The Irish Independent's View: New housing excuses sound remarkably similar to the old ones
To understand the issue better from the inside out, and then to put measures in place that are practical and action-orientated, the minister was meeting with a wide variety of stakeholders.
He also acknowledged that things will probably get worse before they get better.
If this all sounds remarkably familiar, it's because this account of an interview by the housing minister is almost a decade old. This time nine years ago, the housing minister Simon Coveney was building up towards his big announcement of an action plan for housing. 'Rebuilding Ireland' was published in the summer of 2016 – complete with the commitment to end homelessness.
Browne's overhaul of Rent Pressure Zones will arguably make the cost of rent worse
Fast forward nine years and the current occupant of the Custom House, James Browne, is talking in strikingly similar terms about the imperative to increase supply. Browne's overhaul of Rent Pressure Zones will arguably make the cost of rent worse, initially, in order to increase the supply in the longer run, thereby making things better. But the minister doesn't appear to have the political wit to acknowledge there are immediate downsides to his plans.
The impact of the lack of supply in the market is illustrated today in the Irish Independent/REA Average House Price Index. The survey shows asking prices still rising as buyers become desperate to get a home they can call their own. This summer, the minister will also launch an action plan for housing – the latest iteration of a running theme for a decade.
Emerging from the ashes of the Celtic Tiger crash, successive governments of similar hues have failed to sufficiently increase the output of housing to anywhere near the levels required. A record 93,419 houses and apartments were built in 2006 – the highest rate in Europe. Nowadays we seem to be lucky if we break the 30,000 mark. Even the Government's bluff figure of 40,000 is well below that of a generation ago.
Whatever bells-and-whistles plan is launched this time will doubtless try to suggest that the initiatives identified are new and therefore deserving of time to bed in and deliver results. It's a hard sell at this stage as the housing excuses wear thin for this Coalition. It is simply not credible to ask the public to ignore what has gone before simply because there is a new minister appointed in a newly formed government.
Meet the new boss, he sounds remarkably similar to the old boss. Clear, coherent and credible policies will get a better reception than being told it will be different this time around.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Gareth Sheridan faces uphill battle in presidential race — everyone seems to accept this but him
Independent presidential hopeful Gareth Sheridan is not happy with some of the 'hysterical headlines' about him since he announced his intention to seek office last Sunday. He argued he wants people to 'make your judgments based on context and getting to know me', not through 'hysterical headlines'. What are the headlines he speaks of? 'I think my immediate persona that we're seeing online now is the multi-millionaire tycoon, ego maniac,' Sheridan told reporters in the Constitution Room in The Shelbourne Hotel. 'I think it's not really fitting of the person I am. I don't think I've ever used the word tycoon in a sentence, so I thought it was an interesting description." Except he has used the word 'tycoon' in a sentence. He had used it 10 minutes previously. He argued that Article 45 of the constitution stated, 'in simple terms, through your job, you should be able to afford to have a life here'. This, he said, would mean the president could tackle the Government on housing. 'It's taking a multi-millionaire pharma tycoon to now bring this to people's attention,' Sheridan said, completely unprompted. It was a simple mistake, but it underlines the naivety at the heart of his campaign. Nothing will go unnoticed and everything will be scrutinised. At 35, Gareth Sheridan will be the youngest candidate to ever contest the presidential election if he gets on the ballot paper. He is 'confident' he has a pathway to a nomination, arguing that he has as proposers and seconders at least four councillors. But, as one hopeful pointed out this week, that is the easy part. The hard part is getting the whole council to support your bid. The naivety was further underlined by Sheridan's unprompted statement that there was a concerted 'attack on his character' by people in his former business partner Sean Gallagher's circle. He argued that his campaign team has received 'copy and paste' queries on some matters, suggesting that journalists had been leaked negative stories about him. It was an intervention that he could end up regretting. During the press conference, it became clear that he is relying on several key phrases to get him through his points. This includes, 'the nurses holding up signs in Australia asking to come home' and 'grandparents continuing to see their grandkids grow up over an iPad screen'. They are valid points and, as he correctly said 'housing is an anchor for every issue we're facing in the country today'. Gareth Sheridan canvassing at the Tullamore Show with Ella Neville from Mucklagh. Picture: Alf Harvey But, considering he is only in the race since Sunday, these catchphrases have been trotted out so often they are already starting to sound tired. And, as he admitted himself, he is not going to 'pick up a hammer' and head to the buildings sites if he is president. It was also clear that Sheridan was daunted walking into the Constitution Room to face the media. As the hour-long press conference wore on, he became more confident and did, to his credit, deal with every question he was thrown in a straightforward manner. This included topics ranging from his person net worth ($15.5bn), the car he drives (a used 2021 Mercedes hybrid) and whether he had any convictions (none). He also addressed the range of other scandals that have appeared in the media this week. This ranged from his mother's objections to housing, a $25,000 fine and links to an Israeli Defence Forces Hospital. As polished as he is, he faces an uphill battle. Everyone appears to accept this but him. The race was blown open by news Mairead McGuinness was pulling out. But whether it is blown wide open enough to allow him to update his LinkedIn bio from tycoon to president remains to be seen.
Irish Post
14 hours ago
- Irish Post
Budget 2026 day set for October amid rising US tariff pressure and deficit uncertainty
BUDGET 2026 is set to be unveiled on Tuesday, 7 October, in Dublin against a backdrop of rising international uncertainty for the Irish economy. The Government has outlined a €9.4 billion package as part of the Summer Economic Statement, including €7.9 billion in additional public spending and €1.5 billion in tax cuts. However, this package was agreed upon before the recent introduction of 15% tariffs on exports to the United States. This new rate poses a serious threat to Irish trade, particularly in the pharmaceutical sector. US President Donald Trump has also hinted at even higher tariffs in the future, mainly due to the trade surplus between the two nations. Despite the ongoing uncertainty, the Government is maintaining its commitment to long-term investment and fiscal stability. Ministers Paschal Donohoe and Jack Chambers have ruled out one-off cost-of-living payments, insisting that Budget 2026 will prioritise sustainability over short-term relief. Their approach reflects caution in a fragile global environment, with the business lobby Ibec and other economic observers urging a measured and prudent strategy. The Summer Economic Statement stated that €5.9 billion of the increased expenditure will go to current spending, with €2 billion directed towards capital investment under the National Development Plan. However, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (IFAC) has raised concerns about the realism of these projections. It warns that spending overruns are likely in 2026, pointing to evidence that current spending this year has already exceeded budget targets by as much as €2 billion. IFAC also projects a budget deficit of nearly €11 billion next year which is about 3.2% of GNI, excluding corporate tax windfalls. It has criticised the government's signalling that the budget package could be reduced if the global trade environment worsens, arguing that this runs counter to standard economic practice, which recommends increased support during periods of downturn. Nevertheless, Ireland's tax revenues remain strong. Corporate tax receipts have already reached €16 billion this year, with further growth expected in 2026 due to changes in international tax rules. Income tax and VAT revenues are also holding steady, giving the government some room to manoeuvre despite looming deficits. All eyes will be on budget day on October 7th and the preceding weeks for any changes in the US President's tariff rates, which have an outsized impact on the very US-reliant Irish economy. See More: Economy, Irish Budget, Paschal Donohoe, US Tariffs
Irish Post
14 hours ago
- Irish Post
Irish government reveals date new state-of-the-art data centre set to open
A NEW state-of-the-art government data centre is set to be completed by the end of this year, Ireland's Digitalisation Minister Emer Higgins has confirmed. Work began on the site, in Backweston, Co. Kildare, in 2023 and the construction project was completed in July of this year. The internal fit-out is expected to be completed by the end of this year, with services migrating to the new tech centre in early 2026. Ireland's Digitilisation Minister Emer Higgins has provided an update on the new data centre Developed as part of Ireland's National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), under the European Union's recovery plan, NextGenerationEU, the data centre is set to future proof the delivery of essential digital services in Ireland. 'The Backweston shared Government Data Centre is a fantastic example of how NextGenerationEU funding is delivering real, tangible results,' Minister Higgins said after visting the site this week. 'This complex build was completed on time and on budget, which is a testament to the skill and dedication of everyone involved,' she added. 'It will harness the latest and most efficient technologies to ensure that vital Government data is stored in a secure and energy-efficient way, meeting the Government's technology and energy-saving requirements both now and into the future. 'This state-of-the-art facility will give State bodies the ICT infrastructure they need to work more efficiently, streamline processes, reduce duplication and bring greater consistency to how public services are delivered,' the minister explained. 'It will be operational from 2026 onwards, marking a significant step forward in our digital transformation journey, delivering on commitments in the Programme for Government and ultimately helping us to provide better public services to the people of Ireland. I welcome this important progress.' See More: Data Centre, Emer Higgins, Ireland, Kildare
