Gabby Petito murder documentary sparks viewer backlash after it uses fake AI voiceover
Netflix's American Murder: Gabby Petito has upset some people for using an AI-generated voice to narrate Petito's journal entries.
Despite permission from Petito's family, critics argue the AI voice raises ethical concerns.
This isn't the first occurrence of such debate, and it will likely keep happening as the technology improves.
Netflix's latest true-crime docuseries, American Murder: Gabby Petito, has stirred up a heated debate over how to deploy AI to mimic the voices of people who have passed away. The filmmakers employed AI to recreate Petito's voice and have it narrate excerpts from her personal writings, which has reportedly made many viewers feel uncomfortable and raised ethical concerns about using AI to give voice to the deceased.
The three-part series chronicles the 2021 murder of 22-year-old Petito at the hands of her fiancé, Brian Laundrie. It pieces together her final months through interviews, personal videos, and social media posts, evoking how the tragedy happened in real-time on the internet. True crime aficionados famously dissected every frame of Petito's travel vlogs before authorities found her remains in Wyoming.
At the start of the series, a disclaimer appears: 'Gabby's journal entries and text messages are brought to life in this series in her own voice, using voice recreation technology.' That means the voice narrating parts of the documentary isn't actually Petito's but a synthetic recreation made with an AI model. Netflix has said the filmmakers received permission from Petito's family to do so. That hasn't stopped some people from vocalizing how eerie the AI-generated voice feels. Social media content creators have racked up hundreds of thousands of views discussing it.
This isn't the first controversy over AI-generated voices. Roadrunner: A Film About Anthony Bourdain faced similar criticism when its director revealed that parts of the documentary featured AI-generated narration of Bourdain's own words. That movie didn't indicate which bits were narrated by the AI or by Bourdain, which led many to feel that the technique was deceptive.
Filmmaker Michael Gasparro defended the decision in an interview with Us Weekly, saying the team wanted to tell the story as much 'through Gabby's voice as possible.' They had access to a wealth of her journals, notes, and online posts and thought AI narration would bring them to life in a more powerful way. 'At the end of the day, it's her story.'
Technology has always shaped the way we tell stories, but AI presents a new challenge, especially when it comes to memorializing people who can no longer speak for themselves. Robert Downey Jr. has vowed that AI will never replicate him on screen, while James Earl Jones secured a deal with Disney before passing away, allowing them to use his voice for Darth Vader under certain circumstances.
Meanwhile, ElevenLabs has inked deals with the estates of James Dean, Burt Reynolds, Judy Garland, and Sir Laurence Olivier to let it add AI versions of their voices to its Reader app. As deepfake technology and voice cloning become more sophisticated, filmmakers and media companies will have to reckon with how (and if) these tools should be used to tell real-life stories.
Robert Downey Jr. vows there will never be a digital AI replica of him on-screen
How you can get (AI versions of) Judy Garland or Burt Reynolds to read to you
Why the passing of James Earl Jones doesn't mean you won't hear Darth Vader's voice again
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
13 minutes ago
- USA Today
'Love is Blind' star Stacy Snyder reveals payout from class-action lawsuit
The "Love is Blind" production company settled with more than 100 cast and crew members in a 2022 class-action lawsuit. Stacy Snyder, one of the "Love is Blind" cast members who took legal action against the show, has shared how much she made off of the multi-million dollar class action lawsuit. Snyder was on Season 5 of the popular Netflix dating show, where she made it down the aisle with contestant Izzy Zapata, before calling the engagement off at the altar. Originally, the pair said they planned to stay together and work on things, but they ended up breaking up about a week after the season aired. Snyder joined in on what became a class-action lawsuit against the show's production company, Kinetic Content, after it was originally filed by Season 2 contestant Jeremey Hartwell in July 2022, alleging that cast members were forced to work long hours in poor conditions with no pay. In December 2024, Netflix chose to settle for $1.4 million to be divided amongst all parties, more than a third of which was designated for attorneys' fees. Here is what to know about the lawsuit and how much Snyder received from the settlement. What does the 'Love is Blind' lawsuit say? The complaint obtained by USA TODAY accuses Kinetic of enforcing "unsafe and inhumane working conditions," exerting "excessive control" over cast members' lives and pushing "sleep deprivation, isolation, lack of food and excessive alcohol" on contestants for "entertainment value." The cast and crew were required to work 20 hours a day, seven days a week, for just $1,000 per week, the suit also alleged, equating to just $7.14 per hour. The lawsuit ultimately included around 144 former cast and crew members. How much did Stacy Snyder receive from the settlement? Snyder shared what her cut looked like on TikTok in July, posting a video of herself opening the settlement check with the caption, "when the trauma turns into a direct deposit." "This is what I am owed for filming not even two full months," she said, showing an $8,287 check to the camera. "This is more than I got paid for filming an entire season of 12 to 20-hour workdays." In the TikTok, Snyder says she doesn't "know if (she's) mad or happy," adding that "it's more of the justice piece and not the money." "It's just sick that people who have power take advantage of people they know don't know any better in these situations," she said.
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Walmart just ripped and tore $25 off the price of the DOOM: The Dark Ages Xbox controller
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. I'm not going to beat around the bush with this one because, by the looks of it, you don't have a lot of time. The special edition Xbox Series X Core controller that's been decorated with the DOOM Slayer's armor has dropped by $25 at Walmart. Since it's more expensive than a lot of the other Core controller colorways, now is the time to grab one of the best Xbox Series X controller designs going. The reason I say that it doesn't look like you have much time is that the Walmart listing says there are only 7 left at the time of writing. These warnings on retail pages aren't always trustworthy, but seeing as this particular product is out of stock at Amazon, I'm inclined to believe that this one might be running out. Elsewhere, at Best Buy, you can grab it for its full $79.99 price, but Walmart is the only retailer currently stocking it for $54. DOOM The Dark Ages Limited Edition Xbox Series X Wireless Controller | $79.99 $54 at WalmartSave $25.99 - It usually takes a while for brand new Xbox controller limited editions to see deals like this, and in fact, most of them are out of stock by the time they would get price cuts. If you're a fan of DOOM and want an Xbox controller that celebrates the franchise, don't wait around for this deal to disappear. Buy it if: ✅ You're a big DOOM fan✅ You want a new Xbox controller Don't buy it if: ❌ You want a pro controller UK: £54.66 at AmazonView Deal What I admire about this controller design is that it isn't afraid to go all out. A lot of DualSense and Xbox controller limited editions don't exactly commit very hard to their franchise or game. This usually means that the controller just looks sort of ordinary, with a custom color scheme and a few tiny details that represent a certain game. This DOOM Slayer livery isn't afraid to be bold, complete with some 3D textures on it that really set it apart from the rest of the Wireless controller designs. As a result, it actually does look like an authentic recreation of DOOM guy's armor, which I'm sure many people will appreciate having played the new DOOM: The Dark Ages. Alongside the more obvious parts, this controller also has the finer details a true fan would want. The glyphs on the buttons aren't your standard ABXY, and there's even a beautiful blood splatter - because DOOM Slayer's armor has never been clean. If I were you, I wouldn't wait around on this one. If you fancy the look of this controller but have been put off by the price, now is the time to sling your grapple hook at it and reel it in. The only thing I'd advise is that if you want anything more than a standard Xbox controller, maybe look elsewhere. There are plenty of officially licensed Xbox gamepads that will also work as PC controllers and will grant you a lot more functionality. Rather spend your money elsewhere? View all Xbox controllers at Amazon Best value: Grab the new GameSir G7 Pro The best deal right now: PowerA Fusion Pro for $127 If you're buying for another platform, check out the best PS5 controllers, the best Nintendo Switch controllers, and the best racing wheels for PC.
Yahoo
42 minutes ago
- Yahoo
E.l.f. Cosmetics responds to backlash over casting comedian Matt Rife in new beauty ad
Rife was criticized in 2023 for making a joke about domestic violence in his Netflix comedy special. Beauty company E.l.f. Cosmetics responded to backlash this week over its new ad campaign starring comedian Matt Rife, who was criticized for making a joke about domestic violence in his 2023 comedy special. 'You know us, we're always listening and we've heard you,' the brand wrote on Instagram on Wednesday. 'This campaign aimed to humorously spotlight beauty injustice. We understand we missed the mark with people we care about in our e.l.f. community.' The commercial in question features Rife and drag queen Heidi N Closet playing 'beauty attorneys' who want to protect their clients from overpriced beauty products from other brands. The ad was posted on social media on Aug. 11, and the comments section was quickly flooded with questions about why the company would associate with Rife. The ad was still up on E.l.f.'s official Instagram page as of Thursday. Rife has not commented on the backlash but wrote 'Had a great time ❤️❤️' on E.l.f.'s post responding to the criticism. E.l.f. Beauty, the parent company of E.l.f. Cosmetics, did not respond to Yahoo's request for comment. 'We're very surprised,' Kory Marchisotto, E.l.f. Beauty's global chief marketing officer, told Business of Fashion about the negative response to the ad. 'There is a big gap between our intention and how this missed the mark for some people.' Marchisotto said that Rife was cast in the E.l.f. ad because of his TikTok following, which, she said, is 80% female and 75% under the age of 34. Rife's social media following showed strong, positive engagement, Marchisotto added, which factored into the casting decision. (Rife posted the E.l.f. ad on his own Instagram on Tuesday and received many supportive comments from fans.) 'We always aim to deliver positivity, and this one didn't,' Marchisotto told Business of Fashion. 'So we find ourselves in a position where, quite honestly, that doesn't feel good for us.' Rife has been a stand-up comedian for over a decade and made headlines in November 2023 over his Netflix special Natural Selection. In one of the first jokes of the special, he suggests that a waitress with a black eye must not work in the restaurant's kitchen because 'if she could cook, she wouldn't have that black eye.' 'I figure we start the show with domestic violence, the rest of the show should be pretty smooth sailing after that,' Rife says after the joke. Many slammed the joke online and criticized Rife for using a platform as big as Netflix to make light of domestic violence against women. In response to the Natural Selection controversy, Rife wrote in an Instagram Story, 'If you've ever been offended by a joke I've told — here's a link to my official apology.' The link led to a website that sold medical helmets for people with special needs, NBC News reported at the time. Most of E.l.f.'s ads from the last few years have aimed to be as culturally and topically relevant as possible, from casting Jennifer Coolidge at the height of her White Lotus popularity in the brand's first Super Bowl commercial in 2023 to partnering with activist and astronaut Amanda Nguyen for Blue Origin's first all-female spaceflight. In May, the company acquired Hailey Bieber's Rhode skin care brand in a $1 billion deal. Solve the daily Crossword
