Three-language row: MNS defaces Hindi textbooks at Balbharti; Sena (UBT), AAP oppose policy
Raj Thackeray's Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) workers tore Hindi textbooks and defaced them with ink at Maharashtra state publisher Balbharti's building on Wednesday to protest against the three-language policy in primary education. The Shiv Sena (UBT) and Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) units in Pune also put out statements against the policy.
A Government Resolution (GR) issued June 17 by the state government amended a previous GR that made Hindi the compulsory third-language in the state board for classes 1 to 5. According to the new amendment, students can choose Hindi or any other Indian language as their third-language as well. However, political parties and literary organisations like the Maharashtra Sahitya Parishad have expressed their opposition to this policy, saying that it introduces Hindi as a compulsory subject in a backhanded way.
Protesting at Balbharti, MNS city president Dhananjay Dalvi said, 'This is an anti-Marathi move by the Maharashtra government and we can't accept it. The government is lying that it has not made Hindi compulsory. If you go to schools, this Hindi textbook by Balbharti is being published and distributed among students. The students are being taught Hindi. We will not let any Hindi textbooks published at Balbharti be distributed among students.'
MNS workers raised slogans against the Maharashtra government and 'Hindi imposition' at the entrance of the Balbharti building. After marching towards the printing house, they shredded Hindi language textbooks of Balbharti and defaced them with black ink.
Also opposing the three-language formula, Kalpesh Yadav, joint secretary of the UBT's Youth Sena, said, 'Why is the Mahayuti government so obsessed with Hindi? The Education Minister has announced the implementation of the CBSE pattern in Maharashtra. But it is clear that he has not understood CBSE's language policy… now the Education Department has issued an ordinance that students can take Hindi if they want to learn it.'
He remarked, 'If the number of students who want to take other subjects instead of Hindi is 20, a teacher will be provided for teaching or the relevant language will be taught online… This is misleading and an attempt is being made to impose Hindi on Marathi people. I publicly condemn this ordinance of the government. Also, CBSE gives only two language options. Still, why insist on Hindi? If more than 20 children want to learn Marathi, will it be taught in Baroda, Indore and some other cities? Hindi lover Education Minister Dada Bhuse should answer.'
Mukund Kirdat, spokesperson for the AAP said, 'Since the beginning, the Aam Aadmi Party has strongly demanded that the three-language formula should not be implemented from Class 1. But even after that, the order to teach three languages has been issued from Class 1 and Hindi will have to be accepted by Marathi people… Although it is necessary to adopt the three-language formula as per the new education policy, there is no insistence to implement it from Class 1.'
He added, 'Despite this, the coalition government in Maharashtra had issued an order that Hindi language is mandatory. Now it has removed the word 'mandatory', and has made a verbal deception that Hindi will be the third language 'in general'…The administrative lobby in the education department and the North Indian Hindi speaking leaders in the BJP are responsible for this. This is a conspiracy of the cow belt to take over Maharashtra.'
Soham is a Correspondent with the Indian Express in Pune.
A journalism graduate, he was a fact-checker before joining the Express. Soham currently covers education and is also interested in civic issues, health, human rights, and politics. ... Read More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Operation Sindhu: First rescue flight carrying 110 Indian students lands in Delhi; evacuated from war-hit Iran via Armenia
Over 100 students boarding flight to leave Iran NEW DELHI: The first evacuation flight carrying 110 Indian citizens, as part of Operation Sindhu, landed in New Delhi from Yerevan, Armenia, on Thursday, amid the escalating military conflict between Iran and Israel. India launched Operation Sindhu, a mission aimed at ensuring the safety and evacuation of Indian nationals from Iran. The ministry of external affairs confirmed that Indian students residing in Tehran were safely evacuated from the city through coordination by the Indian Embassy. "Indian students in Tehran have been moved out of the city for safety reasons through arrangements made by the Indian Embassy," stated the ministry in their official communication. The Indian students left Zvartnots International Airport in Yerevan via a special flight at 14:55 IST on June 18, with their expected arrival in New Delhi during the early hours of June 19. MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal announced through Twitter, "Operation Sindhu begins. India launched Operation Sindhu to evacuate Indian nationals from Iran. India evacuated 110 students from northern Iran who crossed into Armenia under the supervision of our Missions in Iran and Armenia on 17th June. They departed from Yerevan on a special flight and will arrive in New Delhi in the early hours of 19th June 2025. India accords the highest priority to the safety and security of her nationals abroad." The Indian authorities expressed appreciation to Iranian and Armenian governments for their support in the evacuation process. The MEA stated in an official release that the Indian Embassy in Iran has been supporting numerous Indian nationals to relocate from conflict-affected regions to safer locations within Iran, while arranging their subsequent evacuation through available options. The ministry emphasised its commitment to protecting Indian citizens abroad and advised those remaining in Iran to maintain contact with the Indian Embassy in Tehran and the MEA's round-the-clock Control Room in New Delhi. Emergency contacts: Embassy of India in Tehran Call only: +98 9128109115, +98 9128109109 WhatsApp: +98 901044557, +98 9015993320, +91 8086871709 Regional Contacts: Bandar Abbas: +98 9177699036, Zahedan: +98 9396356649 Email: 24x7 Control Room, MEA, New Delhi Toll-free: 800118797 Landlines: +91-11-23012113, +91-11-23014104, +91-11-23017905 WhatsApp: +91-9968291988 Email: situationroom@ Additional phases of Operation Sindhu are anticipated to proceed as developments occur.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Three-language policy part of NEP, Maha can't opt out of it, says CM
Pune: CM Devendra Fadnavis on Wednesday said the three-language policy, under which the state govt had earlier decided to make Hindi compulsory in all schools, was part of the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 which is being implemented across the country and Maharashtra cannot opt out of it. He said govt has now withdrawn the Hindi compulsion, and students would be allowed to choose any Indian language — not just Hindi — as their third language. "If students want to learn another language, govt will ensure a dedicated teacher is appointed. If the numbers are few, we will facilitate online classes," Fadnavis told reporters. On MNS chief Raj Thackeray's criticism of the new govt resolution, Fadnavis said he has explained the situation to him, reiterating that the three-language system stems from the NEP formed after three years of expert consultations and response to the language preference debate, Fadnavis said, "I fail to understand why we promote English and hesitate to embrace our own languages. Indian languages are far better than English. " He said Tamil Nadu approached the court against the three-language system, but their plea was rejected. "Our govt resolution clearly mentioned that Marathi is compulsory for all schools, and there are no alternatives to it, but there are alternatives to Hindi," he said. Fadnavis said it was because of NEP that students can now pursue engineering, MBBS, or MBA in Marathi. "NEP opened the way to make Marathi a global language for knowledge and economy, hence Maharashtra adopted it. It is not right to make it a controversy. There is nothing wrong in learning three languages as it will only increase knowledge of children," he added. At a press meet in Mumbai, school education minister Dada Bhuse said the three-language policy is already being followed in schools of other mediums, but was not yet implemented in Marathi medium schools.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Students from Bengal wait it out in Israel
Kolkata: With the Iran-Israel conflict intensifying further, a section of students from Bengal in Israel is considering the possibility of leaving the country. The Indian Embassy, in an advisory, has already stated that those willing to exit Israel should take the route via Jordan. Over the past seven days, Divya Mukhopadhyay, a researcher from Bandipur Colony, Khardah, spent sleepless nights at his university in Rehovot, Israel. Mukhopadhyay, who is pursuing post-doctoral research in plant pathology at the University of Jerusalem, went to Israel in 2022. While he is scheduled to complete his research by the end of this year, he now finds himself stranded in central Israel, amid sirens, missile alerts, and underground shelters. "The sirens went off, and the mobile alert system warned them just in time to take shelter underground," said Shubhamoy Mukhopadhyay, Divya's uncle. "On Saturday, a missile landed barely a mile and a half from his residence. There were more sirens on Sunday and Monday. Even on Wednesday morning, they had to rush to safety again," he added. On Wednesday morning, officers from the Rahara police station visited Divya's family in Bandipur to check on their well-being. As tensions continue to escalate in the region, families like Divya's are left hoping for a swift resolution and the safe return of their loved ones. At Haifa, nearly 125 km from Rehovot, air raid sirens and missile alerts have become a grim part of daily life for the students of Bar Ilan University. "There was a drone attack by Iran on Wednesday morning. However, that was intercepted," said Nilabja Roychowdhury. Madhyamgram resident Roychowdhury is a research scholar with the Azrieli Faculty of Medicine, Bar Ilan University, Safed. Akash Panja, a resident of Ghatal who is pursuing research in medicinal chemistry at Ariel University, is, however, hoping that the situation might improve within a week. "My wife is also pursuing research in medicinal chemistry at the same university. We have decided not to leave the country at present. But I am hopeful that the situation will improve soon," he said.
