Scientists ‘disprove' one of Jesus Christ's best-known miracles as study claims it was just ‘a natural phenomenon'
Instead, researchers believe it could have been a freak natural event in Israel's Lake Kinneret — known in the Bible as the Sea of Galilee — that brought a massive haul of fish to the surface for easy collection.
4
4
The story of the 'Feeding of the 5,000' is told in all four Gospels, where Jesus is said to have blessed a small amount of food and miraculously distributed it to feed a vast crowd.
But in a 2024 study published in Water Resources Research, scientists monitored oxygen levels, water temperature, and wind speed across Lake Kinneret — and say they discovered evidence of sudden mass fish die-offs caused by unusual weather patterns.
Strong winds sweeping across the lake, they say, can churn the water and cause an 'upwelling' of cold, low-oxygen water from the bottom, which kills fish and sends them floating to the surface.
According to the researchers, to anyone watching from the shore, it would look like fish were suddenly appearing by the thousands — creating the illusion of a miracle and allowing them to 'be easily collected by a hungry populace'.
The team believes this could explain the Gospel passage where Jesus tells his disciples — after a fruitless night of fishing — to cast their nets on the other side of the boat, suddenly hauling in a bounty.
However, Biblical scholars aren't buying it.
Critics slammed the theory for missing the point entirely, pointing out that no fish were caught during the miracle of the loaves and fishes.
The article on AnsweringGenesis.org hit back, saying: 'Jesus simply took the five loaves and two fish, thanked God, broke the loaves, handed everything to his disciples, and the disciples handed the food out. No fish were caught!'
According to Matthew 14:13–21, Jesus 'saw a great crowd, and he had compassion on them and healed their sick.'
Brit shares 'proof' he's found Jesus's TOMB & Ark of the Covenant in cave
When his disciples told him to send the people away to find food, he replied: 'They need not go away; you give them something to eat.'
After blessing the five loaves and two fish, the Bible says: 'they all ate and were satisfied.
'And they took up 12 baskets full of the broken pieces left over.'
Despite the backlash, the researchers argue that understanding how fish may have mysteriously appeared in huge quantities doesn't take away from the spiritual message of the event — which many see as symbolic of generosity and faith.
Still, religious sceptics say the study adds weight to theories that Jesus' wonders may have had natural explanations — while believers insist some things just can't be explained away by science.
It comes after a stunning AI-generated video claims to reveal the true face of Jesus Christ — using images based on the mysterious Turin Shroud.
Believers say the Shroud of Turin was the burial cloth wrapped around Jesus after his crucifixion.
4
Now, photos of the ancient linen have been processed through Midjourney, an AI image generator, to create a realistic image and video of Christ.
The video shows Jesus blinking, smiling, and praying — potentially as he did before his crucifixion around 33AD.
He appears with shoulder-length brown hair, a beard, brown eyes, a straight nose, and high cheekbones.
His skin tone is pale, which has sparked debate among academics and online.
Last year, The Sun also used AI to recreate the Son of God's appearance.
The Gencraft tool was fed the prompt 'face of Jesus based on the Shroud of Turin' and returned images of a man with hazel eyes, a gentle expression, a neat beard, clean eyebrows, and long brown hair.
Under his weary eyes, signs of exhaustion were visible.
Many researchers agree that the man wrapped in the Shroud appeared to be between 5ft 7in and 6ft tall, with sunken eyes and a full beard.
The markings on the cloth also show what some believe to be crucifixion wounds — including injuries to the head, shoulders, arms, and back, consistent with a thorn crown and Roman whips.
The Bible recounts that Jesus was scourged by Roman soldiers, crowned with thorns, and forced to carry his cross before dying in agony.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Neanderthals bred with humans 100,000 YEARS earlier than first thought, scientists say - as they discover skeleton of five-year-old crossbreed
Neanderthals bred with our human ancestors 100,000 years earlier than previously thought, according to a new study. Experts have discovered that a five–year–old child who lived 140,000 years ago had parents from both species. Their fossil – likely a female – was first unearthed 90 years ago in the Skhul Cave on Mount Carmel in what is now northern Israel. A team from Tel Aviv University and the French Centre for Scientific Research conducted a series of advanced tests on the remaining bones, including a CT scan of the skull. 'Genetic studies over the past decade have shown that these two groups exchanged genes,' said lead author Professor Israel Hershkovitz. 'Even today, 40,000 years after the last Neanderthals disappeared, part of our genome—two to six per cent—is of Neanderthal origin. 'But these gene exchanges took place much later, between 60,000 to 40,000 years ago. Here, we are dealing with a human fossil that is 140,000 years old. 'In our study, we show that the child's skull, which in its overall shape resembles that of Homo sapiens—especially in the curvature of the skull vault—has an intracranial blood supply system, a lower jaw, and an inner ear structure typical of Neanderthals' The finding makes the remains the earliest human fossil in the world to display features of both Neanderthals and Homo sapiens, the team say. A recent study, also carried out by Professor Hershkovitz, showed that Neanderthals lived in what is modern–day Israel as far back as 400,000 years ago. The new findings suggest they encountered early humans that began leaving Africa around 200,000 years ago. This human–Neanderthal type, which researchers have called 'Nesher Ramla Homo' after the archaeological site where it was found – was the result of interbreeding between the two populations. The child is, so far, the earliest evidence of the social and biological ties between these two populations over thousands of years. The local Neanderthals eventually disappeared when they were absorbed into the Homo sapiens population, much like the later European Neanderthals. 'The fossil we studied is the earliest known physical evidence of mating between Neanderthals and Homo sapiens,' Professor Hershkovitz said. 'In 1998, a skeleton of a child was discovered in Portugal that showed traits of both of these human groups. But that skeleton, nicknamed the 'Lapedo Valley Child,' dates back 28,000 years ago—more than 100,000 years after the Skhul child.' Until now, anthropologists have attributed the fossils discovered in the Skhul Cave to an early group of Homo sapiens. 'The current study reveals that at least some of the fossils from the Skhul Cave are the result of continuous genetic infiltration from the local—and older—Neanderthal population into the Homo sapiens population,' Professor Hershkovitz added. The Daily Mail has previously spoken to scientists who explained that hybrid children would likely inherit traits from both of their parents. That means hybrids might have a Neanderthal's long arms and short legs with the smaller skull of a Homo sapiens. Likewise, some of the hybrid children may have had strong Neanderthal facial features but the upright posture and long legs of a modern human. In some cases, this hybridisation process could even lead to the formation of unusual, new traits, not found in either parent. Anne Dambricourt–Malassé, a paleoanthropologist at the French National Centre for Scientific Research and co–author of the study, said that this girl's skeleton tells us what hybrids might have looked like. She explained that the girl had 'a powerful neck, a little higher than Homo sapiens, her forehead was less bulging.' Scientists say that hybrids, such as a girl who lived in what is now Israel 140,000 years ago, would have had a combination of Neanderthal and Homo sapiens traits (AI Impression). To generate these images, ChatGPT was provided with analysis from experts and descriptions of hybrids from the latest research and asked to visualise the results The girl also showed a 'slight subnasal prognathism', meaning that her jaw would have jutted out much like the famous 'Habsburg chin'. Her spine shows that she would have had a more upright position than a Neanderthal, who typically walked with a curved back. However, the girl's jaw, spine, and pelvis all bear features that appear to be more Neanderthal in their origin. The new discovery was published in the journal l'Anthropologie. A close relative of modern humans, Neanderthals went extinct 40,000 years ago The Neanderthals were a close human ancestor that mysteriously died out around 40,000 years ago. The species lived in Africa with early humans for millennia before moving across to Europe around 300,000 years ago. They were later joined by humans, who entered Eurasia around 48,000 years ago. These were the original 'cavemen', historically thought to be dim-witted and brutish compared to modern humans. In recent years though, and especially over the last decade, it has become increasingly apparent we've been selling Neanderthals short. A growing body of evidence points to a more sophisticated and multi-talented kind of 'caveman' than anyone thought possible. It now seems likely that Neanderthals had told, buried their dead, painted and even interbred with humans. They used body art such as pigments and beads, and they were the very first artists, with Neanderthal cave art (and symbolism) in Spain apparently predating the earliest modern human art by some 20,000 years. They are thought to have hunted on land and done some fishing. However, they went extinct around 40,000 years ago following the success of Homo sapiens in Europe.
The Independent
5 hours ago
- The Independent
When is this week's rare black moon?
A rare 'black moon ' is anticipated in the early hours of Saturday morning, though it is not an official astronomical term. This celestial event is a special type of new moon, making it invisible from Earth as the moon passes between the Earth and the sun. There are two classifications: a seasonal black moon, which occurs roughly every 33 months, and a monthly black moon, referring to the second new moon within a single calendar month. The absence of moonlight during a black moon significantly enhances stargazing opportunities, allowing for clearer views of meteor showers. New moons, including black moons, exert a stronger gravitational pull on ocean tides due to the direct alignment of the sun and Earth.
The Guardian
6 hours ago
- The Guardian
Young vape users three times as likely to start smoking, study finds
Young people who vape are three times as likely to start smoking, develop asthma and have poor mental health as those who do not, according to a study that lays bare the health impacts of e-cigarettes. Vaping among young people is consistently linked to later smoking, according to the largest umbrella review of all the evidence on youth vaping, which warns that e-cigarettes could act as a gateway. The researchers found associations with other harmful consequences including asthma, cough, injuries and mental ill health, as well as possible risks of respiratory disease, headaches, poor oral health and substance use. Su Golder, an associate professor in health science at the University of York and an author of the research, said: 'The consistency in the evidence is striking. Across multiple studies, young people who use e-cigarettes are more likely to smoke in the future. These findings support stronger public health measures to protect teens from the risks associated with vaping.' The researchers concluded that although it was not yet possible to definitively say vaping leads children to smoke, precautionary policies to restrict sales and marketing of vapes to young people were needed. Dr Ronny Cheung, of the Royal College of Paediatrics, said the study 'adds to the mounting evidence that youth vaping is a serious threat to health and wellbeing, with strong links to smoking and other harmful behaviours'. Cheung urged the government not to further delay implementing the tobacco and vapes bill, which will limit the flavours, packaging and marketing of vapes. The World Health Organization (WHO) has previously described the rise in children vaping around the world as alarming. Figures compiled by Action on Smoking and Health this year showed that 20% of 11- to 17-year-olds in Great Britain had tried vaping, amounting to an estimated 1.1 million children, triple the levels in 2020. For the new study, which was published in the journal Tobacco Control, researchers examined 56 reviews, most of which suggested that young people who vape are about three times as likely to start smoking as those who do not vape. Asthma was the most common respiratory health condition, with consistent associations of between 20% and 36% increased risk of being diagnosed with the condition, and a 44% risk of worsening symptoms. The researchers acknowledged that the umbrella reviews were of variable quality and that it was difficult to prove a causal relationship since the evidence was mostly observational. They urged further research to better understand whether vapes are genuinely acting as a gateway to smoking. Last month, researchers at the University of Michigan established that a third of UK teenagers who vape will go on to start smoking tobacco, meaning they are as likely to smoke as their peers in the 1970s were. Hazel Cheeseman, the chief executive of Action on Smoking and Health, said: 'The rise in teen vaping in recent years is very concerning and needs urgent action from government. Vapes are effective quit aids for adults who smoke and while they are less harmful than smoking, they are not risk free and should not be used by children.' Dr Stephen Burgess, a statistician at the University of Cambridge, said the research showed 'that vaping users are more likely to engage in certain behaviours, but whether vaping is truly a cause of these behaviours is beyond the scope of the data'. He added: 'The associations demonstrated are both extensive in scope and strong in magnitude – it is clear that vaping users are at higher risk of many diseases than non-users. A causal explanation to the findings is both plausible and consistent with the evidence provided but such a finding can only be made conclusively by a randomised trial. Ann McNeill, a professor of tobacco addiction at King's College London, noted that many of the studies on which the researchers drew for the study were 'rated critically low or low quality, meaning authors should be extremely cautious before making any conclusions'. She said there could be other reasons for the consistency of the relationship between vaping and cigarette smoking – for example, a young person having a sensation-seeking or impulsive personality. Other research looking at population-level trends in vaping and smoking had found that as youth vaping increased in a population, smoking reduced, she said. John Dunne, UK Vaping Industry Association director general, said: 'We have seen a lot of research from the scientific community about vaping which does not stand up to scrutiny and this latest study seems to fit the bill. 'We need to stop demonising vaping because until the relative risks of cigarettes and vaping are understood by smokers then 220 people will needlessly die in the UK of smoking-related illnesses every day.' A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: 'Our health advice is clear, while vapes are less harmful than smoking and can be an effective quit aid for smokers, children and non-smokers should never vape. 'The worrying rise in youth vaping requires attention – that's why we commissioned this research, the largest comprehensive review of the health impacts of youth vaping to date. 'We are taking decisive action through the landmark tobacco and vapes bill and single-use vape ban, which will put an end to the cycle of addiction and stop the next generation getting hooked on nicotine.'
