Florida's Housing Market 'Turning Down Fast'
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
The Florida housing market is "turning down fast," according to real estate analyst Nick Gerli, as sellers are increasingly offering reluctant buyers dramatic price cuts to convince them to close a purchase.
Gerli, founder and CEO of real-estate platform Reventure, shared on X, formerly Twitter, late last month, a Zillow listing of a home in Saint Petersburg, Florida, which was bought by an investor in 2022—the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic homebuying frenzy—for a staggering $550,000 and sold again in late March for a much more reasonable $391,000.
"Twenty-eight percent loss in three years," Gerli wrote in his post.
Why It Matters
The Sunshine State's housing market exploded during the pandemic, when the rise of remote work enabled many out-of-state movers to relocate to more affordable parts of the country offering a better quality of life than the country's busiest metropolises.
The newcomers rapidly increased demand as well as prices across Florida, investors flocked to the state chasing what at the time seemed like sure-fire opportunities, and builders received authorization for building thousands of new homes to keep up with buyers.
But Florida's once red-hot housing market started showing signs of a significant cooldown over the past year, as domestic migration shrank compared to the pandemic boom, housing costs rose sharply, and the threat of more frequent, more severe natural disasters and higher home insurance premiums swayed some buyers away from the state.
The result is that prices have started to drop across much of the state, as historically high mortgage rates are still putting a significant damper on demand, despite growing inventory giving buyers more options. The median sale price of a home in Florida in April, according to Redfin, was $409,900, down 3.2 percent from a year earlier. Home sales were down 8.8 percent from April 2024, at 33,667.
Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Getty
What To Know
Gerli pointed at a home listing in Saint Petersburg as a glaring example of the dynamics unfolding in the state. The property, a three-bedroom home built in 1960 and sitting on 1,703 square feet of land, is estimated by Zillow to be worth about $386,800, having risen in value by 157 percent in the past 10 years.
According to the property's price history, the home was sold in July 1999 for $93,000 and then again in December 2021 for $255,000. At the peak of the pandemic homebuying frenzy, in March 2022, it was listed for sale for $499,900, but the listing was later removed.
The property was listed and sold again in April 2022 for an even higher price tag—$550,000—to a Blackstone-owned entity, according to Gerli. The new owner then listed it for sale again in February 2024 for a lower price, $529,000 and then offered four different price cuts in the following months.
The listing was removed and reposted several times, until the home was sold on March 21, 2025 for $391,000—a drop of nearly $160,000 from the amount it fetched in 2022.
"The house sat on the market for a year, and they incrementally lowered the price until finally it sold," Gerli said. According to the analyst, there was no clear issue with the property. "This does not appear to be a hurricane-damaged property, as they had already cut the price down to $431K (22-percent loss from purchase) before the hurricanes hit," he wrote on X.
"After the hurricane hit, the price went down another $40K (7 percent)."
For Gerli, the fate of this home in Saint Petersburg shows what can happen when investors get involved in a market, contributing to its overheating and then its downturn.
"Investors had a huge impact in driving the Florida real estate bubble during the pandemic boom years of 2020 and 2021," he told Newsweek.
Gerli added: "In markets like Jacksonville and Orlando, investor purchases nearly doubled from the pre-pandemic norm. Since then, they have collapsed by 50-60 percent from peak, leaving a gaping hole in the market. Many investors are now also electing to sell, particularly big Wall Street Investors, because the economics of owning real estate in Florida no longer make sense due to stagnating rents and skyrocketing insurance costs."
On X, he wrote: "Imagine being a neighbor on this street, and getting excited about how much the value of your neighborhood was increasing. Only to now look at the new sales comp, and realize that the marginal buyer is now paying 28 percent less than three years ago. This is what investors do. Make the boom bigger on the way up, but the crash bigger on the way down."
According to Gerli, investors are backing out of Florida for three main reasons—including high interest rates, rising housing costs and falling rents.
"Higher interest rates significantly increased the cost of capital for investors, who almost always use debt to finance their acquisitions. Higher debt costs mean it's difficult to earn cash flow, making owning real estate a less attractive option," he said.
"Second are the costs of holding real estate in Florida. Both property tax and insurance rates have skyrocketed in Florida over the last three years, further hurting investor margins and lowering the incentive to buy," he added.
Gerli continued: "Third is the rental market. Rents in many areas of Florida are now dropping on a year-over-year basis, which makes the whole thesis of owning cash-flow driven real estate hard to justify, especially in market that is in a bubble like Florida. Many investors see this as their last chance to sell out before the prices and rents drop further."
What Happens Next
According to Gerli and most housing experts who talked with Newsweek, what is happening in Florida is the natural correction that you would expect to follow years of overheating. Many locals in the Sunshine State have been priced out of the market in recent years, and without investors buying up properties, demand has naturally come down.
Investors backing off the market could exacerbate these dynamics, accelerating downward pressure on prices and forcing other sellers to slash prices to sell their homes.
"Investors rushing to the exits is already destabilizing the market in Florida and making the downturn worse," Gerli told Newsweek. "In some neighborhoods around Tampa and St. Petersburg, there are examples of investors selling houses at 20-25 percent losses from their purchase price in 2022. These sales are now entering the comps and significantly lowering the values of homes in the surrounding area."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
10 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Elon Musk's teen prodigy Kairan Quazi is ditching SpaceX for billionaire Ken Griffin's Citadel Securities
At just 16 years old, Kairan Quazi has already gained accolades most engineers spend decades accumulating. He graduated from college, helped design software for SpaceX Starlink satellites, and turned down offers from Silicon Valley's buzzy AI labs. Now, the prodigy is taking his next leap—not in Silicon Valley, but on Wall Street, where he's joining Citadel Securities, a liquidity provider, as a quant developer. A defiant attitude Quazi's path has been unconventional from the start. At 9, he left third grade for community college, went on to intern at Intel Labs at 10, and transferred to Santa Clara University at 11, eventually becoming the youngest graduate in its 172-year history. In 2023, he made headlines when Elon Musk's SpaceX hired him at just 14 years old. A 'rare company,' Quazi said at the time, that didn't use his age as an 'arbitrary and outdated proxy for maturity and ability.' The same year, he sparred with Microsoft-owned LinkedIn after it locked him out of the platform for being under 16, blasting the decision as 'illogical, primitive nonsense.' In fact, Quazi has never been shy about critiquing the traditional system that held him back. Once LinkedIn allowed him back on to their platform, Quazi posted a comment slamming the conventional school system. The 16-year-old argued that 'tests are not used to measure mastery, but the ability to regurgitate' and that the modern 'school factory' rewards fear and prestige-chasing over learning. 'Age, privilege, and unconscious (sometimes even conscious) biases are used to gatekeep opportunities,' he wrote, adding that philosophers like Seneca the Younger and Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius might have seen today's education system as dangerous. Two years later, Quazi is channeling that same defiance into a different arena. He turned down offers from top AI startups and tech firms to join Citadel Securities this week in New York, citing the firm's culture of meritocracy and instant feedback. 'Quant finance offers a pretty rare combination: the complexity and intellectual challenge that AI research also provides, but with a much faster pace,' he told Business Insider. At Citadel Securities he said, he'll be able to see the results of his work in 'days, not months or years.' A win-win Citadel Securities—sister company to the well-known Citadel—for its part, has every reason to trumpet the win. The firm, which handles roughly 35% of U.S. retail stock trades and generated nearly $10 billion in revenue in 2024, is locked in a talent war with the likes of OpenAI, Anthropic, and xAI. Recruiting a prodigy who was once deemed too young for LinkedIn—but now works at the intersection of engineering and quantitative problem-solving—is a symbolic coup for Ken Griffin's trading powerhouse. For Quazi, the move also closes a personal loop. His mother worked in mergers and acquisitions as an investment banker, giving him early exposure to finance. And on campus, he saw how coveted quant jobs had become for math and computer-science students. 'It's one of the most prestigious industries you could go into as a computer scientist or mathematician,' he told Business Insider. Now, he's living that reality in New York City. Quazi has moved into an apartment just a 10-minute walk from Citadel Securities' Park Avenue office. 'New York has a very special place in my heart,' he said, noting that his mom grew up in Astoria, Queens. Unlike his time at SpaceX, where his mother had to drive him to work in Redmond, Wash., Quazi's commute is now his own: first on foot, and soon, by subway. 'I felt ready to take on new challenges and expand my skill set into a different high-performance environment,' he said. 'Citadel Securities offered a similarly ambitious culture, but also a completely new domain, which is very exciting for me.' Jackie Scharnick, Citadel's communications director, said Quazi would pass on an interview with Fortune so he could 'focus on his second day of work.' This story was originally featured on Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Wall Street Journal
19 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Hamas Accepts Temporary Cease-Fire Proposal - What's News
Full Transcript This transcript was prepared by a transcription service. This version may not be in its final form and may be updated. Sabrina Siddiqui: Hamas accepts a temporary ceasefire after rejecting a proposal to end the war. Anat Peled: This plan really comes with this looming Israeli threat of basically a military invasion and takeover of Gaza City, where hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are believed to be sheltering and some Israeli hostages are believed to be held. Sabrina Siddiqui: Plus, Home Depot says it will raise some prices due to tariffs. And a leading pediatrics group is recommending Covid shots for young children, diverging from federal health guidelines. It's Tuesday, August 19th. I'm Sabrina Siddiqui for The Wall Street Journal covering for Alex Ossola. This is the PM edition of What's News, the top headlines and business stories that move the world today. Home building in the US increased last month, contradicting expectations that it would fall amid a fragile housing market. According to a report released by the Commerce Department today, housing starts, a gauge of new residential construction, rose to 1.428 million in July from an upwardly revised 1.358 million in June. Economists polled by The Wall Street Journal had anticipated a lower 1.3 million starts. Today's report says the housing starts were 12.9% higher than a year earlier. But residential permits, another measure of trends in housing construction, fell short of forecasts and slipped to 1.354 million from a downwardly revised 1.393 million in June. The National Association of Home Builders said the increase in housing starts occurred despite a slight decline in builder sentiment due to persistently high mortgage rates. Tariffs will soon start hitting some price tags at Home Depot. The home improvement retailer said it will raise prices on some items due to tariffs, reversing an earlier position. In an interview, Chief Financial Officer Richard McPhail said there will be some modest price movement for some categories. The company said that 50% of its products are sourced domestically and aren't subject to tariffs. Wall Street Journal reporter, Nicholas Miller, joins me now to discuss. Nicholas, the company previously said it wouldn't raise prices as a result of tariffs. What changed and what do they now anticipate the impact of tariffs to be? Nicholas Miller: The simple answer is that just tariffs are a lot higher right now than they were in May. In May, they said they were going to try to hold prices and work with suppliers that they don't have to pass tariff costs on to consumers. But they talked today about how they'll be having some modest price increases in certain categories. They said it won't be broad based, but that certain categories, particularly the ones that are impacted by tariffs, will see some modest price increases. They did say that they're still accelerating their supply chain transition to avoid too much exposure to one country. But yeah, this kind of admission that they were going to hike prices a little bit is definitely a notable shift from last quarter. Sabrina Siddiqui: How does Home Depot see the current market and consumer behavior? Nicholas Miller: Home Depot mostly talked today about consumers being unwilling to undertake those larger projects. So they're saying they're still seeing demand for small projects, small renovation projects, but not big renovations. And the company said the number one reason for that was general economic uncertainty, people being unwilling to make some of those big expenditures, not knowing what the future of the economy looks like. And then the second reason they gave was high interest rates. A lot of those big renovations are funded through debt financing and that kind of thing, and whereas the smaller projects are through cash. Just because of high interest rates, it's really pretty expensive to take on debt right now. Home Depot also talked about how home equity values have really skyrocketed in the last couple of years. So theoretically that should give people a lot of the money that they can tap into to fund renovations and that kind of thing. But they're seeing customers do that at very low levels compared with history. And the company talked about potentially seeing a boost when interest rates are lowered and the housing market picks back up. And they also referenced how the tax law Trump recently passed could maybe put discretionary money in consumers pockets, but for now, they're still in wait and see mode. Sabrina Siddiqui: Nicholas Miller is a reporter at The Wall Street Journal. Nicholas, thank you. Nicholas Miller: Thank you so much. Sabrina Siddiqui: Stocks fell in US markets. The Nasdaq was dragged down nearly 1.5% by declines in all Magnificent Seven stocks. The S&P declined 0.6%, closing near its lows on the day, and the Dow ended the day marginally higher 0.02%. NorthWestern Energy Group and Black Hills have agreed to combine to form a large $7.8 billion regulated electric and natural gas utility company. The announcement comes at a time of climbing energy demand across the US. In a joint statement today, the two companies said that their boards approved a definitive agreement to combine in an all stock tax-free merger with a combined enterprise value of $15.4 billion. The merger will create a utility serving roughly 2.1 million customers across eight states. And Alphabet's Google has offered to change terms and conditions for developers using its Play Store in a bid to stave off a potential fine under European Union tech rules. In a blog post today, Google said it would alter developer fees for app downloads and make it easier to lead users to deals and offers outside of its own app store. Google said it would allow developers to steer users to app purchases outside of the Play Store through their own websites and introduced an alternative fee structure for those developers. But the company warned that links leading outside the Play Store can expose users to security threats. The move comes after the European Commission, the EU's executive arm and antitrust watchdog, told Google earlier this year that it believed current Play Store rules might be in breach of the bloc's relatively new rulebook designed to reign in Big Tech market power. Coming up, Hamas has accepted a proposal for a temporary ceasefire in Gaza. How will Israel respond? That's after the break. Hamas has accepted a proposal for a temporary ceasefire in Gaza and the release of Israeli hostages in exchange for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners. The proposal which is similar to terms offered by Israel in July, follows a round of tense talks over the weekend in Cairo between Palestinian factions and officials from Egypt and Qatar. Israel is currently weighing whether to accept the deal and will likely give a response later this week. Anat Peled, a Wall Street Journal reporter in Tel Aviv has the story. Anat, you reported that this offer is very similar to a proposal from Israel last month. What has changed for Hamas since then? Anat Peled: Since the last proposal, Hamas has come slightly more to Israel's position. It's softened its terms on a few issues, including agreeing to accept a lower number of Palestinian prisoners from Israeli prisons, and also has agreed to a larger Israeli buffer zone inside Gaza as Israel wants. But it still demands an end to the war, which is something that Israel for a long time was not willing to commit to. It has vowed to fight the Hamas militant group until it's completely defeated. Sabrina Siddiqui: What are some of the other terms that are outlined in this latest plan from Hamas? Anat Peled: It's pretty straightforward. It's a sixty-day ceasefire where basically Israel would receive about half of the living remaining hostages, which is 10, and the bodies of deceased hostages. And then it would be an exchange for a temporary ceasefire of 60 days and Palestinian prisoners. And according to the proposal, on the first day when they go into this agreement, they would start talking and negotiating for a second phase, which would be a lasting ceasefire. So an end to the war, which is really what Hamas has been adamant about. Sabrina Siddiqui: Based on your reporting, are these terms enough for Israel to accept the plan? Anat Peled: We're unsure how Israel's going to respond. Israel is supposed to hand over its response to the mediators by the end of the week. It comes after Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, indicated that he did not want any more partial deals, wanted to go for one big deal to end everything, but they have not ruled it out so far. And it is important to note that Israel is right now facing increased international pressure. So we're seeing that from many European countries that are very worried about the dire humanitarian crisis in Gaza, including widespread hunger. And then you also have increasing domestic pressure where we're seeing about 80% of Israeli public opinion supports ending the war in exchange for the remaining hostages. And we saw some of the largest protests since the start of the war with hundreds of thousands of Israelis taking to the streets on Sunday, calling to end the war. Sabrina Siddiqui: You mentioned the dire conditions on the ground in Gaza. What would this plan mean for the delivery of humanitarian aid and also for Israel's stated plans to take control of Gaza City? Anat Peled: This plan really comes with this looming Israeli threat of basically a military invasion and takeover of Gaza City, where hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are believed to be sheltering and some Israeli hostages are believed to be held. Israel's plan, as we understand it according to Israeli and Egyptian officials, is to basically move all of the population of Gaza City to Rafah, where Israel plans to establish this tent city, moving the population to an ever-shrinking territory inside Gaza because Israel says that it controls about 75% of the strips. So this would be further displacing them. We're not quite sure what it means for humanitarian aid. Humanitarian aid, it's been in the spotlight recently because we have the UN aid coming in, but we also have this privatized system of aid that's run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which is backed by Israel and the US. And that's been a pretty controversial system, and Hamas has not been a fan of that. So we need to still see how that's going to play out in negotiations. Sabrina Siddiqui: Anat Peled is a reporter for The Wall Street Journal based in Tel Aviv. Anat, thank you. Anat Peled: Thanks for having me. Sabrina Siddiqui: And finally, the American Academy of Pediatrics is recommending parents vaccinate their young children against Covid in a departure from current federal health leaders who have questioned the need for Covid shots for kids, and shifted the guidance. The prominent pediatrician group released its immunization guidelines today and recommended Covid shots for all children ages six months through 23 months. The group said children in that age group are particularly vulnerable to severe Covid infections and that the vaccines would protect them from serious illness. The guidance differs from that of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which now recommends parents of children ages six months to 17 years old talk about the risks and benefits of the Covid vaccine with their doctors. The agency previously recommended adults and children ages six months and older get Covid vaccines, but that changed this year under the leadership of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a longtime vaccine skeptic. A Health and Human Services spokesman, said in a statement that the Academy is "undermining national immunization policymaking with baseless political attacks." And that's what's news for this Tuesday afternoon. Today's show was produced by Pierre Bienaimé with supervising producer, Michael Kosmides. I'm Sabrina Siddiqui for The Wall Street Journal. We'll be back with a new show tomorrow morning. Thanks for listening.
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Senior recoups $10K after being forced out of Winnipeg assisted living facility for renos that never happened
A landlord that ordered over a dozen seniors out of a Winnipeg assisted living facility for renovations in 2023 has paid back thousands of dollars to one resident, after the building was vacated and sold without any renovations ever being done. James Beckta was awarded just over $10,000 after the Residential Tenancies Commission ruled that his former landlord owed him compensation for nine months of additional rent and tenant services he'd paid for after moving out of a Winnipeg assisted living facility in 2023. Beckta, now 80, moved out of the Assiniboine Links, an assisted living facility housed in the historic Odd Fellows Home at 4025 Roblin Blvd., in June 2023, according to the decision by RTC's chief commissioner Nunziata Masi dated July 25. Beckta and other tenants of the assisted-living facility received notices telling them to move out within months for major planned renovations, the decision says. Under legislation, landlords can order residents to move out if planned renovations require the building and/or units to be empty. Paul Beckta, James' son, says they scrambled to find another assisted living facility. The facility that his father moved to in June 2023 had considerably higher fees because it was being run by a for-profit organization, according to the decision. Beckta later moved into a more affordable facility in June 2024, after being on a waitlist for a year. Paul says the moves impacted his father, who suffers from dementia. "Every time you move someone who's progressing through dementia, they take a decline," he said. Before it closed, the Odd Fellows, an international fraternal group, operated Assiniboine Links as a non-profit offered rent and tenant services at a reduced cost thanks to a heavy reliance on volunteers, but the building's ownership group sought a developer to take over the complex after deciding to retire, Masi's decision says. Running the facility became "unsustainable" for the group after the COVID-19 pandemic led to a drop in volunteers, the decision says. There were 17 residents in the building when tenants were notified of the planned renovations and told to leave, CBC News learned at the time. The building was sold in 2022 to the same developer who had planned to build a 199-unit apartment complex next to it. The City of Winnipeg approved that project, but the Manitoba Municipal Board — a board of provincial appointees that was given expanded powers in 2021, allowing it to reverse Winnipeg city council decisions on a variety of land-use decisions — overruled the city's approval after nearby residents complained. The ownership group later struck a new deal with the developer, but the developer was no longer willing to accept the group's condition that said the assisted living facility should be maintained for at least a year after taking possession of the building, according to Masi's decision. The new agreement required the building to be vacant, and the developer told the landlord they would renovate the complex, the decision says. "The developer ultimately did not renovate and instead sold the building to another landlord, who is now operating the complex as an independent living complex, without having done the renovations," Masi wrote. Masi ruled that the ownership group owed Beckta money for nine months of rent and tenant services after he moved into a different facility. Legislation that allows landlords to remove tenants for planned renovations is not "intended as a tool to provide a purchaser with vacant possession," she wrote. 'A battle' Paul, who acted on behalf of his father during the hearings, says an initial claim against the landlord seeking compensation for rent was dismissed, but his father was granted compensation for moving expenses and an unreturned damage deposit. Paul later appealed the decision to the Residential Tenancies Commission, asking it to decide whether a tenant — who exercises their right to terminate a tenancy after a landlord ends their lease agreement for extensive renovations — is still entitled to compensation for moving expenses and to seek additional compensation if the landlord fails to renovate. Paul said he's relieved that the commission ultimately sided with his father. "I think he gets it. He remembers what happened," Paul said. "I told him, like, 'Hey, we won.' He smiled." Paul described the process as "a battle," even for someone like him, who has experience working in government and reading policy. "Hopefully, the former tenants that were there can use this as a means to go and argue and win." His advice to others going through the residential tenancies process is to "know the rules and ask questions." "It's been about two years since all this happened, [and] by the end — however it was going to go — I was glad it was done," he said. "But for me, it also came down to my parents [who] instilled in me at a young age, strong values of what's right and what's wrong." CBC News has reached out to Assiniboine Links' former ownership group for comment.
