are due to claims of 'non-availability of suitable candidates' despite advertised posts. This has been a recurring concern in parliamentary discussions and other official forums.The panel will conduct a detailed analysis of university-wise and category-wise data to determine if NFS rulings have contributed to unequal representation of reserved categories. It will also suggest measures to bridge such gaps.According to the report, under the new oversight plan, universities must submit comprehensive reports whenever candidates meeting eligibility criteria are declared 'not suitable.'
Government sources told TOI that they believe this enhanced review will uncover any biases, procedural flaws, and recommend appropriate actions such as conducting fresh recruitment drives or focused outreach to qualified applicants from underrepresented groups.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
14 minutes ago
- Indian Express
For ‘creamy layer' exclusion, Govt looks at proposal on ‘equivalence' across govt organisations, pvt sector, universities
The government is learnt to be actively considering a proposal to apply the Other Backward Classes 'creamy layer' income exclusion yardstick to attain 'equivalence' among various Central and state government organisations, public sector enterprises, universities and private sector employees. It is learnt that the proposal has been prepared following consultations among the ministries of Social Justice and Empowerment, Education, Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT), Legal Affairs, Labour and Employment, Public Enterprises, NITI Aayog and National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC). Following the landmark Indra Sawhney vs Union Of India ruling, also known as the Mandal verdict, by the Supreme Court in 1992, the concept of 'creamy layer' within the OBCs was introduced in the reservation policy. The 'creamy layer' criteria for those not in government jobs, set at Rs 1 lakh per annum in 1993, was revised in 2004, 2008, 2013. In 2017, the income ceiling was revised to Rs 8 lakh per annum and has remained so ever since. The 'creamy layer' specifies groups among OBCs such as persons occupying constitutional posts; Group-A/Class-I officers of All India Services, Central services and state services; Group-B/Class-II services of Centre and state; employees of PSUs; officers of armed forces; professionals and those from trade and industry; property owners; and an income/wealth test. While 'equivalence' in some Central PSUs was decided in 2017, it remained pending for the private sector as well as universities, educational institutions and different organisations of state governments. The OBCs of the 'non-creamy' layer are granted 27 per cent reservation in Central government recruitments as well as in admissions to educational institutions, based on the Mandal Commission recommendations. In state governments, this reservation percentage varies. In absence of such equivalence, there was difficulty in issuing caste certificates to OBCs. Sources said since the salary of teaching staff of universities, such as assistant professors, associate professors and professors, typically starts from Level 10 and above, which is equivalent to or higher than Group-A posts in the government, there is a proposal that these posts be categorised as 'creamy layer'. This means their children cannot avail benefits of OBC reservation. In the private sector, given the vast gamut of categories of posts and pay and perquisites, it has been noted that it is difficult to establish the equivalence. It is proposed that this can be determined based on the income/wealth criteria. For Central/state autonomous bodies and Central/state statutory organisations, sources said it is proposed to establish equivalence with the list of Central government officials, depending on their level/group/pay scale, as the case may be, because they also adopt the pay scales of respective categories in Central and state governments. Similarly, non-teaching staff of universities are proposed to be placed as creamy layer depending on their level/group/pay scale as the case may be. For state PSUs, it is proposed that as in the case of equivalence in Central PSUs in 2017, all executive level positions, including board-level executives as well as below board-level executives holding managerial positions, are to be treated as under the 'creamy layer' category. However, in their case, a rider has been proposed that those executives whose income is within Rs 8 lakh, which is presently the limit for private persons, will not be categorised as 'creamy layer'. For government-aided institutions, it is proposed that as they generally follow the service conditions and pay scales of the respective Central or state government, the staff in aided institutions may be placed under appropriate categories based on the equivalence of their post and service conditions and pay scales/level. Sources said a large number of cases are pending before the Supreme Court and various High Courts regarding the ambiguity and, therefore, clarity is a must. 'The proposal entails empowerment of OBCs by way of their coverage which will widen the employment opportunities for OBCs,' a top source said, adding that 'by widening the scope of opportunities for OBCs in employment, it will support Atmanirbhar Bharat.'
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
‘Mystery call' tells Malda man of return of son pushed to B'desh
Kolkata/Malda: Pushed into Bangladesh illegally on June 28 by Rajasthan Police and BSF, 22-year-old Malda migrant labourer Amir Sheikh has been brought back to an undisclosed location in India. Bengal govt said it has not been "officially" informed of the development. The news came a day ahead of Calcutta High Court's hearing of a habeas corpus plea moved by Amir's father, Jiyem Sk. Jiyem had alleged that his youngest son was "secretly deported to Bangladesh". On Tuesday, Jiyem told TOI: "We received two anonymous calls informing us that Amir has returned to India. When we wanted to know more, the calls were disconnected. The caller only said he would say as much. We are hoping and praying for Amir's safe return." You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata | Gold Rates Today in Kolkata | Silver Rates Today in Kolkata Bengal Migrant Workers' Welfare Board chairperson and Rajya Sabha MP Samirul Islam said: "Because of the immense pressure that we exerted — both legally and administratively — they are now on the back foot and attempting to bring Amir Sheikh back through the back door with the help of BSF." Malda South Congress MP Isha Khan Chowdhury also told reporters in Delhi that Amir was back in India, hinting that some legal processes were pending. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Back Pain Treatments That Might Surprise You! Back Pain Treatment | Search Ads Undo Kaliachak-I BDO Satyajit Halder also said he was aware of such reports but had no official confirmation. The development caps several tumultuous months for Amir, whose viral video from Bangladesh on July 2, sobbing inconsolably and pleading for help, prompted strong reactions in Bengal. According to the petition in HC, on April 3, Amir migrated to Paradip in Odisha and then to Sikar in Rajasthan in search of livelihood. He was employed in Rajasthan as a labourer. On June 25, Rajasthan Police officers, accompanied by armed BSF personnel, conducted an identity-verification drive at Amir's worksite and "forcibly detained him without any communication of grounds or procedural safeguards". He was held in a detention facility outside Sikar. On June 28, he was allegedly pushed to Bangladesh. Islam said: "Interestingly, there was no way to repatriate Amir except through legal intervention, as he was tagged under a case involving illegal entry into Bangladesh. Central govt is now trying to repatriate Amir to his Malda home to save face." A senior official said Amir, once back in India, has to be produced in a local court so that the charges labelling him as an illegal Bangladeshi are dismissed. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
‘Tricolour at every home is our pride, honour and self-respect'
Lucknow/Ayodhya: Deputy CM Brajesh Pathak joined the Tiranga Yatra in the Milkipur Assembly area of Ayodhya along with hundreds of people on Tuesday. Leading the procession in Kumarganj, Pathak said the tricolour at every home is our pride, honor, and self-respect. The deputy CM said the aim of the 'Har Ghar Tiranga' campaign is to encourage every Indian family to proudly hoist the national flag, fostering a sense of unity, patriotism, and national pride. MLA Chandrababu Paswan also joined the yatra with his supporters. TNN Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
