In Mandi, Kangana Ranaut's statements beg the question — is this the MP its people deserve?
Since June, Himachal Pradesh has been experiencing cloud bursts that have led to flash floods. Many people have lost their lives, and damage to property has been estimated at over Rs 400 crore. When the elected MP from the region, Hindi film actor Ranaut, was asked by the media what she was doing for relief, she said, 'I don't have any cabinet or funds for disaster relief… I have my two brothers, that's my cabinet… MPs are very small in the scheme of things.'
Perhaps, in a state run by the Opposition, this may be partially true — Ranaut is a Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MP, and the state is governed by the Indian National Congress (INC). But she still has at her disposal the Members of Parliament Local Area Development Scheme (MPLADS), an annual entitlement of Rs 5 crore for developmental work in her constituency, including for events such as the ongoing floods. This then is both a dereliction of duty and a lack of empathy.
But, even if Ranaut had managed to muster empathy for the families left to rebuild their homes and businesses, as they struggle to cope with the loss of loved ones, the questions would still remain: Is Ranaut really the politician people deserve?
Flash floods are not new to the mountains. There has been a deluge of flash floods in the Himalayan region of Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand for the past several years. They occur when intense rainfall overwhelms the land's ability to absorb water, causing sudden, high-speed runoff. They're often triggered by cloudbursts or deforestation. A major contributing factor is also unchecked construction or developmental work that exact a high environmental cost.
An MP obviously cannot fix the vagaries of nature. But she can, if she so chooses, amplify the pitfalls of unplanned construction and the ecological damage and devastation they wreak. She can push the government, at the Centre and state, to take corrective action. She can ensure that people at the receiving end have an ally in her. Eighty dead, 31 missing, over 150 homes and 106 cattle shelters destroyed, 14 bridges collapsed, and 31 vehicles swept away. In such circumstances, when Ranaut chooses not to use her voice, it is a deliberate letdown of the very people who have elected her to represent them.
Film stars have always had a penchant for politics. From Amitabh Bachchan to Hema Malini, Jaya Prada to Jaya Bachchan, actors have forayed into politics. Barring Jaya Bachchan, few have managed to live up to the demands of the job. But if the rising floodwaters make one thing clear, it is this: We need public servants who are ready to serve. We need doers, not performers.
In a recent podcast conversation with spiritual mentor Ravi V Melwani, Ranaut opened up about not enjoying her work as a politician. 'I don't enjoy it. I've never thought of serving people… I've lived a very selfish kind of life. I want to have a big house and a big car. I want to have diamonds.'
This isn't a gotcha moment; it is a moment of clarity, if there ever was one.
Indurkar is a writer, editor, and poet from Jabalpur
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
21 minutes ago
- Time of India
Crude awakening for Nayara as geopolitics sounds alarm; symbol of Indo-Russian ties hit hard by West penalty
Mumbai: In August 2017, nine months after a consortium led by Russia's Rosneft bought Essar Oil's 20-mtpa refinery in Vadinar (Gujarat), it was renamed Nayara Energy . The name derives from the Hindi word 'Naya' (new) and 'Era.' It was chosen to signify its shareholders' vision of bringing a new era of development to the asset. Nayara was born at a time India's petroleum sector was undergoing reform - the government had deregulated fuel retail prices, giving private fuel retailers such as Nayara an equal footing to expand their outlets. The reform gave sleepless nights for state-run oil marketing companies, which had hitherto dominated fuel retailing. Now, they feared losing market share to private players Nayara and Reliance Industries . All was well with Nayara and it was on a growth trajectory until it was hemmed in by both the US and the European Union (EU), as they stepped up efforts to target Russia over its invasion of Ukraine. Its oil and energy revenue was low-hanging fruit. The company, once seen as a symbol of India-Russia economic cooperation, is now navigating a perfect storm - sanctions, global shipping disruptions, domestic regulatory pressure, a leadership churn and a digital infrastructure scare. Nayara did not respond to ET's emailed query as of press time. Russian Link For a company that accounts for nearly 8% of India's refining output and 7% of its retail petrol pump network, these challenges are testing Nayara's resilience as well as long-term strategy. Russia's national energy firm and a consortium of international investors Trafigura and UCP Investment Group had acquired the Essar asset for $12.9 billion. This was Rosneft's largest foreign investment in India's refining sector, providing it an entry into one of the fastest-growing world markets. Nayara Energy owns the second-largest private refinery in India, as well as an oil depot terminal, a port, infrastructure and a chain of more than 6,000 fuel stations. It is this spate of expansion that is now threatened. On July 18, the EU unleashed its 18th package of sanctions on Russia, which included restrictions on import of fuels refined from that nation's crude, slashing the price cap on Russian oil to $47.6 per barrel from $60 and targeting the shadow fleet involved in its transport. The price cap will take effect on September 3. Separately, US President Donald Trump has put 50% tariffs on Indian imports, accusing India of funding Moscow's war on Ukraine via its oil purchases. Though Nayara is not directly sanctioned, its significant Russian ownership has triggered cascading effects. Sanctions Biting Within a week of the latest EU sanctions, Nayara Energy chief executive Alessandro Des Dorides resigned and was replaced by Sergey Denisov, who had been with the company since 2017. On July 28, Microsoft restricted Nayara Energy's access to its own data, proprietary tools and products, despite these being acquired under fully paid-up licences, according to the oil retailer. The US firm later restored services, once Nayara began legal actions against it. But the episode underscored the seriousness of the situation. 'Nayara's troubles have just begun. It is not only barred from exporting refined products to Europe, but fearing penalties, shipping companies are pulling back from transporting its products. Insurers and trade finance providers are wary,' said a trader familiar with the matter, on condition of anonymity. 'This is restricting the company's ability to move product to its export markets—Europe, Southeast Asia and parts of Africa.' As per a Care Ratings note in July, exports constituted 25-30% of Nayara's total revenue, while the balance was domestic sales in India. Nayara has negligible direct exports to the EU, while its majority exports are via traders who, in turn, sell to multiple markets. That hasn't stopped Nayara from seeking alternative arrangements for payments as EU's sanctions threaten to bite. It is reportedly seeking a local bank to finance and wire payments for crude oil imports and to help it receive payments for refined fuel product exports. Potential Sale Burdened by the heft of sanctions, Rosneft has not been able to repatriate earnings from Nayara Energy in recent years. The lack of repatriation of earnings from the company is believed to be one of the key reasons it has been mulling selling the Indian unit, said people with knowledge of the matter. But the latest bunch of sanctions has impeded this too. Talks have been held with Indian conglomerates, with the company being valued at more than $20 billion. Separately, UCP Investment Group, one of the largest financial investment groups in Russia, is also looking to sell its stake in Nayara Energy for over $5 billion. This, after Swiss-headquartered commodity trader Trafigura sold its 24.5% stake to Hara Capital Sarl, a wholly owned subsidiary of Italian energy investment firm Mareterra Group Holding, in January 2023. Industry players, however, said that due to the sanctions, Nayara's valuation could come down, making it an attractive asset for international buyers. New Strategies Global roadblocks have forced Nayara Energy to look inwards. Last week, it reached out to state-run refiners, offering them its export volumes of petrol and diesel to prevent a build-up of unsold inventory. While the pivot to domestic markets offers near-term relief, it also squeezes margins. Export markets, especially Europe, historically offered better realisations. Domestic competition, more so from state-owned oil marketing companies, limits pricing power and flexibility. Ironically, all of this comes at a time when Nayara Energy was planning massive growth investments. It had announced plans to invest over ₹70,000 crore in the long term across petrochemicals, ethanol plants and marketing infrastructure expansion, among other projects. It had invested over ₹14,000 crore since August 2017 in various projects in India, including upgrading existing refining facilities, a new petrochemical plant and other infrastructure projects. But thanks to the sanctions, the company now risks losing technical support from European technology licensors, which is crucial to its refinery operations. The key question is whether Nayara can continue to push forward on diversification while its core refining-export engine sputters under the weight of western pressure.
Indian Express
34 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Birsa Munda birth anniversary celebrations: Gujarat CM inaugurates 1,240 projects worth Rs 278 crore in 14 tribal districts
Chief Minister Bhupendra Patel on Saturday inaugurated 1,240 development projects worth Rs 278 crore to be carried out by the state government in 14 tribal districts of Gujarat. During the event, the CM also inaugurated 1,282 works worth over Rs 200 crore under various schemes to be implemented by the Tribal Development Department in 14 tribal districts. Along with this, the individual scheme benefits worth Rs 125 crore were distributed to 6,20,846 tribal beneficiaries across the state. On the occasion of Raksha Bandhan, tribal women tied rakhis to the Chief Minister. On the occasion, CM Patel paid respect to the statue of Birsa Munda. He also took lunch with a tribal family from Mandvi. 'PM Narendra Modi has started the system of celebrating November 15 as 'Tribal Pride Day' in memory of freedom fighter and tribal leader Birsa Munda from the year 2021. In 2025, his 150th birth anniversary is being celebrated across the country,' the CM said. Saluting Birsa Munda, who fought against the British rule for the independence of the country and the rights of the tribal community, CM Patel said, 'Due to the works and sacrifice of Birsa Munda, even today he is worshipped by the tribal community as 'Dharti Aaba' i.e. 'Father of the Earth' and 'God'. Birsa Munda had launched an armed rebellion called 'Ulgulan' (great movement) against the British rule for the land and forest rights of the tribals and had awakened consciousness, courage and valour among the tribals with the loud slogan of 'Abua Dishum.. Abua Raj…' i.e., 'Our country, our rule'. The struggle of Birsa Munda and the sacrifice made by him at the age of just 25 are a golden page in the history of the great revolutionaries of the tribal communities of India.' He said that projects worth Rs 24,000 crore under the Pradhan Mantri Janjatiya Adivasi Nyay Maha Abhiyan (PM-Janman Yojana) have been implemented. In the Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan, five crore citizens of the tribal community in 63,000 villages of the country have been covered for social infrastructure facilities. He said that by providing scholarships to 1 crore tribal youths, their path to a bright future has been strengthened. CM Patel said, 'The state government has provided scholarships worth Rs 4,300 crore to tribal students. Forest rights papers have been issued for 68,169 hectares of land in the state under the Forest Rights Act. The state government has provided scheme benefits to 4,265 villages in 102 talukas of 21 districts under the Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan.' Minister of State for Tribal Development Kunwarjibhai Halpati said that the Prime Minister implemented the Vanbandhu Kalyan Yojana for the development of the tribal community during his tenure as Gujarat Chief Minister, as a result of which the overall development of the tribals has become possible.
Indian Express
34 minutes ago
- Indian Express
AAP slams ‘mismanagement by 4-engine BJP govt' over deaths, water crisis in Delhi amid heavy rain
With heavy rain lashing the Capital on Saturday, deaths of eight persons in two separate incidents, flooding of the Giri Nagar pumping station in South Delhi's Kalkaji halting water supply to several areas, and waterlogging in multiple parts of the city brought the BJP government under criticism from the AAP. Leader of Opposition and former CM Atishi said the flooding of the pumping station left thousands of residents in Kalkaji, Giri Nagar, Govindpuri and Govindpuri Extension facing severe water shortage. 'Mismanagement by the four-engine BJP govt has not only submerged Delhi roads, but caused a water crisis in Kalkaji. The Giri Nagar pumping station is completely submerged. And the people of Giri Nagar, Kalkaji, Govindpuri and Govindpuri Extn are facing several days of water crisis,' she posted on X, along with a copy of her letter to Chief Minister Rekha Gupta. In her letter, Atishi wrote, 'Just a few hours of rain have brought Delhi to a grinding halt. Roads are waterlogged, traffic is at a standstill and even more shocking is that in many parts of Delhi water has entered people's homes. The pumping station of the Giri Nagar UnderGround Reservoir (UGR) is fully submerged in water… So no water is being supplied to the Kalkaji, Giri Nagar, Govindpuri and Govindpuri Extension.' She called the situation 'the direct result of administrative negligence' and urged the Chief Minister to instruct PWD and Water Minister Parvesh Sahib Singh to restore supply immediately. The heavy rain that caused the flooding began late Friday night, with the India Meteorological Department (IMD) upgrading alerts through the early hours of Saturday from yellow to orange and then to a red alert by 6.20 am. By 8.30 am, Safdarjung recorded 78.7 mm of rainfall in the last 24 hours, while Pragati Maidan logged 100.3 mm. The IMD warned of potential waterlogging, traffic congestion, and reduced visibility across the city. The AAP, in an official statement on Saturday evening, also attacked the BJP-led Delhi government over citywide waterlogging. The party's Delhi president Saurabh Bharadwaj alleged 'corruption worth crores in desilting works' and linked it to the Jaitpur incident in which seven people, including two children, died after a wall collapsed amid heavy rain. He further alleged that a 2.5-year-old child drowned in an open manhole, saying, 'I had warned CM Rekha Gupta that opening manholes during rain is a dangerous shortcut.' Senior leader Manish Sisodia, as per the statement, called the Jaitpur incident 'deeply painful' and expressed condolences to the bereaved families. Atishi also posted videos of waterlogged roads in Palam, Dhaula Kuan and Saket, stating, 'On Raksha Bandhan, the entire city is submerged… The collapse of governance under Rekha Gupta's government is preventing brothers from meeting their sisters.' AAP MLAs Sanjeev Jha and Kuldeep Kumar, also questioned the government's claims of monsoon preparedness and blamed the BJP to be responsible for lapses in civic bodies.
