‘My sister-in-law will never organise or contribute to family events, she won't offer to help in any way'
My family are fairly typical in that there are three of us and we have been pretty close over the past few years, particularly since our dad died. We support each other and are very conscious of making life good for our mum who struggled a bit after dad's death.
The grief brought us together and I think we have an understanding of what we mean to each other, even if we don't say it. Maybe in another very Irish way, we don't speak about everything openly and things are mostly discussed in a jokey manner. However, me and my sister (we are twins) have a closer relationship and we can talk openly about most things.
The difficulty is our sister-in-law. My brother got married soon after dad died, even though he had not been dating the girl for very long, I think it might have been, partially, a reaction to the grief. However, my sister-in-law is almost rude to us and is certainly ungenerous in all her dealings with us.
They have a baby so it looks like this relationship will not end, but it is putting the rest of us off organising big get-togethers. My sister-in-law will never organise or contribute to any family events, she won't offer to help in any way and he won't contribute to family gifts (eg for weekends away for my mum). She seems very standoffish and a bit dismissive of our family's desire to get together regularly and I think that now my brother is taking her side.
READ MORE
The fact that my sister-in-law comes from a different culture may be a factor, but she has been in Ireland for more than eight years, so I'm not sure that is an excuse. I'm worried about losing my brother as part of our family, but I'm also upset at the lack of manners of my sister-in-law.
I wish that we could all speak openly about this, but I'd be really worried that this would cause an even bigger rift.
Answer
There are two problems raised in your letter: not speaking about things in your family and the behaviour of your sister-in-law. Not speaking has consequences (particularly for your different culture sister-in-law) and someone needs to break this pattern so that things in the family can be dealt with in a timely and open manner. You and your twin have clearly managed to have a close and honest relationship so you two are in the best position to address this.
Changing the habit of not speaking is a huge thing to do and needs to begin lightly and proceed in stages. For example, you might begin by saying that your family has a tradition of not speaking your minds and inquire what effect this has on everyone. You might then ask if you want this to continue to the next generation. This should get everyone thinking and pave the way for more honest discussions.
The reason you want to challenge this situation is that you do not want to cut your brother off, but you are in danger of doing this if something does not change as a slow estrangement is currently under way. Who is your brother likely to listen to? Can that person be recruited to speak to him? Or can you invite family over to something (like a barbeque) and take any opportunity to inquire about how the family can be adaptable and flexible in times of change. When we feel that our closeness is under threat, the tendency is to hold on tight and protect the group from outside influence but of course in your case, the external person has already arrived, and is no doubt, feeling excluded.
Your say your sister-in-law comes from a different culture so perhaps it is worth discovering more about this. You could ask her how family events happened in her family and country and this might give you a better understanding of her and of how families thrive in her culture.
She may feel very left out of your family and her reaction to this could be to distance herself from you all. Your brother may feel torn between his wife and his family of origin and some sensitivity is needed here. Another possibility is that you put your brother and his wife in charge of organising the next family event and they can decide who should bring what, and who should buy gifts for who – this might help them see that fairness is a very important part of all relationships.
In the end, it is very important that you do not become bitter yourself and acceptance is a good way to free yourself from this. Accept your sister-in-law as part of your family and try to manage the criticism you feel – it will only have the effect of dividing up the family.
We all want to be accepted for who we are, when this happens we might be open to change so work your own attitude first and then see what opportunities arise for connection.
To send your question to Trish Murphy, fill in the form below, click
here
or email
tellmeaboutit@irishtimes.com
.form-group {width:100% !important;}
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
New school admissions system for second-level schools to be piloted in five towns in October
A streamlined system for applying to second-level schools will be piloted across five towns later this year in a bid to overhaul what parents describe as a chaotic and stressful applications process. The single applications system for admission to first year will be piloted in Athenry, Co Galway ; Celbridge , Co Kildare ; Clonakilty , Co Cork ; Greystones , Co Wicklow ; and Tullamore, Co Offaly . Minister for Education Helen McEntee has pledged to expand the system nationwide if it is successful. She said it aims to simplify admissions, provide more certainty for parents, reduce administrative overheads for schools and provide earlier identification of duplicate applications. READ MORE 'This pilot is an important step towards delivering a more efficient, transparent and equitable school application process,' she said. 'It will reduce stress for parents and children, ease administrative burdens on schools and support better planning for school places.' At present, parents are advised to apply to multiple schools in areas that are heavily oversubscribed to boost their children's chances of securing a place in local schools. Many parents have complained that this approach results in long waiting lists and months of stress as they wait to find out if their child has secured a place. Under the new system, parents and guardians will have access to a single online application form who want to apply for a first-year place for their child in participating schools, including for special classes. Applications will open from October 1st for school places in September 2026. A combination of rapid population growth in local areas, a demographic bubble of secondary school pupils and increasing demand for special classes have placed growing pressure on school admissions across the country. Some of the areas where the single applications system have experienced acute enrolment pressure and shortages of school places, with students either left without school places or forced to travel long distances to access a place. The list of participating schools includes: Athenry (Presentation College, Clarin College and Coláiste an Eachréidh); Celbridge (Salesian College, St Wolstan's Community School, Celbridge Community School); Clonakilty (Sacred Heart Secondary School, Clonakilty Community College); Greystones (St David's Holy Faith Secondary School; Temple Carrig Secondary School, Greystones Community College); and Tullamore/Killina (Coláiste Choilm, Sacred Heart Secondary School, Killina Presentation Secondary School, Tullamore College).
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Crucial areas for conserving Irish seabirds identified by BirdWatch Ireland
A map identifying the 73 most important areas for Ireland's seabirds is being launched by BirdWatch Ireland. The wildlife NGO used the international criteria outlined by BirdLife International to identify the most crucial areas used by seabirds in Ireland. Areas designated using this criteria, for Important Bird and Biodiversity Areas (IBAs), are recognised by the European Court of Justice and the European Commission as sites that should be designated by Special Protection Areas by EU member states. The map identifies 73 important areas for Ireland's sea birds, 49 of which are colony/breeding areas and 24 of which are marine areas used by birds for feeding and wintering. A total of 41 of the colony areas are already designated as Special Protection Areas (SPAs). While two areas of the marine have been identified by the National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS) as potential SPAs. These are in the northwest Irish Sea and in the sea off Wexford. Jim Wilson has been observing the birds on the Old Head of Kinsale in Cork for more than 50 years. Mr Wilson described the location as a noisy place due to being in the middle of breeding season, with the sounds of Kittiwakes and other birds including guillemots and razorbills. However, he has noticed that the numbers of Kittiwakes are dwindling at the Old Head of Kinsale at "an alarming rate". The numbers of auk, guillemot and razorbill are also decreasing. He said protecting the sea areas for birds where they hunt is "something we need to do fast". IBAs are not a legal protection mechanism but are used to inform the designation of SPAs for birds under the EU Birds Directive. These Irish sites now form part of a global network of IBAs across 243 countries. Ireland is legally obliged to designate areas that protect the lifecycle of birds as SPAs under Article 4 of the Birds Directive, which is an EU legislation. Ireland has had designated areas for the protection of birds since 1998. A total of 24 species of breeding seabirds are hosted by Ireland's marine area, with 23 of them under a red or amber conservation status. Ireland has committed to designate 30% of its seawaters as marine protected areas by 2030. Around 9.8% have this designation. If all IBAs identified by BirdWatch Ireland on this list were designated as SPAs, that would bring the total are covered up to 17.5%. BirdWatch Ireland said it is conservative in its designation and the areas identified are the most crucial ones for Irish seabirds. Ireland's marine waters represent 8% of the total marine area of the European Union's marine area. Issues impacting the birds include a lack of protection at breeding and colony sites, bird flu, overfishing, predation by invasive species, marine pollution and climate change. Ireland began designating marine SPAs three years ago. Less than 2% of Ireland's Exclusive Economic Zone, the offshore area it has jurisdiction over living and non-living resources, is designated for seabirds. The expansion of human activities at sea, including the development of offshore wind projects, pose potential future threats to the birds. BirdWatch Ireland is calling on the Irish Government to designate the areas identified by the NGO as crucial for seabirds as SPAs. They are also calling for management plans to be developed for all SPAs so that conservation efforts can be measured and for funding to measure the potential impact of offshore renewable energy projects on Irish seabirds.
Irish Independent
7 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Phone Box Babies TV review: Revelations galore in shocking story of abandoned siblings
It was the common sense and gentleness of the three babies concerned – now in their 50s and 60s – that managed to pull the audience through. Also, Phone Box Babies is an RTÉ programme built on other programmes. First of all, the British programme Long Lost Family, hosted by Davina McCall and Nicky Campbell. We have all sobbed our way through Long Lost Family at one time or another, but never, probably, was the long-lost family so large. Here were three siblings who ended up looking for each other as well as looking for their parents. Long Lost Family has an off-shoot, Born Without Trace – surely the saddest title of all time – which concerns itself with babies who were physically abandoned by their parents. In a previous episode of Born Without Trace, it seemed that a significant proportion of the babies abandoned in the UK in the 1960s had been born to Irish parents. But David, John and Helen were not abandoned in Britain, they were abandoned in Belfast, Drogheda and Dundalk. In tartan shopping bags. On cold nights. They were carefully dressed and in good health and only a couple of days old. And all three were found by decent people. In January 1962, David had been found by a doctor's wife on the outskirts of Belfast after he had been left in her car outside her house. She discovered him when she went out to the car to bring in her shopping. In March 1968, Helen was found by a lorry driver, Donal Boyle, in a phone box in Dundalk. Donal was coming down from Belfast and he stopped in Dundalk on a very cold night for something to eat, and then remembered that he had to phone his landlady to ask her to leave a key out for him. As he went into the phone box, someone was leaving it, and that person got into a waiting car. It was John's daughter Donna who saw David and Helen on Long Lost Family and saw that 'David's hands were identical to my father's. I thought John's the middle child here. And he was' It was fascinating to see how emotional the finders of these babies – random strangers, after all – were about the children they had stumbled upon. Helen was reunited with Donal Boyle through Joe Duffy's Liveline, and in 2013 they met. Donal described it as one of the highlights, if not the highlight, of his life. In May 1965, Paul Murphy, a young reporter with the Evening Press, had found John in a phone box in Drogheda. Paul went to visit the baby in hospital – and also to write a piece about it for the Evening Press, which was accompanied by a great photograph. After that, Paul said sadly, the baby disappeared. He never knew what had happened to him. 'Then, in 2013, the baby turned up,' he said. Paul had been thinking about John over the years: 'Like a father, like a brother.' When they met they embraced. All three babies were adopted into loving families and each one was told that they had been adopted. 'I actually think that she made the right decision,' says David of his mother. ADVERTISEMENT Learn more 'They would have called me a bastard,' says John in a separate interview; and who can say that he's mistaken in that? It was quite chilling to see the siblings' adult relief at having escaped the Magdalene homes. It was David and Helen who were united by the Long Lost Family team – John was a later addition, only joining them when his daughter Donna, who had emigrated to Australia, saw David and Helen on Long Lost Family and saw that 'David's hands were identical to my father's…. I thought, 'John is the middle child here. And he was'.' Meanwhile, Davina McCall was telling David and Helen who their biological parents were. Billy Watson, a Protestant living in Dublin. And Marcella Somers, a Catholic from Kerry, who worked then in Dublin. But that wasn't the problem. The problem was that Billy was married – and had 14 children. Talk about a bombshell. One of Billy's nine surviving children from his marriage, William Watson, was happy to meet them. What a lovely man William turned out to be. His wife Breege looked supportive without saying a word – I sometimes think that wives and husbands aren't given enough credit as these explosive family stories detonate into their lives. Anyway, William explained that their father, Billy, had a band that played in Clerys, as well as around the country. He left the domestic duties to his wife. Marcella emerged as a dynamic woman, who was a great friend of the much more conservative Rosie Doherty, the mother of the snooker champion Ken Doherty. Ken remembered Marcella well, from the time she had lived in retirement accommodation in his home place of Ranelagh, Dublin. Marcella was musical, and played the accordion. In old age, Marcella had a doll, which she kept in her room and which she dressed carefully. Marcella died in Kerry in 2017, before her newly discovered children could reach her. David, John and Helen laid flowers on her grave. They don't think that they are the only children of Billy and Marcella to have been abandoned. There is talk of a fourth child, found in a phone box in Newry in 1963.
