I made over a dozen Ina Garten pasta recipes and ranked them by deliciousness

Business Insider

2 days ago

Ina Garten has published many pasta recipes, and I've made 13 from her repertoire so far.
Her mac and cheese is creamy and comforting, while her lemon pasta is ready in 10 minutes.
Garten's easy and rich penne alla vodka takes my top spot.
From a comforting mac and cheese to the quick pasta, pesto, and peas, you'll find a variety of pasta recipes spread across Ina Garten's 13 cookbooks and her Barefoot Contessa site.
I started cooking Garten's recipes after I spent a day following her quarantine routine in May 2020. At the height of the pandemic, I often turned to her pastas for simple but comforting dinners.
I've now made over a dozen of Garten's pasta dishes. Some are vegetarian and take almost no prep, while others are loaded with meat or cheese.
Here's how they all stack up.
In 13th place is Garten's broccoli and bow ties pasta.
Garten's broccoli and bow ties recipe was the first Barefoot Contessa pasta I ever made. It was also the first recipe Garten shared with her Instagram followers after much of the US went into lockdown in 2020.
The Food Network star promised this pasta was "crazy easy" and could be easily adapted with whatever was in your pantry.
The simple recipe includes garlic, lemon, butter, and Parmesan cheese, along with the pasta and broccoli (or, in my case, Broccolini).
Garten's broccoli and bow ties recipe has a light sauce that makes it perfect for spring.
The sauce is made with just lemon zest, butter, olive oil, and minced garlic, which all work together to give the dish a burst of flavor. The sharp Parmesan cheese also adds a nice hint of richness.
While I loved how bright and healthy this dish tasted, I would soon discover other pasta recipes that were far more memorable.
Taking the 12th spot is Garten's simple three-ingredient lemon pasta.
Garten says her three-ingredient lemon pasta is "just about the fastest weeknight pasta meal you can make," and she's not wrong.
The recipe consists of just pasta, unsalted butter, and the juice and zest of two lemons.
Better yet? You'll have dinner on the table in 10 minutes or less.
Garten's lemon pasta has a lovely, bright flavor, but it doesn't stand out enough to be the main course.
There's not much depth of flavor in Garten's three-ingredient pasta. I whipped up her dish for a dinner party, and my friends agreed that it worked better as a side.
"The pasta had me mad at myself for every time I've bought a $20 pasta limon from a restaurant when it's so simple to make," my friend Tyler said. "But if we were just having the pasta on its own, I would have been a little disappointed because it wasn't anything too special."
I would serve Garten's lemon pasta alongside her incredible "outrageous" garlic bread, which goes well with just about everything, and would give this meal some more flavor and heft.
Garten's spring green spaghetti carbonara takes the 11th spot.
As with all the recipes in her "Modern Comfort Food" cookbook, Garten wanted to give a traditional dish — in this case, spaghetti carbonara — a modern twist.
Garten's carbonara comes packed with green veggies, including asparagus, scallions, and two types of peas.
Garten's spring carbonara is deliciously light and creamy.
I was pleasantly surprised by this pasta, which I think is perfect for spring or summer. The carbonara sauce is creamy without being too heavy, and it's balanced perfectly with the fresh flavors from all the veggies.
The pancetta also adds a nice crunch and savoriness to the pasta — I only wish there had been more!
I served the dish to my parents, who both loved it. My dad called it "light and lemony," while my mom thought it'd be ideal for a barbecue.
In 10th place is Garten's comforting baked rigatoni with lamb ragù.
Garten's baked rigatoni with lamb ragù is also from her cookbook "Modern Comfort Food."
It's one of Garten's more complex pasta dishes. The recipe is packed with a long list of ingredients — including two types of cheese, red wine, and plenty of veggies — and takes almost two hours to make.
Garten's baked rigatoni with lamb ragù is super delicious — but it's a lot of work.
The rich sauce has that comforting, traditional Italian taste thanks to the carrots and other vegetables, and the rigatoni noodles are perfect for capturing a nice helping of ragù with every bite.
I made this dish for friends who thought the pasta was worth the wait.
"The dish reminded me of a cross between Bolognese and a baked ziti!" my friend Sara said. "Definitely a labor of love but, to someone not cooking, highly worth it!"
My sous chef, Zach, also loved the taste, although he didn't agree that it was worth the extra effort in the kitchen.
"As Prue would say on 'The Great British Bake-off,' it was worth the calories — but I wouldn't say it was worth the time," he said. "While it was definitely fun cooking it, I think you could genuinely make a dish that was 90% as good with just focusing on the ragù and broiling the pasta, versus fully baking it."
Next time I make this dish, I'll follow Garten's tip to make the ragù a day in advance — which you can refrigerate before baking and serving.
Garten's rigatoni with sausage and fennel takes the ninth spot.
On a 2017 episode of "Barefoot Contessa," Garten said this rigatoni with sausage and fennel was one of her "all-time go-to dinners."
"You can make the whole thing in one big pot, bring it to the table, and everyone loves it," Garten told her viewers.
Garten's recipe is packed with exciting ingredients. In addition to sausage and fennel, the pasta features dry white wine, heavy cream, parsley, tomato paste, and freshly grated Parmesan cheese.
Garten's sausage rigatoni looks beautiful, and it's perfect for cheese lovers.
Garten's rigatoni with sausage and fennel has a gorgeous golden color, and there's a richness to it that I didn't expect. The rigatoni noodle perfectly captures the delicious meaty sauce, and I thought the sweetness of the sausage helped balance the saltiness of the Parmesan.
While I think this pasta is perfect for cheese lovers, it may be too rich for some. I'd recommend using a quarter cup of Parmesan and tasting the sauce before adding more. But I love that Garten's rigatoni is a one-pot dinner, and I think it's perfect for cold days when you need something super comforting.
In eighth place is Garten's "grown-up" mac and cheese.
Garten makes her "grown-up" mac and cheese in an early episode of "Barefoot Contessa," calling it a "cozy and comforting dinner for Jeffrey and me."
"When it comes to comfort food, I'd say mac and cheese is pretty high on everybody's list," Garten says at the beginning of the episode. She's not wrong!
Garten gives the classic dish her "grown-up" twist by adding blue cheese, thick-sliced bacon, freshly chopped basil, and homemade croutons.
Garten's "grown-up" mac and cheese is packed with delicious flavors.
The velvety cheese sauce, smoky bacon, and satisfying tang of blue cheese make Garten's "grown-up" mac and cheese comforting yet unexpected. It's sure to be a crowd-pleaser on any dinner party or holiday menu.
I made Garten's "grown-up" mac and cheese for my family before our last Thanksgiving dinner, and everyone loved this satisfying dish. But surprisingly, this isn't even my favorite mac and cheese from Garten.
Taking the seventh spot is Garten's orecchiette pasta with sausage and broccoli rabe.
Garten calls her orecchiette pasta with sausage and broccoli rabe, which appears in her cookbook "Foolproof," a "whole dinner in one pot."
"It's a terrific thing to make on the weekends because it reheats beautifully for a quick midweek meal," she writes in the description.
The recipe features sweet and hot Italian pork sausages, crushed tomatoes, dry red wine, and freshly grated Parmesan cheese.
Garten's orecchiette pasta is full of beautiful flavors.
Garten's trick of mixing two different types of sausage in the pasta gives this dish so much depth. It's hearty and garlicky, with a deliciously savory red sauce. My friend Kristen also loved it.
"The orecchiette was perfect for scooping up delightful, balanced bites of spicy and sweet, with a robust finish from the red wine," she told me when I asked for her review.
And as Garten promised, this dish was even better the next day as the pasta soaked up more of the sauce's flavors. Who doesn't love great leftovers?
Garten's overnight mac and cheese takes sixth place.
Garten's overnight mac and cheese is a bonus recipe in the reissue of her first cookbook, "The Barefoot Contessa Cookbook." I tested it for a Thanksgiving dinner.
The simple but comforting dish features both Gruyère and sharp white cheddar cheeses, along with heavy cream, breadcrumbs, and cavatappi or elbow macaroni.
Garten's mac and cheese will impress your friends and family.
Garten's mac and cheese needs just 25 minutes in the oven, and it comes out a beautiful golden-brown color.
The dish also stole the show at my Friendsgiving (as did Garten's incredible corn bread). The breadcrumbs gave each bite a nice crunch, and the sauce was creamy and decadent without overpowering the pasta.
And since you can make it a day or two ahead, Garten's overnight mac and cheese is perfect for a dinner party where you'll be juggling quite a few things — or a quick but easy dish to delight everyone at a potluck.
Garten's favorite weeknight pasta rounds out the top five.
Garten shared the recipe for her favorite weeknight pasta in her cookbook, "Go-To Dinners," which was released in October 2022.
"Everyone needs a few quick pasta dinners in their repertoire, and this one is really adaptable," she writes in the recipe description. "It's wonderful as is, but you could also serve it with veal meatballs one night and with a big dollop of ricotta the next. The pancetta and red wine give it fantastic flavor."
The dish features spaghettoni or bucatini, San Marzano tomatoes, and freshly grated Italian pecorino cheese.
Garten's weeknight pasta reminded me of one of my favorite Italian restaurants in New York City.
There's a rustic charm to Garten's weeknight pasta that took me right back to Cotenna, one of my favorite Italian restaurants in New York City.
I loved how the rich pancetta paired with the earthy basil and Chianti. The dish also had a subtle sweetness from the San Marzano tomatoes that delighted my taste buds. The red pepper flakes gave each bite a nice kick, and the pasta looked lovely on the plate.
Overall, I was surprised by how elevated Garten's dish tasted despite minimal prep and effort. I'll definitely make this pasta again.
Garten's summer garden pasta takes the fourth spot.
Garten's summer garden pasta is one of her simplest, yet it has some of the richest flavors of any that I've tried.
While the "Barefoot Contessa" star's dish only has five main ingredients — angel hair, Parmesan cheese, cherry tomatoes, garlic, and basil — it has one very important step. You need to soak the tomatoes, garlic, and basil in olive oil for four hours.
That extra prep resulted in some of the most incredible tomatoes I've ever tasted.
I could honestly eat Garten's olive oil tomatoes as a snack every day. Even though I usually love heavy red-sauce pastas, these tomatoes carried the entire dish on the strength of their intense and rich flavor.
You also can't beat how pantry-friendly this dish is. I almost always have tomatoes and basil in my kitchen, making Garten's summer garden pasta an easy dinner staple. This is one Barefoot Contessa dish I know I'll be returning to repeatedly.
Get the full recipe for Ina Garten's summer garden pasta here.
Making the top three is Garten's creamy (and dreamy) five-cheese penne.
I first made Garten's five-cheese penne when temperatures started to dip and discovered it was the perfect fall or winter dish.
Garten's pasta includes pecorino Romano, Italian fontina, Italian Gorgonzola, fresh mozzarella, and ricotta cheese, along with penne pasta, crushed tomatoes, basil, and heavy cream.
Garten's five-cheese penne is incredibly comforting.
The penne turns into a beautiful golden color after baking it in the oven for 17 minutes, and there are inviting chunks of mozzarella poking out from the top.
I initially expected five different cheeses, plus all that butter and cream, to be too heavy. But Garten's penne strikes the perfect balance of being rich and soothing without being overwhelming.
I can't wait to make this dish the next time I need a comforting meal again.
Get the full recipe for Ina Garten's five-cheese penne here.
My second favorite pasta dish is Garten's weeknight Bolognese.
The weeknight Bolognese is another recipe that Garten shared on Instagram. She told her fans that the dish can be made with a variety of meats or veggies, making it especially pantry-friendly.
Plus, the rich and flavorful dish — which includes ground sirloin, orecchiette, and dry red wine — will only have you in the kitchen for 30 minutes.
Garten's weeknight Bolognese is a quick and delicious twist on a classic recipe.
The weeknight Bolognese has the comfort of Garten's five-cheese penne and the richness of her baked rigatoni, but with far less work in the kitchen.
It's a modern twist on a classic, and Garten's little tweaks all work perfectly together. The orecchiette shells catch some of the sauce in every bite, and the freshly grated Parmesan cheese melts beautifully into Garten's warm sauce.
Garten's recipe has so much flavor, but it's also far less heavy than some of her other pastas on this list. I'd happily make the weeknight Bolognese on any night of any season.
Get the full recipe for Ina Garten's easy weeknight Bolognese here.
Taking the top spot is Garten's penne alla vodka, which tastes as amazing as it looks.
Garten's penne alla vodka was inspired by one of her favorite dishes, the Penne Alla Vecchia Bettola from Nick & Toni's in East Hampton. Joe Realmuto, Nick & Toni's longtime executive chef, showed Garten how to make the dish on an early episode of "Barefoot Contessa."
The dish features penne, vodka, Parmesan cheese, and fresh oregano leaves.
Garten's penne alla vodka is the most beautiful pasta I've ever made.
It took me over a year to discover a pasta I loved more than the weeknight Bolognese, but Garten's penne alla vodka changed everything.
The dish looks stunning on the dinner table and tastes even better. The vodka sauce is creamy and smooth, and Garten's trick of roasting the tomato sauce in the oven infuses each bite with so much depth and flavor.
While you'll need some extra time, Garten's easy penne alla vodka doesn't require too much effort. It's the perfect dish when you need to make an impressive dinner but can't spend too much time doing extra prep. And when it's super chilly, this dish will bring you tons of comfort.
Get the full recipe for Ina Garten's penne alla vodka here.