Independence campaigners react to John Swinney speech on independence
The First Minister insisted in a speech in Edinburgh on Tuesday that independence was 'within reach' and said the constitutional question was the 'defining choice for this generation'.
But the SNP leader's comments, which come before a big party meeting this weekend, have been met with frustration from some corners of the independence movement.
Robin McAlpine (below), head of strategic development at the Common Weal think tank, told The National: 'It is a truth universally acknowledged that an SNP leader in possession of an approaching party conference must be in want of a boilerplate speech about independence. It is the SNP National Council this weekend so regular as clockwork, here is the speech.'
He added: 'As a professional political strategist I can tell you that you don't get to demand space in the political agenda, you need to earn space by having something to say that people want to hear, and that this isn't it.
'But you will have your own tolerance levels for how much longer this can go on with us pretending this is an adequate response. I doubt me telling you it is not will change much.'
READ MORE: John Swinney launches report showing Scotland 'must take charge of own destiny'
Kenny MacAskill, leader of the Alba Party, dismissed the speech as a 'damp squib'.
He said: 'What we needed and what SNP activists, members and supporters are crying out for was a clear vision and action on independence what we got from the First Minister was a damp squib.
'The First Minister said that 'independence is the defining choice' facing the Scottish people but he has yet to set out the positive difference independence will make and back that aspiration with the political will to achieve it.
'Independence is not a nice to do at some point in the future; it is absolutely essential to save our manufacturing industry, prevent further closures and job losses and to deliver lower energy prices for people and businesses. John Swinney needs to pursue independence with the urgency that is required.'
MacAskill reiterated calls for the SNP leader to contest next year's Holyrood election as an unofficial vote on independence, adding: 'John Swinney must unite the pro-independence parties and the wider independence movement by declaring that a majority of votes cast on the list for pro-independence parties will be the mandate for independence.
'Only then can he re-energise the independence campaign, put the fuel back in the tank and motivate independence supporters in the country.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Tice condemns Scottish plan to send 600,000 tonnes of rubbish to England
England should reject Scotland's rubbish, Richard Tice has said, after it emerged that up to 100 truckloads a day are to be sent over the border. The Reform UK deputy leader said it would be 'fair' for Scotland to 'sort its own rubbish' and manage the impact of the SNP's ban on landfill. Scots would be 'furious' at a situation in which large quantities of English waste had to be shipped north, he said. It emerged this week that a Scottish government ban on domestic black bin bag waste being sent to landfill from next year would result in about 600,000 tonnes of rubbish being shipped southwards from next year. Scotland does not have enough incinerators to cope with the surge in demand that the policy will cause. New incinerators and 'energy from waste' facilities that are still being built will not be ready in time. Scottish councils and commercial waste companies have approached firms in England to negotiate 'bridging contracts'. However, as there is also pressure on incinerator capacity there, much of Scotland's excess rubbish is expected to go to landfill in England instead. Experts have said that the equivalent of 80 to 100 trucks a day, seven days a week, will be needed to take the waste to England or even farther afield. Some lorries may have to travel for three days, it has been claimed, as there is particular pressure on sites in northern England. Tice, the Boston and Skegness MP, said: 'Scots would be furious if they were told to take English rubbish. The reverse is also true. Scotland should sort its own rubbish. Fair is fair.' The SNP government introduced the ban to protect the environment and deliver a 'net-zero society'. However, critics have pointed to the emissions which are set to be caused as a result of taking waste large distances — it cannot be disposed of in Scotland. The UK government also wants to eliminate biodegradable waste from landfill. It announced a consultation earlier this year, but there is no firm policy in place south of the border. Thomas Kerr, the Glasgow councillor who defected from the Conservatives to Reform in January, also said England would be within its rights to refuse to take Scottish waste. 'Like the SNP's disastrous deposit return scheme, this rushed-out policy is unworkable and will put huge pressure on English landfill,' Kerr said. 'At the very least, the SNP should wait till our national incinerator capacity is ready. Otherwise English landfills would be well within their rights to refuse to take this, and every day Scots will be left with the mess.' It had been hoped that the landfill ban, which was initially due to come into force in 2021 but was delayed due to the Covid pandemic, would coincide with an increase in recycling rates. However, these have barely shifted in a decade, with Scottish homes recycling 41.6 per cent of their waste in 2013, rising to 43.5 per cent in 2023. Kim Pratt, the senior circular economy campaigner at Friends of the Earth Scotland, said: 'By failing to prepare properly for the upcoming landfill ban, the Scottish government has missed an opportunity to move away from the current throwaway society. 'Without immediate action, Scotland will end up burning and exporting much of its waste. 'The solution is for the Scottish government to invest more in reuse and repair, provide better access to recycling services and close the loopholes in its incineration ban as soon as possible.' Gillian Martin, the SNP's climate action and energy secretary, blamed an 'incineration gap' on 'outside factors' such as inflation and the cost of building new facilities. The SNP government introduced an effective ban on new incinerators in 2022 but said existing plans for 11 sites could still proceed. Martin said: 'We've got plans for more incinerators, with energy from waste schemes, to come on in the next year and over the next three years — so it is a temporary situation.' She added that 'the positive environmental impact of stopping landfills' outweighed the impact of temporary measures to export the rubbish over the border.
Edinburgh Reporter
an hour ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Essential Documents to Prepare During Major Life Changes
Major life events such as marriage, divorce, buying property, or welcoming a child almost always require specific legal documents. Each transition requires paperwork that protects your interests and helps processes move forward without unexpected problems. Reports from the Scottish Legal Aid Board highlight a steady demand for legal support in family matters, with civil legal assistance remaining an important area. Legal paperwork plays a central role during major life changes, especially in family law matters. Correct and organised documentation supports important decisions, prevents disputes, and provides structure when circumstances shift. Solicitors with experience in family law can guide individuals through detailed forms and requirements, helping avoid the types of delays and disputes regularly reported by the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service. Professional guidance can make a marked difference when navigating complex documentation requirements during major life transitions. Key Legal Documents for Marriage and Civil Partnerships When preparing for marriage or civil partnership in Scotland, several types of paperwork should be tackled early. Planning often focuses on the event itself, but safeguarding both parties requires attention to the correct supporting documents. Registrars across Scotland require specific forms submitted within set timeframes. Initial documentation includes marriage or civil partnership notice forms. These must be submitted to the local registrar with original birth certificates and proof of address. Those with previous marriages must submit divorce decrees or dissolution certificates. Missing papers could delay or prevent registration of the marriage. Full-service family law offices can help ensure forms are properly completed, reducing administrative hassle and potential delays. Steps to Protect Your Interests: Prenuptial and Postnuptial Agreements Prenuptial agreements have become more common in Scotland, particularly when one or both parties have large assets, children from previous relationships, or own a business. These agreements specify how assets, debts, and property would be divided if the marriage or partnership ends. For a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, both parties should seek independent legal advice. Mistakes often occur when couples use informal agreements or templates found online that do not comply with Scottish legal requirements. Both parties must disclose their assets fully to avoid agreements being set aside later. Updating Wills and Beneficiaries After Marriage or Partnership Marriage or civil partnership in Scotland automatically revokes previous wills. The exception is when a will states it was drafted with that specific marriage in mind. Without updating your will, assets may not pass to intended beneficiaries, potentially causing family disagreements over an estate. Beneficiary nominations on pensions, life assurance, and investment accounts must also be reviewed, as these do not automatically update because of a marriage. Request the latest policy documentation from each provider and submit updated nomination forms if necessary. Documentation Needs During Separation and Divorce During separation or divorce, accurate paperwork is necessary for safeguarding future interests. Every case must start with a detailed financial statement, which involves collecting recent bank statements, wage slips, mortgage documents, and property valuations. Incomplete financial disclosures often cause delays in contested divorce matters. For those with children, preparing documents showing current childcare arrangements and proposed schedules is important. Professionals recommend using a written parenting plan that addresses who the children will live with, handover routines, and decision-making authority. Its essential when going through something like this, to use a solicitor with full service family law offices, to remove as much of the stress as possible. Step-by-Step Preparation for Divorce and Separation Documents Prepare a complete list of all assets and debts, using independent valuations when needed. Next, gather documentation for pensions, including the most recent statements for each scheme. For jointly owned properties, request current title deeds and understand the legal options for dividing or transferring equity. Draft a minute of agreement if terms can be settled amicably, spelling out the division of property, assets, and any ongoing maintenance payments. This formal document, when registered, makes the agreement binding in the Scottish courts. Correcting Common Errors in Separation Paperwork One recurring problem in Scottish separations involves incomplete financial disclosures. This often leads to delayed proceedings or agreements being challenged later. Solicitors recommend double-checking all figures, using professional valuations where possible, and requesting full pension sharing statements. Another issue is failing to update property records after division or sale. Every change must be formally registered with the Land Register of Scotland using up-to-date transfer forms. Incorrect or missing forms cause many rejected submissions each year. Legal Paperwork for New Parents and Guardians New parents in Scotland must register their child's birth within 21 days, establishing legal parenthood and assigning parental responsibilities. Late registration can disrupt access to child benefits and delay school enrolment for families. Parents need to contact their local registration office to book an appointment. Both parents' names can appear on the birth certificate when they attend the appointment together with proof of identity and the child's NHS birth card. If unmarried, they must complete Form 27 at the registration office. Beyond birth registration, parents should prepare wills that appoint guardians for children. This determines who would care for children if both parents died before the children reach adulthood. Without named guardians, courts decide, which can lead to disputes. Documenting Parental Rights for Non-Biological and Separated Parents Specific paperwork ensures all responsible adults have legal rights. Adoption orders, parental responsibility agreements for step-parents, or surrogacy parental orders are required for those who are not biological parents. Failing to formalise these arrangements restricts adults' ability to make medical and educational decisions. When parents do not live together, creating formal child maintenance agreements is also important. Written agreements detailing financial support help set clear expectations and reduce the likelihood of future disputes about payments. End-of-Life Documentation Everyone Should Consider Preparing for what happens if someone cannot make decisions for themselves or after they pass away should be part of everyone's planning. Many adults have not created a valid will, risking default outcomes that may not align with their wishes. Key End-of-Life Documents for Scottish Residents Power of Attorney (PoA) arrangements play an important role at any adult age. The two main types are continuing PoA, which covers property and finances, and welfare PoA, which specifies health and personal welfare decisions. Setting up both ensures trusted individuals can step in if someone becomes incapacitated. Advance Medical Directives allow a person to detail their wishes regarding future medical care if they later become unable to communicate decisions. Although not legally binding in Scotland, they provide clear instruction to doctors and family members about personal preferences for treatments. Wills, Inheritance Tax, and Asset Distribution Wills are at the heart of end-of-life planning. Without a current will, assets will be distributed according to the default rules of intestacy, which may not match individual family situations. Drafting or updating a will enables people to decide who receives property, money, or personal items. Inheritance tax planning documents can help reduce future tax bills for beneficiaries. This may include keeping detailed records of gifts, establishing trusts, or seeking advice on insurance. Regular consultation with legal advisers ensures strategies remain compliant and effective. Essential Document Preparation Timeline Preparing these documents at the right time is important. Marriage documents should be addressed before the wedding or shortly after. Registering a child's birth and updating wills within three months helps prevent benefits disruption and ensures compliance with local regulations. Separation paperwork should begin once the decision to separate is made. End-of-life documents are best created while in good health, typically starting in the 30s or 40s with regular reviews every few years. This helps keep them current with changing circumstances and wishes. Document Storage Best Practices Proper storage of legal documents ensures they are available when needed. National Records of Scotland recommend keeping originals in a fireproof, waterproof container or a safe deposit box. Digital copies stored securely online serve as practical backups. Information about document locations should be shared with trusted family members or a solicitor. Families who provide clear document instructions encounter fewer delays during probate or family law proceedings. Regular reviews and updates of all legal documents are important, especially after major life changes. Like this: Like Related
Edinburgh Reporter
an hour ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
End of the two child cap coming next year in Scotland
During a visit to a mother and toddler group in Portobello, Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville has confirmed that The Scottish Government will 'effectively' scrap the impact of the two-child limit from 2 March 2026. When she visited Busy Bees Bellfield parent and toddler group Ms Somerville said the introduction of the Two Child Limit Payment will mean 20,000 fewer children will be living in relative poverty in 2026-27, according to modelling carried out by the Scottish Government. Ahead of a statement to parliament on the publication of the annual report on Best Start, Bright Futures, which is the Scottish Government's child poverty strategy, Ms Somerville said:'The Scottish Government has consistently called on the UK Government to end the two-child cap. Reports suggest that they are looking at the impact it is having. But the evidence is clear and families and Scotland can't wait any longer for the UK Government to make up its mind to do the right thing and scrap the cap once and for all. 'The Two Child Limit Payment will begin accepting applications in March next year. At less than 15 months from when we announced this in the Scottish budget, this will be the fastest that a Scottish social security benefit has been delivered. 'This builds upon the considerable action we have taken in Scotland, including delivering unparalleled financial support through our Scottish Child Payment, investing to clear school meal debts, and continuing to support almost 10,000 children by mitigating the UK Government's Benefit Cap as fully as possible. 'However, austerity decisions taken by the UK Government are holding back Scotland's progress. Modelling published in March makes clear that if the UK Government act decisively on child poverty, they could help to take an estimated 100,000 children out of poverty this year.' The UK Government's two child cap is a policy in place since 2017 which restricts any universal credit payment to just two children in one family. This means that families with three and more children cannot have any means-tested support for them. (There are limited exceptions.) The Child Poverty Action Group said that this tax on siblings is 'the biggest driver of rising child poverty in the UK today. It breaks the link between what children need and the support they receive.' Government figures show that one in 9 children are affected by this cap on benefits, and almost 60% of those who are affected by the policy have at least one parent who works. If it is lifted then Treasury Minister, Torsten Bell, said he believes this measure alone could lift 470,000 children in the UK out of poverty. The UK Government is reportedly considering getting rid of the measure which was introduced by the Conservatives, having said they would remove the measure 'when fiscal conditions allow', and the scrapping of this would cost around £3.5 billion a year. The government is due to announce its child poverty strategy in the autumn of this year. Photo courtesy of The Scottish Government Like this: Like Related
