Catalina Sandino Moreno on ‘From' fan theories: ‘Whenever you think that you're in the right lane, you're not'

Yahoo

05-06-2025

From star Catalina Sandino Moreno is completely in the dark about the show's mythology and story arcs. "Season 3 finished in such a way that it just opened up so many doors, and you don't know where the story is going to go," she tells Gold Derby.
"I have no idea where my character is going to go. I'm very curious. I've asked [creator] John [Griffin] and [producers] Jack [Bender] and Jeff [Pinkner]. I'm like, 'Just give me a little,' and they're like, 'Nope,'" she continues. "Well, we just have to wait and see what's going to happen. They're very secretive, as they usually are. Even in Season 4, they're not giving any crumbs."
More from GoldDerby
'Wicked: For Good' trailer teases more monkeys, a wedding, and Dorothy
Walton Goggins and Aimee Lou Wood: The debunked 'White Lotus' feud explained
Justine Lupe on the unexpected chemistries that power Netflix's 'Nobody Wants This'
The horror drama is set in a decaying old ghost town in middle America that appears to be under the control of an unknown malevolent force that traps anyone who arrives. The unwilling residents struggle to stay alive while plagued by nocturnal creatures lurking in the surrounding forest, as they search for secrets hidden within the town and beyond, in the hope of finding a way out.
Oscar nominee Sandino Moreno (Maria Full of Grace) stars as Tabitha Matthews alongside onscreen husband Eion Bailey as Jim Matthews, and Lost alum Harold Perrineau, who plays Boyd Stevens, the town's self-appointed sheriff and de-facto mayor of the ramshackle town of terrified survivors. The series' large ensemble cast includes Hannah Cheramy, Simon Webster, David Alpay, Elizabeth Saunders, Scott McCord, and Ricky He, who are all forced to live as a community of strangers desperate to escape.
SEE After jaw-dropping Season 3 finale, 'From' star Harold Perrineau warns that 'you can fall in love with a character,' but no one is ever safe!
The series began in Season 1 with the arrival of the Matthews family, who soon discover they are mysteriously trapped in the town with no apparent escape. Tabitha, still grieving the death of their youngest child, experiences and witnesses numerous horrors throughout the first two seasons. Her ordeal intensifies in the latest season as she uncovers more about the town's sinister secrets, her own crucial connection to the malevolent creatures and the mysterious force possibly controlling them, and perhaps a way to finally escape the nightmare that has engulfed her and her family.
By the Season 3 finale, it's revealed that Tabitha and Jade (Alpay) are reincarnations of Miranda and Christopher, key figures from the town's past who once tried, and failed, to save the town's children from an evil force. Their return suggests a recurring cycle in which they're fated to confront the town's evil again. This connection resurfaces when they play a specific melody on Miranda's violin, summoning the mysterious children in white who whisper "anghkhooey," meaning "remember," a moment that unlocks memories of their past lives and cements their renewed purpose. Tabitha also envisions a daughter that she and Jade once had in a past life, adding emotional weight to their mission. These revelations deepen their bond and clarify their roles in the battle to break the cycle, unravel the town's curse, and free its inhabitants once and for all.
"That was a huge thing for me, because they didn't tell me that I was the reincarnation of Miranda. That's why I'm so confused about what's going to happen next season," Sandino Moreno says. "I love the relationship between Tabitha and Jade, for the mere reason that Tabitha is married to someone that is very logical, and he sees everything within those eyes, unlike Jade, who is a believer,' she explains. 'Jim is very rational, and she wants to rationalize everything that happens with her, like when she went down the tunnels, and she sees all the monsters, she comes out and is like, 'I saw the monsters,' and he's like, 'Well, did you really? Maybe they were not there. Maybe they're playing with our brains.' He sees what's happening in town so different from what she feels that is happening. And I feel that's the connection between Jade and Tabitha that they see their world the same. And I can't wait to see how are they going to develop this season because they have a lot of similarities in how they see the world."
From is MGM+'s most successful series to date following its strong third season, with surging viewership numbers and deafening social media buzz. Ahead of the Season 3 finale that aired last fall, the network demonstrated its confidence in the show's future, handing it an early renewal, with production on Season 4 set to begin later this year for a 2026 premiere.
Fans have been buzzing about where the show is headed next season, with theories spreading online about the various storylines that have been teased over three seasons, picking apart every potential clue and easter egg along the way. Asked if she has any theories of her own, the actor says she doesn't even try to guess anymore. "I don't do theories I don't understand. I have a 16-year-old, and he was watching and he's like, 'What about this and this and this?' and I'm like, 'Oh, my God, you're right, maybe,'" she says with a smile. "And then, when we did Season 2, I turned to him and said, 'We're not going to do this again, we failed miserably,''" she says, adding that "whenever you think that you're in the right lane, you're not!"
Sandino Moreno is happy to leave that to the show's mastermind creator and showrunner, noting that he has planned out the show's entire plot, and will keep the show's secrets close to his chest until they're revealed in future episodes. "John knows how the show is going to end. He has it very, very clear. He knows the whole folklore about the kids and the stones and the tree, all of it. But he doesn't want to share with anyone!'
From is airing now on MGM+.
SIGN UP for Gold Derby's free newsletter with latest predictions
Best of GoldDerby
Chloë Sevigny on Kitty Menendez and 'Monsters' fascination: 'People are endlessly curious about those who have privilege and abuse it'
Jason Isaacs relives filming 'The White Lotus' piña colada scene: 'It was one of the reasons I was worried about taking the job'
Kaitlyn Dever on playing 'horrible' characters in 'Last of Us', 'Apple Cider Vinegar': 'I just don't see any other option but to give 100 percent'
Click here to read the full article.