Report: Tesla Cybertruck 17 Times More Likely For Fire Fatalities Than Ford Pinto
Read the full story on The Auto Wire
In an explosive report, a group claims to have studied data related to Tesla Cybertruck crashes, concluding the EV is 17 times more likely for fire fatalities in a crash than the Ford Pinto. That's stirring up plenty of controversy since many view the Pinto as an unmitigated disaster, although some are coming to the classic car's defense, as well as contesting claims the all-electric truck is that dangerous. This controversial claim is being made by auto news site Fuel Arc. To back this up, an article on the site provides a simple table with data for the Tesla Cybertruck and Ford Pinto. One column is for total units produced, another for reported fire fatalities, and the final is a fatality rate. That all seems simple enough.
To arrive at the claim the pickup is 17 times more likely to be involved in a fire fatality, the author took the total number of units produced through January 1, 2025, which is 34,438, and the claimed number of fire fatalities of 5 people.
The author does admit the fifth Cybertruck fatality, from an incident in Las Vegas, might be controversial since there are claims that person was burned after dying. Everyone is of course free to accept that as part of the statistics or not.
Meanwhile, the Ford Pinto saw a total production run of 3,173,491 units before the exploding gas tank controversy forced the end of the model line in 1980. The total number of fatalities as recorded by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration was 27.
Using these numbers, that means the fatality rate of the Pinto per 100,000 units made is 0.85 versus 14.52 for the Cybertruck. Again, drop the one death to 4 and recalculate if you don't agree with its inclusion, the Tesla's final number still looks bad.
We're sure Tesla, many Cybertruck owners, and probably some data nerds will take issue with the methodology behind the claim the EV is 14 times more deadly when it comes to vehicle fires. After all this claim assumes that as ownership numbers climb for the pickup, the fatality rate will stay fairly stable.
Some might laugh and say it definitely will, but will it? We don't know.
Another potential flaw is the claimed number of Cybertrucks have been delivered to owners. Tesla is famously secretive about such data, so the author is left to calculate it 'through a variety of means.' But a breakdown of how that was calculated isn't provided, so draw whatever conclusion you want.
The big question which isn't addressed in the report is why the rate for Tesla Cybertruck fire fatalities is higher than for the Ford Pinto. Instead, the claim the Pinto is a symbol of 'corporate greed' is repeated a few times. Was it, or was the Pinto a symbol of bureaucratic incompetence?
And is the Cybertruck just 'unsafe at any speed'? Let us know what you think.
Source: Fuel Arc
Image via Tesla
Join our Newsletter, subscribe to our YouTube page, and follow us on Facebook.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tesla Pushes Hard with New Incentives as Sales Slip
Tesla is pulling out all the stops to entice buyers as its sales continue to slide. The electric vehicle giant, long seen as the face of the EV industry, is introducing a raft of incentives and discounts to jumpstart demand. The Cool Down reported that Tesla posted its weakest sales quarter since mid-2022, prompting the company to offer discounts for various customer groups, including special deals for Lyft drivers and subsidized interest rates. Reports suggest Tesla representatives are even personally reaching out to past leads to encourage test drives. One commenter summed it up aptly: 'They're truly pulling all demand levers.' Tesla's reputation has been hit in recent years, partly due to CEO Elon Musk's polarizing political commentary, which has made the brand less appealing to some potential buyers. However, improvements in quality and service for the Model 3 and Model Y are earning positive feedback from these incentives, such aggressive strategies midway through the quarter may signal deeper challenges. Some experts feel the perks are end-of-quarter level incentives despite it only being about halfway through the quarter. While Tesla's U.S. sales are down, global EV sales continue to rise. The company has also benefited from being the sole automaker exempt from a major automotive tariff, thanks to meeting certain compliance criteria. Still, Tesla faces stiff competition from a growing roster of EV makers offering alternatives to consumers. Tesla owners can still tap into cost savings with EVs, including lower fuel costs, potential solar integration, and tax credits through the Inflation Reduction Act, though these incentives could be threatened by future policy changes. As the EV market evolves, Tesla's latest maneuvers highlight the pressure facing even industry leaders. Whether the discounts and perks will be enough to reverse the sales slump remains to be Pushes Hard with New Incentives as Sales Slip first appeared on Men's Journal on Jun 3, 2025 Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
VinFast Cuts Half Its Canadian Showrooms as EV Market Cools
VinFast, the Vietnamese EV startup that set out to challenge Tesla with a sleek direct-to-consumer model, is pulling back — and hard. This week, the company confirmed it will shut down half of its retail locations in Canada, just two and a half years after entering the market. VinFast launched into Canada in late 2022 with big promises: a sleek, direct-to-consumer electric-vehicle model meant to rival Tesla. Within months, the Vietnamese company opened 10 showrooms across Ontario, Quebec, and British Columbia—five of them within upscale shopping malls like Yorkdale and Park Royal. But as of May 2025, half of those stores are set to close, marking a sharp reversal of its aggressive rollout. Five of its 10 Canadian storefronts are on the chopping block, including all three of its boutique mall locations and two additional showrooms in outlying areas, according to Retail Insider. The move marks a major pivot for the company, which had positioned itself as a disruptor ready to overhaul the traditional car-buying experience. 'VinFast Canada is announcing the closure of our three boutique mall locations and two showrooms in outlying areas as part of a broader strategy to refocus resources and enhance long-term performance,' the company said in a statement. The closures reflect mounting pressure on EV startups as the market cools and interest rates rise. While legacy automakers double down on hybrid models, newer players are struggling to stay competitive. VinFast opened its first Canadian store in December 2022 at Toronto's Yorkdale Mall, mirroring Tesla's showroom-style retail playbook. But plans to scale have sputtered. VinFast said it will maintain five showrooms in British Columbia, Ontario, and Quebec. One survivor: the Mississauga location near Highway 401. The company says it will announce an expanded after-sales service network later this year and is 'considering' franchise dealer partnerships — a potential departure from its original direct-sales ethos. This contraction comes as other EV upstarts also face reality checks. Hype alone won't power growth. Even with global ambitions and a backstory rooted in one of Vietnam's biggest conglomerates, VinFast is learning the hard way: building cars is tough. Selling them might be even Cuts Half Its Canadian Showrooms as EV Market Cools first appeared on Men's Journal on Jun 9, 2025 Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
‘Keep an Eye on the Bigger Picture,' Says Morgan Stanley About Tesla Stock
Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) stock took a sharp hit last week after Elon Musk and Donald Trump – once close buddies – turned on each other in a public social media spat that quickly became an online spectacle. While the internet grabbed its popcorn to watch the drama/comedy unfold, investors were less amused, driving the stock down and wiping out a record $152 billion in market value. Confident Investing Starts Here: Trump warned he might yank Elon's federal subsidies and contracts, while Musk took jabs at Trump's links to Jeffrey Epstein and called for his impeachment. Now, Trump says he's considering ditching his Tesla. But what does Wall Street have to say about all this madness? Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas, one of the Street's biggest TSLA bulls, shared a 'few 'pith and marrow' thoughts' in the wake of the public spat. According to Trump, the whole thing kicked off because Musk was upset his 'Big Beautiful Bill' was not beneficial to Tesla. However, Jonas makes short shrift of the implications. 'We do not believe the phasing out of EV tax credits from the BBB (Big Beautiful Bill) is material to the long term outlook for TSLA,' the analyst said While Musk's involvement with the Trump administration and his increasingly polarizing politics were the cue from a massive drop in sales for Tesla earlier this year, Jonas does not think the argument will help bring back buyers that once considered buying a Tesla but were turned off by Musk's recent activities. In fact, Jonas thinks the argument could 'potentially (temporarily) alienate multiple sides of the political spectrum.' Yet, zooming out, Jonas thinks it's important to keep an eye on the bigger picture and that offers plenty of promise. 'While emotions are running high, we are not convinced the longer-term vectors that drive the stock's value have changed here,' he said. ' AI leadership, autonomy/robotics, manufacturing, supply chain re-architecture, renewable power, critical infrastructure… Tesla still holds so many valuable cards that are largely apolitical, in our opinion.' Nevertheless, investors should prepare for a rocky ride over the near-term. Donning his 'trading cap,' Jonas feels more confident about short-term volatility than about the stock's immediate direction. The analyst says he's sticking with his $410 price target on Tesla shares, even as he braces for the stock to post further losses. That figure implies a one-year gain of 36%. Meanwhile, Jonas maintains an Overweight rating (i.e., Buy). (To watch Jonas' track record, click here) That view, however, stands in contrast to the broader Street sentiment. Based on a mix of 16 Buys, 10 Holds, and 10 Sells, the analyst consensus rates the stock a Hold (i.e., Neutral). Going by the $285.91 average target, the shares are expected stay range-bound for the foreseeable future. (See TSLA stock forecast) To find good ideas for stocks trading at attractive valuations, visit TipRanks' Best Stocks to Buy, a tool that unites all of TipRanks' equity insights.
