logo
'You's' Ending Was Literally The Only Possible Conclusion For Joe Goldberg — And Penn Badgley Has Been Telling Us For Years

'You's' Ending Was Literally The Only Possible Conclusion For Joe Goldberg — And Penn Badgley Has Been Telling Us For Years

Buzz Feed02-05-2025
Needless to say, there are some *serious* You Season 5 spoilers ahead.
Last month, the much-anticipated final ever season of the hit Netflix series You finally hit our screens, and viewers couldn't be more excited to find out what will become of one of TV's most beloved serial killers, Joe Goldberg — played by Penn Badgley.
Netflix
And murder is far from the only crime that Joe has in his repertoire, with the entire premise of the show hinging on the fact that he is an obsessive stalker who manipulates women into being in a relationship with him, and will stop anyone who gets in his way. If those women see through him and decide that they don't want to date him? Well, that's when the killing comes in.
Netflix
Oh, and he also masturbated on the street a lot during Season 1.
Despite all of this, many of You's viewers have been completely on Joe's side throughout the show — largely due to him being the narrator, which allows him to manipulate fans with his charm in the same way he does his love interests on-screen.
Andddd as a result, many people hoped that the show would end with Joe getting away with all of his crimes and running off into the sunset, but they should have known that this was never going to happen.
If you're wondering, the explosive final episode sees Joe go head-to-head with his Season 5 love interest Louise 'Bronte' Flannery, played by Madeline Brewer. The episode starts with the two attempting to flee the country after Joe was secretly recorded confessing to two of his murders. However, Joe is unaware that Bronte is only still with him because she wants him to confess to killing her friend Guinevere Beck, who was the focus of the show's first season.
She ends up pulling a gun on him and demanding answers when they're in the bedroom together, and it is at this point that Joe's facade starts to break. At first, he berates Bronte — warning her that nobody will ever love her the way that he does. When this doesn't land, and after a call from his young son, Henry, who calls him a 'monster,' Joe plays the victim; sobbing about how unlovable he is and asking Bronte if this is what he deserves.
Bronte doesn't fall for this either, and that is when Joe turns overtly nasty, boasting about how he got away with murdering her friend on camera before physically attacking her, including punching her in the face.
An anxiety-inducing chase ensues, and, rather cleverly, this is the first time in five seasons that viewers are explicitly exposed to the reality of just how terrifying and powerful Joe is, without any of his trademark charm.
Joe shoots, strangles, and even drowns Bronte on camera, which she (inexplicably) survives, pulling a gun on him to stop him from leaving as the police arrive. At this point, Joe begs Bronte to kill him, clearly choosing death over facing justice, but she refuses to give him what would be the easy way out. She does, however, accidentally shoot him in the penis as he is arrested, after warning him: 'You are going to live the rest of your life alone.'
Which is exactly what happens. Joe ends up being sentenced to life in prison without parole, and in his final voiceover, he still refuses to take accountability for his actions, saying: 'My punishment is even worse than I imagined. The loneliness, my god, the loneliness. No hope of being held, knowing this is forever. It's unfair, putting all of this on me, aren't we all just products of our environment? Hurt people hurt people.'
Meanwhile, all of Joe's survivors are thriving and free — even Beck gets some form of justice after Bronte redacts all of the edits that Joe had secretly made to her posthumous book, and releases an edition containing only Beck's words, not those of her killer.
Netflix
And, if you think about it, this was literally the only possible resolution for Joe Goldberg. After all, throughout the entire show, nobody has been a bigger Joe hater than Penn, who plays him, and he has made it abundantly clear throughout the show's run that he would not be satisfied if Joe did not get his comeuppance.
While getting away with everything was clearly not an option, dying is undeniably too good for Joe, which means that, realistically, he was always going to end up in prison.
And Penn affirmed this mindset in a recent interview with Extra TV, where he said: 'The concept needed to come to a close, the writers, me, everybody involved — the fans — we needed to bring this man to his rightful end, and I think we did so.'
Netflix
But he did deny having any direct involvement in what happened, saying: 'If I had any input, it was only through years of being the way I've been about him. The writers, I've always left them to their own devices because they do what they do best… I think we ended it very well.'
Speaking to the Guardian about Joe's ending, Penn added: 'It was as though I couldn't sustain the rage anymore, couldn't sustain the levels of artifice with him, just all of it. Nothing is really good enough. There's levels to it; it's not just like: does he die? Does he go to jail? Is he tortured? Does he live and is he miserable alone? It's really about how we get there.'
Netflix
He reiterated that he believes they 'reached truly the best resolution for him.'
In the same interview, Penn shared his concern that he'd made Penn 'too likable,' something that he has publicly grappled with for years. Speaking to EW back in 2020 about the way some viewers defend Joe, Penn exclaimed: "He's a murderer! He's a sociopath. He's abusive. He's delusional. And he's self-obsessed. You can't fool yourself into thinking that he just needs somebody who's right for him. Nobody's right for him!"
Netflix
'I don't think redemption is possible for [Joe],' Penn added in another interview. 'I mean, maybe theoretically it's possible for all people, but he's among the worst.'
That same year, he said during an appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert: "I struggled greatly with the conflict of playing such a guy and him being partly so likable and having such a, as we say, thirsty response to him."
Netflix
A sentiment Penn had expressed in 2019 when he quote-tweeted a fan who'd written: 'the amount of people romanticising @pennbadgley's character in YOU scares me," and added: "Ditto. It will be all the motivation I need for season 2."
And perhaps the most poetic part of You's series finale is the self-referential way it addresses viewers' love for Joe Goldberg. In the episode's very final moments, Joe receives fan mail in prison, and asks: 'Why am I in a cage when all these crazies write me all the depraved things they want me to do to them?'
Perhaps anticipating that some fans may be left disappointed by Joe finally facing justice, the show then holds a mirror up to viewers as Joe continues: 'Maybe we have a problem as a society. Maybe we should fix what is broken in us. Maybe the problem isn't me… Maybe it's you.'
Netflix
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Wednesday' Season 1 Recap: Everything To Remember For Season 2
‘Wednesday' Season 1 Recap: Everything To Remember For Season 2

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

‘Wednesday' Season 1 Recap: Everything To Remember For Season 2

Wednesday Addams (Jenna Ortega) got up to plenty of mischief and adventure in Season 1 of the eponymous Netflix series, created by Alfred Gough and Miles Millar. The coming-of-age series centering the young heroine as she carves out her own path amongst her Outcast peers at Nevermore Academy had plenty of mystery and investigation, none of which daunted her. Some might even say it was the social scene at school that haunted her more than a mysterious monster lurking in the woods, students keeping secrets from her and those very obviously and vocally out to get her. More from Deadline 'Wednesday' Season 2: Everything We Know About The Cast, Premiere Date & More 'Wednesday' Renewed For Season 3 By Netflix Matty Brown Talks 'The Sand Castle' As Migrant Drama Becomes Most Watched Arabic Language Title On Netflix In First Half Of 2025 For those needing a refresher about what happened in Wednesday Season 1 ahead of the arrival of Season 2 Part 1, below lies a recap of the most salient plot points. Wednesday Enrolled At Nevermore Academy At the start of the series, viewers watch Wednesday pour two bags of piranha in the Nancy Reagan High School swimming pool to send a message to one of the swimmers, Dalton, who bullied her younger brother Pugsley (Isaac Ordonez) by shutting him in a locker, tied up, with an apple in his mouth. This action gets her expelled from the 'Normie' high school. She's been to 8 schools in 5 years. Wednesday comes from a family of Outcasts, or people with special abilities that set them apart from regular humans. Wednesday's psychic ability had just begun to show at the beginning of Season 1. She inherits the visions from her mother, Morticia Addams (née Frump), played by Catherine Zeta-Jones. Morticia, Pugsley and her father Gomez (Luis Guzmán) accompanied Wednesday to Nevermore Academy, a school teeming with Outcasts in Jericho, Vermont. Morticia and Gomez met at Nevermore — founded in 1791, and Morticia roomed with Principal Larissa Weems (Gwendoline Christie). A condition of Wednesday starting mid-term at Nevermore was that she attend therapy sessions with Jericho's own Dr. Valerie Kinbott (Rikki Lindhome), but Wednesday is reluctant to participate. Her Roommate Enid Is Quite The Opposite In Personality and Décor Enid Sinclair (Emma Myers) is Wednesday's roommate at Nevermore, and Enid loves color. Wednesday is allergic to color, so she strips her half of the room, only decorating in black and white. Even her school uniform is black and white. Enid's bubbly personality clashes with Wednesday's keep-to-herself exterior, but slowly the two form a distinct bond that culminates in a heartfelt hug, which Wednesday resists until the Season 1 finale. Enid descends from werewolves, but she had not yet 'Wolfed Out,' meaning undergone the full transformation. The furthest she could get is sharpening her rainbow-manicured nails into sharp acrylic-like claws. Luckily Enid's ability came at just the right time later on in the show, and after she stood up to her mother, who was putting pressure on her to go to lycanthropy conversion camps. Enid introduced Wednesday to the social scene at Nevermore — the four main cliques being Furs, Fangs, Stoners and Scales. Furs are werewolves, Fangs are vampires, Stoners are gorgons and Scales are sirens, leader of whom is Bianca Barclay (Joy Sunday). She used to date Xavier Thorpe (Percy Hynes-White), 'resident tortured artist' as Enid describes him. Xavier is an Unknown, but his ability is soon revealed as visions too, which appear in his dreams. He usually transcribes what he sees to paper, and he can make his drawings and paintings come to life. Wednesday's Visions Portend Something Bad Happening At Nevermore Just as she started classes, Wednesday began to have visions. These occur when she comes in contact with a person or object. Her mother left her with an Aztec necklace made of obsidian that priests used to conjur visions. Her first premonition took place while she escaped a therapy session in Jericho and she bumped into an apple farmer, foreseeing his death by a mysterious creature responsible for several other murders in the woods surrounding Jericho and Nevermore. After Rowan (Calum Ross) tried to push a gargoyle statue onto her to kill her, she bumped into him at the Harvest Festival and foresaw his death right before it happened. RELATED: Also in that vision, she saw a mysterious book, fire being set to the Nevermore Quad (Pentagon) and more. The Nightshades Rowan, a telekinetic, claimed his mother foresaw Wednesday in a vision with Joseph Crackstone, founder of Jericho, 25 years ago. He vowed to prevent that from coming true by killing her at his mother's behest because she would destroy the school, but this backfired as the mysterious monster came out of the shadows and killed Rowan. Wednesday tracked down the book from which Rowan ripped his mother's illustration of her and Crackstone backed by a fire. A faded symbol in the upper right-hand corner led her to secret society The Nightshades — members including Bianca, Ajax (Georgie Farmer), Xavier, Divina (Johnna Dias-Watson), Yoko (Naomi J. Ogawa) and Kent (Oliver Watson). Technically, the society lost its charter years ago, but Principal Weems looked the other way as long as they didn't cause trouble. Wednesday's mother was in The Nightshades as well. The Love Triangle Xavier saved Wednesday from the above-mentioned gargoyle incident early on in the series and re-introduced himself after the two had met when they were young at a funeral of one of Wednesday's grandmother's friends. He had hid in the casket and almost got cremated. Wednesday heard him screaming and saved his life. RELATED: Xavier was one of Wednesday's love interests last season, but he competed with Tyler (Hunter Doohan) a Normie Wednesday met at Jericho's Weathervane coffeeshop in town after she escaped from her first therapy session. The Hyde Uncle Fester (Fred Armisen), who appeared in Episode 7 of Season 1, helped Wednesday identify the monster killing people in the woods and taking their body parts by pointing her towards Nathaniel Faulkner's diary, which was in The Nightshades' secret library. As she delved further into the research about Hydes, Wednesday realized that she must track down two people responsible for the killings — the Hyde itself, which she knows is a human because she saw its monstrous footprints transition back into human ones in the mud after an encounter — and its master, the person who has unlocked the Hyde's nature within the human. Because the Hyde haunted Xavier's dreams and he constantly paints it — as discovered by Wednesday in his hidden art studio — she suspected Xavier is the Hyde. And when she saw him call for an emergency session with Dr. Kinbott, she believed Kinbott was responsible for unlocking the Hyde. Turns out, Tyler was the Hyde. His mother was also a Hyde, and she attended Nevermore. Hunter's father Sheriff Donovan Galpin (Jamie McShane) failed to ever mention this detail, but the trauma of her post-partem depression triggering the condition passed onto Tyler, and his master used that information to unlock the creature in him as well. More on the master below. Garrett Gates – Gomez's Shady Past Sheriff Galpin also immediately pinpointed Wednesday because her father had a file with the Jericho Police Department from his days as a student at Nevermore. When Gomez was arrested for murder at Nevermore's Parents' Weekend, Wednesday gets on the case and digs up the dead body of the boy her dad supposedly killed, Garrett Gates. This all happened at the Goth & Glamor Rave'N her parents attended when Garrett approached Morticia, who was the one responsible for stabbing Garrett with a sword. The blue tinge of Garrett's corpse's finger signals that he was poisoned, though, and this led to the discovery that Garrett's father had sent him to the Rave'N to poison the outcasts, only the poison vial cracked and leeched into his skin instead. RELATED: Garett was brother to Laurel Gates, who had supposedly died by drowning overseas when she was sent away from Jericho as an orphan, but later on in the show, Wednesday, Enid and Tyler discover that someone is living in the old Gates mansion in Laurel's bedroom. Principal Weems Died Principal Weems, who had grown fed up with Wednesday's relentless pursuit of the truth, granting Wednesday one last favor to visit Eugene Ottinger Ottinger (Moosa Mostafa) in the hospital after the Hyde had attacked him. There, Eugene tipped Wednesday off as to who the Hyde's master was. Wednesday figured out that Weems was a shapeshifter with Morticia's memory of Weems' 'dead ringer' impression of Judy Garland. This confirmed that it was Weems disguised as Rowan leaving school following his death. Thus, Wednesday had Weems pretend to be Tyler in a confrontation with none other than Nevermore's first Normie teacher Ms. Marilyn Thornhill (Christina Ricci), who was actually Laurel Gates. They drew the confession out of her that she was the Hyde's master, but unfortunately when Weems changed back, Laurel killed her by injecting her with poison. This death made way for Steve Buscemi's Principal Barry Dort. Joseph Crackstone, Laurel Gates & Goody Addams Once Xavier told Wednesday that it was Joseph Crackstone in the illustration, she made Enid switch volunteer assignments on Outreach Day so that she could investigate Pilgrim World, the theme park dedicated to the Founder of Jericho, who imprisoned and alter burned outcasts in a mass genocide, which Wednesday's ancestor Goody Addams (also portrayed by Jenna Ortega) survived. Goody, one of the original outcasts, came over from Mexico, and her line leads to Gomez. At Pilgrim World, Wednesday didn't glean too much about Crackstone other than that he took Goody's Book of Shadows, but the real book had been replaced with a fake Etsy version. Goody later visited Wednesday in visions, and it was she who guided her descendant to the Gates mansion. Goody began to be Wednesday's spirit guide, teaching her the ways of her visions, but she sacrificed her afterlife self to save Wednesday from dying, disappearing from the realm Wednesday looked into in her visions. RELATED: This near-death experience took place when Laurel Gates dragged Wednesday to Crackstone's Crypt, clarifying the purpose of the missing body parts of the Hyde victims. Laurel planned to resurrect Crackstone, using Wednesday's DNA, an incantation and a crazy machine to channel his spirit into a sewn-together body. Crackstone came back to life in the Frankenstein-esque body, but Goody, before she vanished, told Wednesday to stab him in his black heart to kill him, which Wednesday eventually did with the help of Bianca, Xavier and even Enid, who wolfed out just in time to battle Tyler's Hyde in the woods. Someone Almost Killed Thing Before the identities of the Hyde and its master were revealed, someone stabbed Thing, the detached hand that is the Addams family's companion, in the back and left him hanging in Wednesday's room. Wednesday whisked the dexterous appendage and his digits to her Uncle Fester, who wass sleeping in Eugene's bee shed, to revive him with his electric shock ability. This scene held the most emotion viewers saw from Wednesday, who cried and willed Thing back to life Earlier on in the show, Wednesday had shared with Enid that she hadn't cried since she was 6 years old when some bullies ran over and killed her pet scorpion Nero. Wednesday Gets an iPhone, and a Stalker The show left off with Xavier, who was first framed for being the Hyde and then released, gifting Wednesday a phone. The vibe between the pair was uncertain as she had kissed Tyler, which then gave her a vision that he was the Hyde. White will not be returning to Season 2 of Wednesday. As Lurch (George Burcea) drove her away from her first semester at Nevermore in the snow, Wednesday received several texts from a mysterious stalker. RELATED: Best of Deadline 2025 TV Series Renewals: Photo Gallery 2025-26 Awards Season Calendar: Dates For Emmys, Oscars, Grammys & More 2025 TV Cancellations: Photo Gallery

Duchess Meghan turns 44: British royal gets sweet birthday shoutout from As Ever brand
Duchess Meghan turns 44: British royal gets sweet birthday shoutout from As Ever brand

USA Today

time4 hours ago

  • USA Today

Duchess Meghan turns 44: British royal gets sweet birthday shoutout from As Ever brand

Duchess Meghan may be busy building her business kingdom, but today she's being crowned. The British American royal and entrepreneur, who turned 44 on Monday, Aug. 4, received a warm birthday shoutout on Instagram from her lifestyle brand As Ever, which launched in April to fan acclaim. The company, which has become known for its homey aesthetic and assortment of fruit spreads, herbal teas and baking mixes, shared a black-and-white photo of the duchess wearing a sun dress and wide-brimmed hat alongside its celebratory message. "Celebrating the woman behind it all," the company wrote in the post's caption. "She pours her heart, vision and magic touch into every detail, and today, we raise a glass to her! Happy birthday to our founder @meghan 🥂" See Duchess Meghan's daughter Lilibet: Young princess makes adorable cameo in As Ever teaser Meghan, who is married to Prince Harry, has yet to share any glimpses of her birthday festivities with her 4.1 million Instagram followers. The Duchess of Sussex has been more open about her family life with Harry, which includes children Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet, with a series of candid posts. Meghan first teased As Ever in March 2024 when she made a buzzy return to Instagram after a yearslong social media hiatus to introduce fans to the lifestyle project, formerly named American Riviera Orchard. The duchess later revealed she renamed the brand As Ever because the previous title, a reference to her and Harry's Montecito residence, "limited me to things that were just manufactured and grown in this area." The first As Ever drop sold out in under an hour, and one product — the limited-edition wildflower honey with honeycomb for $28 — had fans buzzing, selling out in less than five minutes. The featured products in the company's first collection included $12 herbal tea in three flavors: hibiscus, peppermint and lemon ginger. 'You have to be authentic': Duchess Meghan responds to twerking video backlash The lifestyle brand teased its upcoming release, a vintage rosé wine, in an Instagram video on Aug. 3. "Goodness in a glass. Right around the corner... Cheers to August!" the company wrote alongside the teaser. As Ever is produced alongside Netflix, which also distributes Meghan's lifestyle show "With Love, Meghan." The series premiered in March and was quickly renewed for a second season, although a release date has not been announced. Contributing: Taijuan Moorman and Jay Stahl, USA TODAY

Why Does Anna From Netflix's ‘My Oxford Year' Look So Familiar?
Why Does Anna From Netflix's ‘My Oxford Year' Look So Familiar?

Forbes

time4 hours ago

  • Forbes

Why Does Anna From Netflix's ‘My Oxford Year' Look So Familiar?

Netflix's new romantic comedy drama My Oxford Year stars Sofia Carson as Anna De La Vega. What else has Carson starred in? Directed by Iain Morris, My Oxford Year debuted on Netflix on Friday. The summary for the movie reads, 'When Anna (Carson), an ambitious young American woman, sets out for the UK and the University of Oxford to fulfill a childhood dream, she's got her life completely on track. That is, until she meets a charming and clever local, Jamie (Corey Mylchreest), who profoundly alters both of their lives.' Born Sofía Daccarett Char in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., on April 10, 1993, Char, who uses her mother's maiden name Carson as her professional name, made her screen debut in a guest role in a 2014 episode of the Disney Channel series Austin & Ally. Carson's next guest role came in 2015 in the MTV series Faking It, which was followed by a role in the same year that helped launch her career. Here's a look at some of the other TV series and films that Carson has appeared in and why she looks so familiar as Anna in My Oxford Year. 'Descendants' (2015) Sofia Carson's first big screen role came in the Disney TV movie Descendants, where she plays Evie, the daughter of the Evil Queen from Snow White in Disney lore. Carson reprised the role of Evie in the TV movies Descendants 2 in 2017 and Descendents 3 in 2019, as well as the TV special Descendants: The Royal Wedding in 2021. In additon, Carson voiced the role of Evie in the animated Disney series Descendants: Wicked World from 2017-2019. 'Adventures In Babysitting (2016) Sofia Carson and Sabrina Carpenter starred as Lola Perez and Jenny Carpenter in the TV movie Adventures in Babysitting, which aired on the Disney Channel. Adventures in Babysitting is a remake of the 1987 comedy hit of the same name that starred Elisabeth Shue and was directed by Chris Columbus. 'Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists' (2019) Sofia Carson starred as fashion trendsetter Ava Jalali in Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists, the third series in the Pretty Little Liars TV franchise. The crime mystery series ran on Freeform for one season and consisted of 10 episodes. 'Feel The Beat' (2020) Sofia Carson's first film on Netflix came with the dance comedy drama Feel the Beat. Carson stars as April, an aspiring Broadway dancer who after a tough break during an audition, moves back to her home town in Wisconsin and coaches a group of young dancers. 'Purple Hearts' (2022) Sofia Carson starred opposite Nicholas Galitzine in Netflix's Purple Hearts, about an aspiring musician, Cassie, who struggles to buy insulin as a Type 1 diabetic. Cassie and a Marine, Luke (Galitzine), however, find a solution with a marriage of convenience. Cassie can get health benefits as a military spouse and Luke can get an increase in pay — but then both of their lives become very complicated. 'Carry-On' (2024) Sofia Carson starred in a supporting role opposite Taron Edgerton in Carry-On, a Netflix original movie that was released on December 2024. Edgerton plays Ethan, a TSA officer in Los Angeles who is blackmailed by a mysterious man called The Traveler (Jason Bateman) to allow a bomb carrying a lethal chemical agent aboard a flight. When Ethan tries to stop The Traveler's plans, it puts his and his girlfriend Nora's (Carson) life — as well as the life of their unborn child — in danger. 'The Life List' (2025) Released in March, Netflix's romantic drama The Life List stars Sofia Carson as Alex, a woman who seeks to attain unrealized goals from childhood after her mother dies. The Life List also stars Connie Britton and Kyle Allen. 'Netflix TUDUM' (2025) Sofia Carson has become such of a fixture on Netflix that she hosted the streaming platform's annual TUDUM event in May. The live presentation gave a preview of the Netflix's upcoming programming including Wednesday Season 2, Stranger Things Season 5 and Guillermo del Toro's Frankenstein. My Oxford Year, starring Sofia Carson, is new on Netflix.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store