logo
Comment: A cautionary tale for Asean from the Middle East

Comment: A cautionary tale for Asean from the Middle East

The Star2 days ago
(A commentary by Dr Julia Roknifard, a Middle East expert and a Senior Lecturer for the Bachelor's program on Philosophy, Politics, and Economics (PPE) at Taylor's University. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of BERNAMA.)
As the Middle East remains in a state of dangerous instability, Asean presented with an opportunity to examine the causes of these conflicts and draw valuable lessons.
While taking pride in its longstanding neutrality and consensus-building, which have underpinned its regional stability, Asean must adapt to emerging geopolitical realities.
For the grouping to maintain its relevance and agency in a contested multipolar world, it must avoid the strategic fragmentation that has plagued the Middle East and strengthen its own framework for collective security.
Asean's fragile consensus
Asean, in contrast, has often been lauded for its cautious but sustainable approach to diplomacy, with principles of non-interference, consensus, and neutrality at its core.
The "ASEAN Way' of informal dialogue and mutual respect has helped prevent open conflict among its members for decades.
There are challenges, however, with great power rivalry over the South China Sea, which has exposed Asean's internal divisions as just one glaring example.
While Vietnam and the Philippines seek stronger resistance against encroachments, others like Cambodia and Laos often take a more accommodating stance. This divergence threatens to paralyse the grouping when collective action is most needed.
Furthermore, Asean faces growing pressure from external powers such as China, the United States, India, Japan, and the European Union, all vying for influence in the region.
The Quad, AUKUS (Australia, the UK, and the US), and increased US military presence signal a securitised Asia-Pacific that could soon drag Asean into rivalries it has long sought to avoid.
Without greater strategic cohesion, Asean risks repeating the Middle Eastern pattern of division and dependency, becoming an arena for power projection rather than an actor shaping its own future.
Key lessons and the way forward for Asean
The Middle East demonstrates that a lack of regional unity leaves individual nations vulnerable to manipulation and exploitation.
Asean must recognise that its strength lies not in the sum of its parts, but in its ability to act with a unified voice. While complete consensus may be elusive, a flexible core group of willing states could lead on issues of regional security without waiting for unanimity.
Asean's commitment to neutrality has served it well, but in a more polarised world, neutrality must evolve into proactive non-alignment.
This means not only avoiding entanglement in great-power blocs but also taking a firmer stand on regional security issues, particularly in maritime disputes, cross-border security, and transnational crime.
It is important to note that these very criminal networks that operate along porous borders are often exploited to traffic arms that could be used by non-state actors to create instability.
Unlike the Middle East, Asean has an advantage through its institutional foundation, which could facilitate a multilateral defence or security coordination framework.
While a full military alliance may be unrealistic, a regional maritime coordination centre, joint patrol arrangements, or a rapid response force for non-traditional threats such as disaster relief, piracy, and cyberattacks would enhance Asean's credibility and security.
Asan should adopt a more robust position against the militarisation of its region by external actors.
Just as foreign bases and arms deals in the Middle East have entrenched foreign influence, Southeast Asia must guard against becoming a base for great-power military logistics or surveillance.
Transparency, dialogue, and clear regional red lines can help manage this risk.
Institutions such as the Arab League have been ineffective in part due to a lack of enforcement capability and legitimacy. Asean must avoid the same fate by streamlining decision-making, empowering its secretariat, and reducing the influence of members who act as proxies for external interests.
To secure its future, Asean must begin a serious conversation about regional defence autonomy. This doesn't mean cutting ties with the US or China or other blocs, but rather strengthening the grouping's collective bargaining power and ability to shape outcomes in its own neighbourhood.
South-East Asia's economic dynamism and strategic location give it leverage, but only if wielded with strategic intent.
Asean could develop a code of conduct not only for the South China Sea but for all foreign military activity in Southeast Asia. This would require transparency on base agreements, arms transfers, and intelligence-sharing with external powers.
This must be paired by expanding the Asean Défense Ministers' Meeting (ADMM) to include a permanent crisis monitoring centre capable of early warning and real-time coordination.
Intelligence sharing and surveillance coordination, which are currently fragmented, will be far more effective and successful through this.
The grouping must also reinforce its political values. Non-interference must not become a shield for impunity.
Myanmar's crisis is a test of Asean's will to uphold basic norms of governance and order. If unresolved, it threatens to erode the region's moral authority and cohesion.
Asean must shape its own trajectory
The Middle East did not descend into chaos overnight. It unravelled through decades of missed opportunities, broken alliances, and dependence on foreign patrons.
For now, Asean is in a far better position as it can either build on its history of cautious cooperation to become a more resilient, strategic actor, or it can cling to an outdated consensus model and become another arena for global competition.
Asean's future as a stable, independent regional bloc depends on whether it can draw the right lessons from the Middle East and act on them before the storm arrives. - Bernama
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nga: Anwar's fuel price cut proves promises kept
Nga: Anwar's fuel price cut proves promises kept

New Straits Times

time2 minutes ago

  • New Straits Times

Nga: Anwar's fuel price cut proves promises kept

KUALA LUMPUR: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's announcement of initiatives to ease the people's cost of living proves that the Madani government is fulfilling its promises, said Housing and Local Government (KPKT) Minister Nga Kor Ming. He said the reduction of the RON95 fuel price to RM1.99 per litre makes it one of the lowest in the world. "This demonstrates his concern in addressing cost-of-living issues despite financial constraints. On behalf of 22,000 KPKT families, I would like to thank the Prime Minister for the good news. Anwar said if he became Prime Minister, fuel prices would go down, and now, they will really go down. "Even with the current financial limitations, we've managed to reduce the fuel price, maintain toll rates, provide SARA (Sumbangan Asas Rahmah), and give various incentives," he said at a press conference after officiating the Asean Real Estate Conference (AREC) 2025 and the International Architecture, Interior Design and Building Exhibition (ARCHIDEX) 2025, here yesterday. Nga said the one-off RM100 aid under SARA for all Malaysians aged 18 and above also reflects the government's commitment to helping not only the B40 group but also the M40 group, which is often excluded from such aid. He said the RM2 billion allocation, benefiting 22 million Malaysians, is expected to have a multiplier effect on the economy, while the postponement of toll rate hikes serves as an anti-inflationary measure. Nga emphasised that the Madani government will continue its nation-building efforts and urged all Malaysians to unite in helping the country rise again and gain global respect. "Sometimes in the government, we are required to make some unpopular, extremely difficult decisions as leaders who care about the next generation. "I expect more good news in 2026 Budget, which is scheduled to be tabled in October, so stay tuned," he said. Yesterday, the Prime Minister announced several key initiatives as a gesture of appreciation from the Madani government to the people, including a one-off RM100 aid under the SARA programme, a freeze on toll hikes for 10 highways, and a targeted subsidy bringing the RON95 fuel price down to RM1.99 per litre. Meanwhile, Nga said the Madani government will continue with housing reforms through initiatives such as PR1MA, affordable housing, and low-cost homes. "You have to give us at least three terms to realise our vision. We're only halfway through the first term. If you give us a second and third term — 15 years — we will be able to deliver on our promises." - BERNAMA

Anwar Calls For Collective, In-Depth Approach In Fatwa Decisions
Anwar Calls For Collective, In-Depth Approach In Fatwa Decisions

Barnama

time35 minutes ago

  • Barnama

Anwar Calls For Collective, In-Depth Approach In Fatwa Decisions

KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 (Bernama) -- Fatwa institutions must operate collectively and ensure that any fatwa or religious edict issued is based on information gathering and in-depth analysis of the issue by qualified experts, says Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. In a Facebook post tonight, Anwar said the matter was among those discussed during his meeting today with the Penang State Fatwa Committee led by Penang Mufti Assoc Prof Dr Mohd Sukki Othman. 'The responsibility of issuing fatwas is a noble and vital duty in providing clarity on religious rulings for the understanding of the ummah (Muslim community).

PM's Announcement Timely, Provides Relief Amid Rising Cost Of Living Pressures
PM's Announcement Timely, Provides Relief Amid Rising Cost Of Living Pressures

Barnama

timean hour ago

  • Barnama

PM's Announcement Timely, Provides Relief Amid Rising Cost Of Living Pressures

Experts contacted by Bernama described the Prime Minister's announcement as timely, highlighting the government's commitment to building a fairer and more prosperous future for the people. KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 (Bernama) -- The much-awaited announcement by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, made in appreciation of all Malaysians, was finally unveiled today, offering a ray of hope and underscoring the government's continued concern for the people's well-being. He said the announcement came amid mounting challenges, including food inflation, soaring house prices, burdensome loan interest rates and global economic uncertainty. Universiti Malaya sociopolitical analyst Datuk Professor Dr Awang Azman Awang Pawi said several of the measures introduced by Anwar brought significant benefits to the people, particularly in alleviating the burden of the rising cost of living. They viewed it as a clear reflection of the government's concern over the public's struggles with the rising cost of living, as well as a step towards restoring confidence and stability in the national economy during these challenging times. The Prime Minister also announced that there would be no increase in electricity bills for the majority of domestic consumers in Peninsular Malaysia following the restructuring of electricity tariffs that took effect this month. Earlier today, Anwar announced several key initiatives as a gesture of appreciation to the people, including a one-off RM100 aid under the Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (SARA) programme, a freeze on toll hikes for 10 highways, and a targeted subsidy bringing RON95 fuel price down to RM1.99 per litre. 'Any government initiative that helps ease the people's burden should be welcomed. This announcement comes at a critical time, as many are caught in a cycle of household debt, employment uncertainty and a widening income gap,' he told Bernama. In fact, he said 85 per cent of domestic users would see up to a 14 per cent reduction in their July 2025 bills for the same level of usage compared to the first half of this year. Awang Azman said the one-off assistance was much needed as an interim measure while awaiting more structured and far-reaching government policies through the upcoming budget or the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP). He said that the initiative also demonstrated the prime minister's concern for the people's real needs. 'The next step is not just to provide temporary relief but is expected to be expanded through the upcoming budget and the 13MP, which will address root issues such as the wage-cost of living mismatch, the need for affordable housing, and the strengthening of the social safety net,' he said. Awang Azman pointed out that attention needed to be given to transparency and efficiency in implementation to ensure the initiatives truly benefited the deserving groups. 'Effectiveness lies not only in the content but also in how the initiatives are implemented. Is the monitoring mechanism transparent enough to prevent leakages? The real challenge for the MADANI government is to implement this policy with integrity and efficiency so that it truly serves the people at the grassroots level,' he added. Meanwhile, director of the MBA & DBA Programme at Putra Business School Prof Dr Ahmed Razman Abdul Latiff said the government had shown attentiveness to the people's concerns by announcing immediate aid without waiting for the 2026 Budget. 'The assistance is provided immediately to individuals and those in need without waiting for next year's budget to be tabled. Although inflation is low, the reality is that many still require direct aid,' he said. Rejecting views suggesting the announcement was purely populist, Ahmed Razman said the cash assistance also extended to those in the M40 group, who were often mistakenly perceived as sidelined in aid distribution. Political analyst Prof Datuk Dr Sivamurugan Pandian viewed the good news announced by the prime minister as a continuation of various incentives and assistance introduced by the MADANI Government to ensure the people continued to receive direct and ongoing benefits. 'I believe this is not the end. There will be several more phases rolled out later, depending on the government's position and capabilities at that time,' said the sociology of political society lecturer at Universiti Sains Malaysia. While some regarded the announcement as a temporary measure, he said it nevertheless had a significant impact amid rising cost of living pressures. Citing the announcement that RON95 would be priced at RM1.99 per litre once the targeted subsidy takes effect, Sivamurugan said it demonstrated that the Prime Minister had delivered on one of his promises. 'If we look at the Prime Minister's social media branding prior to the announcement, it clearly hinted at the petrol price that the public had been eagerly awaiting. 'It might seem like a small decrease but it has a big impact because he is fulfilling a promise the people have been waiting for,' he said. Sivamurugan said the government's ability to meet the people's immediate needs while maintaining sound fiscal management showed an inclusive approach prioritising public well-being without undermining the country's financial position. --BERNAMA BERNAMA provides up-to-date authentic and comprehensive news and information which are disseminated via BERNAMA Wires; BERNAMA TV on Astro 502, unifi TV 631 and MYTV 121 channels and BERNAMA Radio on FM93.9 (Klang Valley), FM107.5 (Johor Bahru), FM107.9 (Kota Kinabalu) and FM100.9 (Kuching) frequencies. Follow us on social media : Facebook : @bernamaofficial, @bernamatv, @bernamaradio Twitter : @ @BernamaTV, @bernamaradio Instagram : @bernamaofficial, @bernamatvofficial, @bernamaradioofficial TikTok : @bernamaofficial

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store