Senate GOP declines to meet with parliamentarian on whether Trump tax cuts add to deficit
And Republicans so far have 'flat out refused' to have any such discussion, they say.
The partisan battle over how to 'score' the budgetary impact of making Trump's 2017 tax cuts permanent could determine whether Senate Republicans would need to rewrite the sprawling 940-page bill on the Senate floor.
Democrats must decide whether to force Republicans to obtain a parliamentarian ruling on the Senate floor Monday on whether making the 2017 Trump tax cuts permanent would violate Senate rules.
An adverse ruling on the issue could derail the bill, but Republicans are confident that won't happen.
Democrats say Republicans are trying to dodge the Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough from ruling on whether the tax portion of the 'big, beautiful bill' exceeds the reconciliation package's deficit target for 2025 to 2034 and whether it increase deficits beyond 2034.
Democrats think that if MacDonough weighs in on the subject, she would rule that Senate precedent requires that changes in tax law be scored on a 'current law' baseline.
Such a ruling that would show that extending the Trump tax cuts permanently violates the Senate's Byrd Rule.
A person close to the conversation said that Senate Budget Committee Republicans 'flat out refused' to meet with the parliamentarian to talk about what baseline should be used for Trump's big, beautiful bill.
Democrats 'asked that this be adjudicated by the parliamentarian' and Republicans 'have refused, basically saying they can do what they want,' said the source familiar with the behind-the-scenes debate.
Democrats brought up the issue at the start of the Byrd Bath process for the bill.
Senate Budget Committee Chairman Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) again tried to meet with Republicans this past week to discuss the budget baseline with the parliamentarian and Republicans once again declined to participate, according to the source.
The Byrd Rule determines what legislation is eligible to pass the Senate with a simple-majority vote and avoid a filibuster.
It states that legislation passed on the reconciliation fast track must comply with the reconciliation instructions, and it requires the legislation not increase the deficit in fiscal years beyond the budget window.
Merkley on Sunday circulated a letter he received from Congressional Budget Office Director Phillip Swagel stating that the Finance portion of the GOP megabill would increase the deficit by nearly $3.5 trillion over the 2025-2034 window, exceeding the target set by the reconciliation instructions.
Swagel also told Merkley that the Finance text would 'increase deficits in years after 2034.'
That would appear to violate the Byrd Rule and subject the entire bill to a 60-vote point-of-order objection.
Republicans, however, say that the parliamentarian doesn't have a role in judging how much the tax portion of the One Big, Beautiful Bill Act would add to the deficit within the bill's 10-year budget window or whether it would add to deficits beyond 2034.
They argue that Budget Committee Chairman Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) has authority under Section 312 of the Congressional Budget Act 'to determine baseline numbers of spending and revenue.'
Ryan Wrasse, a spokesman for Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) pointed to a Budget Committee report published when Democrats were in the majority in 2022 stating that the Budget Committee, through its Chair, makes the call on questions of numbers,' not the parliamentarian.
Graham received a letter from Swagel, the CBO director, on Saturday stating that the Finance Committee's tax text does not exceed its reconciliation instructions or add to deficits after 2034 when scored on the 'current-policy' baseline that Graham wants the Joint Committee on Taxation and CBO to use.
Taylor Reidy, a spokesperson for the Budget panel, asserted on X, the social media platform, that 'there is no need to have a parliamentarian meeting with respect to current policy baseline because Section 312 of the Congressional Budget Act gives Sen. Graham — as Chairman of the Budget Committee — the authority to set the baseline.
Senate Democrats, however, argue that a current policy baseline has never been used for a budget reconciliation package before and that directing JCT and CBO how to score a bill violates the spirit of the Byrd Rule and Section 313 of the 1974 Budget Act, which determines what can get into a reconciliation package.
Democrats note that conservative Rep. Chip Roy (R-Texas), a fiscal hawk, compared the 'current-policy' baseline to 'fairy dust' if it's used to argue that extending tax cuts don't add to the deficit.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
A quick look back at this week's biggest stories
Here is a look back at the top stories of the week, if you're looking for a quick recap — as well as our best photo galleries and some stories away from the headlines. — Trump and Putin meet about Ukraine A much-anticipated meeting between the U.S. and Russian leaders on Friday ended without agreement on a ceasefire or a broader deal about the war in Ukraine. Read our analysis of the meeting in Alaska, and here is our story about reactions as they were coming in Saturday morning. You can also look at a report from the frontlines in Ukraine, where the defenders face big challenges. And watch an unusually animated President Putin respond to a shouted question from a reporter in Alaska. — Federal intervention in Washington, DC The Trump administration attempted to take control of the police force of the nation's capital, partially retreating on Friday after the city's leadership sued. The administration also deployed National Guard units in the district, saying it's to reduce crime. — Floods in India and Pakistan, and the war in Gaza Hundreds of people have died in flash floods in the mountainous districts of the two South Asian nations, caused by cloudbursts. Scientists say climate change is a contributing factor. A collection of some of our best photos is here. And in Gaza, hunger continues, now exacerbated by a lack of adequate drinking water as the Israeli government announces a settlement project that 'buries the idea of a Palestinian state'. — Away from the headlines If you want content away from the top stories, you mustn't miss the lost and found wallet of a Michigan autoworker, the 'Frankenstein bunnies' of Colorado, and the dwindling octopus populations of Spain's seas. Also, bugs have become popular pets in Japan. For our best visual journalism, look at the photos of the week, people celebrating the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan in Kabul, Shiite Muslims in Iraq marking Arbaeen, and Zimbabwe taxi drivers showing off their love of Premier League soccer.
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Ohioans came out strong for Trump — now they're bracing for his tariffs
COLUMBUS — In 1837, two brothers-in-law living in Ohio — one a candle maker, the other a soap maker — merged their businesses to form what later became the multinational juggernaut Procter & Gamble. Nearly two centuries later, the company — which makes everything from toothpaste to diapers — could be the canary in the coal mine as the U.S. economy wobbles under the weight of President Donald Trump's sweeping tariff agenda. Procter & Gamble announced last month that it was increasing prices on its products. Many Ohioans say they are bracing for diminished business and higher costs as a result of tariffs, while others see Trump's plan as the only way to revive the state's manufacturing base. "I'm still confident that things still need to play out," said Mark Patterson in Springfield, west of the state capital. "And I think it's kind of a wait-and-see at this point." Patterson runs a small sheet metal fabrication business and has two other employees. He said he's seen a boost in orders and thinks it's a sign that companies are prioritizing American-made products. Trump has claimed that his steep tariffs on imports from around the world will accomplish many things: the restoration of American manufacturing, trade deals on the United States' terms and mountains of cash for the federal government. Canada was hit with 35 per cent tariffs but the levies exclude goods compliant with the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement on trade. The president also slapped high tariffs on steel, aluminum, copper and automobiles. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has said Ohio is likely to be the seventh-most tariff-affected state. Canada is Ohio's largest export market — the state sent $21.4 billion in goods north and imported $17.9 billion in Canadian products in 2023. Ohio is part of the integrated automobile sector that links Canada and the United States. Honda and the Big Three automakers — Ford, Stellantis and General Motors — employ thousands of workers in vehicle and parts manufacturing in Ohio, while smaller businesses in the state support the automotive supply chain. "The parts industry is very, very fragile," said Michael Gorman, a professor of business analytics and operations management at the University of Dayton. The industry works on thin margins and manufacturers can employ complicated logistics and delivery arrangements. Many companies in the auto sector stockpiled supplies as the tariffs loomed. Those supplies are running low now. Gorman said that while larger companies have more flexibility to switch suppliers for some components, smaller firms may not be able to survive. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has said companies with fewer than 500 workers will be hit especially hard by the duties. "When orders are unpredictable, then orders based on those orders are even more unpredictable because everybody's guessing what everybody else is going to do," Gorman said. "And right now, with the high level of uncertainty, it's not clear what the future holds." Ohio's auto industry isn't the only one with reasons to worry. Hoster Brewing is the oldest brewery in Columbus; it pulled its first pint in 1836. Ian Hansford, bar manager at Hoster, said profit margins are dwindling as the brewery gets hammered by tariffs on critical inputs like steel, aluminum and grain. "Our costs have gone up about 30 per cent just to craft beer from start to finish," he said. While the brewery hasn't increased its prices yet, Hansford said the current tariff climate is "not sustainable at all." "I think the … song and dance of the American government needs to end eventually, because it's only hurting American people," he said. Ohioans are proud of the famous businesses and brands with roots in their state. The Wendy's burger chain was launched here, as was KitchenAid, which assembled its first stand mixer in 1919 in Springfield. Goodyear Tire started in Akron in 1898. Residents also talk about Ohio's connections to General Electric, which recently announced it will invest $3 billion to expand U.S. manufacturing and create 1,000 jobs over five years. None of those new jobs will be in Ohio. U.S. Vice-President JD Vance, a former Ohio senator, has stood by Trump's tariffs and Sen. Bernie Moreno — like many other Republicans in the state — also has defended the duties. They promise the long-term benefits will outweigh the short-term pain. Ohio has long had a neighbourly relationship with Canada, said Democratic state Rep. Anita Somani. She said she's worried about the damage being caused by decisions made in the White House, especially since many Canadian companies invest in Ohio. "They don't know what to do," Somani said of the Canadian businesses. "A lot of the other companies aren't sure how to invest because nobody knows if the tariffs are going to increase, decrease, stay the same. And when you have that uncertainty (in your) cost of doing business, you don't do business." Manufacturing employment has been declining throughout the United States for decades, including in Ohio, but there have been some promising signs in the state lately. The Ohio Manufacturers Association said in a recent report that the state remains a manufacturing "powerhouse," citing recent investments and Intel's plans for a massive new computer chip fabrication plant. Intel recently announced it's slowing construction of the Ohio site. Behind that optimism is a landscape dotted with empty warehouses and shuttered factories — remnants of industries that have died or moved on. Ohio was long a swing state but has shifted over the last 12 years toward the Republican party, said Dan Birdsong, a professor of political science at the University of Dayton. In 2016 and 2020, Trump won Ohio by eight percentage points — that margin expanded to 11 points in last year's election. But areas of the state where Trump has seen his strongest support may also be the ones most at risk from his trade policies. Recent polling shows only 48 per cent of Ohioans approve of Trump on trade, Birdsong said. "You have some really strong supporters of the president, but also industries that might be more harmed by the trade practices," Birdsong said. "That's the question — with tariffs and with trade and the changes, is this going to have a negative impact on the regions where Trump saw a lot of his support over the last three election cycles?" All presidents are given a bit of leeway early in a term and Trump's most ardent supporters seem willing to give him time, Birdsong said. More traditional Republicans and the Independents who backed Trump in 2024 seem to be more wary ahead of next year's midterm elections. Birdsong said it may ultimately come down to voters' pocketbooks. "If the economy goes south, if it gets bad, then it puts the Republicans on defence," he said. "And allows Democrats to at least articulate a vision for why they should have some more representation." This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 16, 2025. Kelly Geraldine Malone, The Canadian Press
Chicago Tribune
13 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
The Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for Aug. 16
Planes whizzing around the city for the annual Chicago Air and Water Show are a sign that summer is winding down. But before the planes came dark skies and tons of rain, with several parts of the Chicagoland under flash flood and severe weather warnings. But enough about the weather — let's recap what else happened this week. Chicago Public Schools students return to the classroom Monday as school leaders continue to hammer out the district's budget. At Wednesday's school board meeting, CPS CEO Macquline King presented a balanced budget that divided members, who must pass a spending plan by the end of August. Plus, the University of Chicago announced that it will pause admissions for Ph.D. and master's programs across several schools amid mounting financial strains. The city of Chicago is facing its own budgetary problems, with the city's chief financial officer speaking Tuesday about how new state actions could help. But City Hall did score a win when the mayor and Chicago Fire Fighters Union Local 2 reached a tentative contract agreement following years of bargaining. Both Republican and Democratic state politicians headed to Springfield this week for their party's day at the Illinois State Fair. The politicos weren't there merely to catch the Snoop Dog show and take in the butter cow, but also to give stump speeches, talk nationwide redistricting efforts and gear up for the 2026 midterms. Meanwhile, the Texas House Democrats who fled to Illinois last week said Thursday that they plan to return to Austin after lawmakers adjourn their current special session and California Democrats introduce their retaliatory map designed to neutralize the Texas GOP's efforts. From the crime and public safety beat, another corrupt Illinois politician is going to serve time, the Cook County state's attorney's office declined to charge the officers who shot and killed Dexter Reed during a March 2024 traffic stop and the Chicago police officer who fatally shot Officer Krystal Rivera earlier this year was stripped of police powers after being accused of battery against another female officer. Chicago is the subject of more threats from President Donald Trump. After mobilizing National Guard troops in Washington, D.C., to help fight crime, the president suggested doing the same in the Windy City. Trump also met with Russian President Vladimir Putin at a summit in Alaska on Friday to discuss ending the war in Ukraine. It's been a little more than a week since the latest round of U.S. tariffs took effect, but it's difficult to interpret the impact they've had on the economy. While the stock market soared to historic highs this week, the latest report from the consumer price index showed the cost of some everyday goods is climbing and the Federal Reserve announced that, across the board, inflation was unchanged. Back home, the Chicago Bulls are preparing to get back out on the court, releasing their schedule for the 2025-26 season, which starts on Oct. 22, and across town, the Sky notched their 11th loss in 12 games, as injured star Angel Reese sat out for a sixth straight. Things aren't much better for Chicago area baseball fans. The Cubs are falling further back from first place in the NL Central, the White Sox are 44-78, and Clarendon Hills suffered a stinging defeat in their opening game of the Little League World Series, losing 16-1. But you know who had a good week? Swifties. The pop star announced her 12th studio album, 'The Life of a Showgirl,' late Monday and appeared on her boyfriend Travis Kelce's 'New Heights' podcast Wednesday to discuss the upcoming record. Now let's get to it. Can you guess who said what this week? Take the Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz to find out. Missed last week? You can find it here or check out our past editions of Quotes of the Week.
