'BN rural, PH urban' formula not foolproof, says analyst
Universiti Malaya socio-political analyst Datuk Professor Dr Awang Azman Awang Pawi said while BN's deep-rooted grassroots networks and PH's stronger traction among urban, younger and middle-class voters made the division of focus appear realistic, Sabah's voting patterns were far more fluid compared to Peninsular Malaysia.
"Fundamentally, this division of focus appears realistic because it takes into account Sabah's demographic reality.
"However, voters can easily shift support based on current issues, candidate personalities, and local sentiments.
"Thus, the formula is not foolproof," he said when contacted.
He added that the BN–PH strategy carries both the potential to complement each other and the risk of creating friction, depending on how it is managed.
"If BN focuses on rural seats and PH on urban ones, both sides can avoid clashing and work together more effectively against Warisan and Perikatan Nasional (PN).
"But this only works if there is a clear seat-sharing deal and strong candidates.
"Problems may also arise in semi-urban or mixed seats, where support overlaps. Umno's rejection of Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) could also put PH in a difficult position, forcing it to choose between siding more with BN or with GRS," he said.
On Sunday, Umno Supreme Council member Datuk Seri Ahmad Maslan announced that BN is expected to dominate rural seats while PH will take charge of urban constituencies under a seat-sharing agreement finalised for the upcoming Sabah state election.
Previously, BN chairman Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said the coalition's pact with PH for the upcoming Sabah election was final, but that they remained open to cooperation with other Sabah-based parties or coalitions.
Zahid also said that while the cooperation between PH and GRS was a mutual agreement between the two coalitions, the partnership between BN and PH was now officially confirmed.
Commenting further, Awang Azman said BN's refusal to work with GRS may strengthen PH's position as the balancing force, but it could also weaken the unity government if not managed carefully.
He added that the refusal could indirectly strengthen GRS's reliance on PH, positioning the coalition as the "bridge" to ensure state–federal stability.
"However, this may also open BN to accuse PH of betraying its interests, which could strain relations within the unity government.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
'BN rural, PH urban' formula not foolproof, says analyst
KUALA LUMPUR:The electoral formula that Barisan Nasional (BN) should concentrate on rural seats while Pakatan Harapan (PH) focuses on urban areas may sound practical, but it is not a foolproof strategy for the Sabah state election. Universiti Malaya socio-political analyst Datuk Professor Dr Awang Azman Awang Pawi said while BN's deep-rooted grassroots networks and PH's stronger traction among urban, younger and middle-class voters made the division of focus appear realistic, Sabah's voting patterns were far more fluid compared to Peninsular Malaysia. "Fundamentally, this division of focus appears realistic because it takes into account Sabah's demographic reality. "However, voters can easily shift support based on current issues, candidate personalities, and local sentiments. "Thus, the formula is not foolproof," he said when contacted. He added that the BN–PH strategy carries both the potential to complement each other and the risk of creating friction, depending on how it is managed. "If BN focuses on rural seats and PH on urban ones, both sides can avoid clashing and work together more effectively against Warisan and Perikatan Nasional (PN). "But this only works if there is a clear seat-sharing deal and strong candidates. "Problems may also arise in semi-urban or mixed seats, where support overlaps. Umno's rejection of Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) could also put PH in a difficult position, forcing it to choose between siding more with BN or with GRS," he said. On Sunday, Umno Supreme Council member Datuk Seri Ahmad Maslan announced that BN is expected to dominate rural seats while PH will take charge of urban constituencies under a seat-sharing agreement finalised for the upcoming Sabah state election. Previously, BN chairman Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said the coalition's pact with PH for the upcoming Sabah election was final, but that they remained open to cooperation with other Sabah-based parties or coalitions. Zahid also said that while the cooperation between PH and GRS was a mutual agreement between the two coalitions, the partnership between BN and PH was now officially confirmed. Commenting further, Awang Azman said BN's refusal to work with GRS may strengthen PH's position as the balancing force, but it could also weaken the unity government if not managed carefully. He added that the refusal could indirectly strengthen GRS's reliance on PH, positioning the coalition as the "bridge" to ensure state–federal stability. "However, this may also open BN to accuse PH of betraying its interests, which could strain relations within the unity government.
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
Anwar: Meeting with BN and GRS leaders a step towards political stability
PETALING JAYA: Prime Minister Datuk Anwar Ibrahim said the meeting with Barisan Nasional (BN) chairman Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi and Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) president Datuk Seri Panglima Hajiji Noor was held in a harmonious manner. 'This meeting reflects political maturity and a commitment to strengthening cooperation for the sake of national stability, discussing the relations between the Federal Government and the Sabah State Government,' he added in a social media post on Monday (Aug 18). 'I believe political stability is the foundation for progressing the development agenda and the welfare of the people. Anwar said that close collaboration between state and federal leaders is vital in ensuring that people's aspirations are realised holistically and in an inclusive manner. 'I hope that this spirit of consensus will continue to be the foundation for a stronger national unity, and that the future of Malaysia becomes a progressive, fair and prosperous future for all,' At the Dewan Rakyat on Monday, Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Fadillah Yusof said that 13 out of the 29 demands under the MA63 have been resolved, and nine of the 13 were finalised during the Madani administration, while four were carried out through previous administrations. 'This includes education, health, petroleum and oil royalties,' said the Energy Transition and Water Transformation Ministry.
Borneo Post
6 hours ago
- Borneo Post
People's priorities main focus of Warisan, says Shafie
Shafie (right) speaking to Chris at his residence in Kota Kinabalu. KOTA KINABALU (Aug 18): Parti Warisan (Warisan) will contest the upcoming state elections on its own, with the people's priorities as its main focus, said its president Datuk Seri Shafie Apdal. Responding to analyst reports predicting no single party will secure a majority, Shafie said Warisan has been an opposition party in Sabah for six years, and the priority is ensuring Sabahans decide their own future. 'I cannot make assumptions that if we don't have the numbers, then we have to work with others — we're not driven by greed. 'I'm worried that an election partner would be more concerned about benefits from the seats they win. To me, we need clarity. Let us be the only choice for Sabahans — we must resolve the people's needs now,' he said after receiving a courtesy call from United States Embassy political counsellor Chris Carver at his residence here today. Shafie stressed that Warisan will be selective in fielding candidates to prevent individuals implicated in corruption from further tarnishing Sabah's politics. 'We are not here to please them. We have to win the elections. I already told them that no corrupt practices will be tolerated,' he said. When asked if Warisan, as the main local party, would work with other Sabah-based parties, Shafie emphasised that trust and consistency are crucial. He revealed that a leader of a component party in a local coalition had told him they would leave the coalition last year, yet remained in it. 'This shows inconsistency. If they don't get the seats or arrangements they want, they will pull out. This means they are still thinking of themselves instead of the people, who still face water and electricity problems. 'Warisan was set up to fight for Sabah's rights, not to be YBs. We want proper leaders,' he said. Although not discounting potential cooperation with local parties, Shafie stressed that Warisan's focus is to work directly with the people to drive transformative change. On candidates, he said there are three to five potential individuals for each constituency, and all profiles are being scrutinised carefully. 'First, we have to win. Second, once they become YBs, they must serve their people. The people's voice must be the priority,' he said. Shafie's meeting with Chris also touched on Sabah's economy, well-being and opportunities for international partnerships. 'Interestingly, we also talked about women's football, which is very popular in Sabah. Many Malaysian national team players are Sabahans, showing our strength and passion for the game,' he said. He added that the US Embassy's recent soccer clinic in Sabah highlighted the potential for youth development and sports exchanges. 'It's always encouraging when Sabah is recognised not just for our resources, but for our people and their talents,' said Shafie.
