'Poison': Rajasthan govt pulls class 11–12 textbooks over 'Gandhi family overdose', says icons like Shastri, Patel, Ambedkar missing
Azadi Ke Baad Ka Swarnim Bharat
for Classes 11 and 12, alleging that it gives undue emphasis to the Gandhi family while ignoring other national leaders. The two-part book, which has been used in schools for over 20 years, was revised in 2015 and 2019, and serves as non-evaluative reading material for students.
According to Dilawar, the book highlights the contributions of Jawaharlal Nehru, Indira Gandhi, Rajiv Gandhi, Sonia Gandhi, and Atal Bihari Vajpayee, but neglects other prominent figures such as Lal Bahadur Shastri, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, BR Ambedkar, and BJP leaders like Bhairon Singh Shekhawat and Vasundhara Raje. The minister claimed that the book gives the impression that only the Gandhi family played a role in India's progress, which he called 'misleading and disrespectful.'
He also pointed out that the book fails to include recent national developments like the abrogation of Article 370 in 2019, an event he considers crucial for India's unity and security. Although the textbook was updated in 2019, it only mentions Prime Minister Narendra Modi in five paragraphs and does not include any of his photographs. The text highlights major policy changes like the Swachh Bharat Mission, GST, demonetisation, and the formation of NITI Aayog.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Cloud security in action: customer success stories with Orca Security
CIO | AWS
Learn More
Undo
Committee formed, but little progress
After the BJP-led government under Chief Minister Bhajan Lal Sharma came to power in 2023, a syllabus review was initiated in November 2024. A nine-member panel headed by Prof Kailash Sodani of Vardhman Mahaveer Open University was formed for textbook revision. However, the committee has met only once so far.
Despite the book being distributed to 80% of government schools for the current academic year, Dilawar stood by the decision to withdraw it. 'Just because poison is bought doesn't mean it must be consumed,' he said, adding that incomplete or biased content should not be taught in schools.
Live Events
Political backlash over textbook row
The move has triggered political criticism. Chief of the Pradesh Congress Committee Govind Singh Dotasra accused the state government of trying to impose an RSS-backed ideology through education. He argued that the curriculum, revised in 2020, was inclusive and mentioned contributions from various political leaders including Morarji Desai, Manmohan Singh, Indira Gandhi, and Modi.
He also slammed the minister for focusing on Modi-centric content, calling it 'dictatorial,' and promised to raise the matter with the Chief Minister's Office. According to Dotasra, the government should focus on education, not politics.
Authors defend the textbook
Prof Om Prakash Mahla, one of the authors of the book, defended its content. Speaking to TOI, he said the book was prepared without political bias and covered national achievements under various governments, including Atal Bihari Vajpayee's Pokhran nuclear tests. He maintained that the goal was to provide a balanced overview of India's post-independence journey to young learners.
Syllabus revision
The syllabus revision process is expected to continue, and a new version of the textbook may be issued next academic year. The controversy has reignited the debate over political influence in school education, with stakeholders demanding transparency and inclusivity in curriculum development.
Inputs from TOI
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Wire
4 minutes ago
- The Wire
'I Want the Situation in Assam to be Explosive': Himanta's Communal Remark to Defend Gun License Decision
Communalism Sarma's comment had stemmed from his decision to issue from this August 1 gun licenses online to only 'indigenous' residents. New Delhi: 'I want the situation in Assam to be explosive.' Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma made this communally provocative statement when reporters asked him this past week if the situation in the state could turn 'explosive' if his government goes ahead with its decision to issue gun licenses to 'original inhabitants'. Speaking on the sidelines of an event organised at an agricultural project of the government at Gorukhuti in Sipajhar, Sarma said, 'Someday, the situation will be explosive in Assam. How will our people survive if there is an explosion?' Sarma's comment had stemmed from his decision to issue from this August 1 gun licenses online to only 'indigenous' residents. Since this May 28, he has been claiming that 'indigenous' people residing in 'vulnerable remote areas' of five districts of the state were feeling 'insecure' and therefore, his government would be 'lenient in giving licenses to eligible people' in those areas. The districts named by the chief minister – Dhubri, Morigaon, Barpeta, Nagaon and South Salmara-Mankachar – are where Muslims of Bengali origin are in large numbers. Sarma is often noted for pairing his decision to issue gun licenses to 'our' people with the massive eviction drive the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has been carrying out in the state, affecting a large number of Bengali origin Muslims, locally called Miya Mussalman. The agricultural project at Gorukhuti was launched after a massive eviction drive was carried out in 2021 by Assam Police citing a Gauhati High Court general order to clear forest areas of eviction. That drive had killed an evictee, following which a government-appointed cameraperson was seen in a trial video clip jumping on his dead body. The Opposition parties in the state have been condemning the chief minister for his government's policy to issue gun license to local people in an election-bound state. State Congress chief Gaurav Gogoi had said, 'People of Assam want water, employment, education, and medical facilities, not guns." Citing the recent order of the Supreme Court coming down heavily on the Sarma government over alleged police access, Gogoi said the controversial move to issue gun licenses 'may lead to an increase in fake encounters.' After Sarma reiterated his government's policy on July 25, Asam Jatiya Parishad president Lurinjyoti Gogoi repeated his condemnation, calling it a 'dangerous' proposition, adding that it 'is an insult to police and Border Security Force' that guards the districts along the Assam-Bangladesh border. 'No less a veiled attempt at instigating violence in a poll-bound state' On asked about the Sarma government's decision, an editor of an Assamese daily agreed to give his opinion on condition of anonymity, 'What Sarma said at Gorukhuti was no less a veiled attempt at instigating violence in a poll-bound state. His decision to carry out eviction in Miya Mussalman areas and also bringing in a policy to issue gun licenses to khilonjia (indigenous) people in those areas must be seen together, as an attempt to communally awaken the majority Assamese community, particularly in Upper Assam, as his government is getting very unpopular in those areas, mainly due to charges of corruption and nepotism. Upper Assam, mind you, has the highest number of assembly segments.' The editor said, 'People are also seeing now a clear chief ministerial candidate in the Opposition camp in Gaurav Gogoi and that is making Sarma worried. The only thing that can perhaps save him is communal polarisation of votes.' Prior to the anti-foreigner Nellie massacre in 1983 in Assam, former prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee had made a speech which some considered it provocative. Journalist N P Ullekh, in his book, 'The Untold Vajpayee: Politician and Paradox', had mentioned that speech delivered a week before the massacre in Guwahati where he said ' a river of blood' would flow in Assam if elections were allowed by Indira Gandhi government to take place in 1983. In 1996, while debating a motion of confidence in the Lok Sabha moved by the then Vajpayee government, senior Left MP Indrajit Gupta had read out excerpts from that inflammatory speech of the BJP leader. The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
Time of India
17 minutes ago
- Time of India
School building set on fire by miscreants in Arunachal Pradesh's West Siang
Representative Image NEW DELHI: Unidentified miscreants set on fire the annexure building of an Upper Primary School in Arunachal Pradesh's West Siang district, police said on Monday. An annexure building of an Upper Primary School in Arunachal Pradesh's West Siang district was set ablaze by unidentified miscreants on Sunday, resulting in complete destruction of nursery and early primary classrooms at Lipu Bagra village near Aalo town. The burned structure housed classrooms for nursery, Class I, and Class II students. The incident has prompted police to launch an investigation. "The fire incident is shrouded in mystery. There were no eyewitnesses, and no call was made to the fire station at Aalo. One teacher who lives near the school was also unaware of the incident," West Siang Superintendent of Police Kardak Riba said. Police have registered a case under relevant sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, utilizing technical evidence in their investigation. "I am deeply disturbed by the unfortunate incident at Lipu Bagra, where miscreants set fire to the Upper Primary School in the dead of night. Although I am currently out of station on unavoidable official duties, I have been in constant touch with the district administration," local MLA Topin Ete said in a statement. The BJP legislator has directed officials to implement immediate relief measures and instructed the DDSE to arrange alternative accommodations for affected students. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Live Update: The Strategy Uses By Successful Intraday Trader TradeWise Learn More Undo "Education is the foundation of our society. Such cowardly acts will not shake our collective resolve. I stand in full solidarity with the students, teachers, and the community of Lipu Bagra. Together, we will rebuild, stronger and more united than ever," Ete added. The MLA has called for strict action against those responsible for the incident while ensuring that students' education continues without disruption through alternative arrangements.
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
Cash discovery row: SC questions Justice Yashwant Varma over his petition
New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday questioned Allahabad High Court Judge Yashwant Varma over his plea seeking invalidation of a report by an in-house inquiry panel which found him guilty of misconduct in the cash discovery row . A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and AG Masih quizzed Justice Varma over the parties made in the petition and said he should have filed an in-house inquiry report with his plea. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Product Management MBA MCA Project Management Design Thinking others Degree Finance Digital Marketing Healthcare Technology Data Science healthcare Management Artificial Intelligence PGDM Data Science CXO Operations Management Data Analytics Leadership Others Public Policy Cybersecurity Skills you'll gain: Product Strategy & Roadmapping User-Centric Product Design Agile Product Development Market Analysis & Product Launch Duration: 24 Weeks Indian School of Business Professional Certificate in Product Management Starts on Jun 26, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Creating Effective Product Roadmap User Research & Translating it to Product Design Key Metrics via Product Analytics Hand-On Projects Using Cutting Edge Tools Duration: 12 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Product Management Starts on May 14, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Product Strategy & Competitive Advantage Tactics Product Development Processes & Market Orientations Product Analytics & Data-Driven Decision Making Agile Development, Design Thinking, & Product Leadership Duration: 40 Weeks IIM Kozhikode Professional Certificate in Product Management Starts on Jun 26, 2024 Get Details Senior advocate Kapil Sibal , appearing for Justice Varma, submitted that there is a process under Article 124 (the Establishment and constitution of the Supreme Court), and a judge can't be a subject matter of public debate. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Cardiologist Reveals: The Simple Morning Habit for a Flatter Belly After 50! Lulutox Undo "The release of video on SC website, public furore, media accusations against judges are prohibited as per constitutional scheme," Sibal said. At this point, the bench said, "Why did you appear before the inquiry committee? Did you take a chance of a favourable order there first?" Live Events The hearing is underway.
