Doubling Up: How ‘Sinners' and Other Movies Multiply One Actor
This year at the movies, you'd be forgiven for thinking you are seeing double — because you are. Since March there have been three films featuring stars acting opposite themselves. 'Mickey 17' has two versions (at least) of Robert Pattinson as an expendable working grunt on an alien planet in a futuristic world. Robert De Niro played two different mobsters in 'The Alto Knights.' And Michael B. Jordan just made his doubles debut as swaggering twins in Ryan Coogler's 'Sinners,' a vampire movie set in 1930s Mississippi.
Having the same actor appear two — or sometimes three or four or more — times onscreen is one of cinema's most enduring tricks. And while the effect has long been a powerful bit of movie magic, the technology has evolved over the years. Here are some of the landmarks.
An In-Camera Method to Buster Keaton's Madness
The use of doubling goes all the way back to the silent era in this Buster Keaton short in which the protagonist, played by the prodigious physical comedian, dreams himself as every single person in a show — from the band to the audience members. (He also appears in blackface as a minstrel, an upsetting byproduct of the era.) How did Keaton accomplish this? Through masking and double exposure. He and his cameraman Elgin Lessley would cover part of the lens, perform a beat, and then rewind, uncovering the previously masked portion to add another version of himself to the shot. The effect is a wondrous confluence of Keatons all acting at once.
Split-Screen High Jinks
In many ways, Disney's 1961 caper remains the go-to example of doubling an actor. Hayley Mills plays a pair of twins who conspire to get their divorced parents back together. The split-screen technique sounds almost quaint these days. Mills would perform the scene as one twin opposite her double and then switch clothes and do it all again as the other twin. The camera would have to remain perfectly stable, and nothing on set could be altered between takes. Mills also could not reach out to her scene partner. 'When we were shooting a scene, on pain of death did you cross over the dividing line,' Mills later told Vulture. After shooting, the two strips of film were fed into what was called an optical printer and rephotographed with mattes, which blocked out the sides that didn't feature Mills so that they could be combined.
Crossing the Line
The cinematographer Dean Cundey remembered seeing 'The Parent Trap' as a child and figuring out the trick. 'I thought, 'Well, that's intriguing but they don't ever cross the line,'' he said in an interview with The New York Times. 'I bet the way they did that was they put two pieces together down the middle.' Though Cundey would later shoot Nancy Meyers's 1998 remake of 'The Parent Trap,' he helped solve the problem on 'Back to the Future Part II,' Robert Zemeckis's sequel to the time travel hit that features actors playing their characters' ancestors and descendants. The solution? The VistaGlide motion control dolly system, developed by the visual effects company Industrial Light & Magic. The technology meant that Cundey could shoot a scene as he normally would, without keeping the camera in a fixed position, and then the computerized dolly would be able to repeat that exactly for the next take when Michael J. Fox would change clothes to play Marty McFly's son, for instance.
Motion control also figured into the sequence in which an old Biff (Thomas F. Wilson) hands his younger self a sports almanac as part of a ploy to get rich in the future. While Cundey explained they could have simply had Wilson pass the book out of frame, instead they put it on a motion-controlled robotic arm. 'He would hold the book in one hand and follow across, and then we would cut and he would go get made up and the book would come across and he would grab it and take it,' Cundey said, adding, 'We went the extra step to develop the motion-control arm that passed the book and it never left the audience's sight. Those are the kind of shots that are interesting because they just tell the story.'
Following the Feet
In Harold Ramis's comedy, Michael Keaton plays an exasperated family man who clones himself so he can get more done. Eventually there are four Michael Keatons onscreen, each with a vastly different personality. The visual effects supervisor Richard Edlund quickly figured that one of the main challenges would be making sure Keaton was making eye contact with himself when the clones were interacting. So Edlund devised a contraption that was essentially a tripod affixed with a pistol scope and a laser that could send information to a computer. For the first take, an operator would use it to follow Keaton's feet. On the second take, Keaton would act opposite a stand-in who would hold a monitor that played Keaton's first take and stand over a laser dot that played back the movements Edlund's device had captured. 'Michael would be talking to the monitor in sync and he had a hearing aid off screen on the other side so you never saw it,' Edlund said in an interview. When Keaton had to cross in front of himself, they used pieces of green screen on the set. Meanwhile, throughout production, a team was stationed in a trailer creating composites of the takes so Ramis could get a sense of what the final product would look like.
Facebook Face Swap
'I'm 6'5, 220 and there's two of me.' That line spoken by Armie Hammer as one of the Winklevoss twins in David Fincher's 'The Social Network' is also indicative of what Fincher had to accomplish in the film to bring the imposing Harvard bros to life. Instead of casting actual twins, Fincher chose Hammer and another actor, Josh Pence. But Pence's face is never seen onscreen. Instead, Fincher scanned Hammer and Pence's visages with a medical-grade laser and digitally replaced Pence's face with Hammer's. 'It was really motion-capture acting in a way,' Pence told The Huffington Post in 2020.
A Cigarette Pass and a Camera 'Halo'
On 'Sinners,' Ryan Coogler not only wanted to turn Michael B. Jordan into Depression-era twins named Smoke and Stack, he wanted to do so on 65-millimeter IMAX film. 'There are a lot of extra challenges that come with the 65-millimeter film,' the visual effects supervisor Michael Ralla said. 'Not only is it the resolution — how big the negative is — but with that there's interesting challenges where the film is warping as it's being pulled through the camera, and then it's being pulled through the scanner again. Compared to digital photography where you have a perfectly stable frame, there's a lot of movement that we need to make sure is consistent across the frame.'
The filmmakers developed what Ralla and the visual effects producer James Alexander called a matrix to decide how exactly they were going to double Jordan for each particular moment. In some cases that meant simple over the shoulder shots, in others it meant using a techno dolly, essentially a more advanced version of the VistaGlide. Their standout innovation was what they called the halo. It's a rig that sat on Jordan's shoulders with 12 cameras that could capture anything he did with his head. They could then use those images to replace a double's noggin with Jordan's.
Still, one of the most impressive moments of twinning in the movie is all Jordan. Early in the film, Stack hands Smoke a cigarette. Jordan intensely rehearsed the moves of both characters with a body double, and then would swap places during the shoot. 'We had a little pole that would show where the cigarette handover had to happen,' Ralla said. 'They knew how to touch that pole that was digitally removed later and the two were combined.'
The action took a long time to get right, but Ralla said it was worth it because of how it shows Jordan's characterization of the twins. 'All the body movement, all the mannerisms, all the body language is established so well already and we weren't able to see it during the shoot yet,' Ralla said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Cosmopolitan
4 hours ago
- Cosmopolitan
Miley Cyrus Wears Completely Sheer Dress and Black Underwear in NYC
Miley Cyrus is busy promoting her new album, Something Beautiful, and took a moment to sign autographs for a group of fans waiting outside her hotel. Her outfit? An entirely sheer Ludovic de Saint Sernin black dress, which she paired with sunglasses and a pair of black underwear. No one has ever looked better, fact. Miley's outing comes amid her opening up about where things stand with her parents amid their ongoing (and often messy) family feud. Speaking on The New York Times' The Interview podcast, Miley said that she "took on some of [her] mom's hurt" during Tish Cyrus and Billy Ray Cyrus' divorce in 2022, but that now she feels like her "adult self has caught up." She added, "My mom is like so in love with my stepdad Dom, who I also just completely adore. And now that my dad, I see him finding happiness outside of that too, I can love them both as individuals instead of as a kind of, you know, a parental pairing." And of seeing her parents dating other people, Miley noted "At first, it's hard. The little kid in you reacts before the adult in you and go, 'Yes, that's your dad, but that's just another person that deserves to be in his bliss and be happy.'" FYI, Miley confirmed that she and Billy Ray had ended their feud back in May, saying 'My dad and I have had our challenges over the years. Now, in my thirties, family is my priority above all else. I'm at peace knowing bridges have been built and time has done a lot of healing. Grateful for the good health and love that flows through my family.'
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Three of the best: Camden's punk and metal pubs
Camden has long been known for its music pubs. This is the part of London where musicians of all creed congregate: it saw Madness become stars, gave the backdrop to the Libertines (and all the indie that followed) and there's even a little blues there, too. Today, though, it's most known for its metal scene. This is metal as a very broad church, incorporating everything from punk to thrash to speed, gothic and even, here and there, a little glam. Below are two 'proper' metal pubs, alongside a punk originator that's a pioneer of the area. 94 Parkway, NW1, Punk in spirit rather than strictly on musical grounds, this is the pub that made Camden the centre of London's musical universe for a time. Plastered in posters, the walls reek of history: of Madness getting their start here, of Amy Winehouse behind the bar. Today, there's still music four nights a week. 33 Kentish Town Road, NW1, @thedevcamden No, not that one, not the one with all the Guinness. This Dev — that's its nickname, too — has been going far longer and, as its regulars will attest, at a far harder pace. It is dark and black and full of posters. Red neon buzzes. There are antlers. And then there is a corner that roars with flying V guitars and Marshall stacks: if you want it loud, you want it fast, and you like bands obsessed with skulls, there are few finer places. Oh, and the karaoke is pretty good too. 3 Greenland Place, NW1, A metalheads' den, but one with a surprising sense of order — many of the band posters sit neatly in frames. Downstairs is spartan: dark paint, dark floor and a bright glowing cross — iconography in the Black Sabbath vein. There's a great stage set-up, though a low ceiling means everything seems even louder than it might. Good choice of beers and all the pentagrams and bleeding eyes are offset by the vegan bites on offer. Gigs almost every night.
Yahoo
19 hours ago
- Yahoo
Edmund White, a groundbreaking gay author, dies at 85
NEW YORK (AP) — Edmund White, the groundbreaking man of letters who documented and imagined the gay revolution through journalism, essays, plays and such novels as "A Boy's Own Story" and "The Beautiful Room is Empty," has died. He was 85. White's death was confirmed Wednesday by his agent, Bill Clegg, who did not immediately provide additional details. Along with Larry Kramer, Armistead Maupin and others, White was among a generation of gay writers who in the 1970s became bards for a community no longer afraid to declare its existence. He was present at the Stonewall raids of 1969, when arrests at a club in Greenwich Village led to the birth of the modern gay movement, and for decades was a participant and observer through the tragedy of AIDS, the advance of gay rights and culture and the backlash of recent years. A resident of New York and Paris for much of his adult life, he was a novelist, journalist, biographer, playwright, activist, teacher and memoirist. "A Boy's Own Story" was a bestseller and classic coming-of-age novel that demonstrated gay literature's commercial appeal. He wrote a prizewinning biography of playwright Jean Genet and books on Marcel Proust and Arthur Rimbaud. He was a professor of creative writing at Princeton University, where colleagues included Toni Morrison and his close friend, Joyce Carol Oates. He was an encyclopedic reader who absorbed literature worldwide while returning yearly to such favorites as Tolstoy's 'Anna Karenina' and Henry Green's 'Nothing.' "Among gay writers of his generation, Edmund White has emerged as the most versatile man of letters," cultural critic Morris Dickstein wrote in The New York Times in 1995. "A cosmopolitan writer with a deep sense of tradition, he has bridged the gap between gay subcultures and a broader literary audience." The age of AIDS, and beyond In early 1982, just as the public was learning about AIDS, White was among the founders of Gay Men's Health Crisis, which advocated AIDS prevention and education. The author himself would learn that he was HIV-positive in 1985, and would remember friends afraid to be kissed by him, even on the cheek, and parents who didn't want him to touch their babies. White survived, but watched countless peers and loved ones suffer agonizing deaths. Out of the seven gay men, including White, who formed the influential writing group the Violet Quill, four died of complications from AIDS. As White wrote in his elegiac novel "The Farewell Symphony," the story followed a shocking arc: "Oppressed in the fifties, freed in the sixties, exalted in the seventies and wiped out in the eighties." But in the 1990s and after he lived to see gay people granted the right to marry and serve in the military, to see gay-themed books taught in schools and to see gay writers so widely published that they no longer needed to write about gay lives. "We're in this post-gay period where you can announce to everybody that you yourself are gay, and you can write books in which there are gay characters, but you don't need to write exclusively about that," he said in a Salon interview in 2009. "Your characters don't need to inhabit a ghetto any more than you do. A straight writer can write a gay novel and not worry about it, and a gay novelist can write about straight people." In 2019, White received a National Book Award medal for lifetime achievement, an honor previously given to Morrison and Philip Roth among others. 'To go from the most maligned to a highly lauded writer in a half-century is astonishing,' White said during his acceptance speech. Childhood yearnings White was born in Cincinnati in 1940, but age at 7 moved with his mother to the Chicago area after his parents divorced. His father was a civil engineer "who reigned in silence over dinner as he studied his paper." His mother a psychologist "given to rages or fits of weeping." Trapped in "the closed, sniveling, resentful world of childhood," at times suicidal, White was at the same time a 'fierce little autodidact' who sought escape through the stories of others, whether Thomas Mann's "Death in Venice" or a biography of the dancer Vaslav Nijinsky. "As a young teenager I looked desperately for things to read that might excite me or assure me I wasn't the only one, that might confirm my identity I was unhappily piecing together," he wrote in the essay "Out of the Closet, On to the Bookshelf," published in 1991. As he wrote in "A Boy's Own Story," he knew as a child that he was attracted to boys, but for years was convinced he must change — out of a desire to please his father (whom he otherwise despised) and a wish to be "normal." Even as he secretly wrote a 'coming out' novel while a teenager, he insisted on seeing a therapist and begged to be sent to boarding school. One of the funniest and saddest episodes from "A Boy's Own Story" told of a brief crush he had on a teenage girl, ended by a polite and devastating note of rejection. 'For the next few months I grieved,' White writes. 'I would stay up all night crying and playing records and writing sonnets to Helen. What was I crying for?' He had a whirling, airborne imagination and New York and Paris had been in his dreams well before he lived in either place. After graduating from the University of Michigan, where he majored in Chinese, he moved to New York in the early 1960s and worked for years as a writer for Time-Life Books and an editor for The Saturday Review. He would interview Tennessee Williams and Truman Capote among others, and, for some assignments, was joined by photographer Robert Mapplethorpe. Socially, he met Burroughs, Jasper Johns, Christopher Isherwood and John Ashbery. He remembered drinking espresso with an ambitious singer named Naomi Cohen, whom the world would soon know as "Mama Cass" of the Mamas and Papas. He feuded with Kramer, Gore Vidal and Susan Sontag, an early supporter who withdrew a blurb for "A Boy's Own Story" after he caricatured her in the novel "Caracole." "In all my years of therapy I never got to the bottom of my impulse toward treachery, especially toward people who'd helped me and befriended me," he later wrote. Early struggles, changing times Through much of the 1960s, he was writing novels that were rejected or never finished. Late at night, he would "dress as a hippie, and head out for the bars." A favorite stop was the Stonewall, where he would down vodka tonics and try to find the nerve to ask a man he had crush on to dance. He was in the neighborhood on the night of June 28, 1969, when police raided the Stonewall and "all hell broke loose." "Up until that moment we had all thought homosexuality was a medical term," wrote White, who soon joined the protests. "Suddenly we saw that we could be a minority group — with rights, a culture, an agenda." Before the 1970s, few novels about openly gay characters existed beyond Vidal's 'The City and the Pillar' and James Baldwin's 'Giovanni's Room.' Classics such as William Burroughs' 'Naked Lunch' had 'rendered gay life as exotic, marginal, even monstrous,' according to White. But the world was changing, and publishing was catching up, releasing fiction by White, Kramer, Andrew Holleran and others. White's debut novel, the surreal and suggestive "Forgetting Elena," was published in 1973. He collaborated with Charles Silverstein on "The Joy of Gay Sex," a follow-up to the bestselling "The Joy of Sex" that was updated after the emergence of AIDS. In 1978, his first openly gay novel, "Nocturnes for the King of Naples," was released and he followed with the nonfiction "States of Desire," his attempt to show "the varieties of gay experience and also to suggest the enormous range of gay life to straight and gay people — to show that gays aren't just hairdressers, they're also petroleum engineers and ranchers and short-order cooks." With "A Boy's Own Story," published in 1982, he began an autobiographical trilogy that continued with "The Beautiful Room is Empty" and "The Farewell Symphony," some of the most sexually direct and explicit fiction to land on literary shelves. Heterosexuals, he wrote in "The Farewell Symphony," could "afford elusiveness." But gays, "easily spooked," could not "risk feigning rejection." His other works included "Skinned Alive: Stories" and the novel 'A Previous Life,' in which he turns himself into a fictional character and imagines himself long forgotten after his death. In 2009, he published "City Boy," a memoir of New York in the 1960s and '70s in which he told of his friendships and rivalries and gave the real names of fictional characters from his earlier novels. Other recent books included the novels "Jack Holmes & His Friend" and 'Our Young Man' and the memoir 'Inside a Pearl: My Years in Paris.' "From an early age I had the idea that writing was truth-telling," he told The Guardian around the time 'Jack Holmes' was released. 'It's on the record. Everybody can see it. Maybe it goes back to the sacred origins of literature — the holy book. There's nothing holy about it for me, but it should be serious and it should be totally transparent.' Hillel Italie, The Associated Press
