Divergence emerges between human traders and computer-driven investors
Computer-guided traders haven't been this bullish on stocks compared to their human counterparts since early 2020, before the depths of the Covid pandemic, according to Parag Thatte, a strategist at
Deutsche Bank AG
.
Productivity Tool
Zero to Hero in Microsoft Excel: Complete Excel guide
By Metla Sudha Sekhar
View Program
Finance
Introduction to Technical Analysis & Candlestick Theory
By Dinesh Nagpal
View Program
Finance
Financial Literacy i e Lets Crack the Billionaire Code
By CA Rahul Gupta
View Program
Digital Marketing
Digital Marketing Masterclass by Neil Patel
By Neil Patel
View Program
Finance
Technical Analysis Demystified- A Complete Guide to Trading
By Kunal Patel
View Program
Productivity Tool
Excel Essentials to Expert: Your Complete Guide
By Study at home
View Program
Artificial Intelligence
AI For Business Professionals Batch 2
By Ansh Mehra
View Program
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Undo
The two groups look at different cues to form their opinions, so it's not a shock that they see the market differently. While computer-driven fast-money quants use systematic strategies based on momentum and volatility signals, discretionary money managers are individuals looking at economic and earnings trends to guide their moves.
Still, this degree of disagreement is rare — and historically, it doesn't last long, Thatte said.
'Discretionary investors are waiting for something to give, whether that's slowing growth or a spike in inflation in the second half of the year from tariffs,' he said. 'As the data trickles in, their concerns will either be proven right if the market sells off on growth fears, or the economy will remain resilient, in which case discretionary managers would likely begin to lift their stock exposure on economic optimism.'
Live Events
Bloomberg
Wall Street offers a lot of confident predictions, but the reality is nobody knows what will happen with President Donald Trump's trade agenda or the Federal Reserve's interest-rate policy.
With the S&P 500 Index repeatedly hitting all-time highs, professional investors aren't sticking around to find out. As of the week ended Aug. 1, they'd cut their equity exposure from neutral to modestly underweight on lingering uncertainty surrounding global trade, corporate earnings and economic growth, according to data compiled by Deutsche Bank.
'No one wants to buy pricier stocks already at records so some are praying for any selloff as an excuse to buy,' said Frank Monkam, head of macro trading at Buffalo Bayou Commodities.
Chasing Momentum
Trend-following algorithmic funds, however, are chasing that momentum. They've been lured into a buying spree after cut-to-the-bone positioning in the spring cleared the path to return in recent months as the S&P 500 rallied almost 30% from its April low. Through the week ended Aug. 1, long equity positions for systematic strategies were the highest since January 2020, Deutsche Bank's data show.
This divergence underpins the tug-of-war between technical and fundamental forces, with the S&P 500 stuck in a tight range after posting its longest streak of tranquility in two years in July.
The Cboe Volatility Index — or VIX — which measures implied volatility of the benchmark US equity futures via out-of-the-money options, closed at 15.15 on Friday, near the lowest level since February.
The VVIX, which measures the volatility of volatility, dropped for the third time in four weeks.
'The rubber band can only stretch so far before it snaps,' said Colton Loder, managing principal of the alternative investment firm Cohalo. 'So the potential for a mean-reversion selloff is higher when there's systematic crowding, like now.'
This kind of collective piling into a trade periodically happens with computer-driven strategies. In early 2023, for instance, quants loaded up on US stocks on the heels of the S&P 500's 19% drop in 2022, until volatility spiked in March of that year during the regional banking tumult. And in late 2019, fast-money traders powered stocks to records after a breakthrough in trade talks between Washington and Beijing.
This time around, however, Thatte expects this split between man and machine to last weeks, not months. If discretionary traders start selling in response to weaker growth or softening corporate earnings trends, pushing volatility higher, computer-based strategies are likely to begin to unwind their positions as well, he said.
Bloomberg
In addition, fast-money investors will likely reach full exposure to US equities by September, which could prompt them to sell stocks as they become vulnerable to downside market shocks, according to Scott Rubner of Citadel Securities.
CTA Risk
Given how systematic funds operate, selling may start with commodity trading advisors, or CTAs, unwinding extreme positioning, Loder said. That would increase the risk of sharp reversals in the stock market, although there would need to be a substantial selloff for a spike in volatility to last, he added.
CTAs, who have been persistent stock buyers, are long $50 billion of US stocks, putting them in the 92nd percentile of historical exposure, according to Goldman Sachs Group Inc. However, the S&P 500 would need to breach 6,100, a decline of roughly 4.5% from where the index closed on Friday, for CTAs to begin dumping stocks, said Maxwell Grinacoff, head of equity derivatives research at UBS Group AG.
So the question is, with quant positioning this stretched to the bullish side and pressure building in the stock market due to extreme levels of uncertainty, can any rally from here really last?
'Things are starting to feel toppy,' said Grinacoff, adding that the upside for stocks 'is likely exhausted' in the short run given that CTA positioning is near max long. 'This is a bit worrisome, but it's not raising alarm bells yet.'
What's more, any pullback from systematic selling would likely create an opportunity for discretionary asset managers who missed out on this year's gains to re-enter the market as buyers, warding off a more severe plunge, according to Cohalo's Loder.
'Whatever triggers the next drawdown is a mystery,' he said. 'But when that eventually happens, asset-manager exposure and discretionary positioning is so light that it will add fuel to a 'buy the dip' mentality and prevent an even bigger selloff.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
6 minutes ago
- Time of India
Breaking news live updates, August 12: Rahul Gandhi lauds INDA bloc MPs for support in 'movement against vote theft'
00:17 (IST) Aug 12 US stocks are drifting around their record heights on Monday as Wall Street waits for an upcoming update on inflation. The S&P 500 fell 0.1% and is just below its all-time high set two weeks ago. The Dow Jones Industrial Average was down 171 points, or 0.4%, as of 2:30 p.m. Eastern time, and the Nasdaq composite fell 0.1%, coming off its own record. The highlight of this week for Wall Street is likely to arrive on Tuesday, when the government will report how bad inflation was across the country in July. Economists expect it to show U.S. consumers had to pay prices for groceries, gasoline and other costs of living that were 2.8% higher in July from a year earlier, a slight acceleration from June's 2.7% inflation. Inflation has remained above 2%, even if it has improved substantially from its peak above 9% three years ago. And the worry is that President Donald Trump's tariffs could push it higher. That in turn is raising fears about a potential, worst-case scenario called 'stagflation' where the economy stagnates but inflation remains high. The Federal Reserve has no good tool to fix both at once, and it would need to concentrate on either the job market or inflation first. But helping one of those areas by moving interest rates would likely hurt the other. A top Fed official, Michelle Bowman, said on Saturday that she believes the job market is the bigger concern. She is still backing three cuts to interest rates by the Fed this year following this month's stunning, weaker-than-expected report on the U.S. job market. Trump himself has also been angrily calling for cuts to interest rates to support the economy. Other Fed officials, led by Chair Jerome Powell, are more hesitant. Powell has said he wants to wait for more data about how Trump's tariffs are affecting inflation before the Fed makes its next move, and Tuesday's update on the consumer price index may offer a big clue about that. Strategists at Stifel are warning that stagflation may already be on the way, with spending by U.S. consumers slowing, and they warn that it could cause the U.S. economy to slow to a crawl by the second half of the year. That in turn could create a reckoning for investors after they sent stock prices soaring to records from their low point in April. 'Rate cuts cannot save an overvalued S&P 500,' according to the strategists, led by Thomas Carroll and Barry Bannister. One way companies can make their stock prices appear less expensive is to deliver bigger profits. Micron Technology climbed 3% Monday after raising its forecasts for profit and revenue in the current quarter, which will end later this month. The maker of memory for computers said it's benefiting from higher prices for its products. AMC Entertainment rose 2.9% to shave its loss for the year so far, which came into the day at 26.4% after it reported better results for the spring than analysts expected. The theater chain said moviegoers paid more for their tickets per person than ever before, while also spending more on food and drinks. TKO Group Holdings climbed 8.2% after reaching a deal to distribute the full slate of its 13 marquee UFC numbered events, along with 30 'Fight Nights' on the Paramount+ streaming platform. Paramount Skydance's stock fell 1.6%. Nvidia and Advanced Micro Devices advanced after a U.S. government official confirmed that the two agreed to share 15% of their revenues from chip sales to China with the U.S. government. The two had said in July that Washington would allow them to resume sales of their advanced H20 and MI308 chips, which are used in artificial intelligence development, in China but didn't reveal the 15% cut. Nvidia added 0.2%, and AMD climbed 0.7%. On the losing side of Wall Street was after the AI application software company warned it may report an operating loss as large as $124.9 million for its first quarter. CEO Thomas Siebel called the first-quarter sales results 'completely unacceptable,' and its stock tumbled 25%. In stock markets abroad, indexes were mixed amid mostly modest movements across Europe and Asia. In the bond market, the yield on the 10-year Treasury held at 4.27%, where it was late Friday.
Deccan Herald
6 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
UK employers report weaker hiring and pay growth in July
Hiring intentions by British businesses fell to their weakest since the Covid-19 pandemic and recruiters said starting pay was rising at the slowest pace in over four years, according to surveys on Monday which add to signs of a weakening jobs market. With the Bank of England watching the jobs market closely, the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development said only 57% of private sector employers planned to recruit staff over the next three months, the lowest since the start of 2021 though only slightly down from 58% in the last quarterly survey. The professional body for the human resources sector said higher employer social security charges introduced by finance minister Rachel Reeves and an increased minimum wage were hurting jobs, particularly in hospitality and social care. Planned changes to employment law which are likely to make it harder to sack employees in their first two years in a job were also making businesses more reticent to hire younger, less experienced staff, CIPD economist James Cockett said. Other business surveys have shown similar concerns, as well as broader headwinds from weak domestic demand and residual uncertainty for some exporters over U.S. trade tariffs.
Time of India
24 minutes ago
- Time of India
LIC's goal is 'Insurance for All' by 2047, policy numbers should grow from Q2: R Doraiswamy, MD & CEO
Life Insurance Corporation of India 's new chief executive R Doraiswamy is betting on a diversified product mix and higher sales through bancassurance channels to keep the state behemoth ahead of private rivals. In his first interview since taking over, Doraiswamy discusses with ET his plans on increasing the share of non-participating products to 40% of annual premium equivalent-a switch that is key to boosting profitability. Edited excerpts: Your market share in individual policies is 39% by count and 63% by premium. How do you see policy volumes growing? Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass Batch-1 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 2 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 3 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals By Vaibhav Sisinity View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 4 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals Batch 2 By Ansh Mehra View Program The broader goal is "Insurance for All" by 2047. The industry saw a drop in volumes after last year's product rule changes, but our sales have stabilised. We expect growth in policy numbers to turn positive from the second quarter onwards, with stronger momentum in the third and fourth quarter. Market share being a by-product of growth, when LIC grows at a rate higher than the rest of the industry, my market share is going to go up. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Undo LIC's margins improved 150 bps in the first quarter to 15.4%. Is it sustainable and when can you match private sector levels of around 25%? Three factors drove our margin expansion-higher non-PAR contribution, expense optimisation, and revised commission structures following the October 1, 2024 norms on products. There were some changes in some products, we had to be compliant with the surrender value norms, tweak the agency commission from being totally front-ended to introducing some deferred payments of commission. Our margins also follow a seasonal pattern, rising from the first quarter to the fourth because PAR profits are booked in the last quarter. We have consciously shifted from a 7% share in non-participating (non-PAR) annual premium equivalent (APE) at the time of listing to around 30% now. This could rise further to 35-40% in the near term, before we balance the mix back towards participating (PAR) products. Live Events Which products will drive growth this year? Customer preferences vary. Younger buyers lean towards guaranteed non-par protection products, while others prefer savings-oriented participating or non-participating plans. ULIPs see strong demand in rising markets and a slowdown when markets dip. This year, we expect ULIPs to grow alongside non-PAR savings and protection products. We try to fill product gaps and cater to all segments from micro-insurance to high-ticket savings. Our recent launch, Jeevan Utsav, has already set a trend in the market. Over the next few months, we will bring out three to four innovative products across categories. What is your vision for LIC? LIC is a major financial institution player in the country, and they are playing a major role in developing India's economy for the last 69 years. If you look at what we have to do, our objectives are very clear, extend insurance coverage across the country at affordable prices, and mobilise savings for the welfare of policyholders while delivering decent returns. Globally, we are already the fourth-largest life insurer, and see whether we can still grow more. LIC's share of bancassurance is less than 7% despite several bank tie-ups. Given open architecture in agencies, how do you plan to improve channel mix? Our individual agency network is the backbone of LIC. It is a distribution strength we will continue to nurture. That said, we are changing in other channels, bancassurance and corporate. Our bank assurance premium share has risen from less than 3% two years ago to 6.77% today. We expect it to cross 10% in the near future. LIC has recently invested large sums in Adani bonds and SBI QIP. How much investment is likely to come into equity markets from LIC this year? When you have such large investable funds to be invested, you are looking at various options which are giving you a decent return. We need to look at both debt as well as equity in the proportion that we are supposed to invest. But at many times you find that you will do more on one side or the other based on availability. We have to have a clear rating of those instruments, paying certain dividends and stuff like that. The regulator has allowed insurers to hedge through derivatives. What are your plans? LIC has already started doing FRA (forward rate agreements), and now we are actively looking at bond forwards. Once we have enough tie-ups on that, we will be moving to bond forwards to hedge our interest rate risk only in perspective of our guaranteed protection. On the equity front, we are still weighing the options. The Centre is talking about reducing stake to 90% in LIC by FY27 by selling 6.5%. How much of that will happen this year? This decision will be taken by the government. LIC owns a strategic stake in IDBI Bank . Will you continue to own a strategic share in the bank or exit completely eventually ? The vision of LIC is to be a transnationally competitive financial conglomerate. That is a vision, if you look at this. So, when you are looking at a financial conglomerate, you would like to have a bank as a major partner, a housing finance company, or a mutual fund. But the Act and regulations do not permit LIC to have a bank of its own. Whereas a bank can have an insurance company, an insurance company can't promote a bank. That is what the problem is. RBI has already made their position clear. What is the status of the health insurance venture? We have the options in front of us. We are doing due diligence into existing SAHI (standalone health insurance) companies, which we can have a stake at. Only thing is, we are not fixing a particular time limit. We are examining those options.
