Nun Arrests Threaten BJP's Kerala Christian Project: How The Party May Undo The Damage
The state unit of the BJP has already sent its General Secretary, Anoop Antony—the party's Christian face in Kerala BJP—to Raipur to engage with Chhattisgarh leaders
Two Catholic nuns from Kerala — Sister Preethi Mary and Sister Vandana Francis of the Assisi Sisters of Mary Immaculate (ASMI) — were arrested by the Railway Police in Chhattisgarh on charges of human trafficking and forced religious conversion of tribal girls from Maoist-affected Narayanpur.
Although their bail pleas were rejected on July 30 by a Durg court, which referred the nuns to the National Investigation Agency (NIA) court in Bilaspur, the political fallout has already begun and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) — the new kid on the bloc in Kerala politics, which saw a 3.7% jump in vote share with its first ever Lok Sabha seat from the state in 2024 election backed by the Christian community in the state—stands to lose much of its hard-earned political space among the community that so far aligned with either the Congress-led UDF or the Left-led LDF.
Sources indicate that while the intervention in the BJP came from the highest quarters to douse it before it turns into a wildfire, the Kerala BJP is in a precarious situation.
Undoing Christian outreach in Kerala?
The Kerala BJP has invested heavily in building goodwill with church leaders—organising Sneha Yatras, nurturing Christian leadership within the party, and portraying a moderate, inclusive face to Kerala's sizable Christian electorate. According to 2011 census, Kerala's Christian population makes up roughly 18-19% of the state's total population.
But the arrest has thrown all that into disarray. BJP insiders admit it is a 'severe headache" that has the potential to seriously undo the ground gained among Christians, a vote bank the BJP hoped to cultivate ahead of the 2026 Assembly polls.
Daily street protests in solidarity with the two nuns have become a common sight in different parts of Kerala, including Thrissur—BJP's first-ever Kerala seat that was won backed by the overriding support of the Christian community. What should trouble the BJP is the active role played by the Church, where powerful bodies such as the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church threw their weight behind the agitation.
In Thiruvananthapuram, Father Eugene Pereira, Vicar General of the Latin Catholic Archdiocese, who has been the face of many protests from the Vizhinjam Port Protest in 2022 to Muthalapozhi protests too, lent his voice for the two arrested nuns, calling it 'a violation of the constitutional rights of minorities".
The Church of South India (CSI) Synod Secretariat—one of the largest Protestant denominations in India, which covers four southern states—Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh/Telangana and the union territory of Puducherry — has now come out with a condemnation, making it politically hard for the BJP.
In a statement issued here on Thursday, CSI Synod general secretary C. Fernandas Rathina Raja said, 'Such acts not only violate the fundamental rights but also infringe upon the constitutional guarantee of religious freedom and the right to practice and propagate one's faith."
BJP's damage control
The BJP, whose state unit understands the precarious situation they are in, have found an ally in its top leadership, which has stepped in for a timely stitch to save nine. Union Home Minister Amit Shah is believed to have asked the BJP-led Chhattisgarh government not to oppose the bail plea of the two nuns who are expected to walk out on Friday itself.
CPIM MP from Kerala John Brittas told the media in Delhi, 'The left delegation MPs met the Home Minister… He promised to facilitate the nuns' release. They will be released on bail tomorrow. That is the expectation. He also said that appropriate instructions have been given to the Chhattisgarh government. They will not oppose the bail of the nuns…"
Meanwhile, the state unit of the BJP has already sent its General Secretary, Anoop Antony—the party's Christian face in Kerala BJP—to Raipur to engage with Chhattisgarh leaders, promising resolution and justice for the nuns. While he met the two nuns who are in judicial custody, Antony also had a closed-door meeting with Chhattisgarh CM Vishnu Deo Sai and Deputy CM Vijay Sharma, who also holds the Home portfolio, over the issue and how the release of the two nuns can be secured legally.
Interestingly, Kerala BJP state president Rajeev Chandrasekhar was swift in distancing himself from the Chhattisgarh CM's rhetoric, calling the incident a 'misunderstanding" due to procedural lapses—not trafficking or conversion—and pledged party support to the nuns, calling both of them innocent.
Interestingly, as Shah promised Brittas about the release of the two nuns on Friday, Union Minister of State for Minority Affairs and another Christian face of the BJP from Kerala is in the state while the Parliament is in session. It is seen that George Kurian is being sent as the Centre's representative during the nuns' homecoming.
Does that mean all is well? No. There lingers a problem within the saffron fold where senior functionaries of Hindu Aikya Vedi, an umbrella organisation of pro-Sangh groups, are taking to social media and lashing out at the 'Christian missionaries" for their alleged 'massive conversion"—something both the state BJP and central BJP are not very comfortable with.
Moreover, this momentary glitch between the Church and the BJP in Kerala has given a space to the left and the Congress to exploit further.
But every time such glitch happens, I am reminded of a Sangh ideologue who once said, 'Kerala is like a test match. You have to be patient."
About the Author
Anindya Banerjee
Anindya Banerjee, Associate Editor brings over fifteen years of journalistic courage to the forefront. With a keen focus on politics and policy, Anindya has garnered a wealth of experience, with deep throat in ...Read More
Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated!
tags :
news18 specials saffron scoop
view comments
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
August 01, 2025, 14:00 IST
News politics Nun Arrests Threaten BJP's Kerala Christian Project: How The Party May Undo The Damage
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
8 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Letter from Delhi Police refers to Bangla as ‘Bangladeshi language', TMC demands apology
A LETTER from Delhi Police to Banga Bhawan in New Delhi's Chanakyapuri, in which Bangla is referred to as 'Bangladeshi language', triggered a political row on Sunday with the ruling Trinamool Congress (TMC) in West Bengal calling it a deliberate attempt to strip a constitutionally recognised Indian language of its identity and demanding an apology. As Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee targeted the Centre, the BJP hit back, accusing the TMC of shielding illegal Bangladeshi settlers. This comes amid allegations of harassment faced by migrant workers from Bengal in BJP-ruled states on suspicion of being Bangladeshis — an issue highlighted by the Chief Minister at her recent rallies. The letter dated July 24, written by Inspector Amit Dutt from Lodhi Colony Police Station to Officer-in-charge of Banga Bhawan, requested for a translator to decipher documents seized from suspected Bangladeshi nationals. It said that police needed an interpreter 'proficient in Bangladeshi national language' to translate documents for a case involving eight persons 'strongly suspected to be Bangladeshi nationals residing illegally in India'. 'Upon inquiry, copies of national ID cards, birth certificates, bank account details etc. were found from these suspected Bangladeshi nationals. The suspected Bangladeshi nationals were arrested and remanded in judicial custody on the order of the honorable court concerned,' the letter stated. Inspector Dutt, the Investigating Officer, wrote in the letter that the identification documents contain texts written in 'Bangladeshi' and are needed to be translated to Hindi and English. 'Now, for the investigation to proceed further, it is requested that an official translator /interpreter proficient in Bangladeshi national language may kindly be provided for the aforesaid purpose,' the letter said. 'Emphasis is laid on the fact that the requisite report would be a pivotal piece of evidence for successful prosecution of suspected Bangladeshi nationals facing trial. Expeditious disposal of this letter is desired as the same is required to be submitted before the honorable court in a timed manner. Any bills raised against the translation service shall be payable by the department and a quotation for the same may be communicated before hand,' Dutt said in the letter. Although senior police officers confirmed that the letter was sent to Banga Bhawan, an official response from Delhi Police is awaited. Targeting the Centre and the BJP, the TMC, which posted the letter on its X handle, said in a post: 'Is there no limit to @BJP4India's hatred for Bengalis? After repeatedly harassing and detaining Bengali-speaking workers across BJP-ruled states, @AmitShah's @DelhiPolice has now crossed all lines by officially branding our mother tongue, Bangla, as the 'Bangladeshi language'. Make no mistake: this is not a clerical error. It is a calculated insult, an official attempt to strip a constitutionally recognised Indian language of its identity and portray millions of Bengali-speaking Indians as outsiders in their own country.' 'Bangla is spoken by over 25 crore people globally and recognised as one of India's 22 official languages. Calling it 'Bangladeshi' is a deliberate affront, a vile attempt to delegitimise the language, erase its Indian roots, and brand Bengali speakers as outsiders,' it said, and demanded an 'unconditional apology, immediate correction, and strict action against the officials responsible'. In a post on X, Chief Minister Banerjee said: 'See how Delhi Police, under the direct control of Ministry of Home, Government of India is describing Bengali as 'Bangladeshi' language! Bengali, our mother tongue, the language of Rabindranath Tagore and Swami Vivekananda, the language in which our National Anthem and the National Song (the latter by Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay) are written, the language in which crores of Indians speak and write, the language which is sanctified and recognised by the Constitution of India, is now described as a Bangladeshi language!! Scandalous, insulting, anti-national, unconstitutional!! This insults all Bangla-speaking people of India. They cannot use this kind of language which degrades and debases us all.' 'We urge immediate strongest possible protests from all against the anti-Bengali Government of India who are using such anti-Constitutional language to insult and humiliate the Bengali-speaking people of India.' TMC national general secretary Abhishek Banerjee called it a 'calculated attempt by the BJP to defame Bengal, undermine our cultural identity and equate West Bengal with Bangladesh for narrow political propaganda'. 'This is a direct violation of Article 343 and the Eighth Schedule of the Constitution,' he said in a post on X. 'There is no language called 'Bangladeshi'. To call Bangla a foreign language is not just an insult — it's an attack on our identity, culture and belonging.' Hitting back at the TMC, the BJP said in a post on X: 'Delhi Police apprehended 8 illegal Bangladeshi nationals and referred to their spoken tongue as the 'Bangladeshi language'. Now TMC is outrageously claiming this is an 'insult to our language'. But here's the irony — their entire outrage is rooted in defending Bangladeshis. What does that have to do with India or Indian Bengalis?' 'Let's get this straight — for TMC, a heavily Urdu-influenced dialect spoken by illegal migrants is now the real Bengali language? Is this what TMC politics has come to — defending foreign nationals while eroding Indian identity?' State BJP president Shamik Bhattacharya said he saw no mistake on part of Delhi Police in the letter. 'The language is absolutely correct. You bring a book from Bangladesh and read it and read any book from West Bengal. After reading the two books, you will understand which one is written by Subodh Sarkar and which one is written by some Shafiqul Islam from Bangladesh,' he said. 'So if someone speaks Bangla, he doesn't become an Indian, it is not like his/her name will have to be included in the voter list if he speaks Bangla, such things will not work anymore. In a pre-planned manner with fake Aadhar cards these people have entered Banga Bhawan too.'
The Hindu
10 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Siddaramaiah condemns Ram Sene leader's act of poisoning drinking water in school
Chief Minister Siddaramaiah has condemned a Sri Ram Sene leader and two others for poisoning a drinking water tank in Hoolikatti village near Saundatti in Belagavi district near a school, with the intention of ensuring the transfer of a Muslim headmaster. The three accused have been arrested with respect to the incident that occurred on July 14. 'Three people, including Sri Ram Sene taluk president Sagar Patil, have been arrested for poisoning the drinking water of schoolchildren in Hoolikatti with the malicious intention of transferring the headmaster of the government school. Many children fell ill in this incident that took place 15 days ago. Fortunately, no one was killed,' the CM said in a social media post. 'This incident, which could have led to the massacre of small children, is proof that religious fundamentalism and communal hatred can lead to any heinous act. Is it possible for such a level of hatred to arise in the land of Sharanas? I cannot believe it even at this moment,' he said. Taking potshots at the BJP leaders, he said: 'Let the BJP leaders, who sow hatred in society in the name of religion and cook their political rice, do some self-criticism. Will (Sri Ram Sene president) Pramod Mutalik bear the responsibility for this incident? Will (BJP State president) B.Y. Vijayendra bear the responsibility? Will (Leader of the Opposition in the Assembly) R. Ashok bear the responsibility? Let the leaders who always support the anti-social acts committed by such people now come forward and atone for their sins. All kinds of sectarianism and fundamentalism are dangerous to human society.' 'We have formed a special task force to prevent hate speeches and communal riots, and we are taking all possible action against such people within the ambit of the law. For all our efforts to bear fruit, the public should also raise their voice against such forces, resist them, and file complaints. Congratulations to the police personnel who broke the evil plan of carrying out the massacre of children. I am fully confident that the justice system will ensure that the offenders get befitting punishment for such heinous acts,' the CM said. Meanwhile, Belagavi SP Bheemashankar S. Guled told reporters in Belagavi on Saturday that Sagar Patil and Nagangouda Patil had blackmailed Krishna Madar, a local resident over his inter-faith love affair and forced him to poison the water. Krishna Madar bought three types of insecticide and put the mixture into a juice packet. He convinced a primary school student to empty the contents of the juice packet into the water. Investigation was conducted following a complaint. Further investigation is on.
Indian Express
18 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Reservation, 3rd language Hindi: Maharashtra govt rolls back 7 key decisions in six months
From quotas based on income and caste to Hindi as third language; caste on exam hall tickets to sweet dish in school meals; and even blank pages in textbooks to reduce the weight of school bags. These are some of the seven key decisions taken in the education sector by the BJP-led state government in Maharashtra that were rolled back over the past six months, triggering criticism from experts that they were implemented 'without thought' or 'adequate consultation'. Six of these decisions were rolled back following a backlash from stakeholders, including the parents of students — for instance, the centralised uniform policy drew criticism for poor quality and delayed availability. In one case, the rollback came after the Bombay High Court granted interim relief to minority trust-run junior colleges that were asked to implement social reservation. Of these rollbacks, six came under the School Education Ministry currently headed by Dada Bhuse who took over last December from Deepak Kesarkar (August 2022 to November 2024) — both belong to Shiv Sena led by Eknath Shinde. The other key U-turn involved 10% EWS (Economically Weaker Section) quota in private medical colleges. Speaking to The Indian Express, Kesarkar blamed the rollbacks on 'certain challenges in its implementation at the ground level' while Bhuse pointed to 'adjustments' that were incorporated based on 'feedback'. The Opposition alleged that at least some of these decisions were taken with an eye on local body polls expected later this year, particularly those related to reservation that were announced and withdrawn within a month in June — a charge denied by the government. Consider the decisions and the rollback: Hindi as mandatory third language in primary classes: On April 16, a government order mandated Hindi as the third language in Classes 1-5 in state board schools where students previously studied only two languages. The decision sparked criticism and political backlash, prompting a revised order on June 17 making it optional. Even this failed to calm concerns and as protests intensified, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis declared after a high-level meeting on June 23 that a final decision would follow stakeholder consultations. On June 29, he revoked both orders and set up a new panel led by educationist Narendra Jadhav to make fresh recommendations. Quotas in minority trust-run junior colleges: In late May, Maharashtra launched its first state-wide centralised online FYJC (First Year Junior College) admissions, including SC/ ST/ OBC reservations in the seat matrix for minority trust-run institutions, too, despite them being exempt under several court rulings. Traditionally, such colleges reserve 50% of seats for their community, 5% for management and the rest for open category on merit — without social reservation. On June 10, the state minority educational institutions association and colleges filed a petition in the Bombay High Court. Two days later, the HC granted interim relief, halting the policy. The government formally reversed its decision on June 23. One state one uniform: On April 2, the government scrapped its 'One State, One Uniform' policy and handed over the responsibility of deciding school uniforms to school management committees. It reversed a decision taken in May 2023 under Kesarkar to standardise uniforms from Classes 1-8 across government schools and introduce a centralised system for manufacturing and distributing uniforms to over 44 lakh students. The implementation began in 2024-25 but the uniforms did not reach students until October 2024. Later, there were several complaints regarding poor quality and fit of the garments. In December 2024, the centralised process was withdrawn due to logistical issues. Sweet dish in midday meal: On June 11, 2024, the government declared that midday-meals in government schools will have a three-course plan, including sprouts and sweet dish along with new options using rice, lentils, legumes and vegetables. On January 28 this year, after Bhuse had taken over, it was announced that sweet dish would be provided only if the school management committees are able to raise funds from the public for the sugar required. Blank pages in textbooks: On March 8, 2023, the government announced the inclusion of blank pages after every chapter in textbooks prepared by Balbharti for the state board curriculum for classes 2-8, as an alternative to carrying nortebooks separately. The reason: it will reduce the weight of school bags. Triggering backlash, with students carrying the textbooks and notebooks to school, the move was in place for only one academic year – 2024-25 – and was rolled back on January 28. Caste on HSC exam hall ticket: The state board printed caste categories on hall tickets, issued on January 11, for the Higher Secondary Certificate exam. Following sharp criticism from social groups, the board expressed regret and issued a new order on January 18 withdrawing the hall tickets and issuing new ones on January 23. 10% EWS quota in private medical colleges: On July 23, the information brochure for state medical admissions, released by the CET Cell, listed a 10 percent EWS (Economically Weaker Section) reservation. Aspirants, their parents and colleges wrote to the Minister that implementing the quota without increasing seat intake would reduce the slots available under the general pool. On July 30, a day after a delegation of parents met the Minister, the move was withdrawn through a notification stating that the quota would be implemented only if additional intake is approved. Vasant Kalpande, a former Director of Education in the state, blamed the disconnect between decision-making and implementation on a 'lack of dialogue in educational governance'. 'The current top-down approach is detrimental to effective policy-making in a state as diverse as Maharashtra. Effective governance hinges on dialogue with stakeholders, empathy, and sensitivity. With varying needs among students and teachers, a one-size-fits-all approach cannot work,' he said. Basanti Roy, who served over 30 years in the state's education department, stressed the importance of piloting new initiatives to identify challenges and assess impact before scaling them. Without this, she warned, 'reversals become inevitable'. 'In the rush to innovate, we are neglecting due diligence,' she said. Can't be seamless always: Minister When contacted, Kesarkar, under whose tenure the decisions related to blank pages, uniforms and sweet dish were made, described them as 'student-centric'. 'The process of decision-making involved thorough consultation with stakeholders concerned. There could have been certain challenges in its implementation at the ground level. But those could have been resolved by applying corrective measures which could have shown benefits of these decisions in the coming years,' he said. Bhuse, the current minister, said education policies are shaped after careful evaluation. 'All policy decisions taken by the School Education Department are made with the best interests of our key stakeholders — students, parents, teachers, and schools — in mind. When feedback indicates the need for adjustments, those are duly considered and incorporated. However, that does not imply the original decisions were flawed.' Citing an example, he said, 'The initiative to provide high-quality uniforms to government school students was launched with the right intent, but challenges in large-scale implementation required modifications in the process.' Pointing to 'successful' decisions, Bhuse said, 'Take the example of the 'Copy-Free Exam' campaign during the state board examinations. It may not have completely eradicated malpractice, but it significantly curbed it by raising awareness. Another example is the extension of the centralised online admission process for Class 11 across the state. Although it had initial challenges, as expected in its first year, it has ensured that lakhs of students receive equal opportunities to secure admission to colleges of their choice.' Noting that no decision would be perfect for all, he said, 'I come from a rural background but I am equally familiar with urban realities. This dual perspective helps me understand the diverse needs of our education system. We must accept that not everything can be seamless all the time — there's no one-size-fits-all solution in public policy.'
