Gabby Petito murder documentary sparks viewer backlash after it uses fake AI voiceover
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission.
Netflix's American Murder: Gabby Petito has upset some people for using an AI-generated voice to narrate Petito's journal entries.
Despite permission from Petito's family, critics argue the AI voice raises ethical concerns.
This isn't the first occurrence of such debate, and it will likely keep happening as the technology improves.
Netflix's latest true-crime docuseries, American Murder: Gabby Petito, has stirred up a heated debate over how to deploy AI to mimic the voices of people who have passed away. The filmmakers employed AI to recreate Petito's voice and have it narrate excerpts from her personal writings, which has reportedly made many viewers feel uncomfortable and raised ethical concerns about using AI to give voice to the deceased.
The three-part series chronicles the 2021 murder of 22-year-old Petito at the hands of her fiancé, Brian Laundrie. It pieces together her final months through interviews, personal videos, and social media posts, evoking how the tragedy happened in real-time on the internet. True crime aficionados famously dissected every frame of Petito's travel vlogs before authorities found her remains in Wyoming.
At the start of the series, a disclaimer appears: 'Gabby's journal entries and text messages are brought to life in this series in her own voice, using voice recreation technology.' That means the voice narrating parts of the documentary isn't actually Petito's but a synthetic recreation made with an AI model. Netflix has said the filmmakers received permission from Petito's family to do so. That hasn't stopped some people from vocalizing how eerie the AI-generated voice feels. Social media content creators have racked up hundreds of thousands of views discussing it.
This isn't the first controversy over AI-generated voices. Roadrunner: A Film About Anthony Bourdain faced similar criticism when its director revealed that parts of the documentary featured AI-generated narration of Bourdain's own words. That movie didn't indicate which bits were narrated by the AI or by Bourdain, which led many to feel that the technique was deceptive.
Filmmaker Michael Gasparro defended the decision in an interview with Us Weekly, saying the team wanted to tell the story as much 'through Gabby's voice as possible.' They had access to a wealth of her journals, notes, and online posts and thought AI narration would bring them to life in a more powerful way. 'At the end of the day, it's her story.'
Technology has always shaped the way we tell stories, but AI presents a new challenge, especially when it comes to memorializing people who can no longer speak for themselves. Robert Downey Jr. has vowed that AI will never replicate him on screen, while James Earl Jones secured a deal with Disney before passing away, allowing them to use his voice for Darth Vader under certain circumstances.
Meanwhile, ElevenLabs has inked deals with the estates of James Dean, Burt Reynolds, Judy Garland, and Sir Laurence Olivier to let it add AI versions of their voices to its Reader app. As deepfake technology and voice cloning become more sophisticated, filmmakers and media companies will have to reckon with how (and if) these tools should be used to tell real-life stories.
Robert Downey Jr. vows there will never be a digital AI replica of him on-screen
How you can get (AI versions of) Judy Garland or Burt Reynolds to read to you
Why the passing of James Earl Jones doesn't mean you won't hear Darth Vader's voice again
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Tom's Guide
2 hours ago
- Tom's Guide
Netflix just added a fast-paced action thriller — and it's my favorite Gerard Butler movie
"Plane" is my favorite movie new on Netflix this week. It might even be my favorite movie coming to Netflix this month. It's definitely my favorite Gerard Butler movie — well, at least for live action. Now, I'll fully admit I have a soft spot for the Scottish actor. I've written about how "Gamer" is my favorite "bad movie," and I'll gladly hit play on "Den of Thieves," "300" or even "The Ugly Truth." I could go on and on, but honestly, if I could recommend just one Gerard Butler movie — setting aside "How to Train Your Dragon" — it'd be "Plane." This movie delivers what it promises. It's not overly convoluted and the action sequences are great, even if they're not on par with something you'd get from a "John Wick" movie. So sit down, grab some popcorn, and set the phone aside for this fast-paced 107-minute-long action thriller. Here's why "Plane" is the movie you need to be streaming right now on Netflix. In "Plane," Butler stars as commercial airline pilot Brodie Torrance. He's looking to join his daughter for some quality time, and the only thing standing in his way is completing Trailblazer Airlines Flight 119. This looks set to be an uneventful flight, with just 14 passengers heading from Hawaii to Japan. Even the addition of a fugitive being extradited by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police seems unlikely to send things into chaos. But Torrance is forced to go through a storm, during which a lightning strike fries the plane's avionics. He manages to land the plane safely — only to discover he's in the pirate-controlled Jolo Islands. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. Now, Brodie, a former RAF pilot, and the fugitive Louis (Mike Colter), a former French Foreign Legionnaire, have to use their military training to keep the surviving passengers and crew alive until they can finally be rescued — or find another way off the island. In retrospect, "Plane" came at just the right time for me. Too many movies, including more than a few disappointing Marvel movies, were convoluted, filled with bad CGI and just too often ... well, boring. Not "Plane" though. This movie harkens back to the era of 2000s action movies that were slick but not campy, with just the right level of production value and a simple premise. This movie also does get one little thing right, which many action movies struggle with. Butler is the star of this movie, and he gets in some great fights during it. But he's supposed to be an aging, perhaps even washed-up, former RAF pilot. The movie leans into this, letting Butler get beat up more than once, and it's clear as you watch it that Louis, who is a former French Legionnaire (it seems likely he was involved in some special or black ops while in the service) and still in peak shape, is the better killer of the two. Which he should be, based on what we know about the characters. Many action movies would force Butler to be the one to always get the glory and come away looking the best, but "Plane" allows Butler to perform the way we'd expect his character to perform. Most importantly, though, the action in this movie is fun. There's a scene where Colter's Louis takes out some bad guys with a sledgehammer, and that's never a bad time. Don't just take my word for it, though. If you head over to Rotten Tomatoes, you'll see this has a 79% rating from critics (not bad) but a 94% rating from audience viewers. After looking through the reviews, it's clear the audience got this one right, because they view a "standard" action thriller as a good thing, not a failure to be something greater. To be clear, "standard" is pretty apt for describing "Plane," but that's exactly why it works so well. It's all killer, no filler, giving you exactly what you want from a fast-paced extraction action movie. I promise you that there are better action movies out there. But, I also promise you that you'll have a great time watching "Plane." I know I did. Stream 'Plane' now on Netflix Malcolm has been with Tom's Guide since 2022, and has been covering the latest in streaming shows and movies since 2023. He's not one to shy away from a hot take, including that "John Wick" is one of the four greatest films ever made. Here's what he's been watching lately:
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Fantastic Four producer teases the new Marvel movie's villain and says Galactus is "the most epic of the most epic that you can imagine"
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. Whatever your expectations are for The Fantastic Four: First Steps villain Galactus, raise them – according to producer Grant Curtis, at least. "The most epic of the most epic that you can imagine," Curtis said in a new interview with Collider when asked what we can expect from the world-devouring entity. "Because that's the global stakes we're dealing with, the universal stakes we're dealing with. That's Galactus. When Galactus's gaze comes across your planet, you're not in a good spot. I think that's as big of a scope and scale you could ever ask a villain to bring with him or her. And that is what Galactus brings... One of the beautiful things about working with Kevin Feige and with [director] Matt Shakman, they are totally in on sci-fi." The movie's big bad will be played by Ralph Ineson, who's best known for his role in the UK version of The Office but has also appeared in movies like The Green Knight, The Northman, and Nosferatu. Julia Garner will play Galactus' herald, Silver Surfer. The character previously appeared in 2007's Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer, where he was depicted as a cloud-like form, but First Steps is taking Galactus back to his comic book origins. We recently got our first look at him, headpiece and all, in an unlikely way: a Snapple promotion. As for Marvel's First Family, Pedro Pascal, Vanessa Kirby, Joseph Quinn, and Ebon Moss-Bachrach are bringing Reed Richards, Sue Storm, Johnny Storm, and Ben Grimm to the MCU. The cast also includes John Malkovich, Natasha Lyonne, and Paul Walter Hauser. The Fantastic Four: First Steps arrives in theaters on July 25 as part of Marvel Phase 6. For more, check out our guide to all the other upcoming superhero movies still to come in 2025 and beyond.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Fantastic Four leaks aren't stopping and they're getting even more bizarre – with Galactus being fully revealed in a Snapple promotion
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. Drink it in: The first full look at Fantastic Four's Galactus is here – thanks to a Snapple promotion. While we've had brief glimpses of the Devourer of Worlds stomping his way through 1960s New York in the early Fantastic Four trailers, we haven't seen the entire figure of the Ralph Ineson-voiced villain. Until now, that is. As you can see below (H/T Galactus is sporting his comic-accurate headgear and – if you ask us, anyway – the face looks modelled slightly on Ralph Ineson, which is a neat touch. There's also more Snapple-related Fantastic Four promos abound. Artist Dylan Schepers is even showcasing most of the work on his website, as well as the flavors tied to each hero. If you're curious, Reed Richards is Snapple Apple, Sue Storm is Peach Tea, Johnny Storm is Peach Tea Zero Sugar, and Ben Grimm is Kiwi Strawberry. If you've been following along, you'll know that this isn't the only Fantastic Four leak in recent days. Thanks to a wave of upcoming Funko Pops, we now know that Sue Storm will seemingly give birth during the course of the Marvel Phase 6 entry, with son Franklin Richards playing some sort of role in the narrative. Fantastic Four, starring Pedro Pascal, Vanessa Kirby, Ebon Moss-Bachrach, and Joseph Quinn, hits cinemas on July 25. For more, check out the upcoming Marvel movies headed into cinemas over the next few years. Then catch up on the story so far with the Marvel timeline and how to watch the Marvel movies in order.
