Clear stand on heritage tag for Savarkar Sadan: HC to State
The PIL, filed in view of the imminent razing of the building for a redevelopment project, seeks heritage status and 'monument of national importance' tag for the building, alongside a special compensation policy for its inhabitants.
On Friday, Abhinav Bharat Congress representative Pankaj Phadnis submitted a letter to the court issued by the deputy municipal architect of Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation in 2012. The letter stated that the under-secretary of the urban development had in 2009 approved a proposal to include Savarkar Sadan in the heritage list and a notice was accordingly issued inviting suggestions and objections from the public. The proposal was then sent to the principal secretary, the letter stated, although no notification was issued thereafter.
As reported by HT on May 5, Savarkar Sadan, which houses a mini museum dedicated to Savarkar on the ground floor, may be razed as some property owners are in talks with a builder for redeveloping the property. Two adjacent plots are likely to be amalgamated for the redevelopment project – one houses Laxmi Sadan, where renowned classical vocalist Pandit Jitendra Abhisheki once resided, while the other faces the Shivaji Park.
The petition cited the HT report, stating, '...the petitioner was startled to see a report in a prominent newspaper about imminent demolition of Savarkar Sadan quoting three reliable sources.'
It refers to the high court's directions to the BMC in October 2008 to decide on heritage status for Savarkar Sadan within 12 weeks. The Heritage Conservation Committee also recommended the same, the petition notes, stating, 'It is ironic that 17 years later, the same argument has to be repeated.'
'The status of the said property shall not be changed and the position as prevailing today shall be maintained,' the court said in its order on Friday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scroll.in
27 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
The true story behind a ‘real' photograph of Rani Lakshmibai
In 2003, a painted portrait of Hindutva ideologue VD Savarkar was installed in Parliament, sparking an uproar. Objections were raised over the fact that he had been accused in the Mohandas Gandhi assassination case, even though he escaped being charged in the conspiracy. As the controversy raged on, it was also discussed by us members of Sahmat, the trust established in memory of activist-artist Safdar Hashmi. Sahmat ideologue Rajendra Prasad had found Savarkar's book, The Indian War of Independence of 1857, in Delhi's Teen Murti library. Banned by the British, the first edition of the book in English was published in 1909. Leafing through the book I was astonished to see a reproduction of a postcard with a photograph titled 'Lakshmi Bai – The Rani of Jhansi and leader in the Indian War of Independence of 1857'. My heart raced. I thought I knew my photo history, but I had never seen this image or even a reference to it. I had visited the Jhansi fort as a child with my mother and the vivid tales told by the guide were seared in my memory. I had grown up hearing the famous poem Jhansi Ki Rani by Subhadra Kumari Chauhan. I have also seen countless paintings and other images of Lakshmibai. But a photograph, as an authentic portrait, would mean something else entirely. While working on an exhibit on the Uprising of 1857 with Sahmat a little later, I included this image of the Rani and it travelled across India as part of the display. Some years after this, in 2010, I saw a television news report about an exhibition in Bhopal with the same photograph, attributing it to an album in the collection of my artist friend Amit Ambalal in Ahmedabad. Play I contacted Ambalal who told me that he had bought the album in Jaipur in the 1960s and sent me images of the pages. There, among photos and paintings of the other freedom fighters of 1857, was the Rani of Jhansi. Devanagari and Urdu scripts on the back of the photograph identified her. This was thrilling. There was now a second historical source of the image and, importantly, it was in India. Excited by this discovery, in the following months I contacted many experts in the field to authenticate the image. Could the Rani have been photographed? Rani Lakshmibai had died in battle on June 18, 1858, but it was entirely possible that she had been photographed. Photography was fairly widespread in India by the mid-1850s. I began a long search to authenticate the image and its source. Around 2006-'07, I got in touch with photo historian Sophie Gordon, who was the curator of theatre director and collector E Alkazi's extensive early Indian photography collection in London. She had found an advertisement in a Delhi gazette shortly after the 1857 uprising, where there were photos of Jhansi offered for sale. But no images were traceable. As part of my search into sources that could help verify the authenticity of the photograph, I had reached out to Bhawa Nand Uniyal, a collector of rare books from Delhi who was in London at the time. I told Sophie Gordon that Uniyal had written back to tell me that he had found a post-Independence edition of Savarkar's book in his collection stating that the postcard was not Rani Lakshmibai, but Begum Shahjahan of Bhopal. 'Now he finds this reference in the catalogue of proscribed material in the India Office Collections,' I said in my email to Gordon. 'It obviously is not in the photography collection because it is a printed postcard. Are you still interested in this? Being there, you probably have much easier access to dig this would be a terrific coup.' I gave her the reference details Uniyal had sent me: Listed item no: 176 in publications proscribed by the GOI Reference no: EPP 1/36 IOLR A catalogue of the collections in the India Office Library and Records and the department of Oriental Manuscripts & Printed books. Edited by Graham Shaw and Mary Lloyd 1985. Then, in 2010, I got a message from archivist and researcher Pramod Kumar KG, who found the same image in a photo album in the archives of the Chowmohalla Palace in Hyderabad. 'This particular page has a carte-de-visite showing the lady in question seated on a chair. The caption in Urdu reads HH the ..... of Tanjore,' said Pramod Kumar's message. 'The main name is illegible though Her Highness and Tanjore is pretty clear. Looking at the image it is quite possible that this is the work of the Johnston & Hoffman Studio, here I am going by the props and the way the image is taken. Hope this helps clear the confusion.' Shortly thereafter, a response from Sophie Gordon, by then the curator of photography of the Royal Collections at Windsor Castle, helped clear the matter up. 'The portrait of the woman identified as the Rani of Lakshmi is, as Pramod suspected, a princess of Tanjore,' wrote Gordon. 'The Royal Collection has this portrait in the photograph collection where it is captioned as 'HH The Princess of Tanjore', from the Bourne and Shepherd studio. It is an albumen print (ie not a daguerreotype, and must therefore date to a later period). I should date to sometime in the 1870s.' There was also an interesting history to the album. 'The portrait is on a page with other portraits of her two daughters and her official consort. The album itself is a collection of portraits of the many rulers of India, presented to Queen Victoria in the mid-1880s,' said Gordon, who had sent along an image of the entire album page. 'Unfortunately, I have never seen a photographic portrait of the Rani of Jhansi. I hope this is helpful.' Here ended the seven-year long search, from the Teen Murti library to Bhopal, Hyderabad, the India Office Library and finally Windsor Castle in England. The image Sophie Gordon had sent was by far the clearest and showed other members of the Tanjore ruling family being photographed in the same setting. It was amazing that this image had been in wide circulation at some point in the late 19th century as a photograph of the Rani of Jhansi. It was a testament to the power of her myth in the Indian imagination in our struggle for freedom. Sadly, it was not the Rani. But the tale was worth telling. It took seven years to hunt down the source of this photograph and even longer tell this tale. But in this age of artificial intelligence, misinformation, and fabrications, a search through 19th century archival material to authenticate history is even more important.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
It's imperative to ask who shapes the judges & how: Justice Surya Kant
A judge does not only adjudicate disputes, but also represents the nation's fabric and moral compass, said Supreme Court Justice Surya Kant, while emphasising the importance of asking who shapes the judiciary and how? From left: Professor Balram Gupta, Punjab & Haryana high court chief justice Sheel Nagu and Supreme Court Justice Surya Kant during the book launch at the Chandigarh Judicial Academy, Sector 43, on Saturday. (Ravi Kumar/HT) The top court judge was speaking at the book launch of 'Shaping the Judges', honouring the life of professor Balram Gupta, at the Chandigarh Judicial Academy, Sector 43, on Saturday evening. Calling the book a remarkable tribute to professor Gupta, Justice Surya Kant said the judge must not be just a working mechanic. 'A mason lays brick after brick without caring how a building is built. A judge, on the other hand, must be an architect thinking of the way the building has come for the future generations. His life will continue to inspire them,' he added. Titled 'Shaping the Judges: Essays in Honour of Dr Balram K Gupta', the volume compiles thought-provoking essays from India's leading judicial minds, including 10 sitting Supreme Court judges. Among them, Justice Surya Kant's piece — 'Humour in Judgment Writing' — makes the case for letting wit breathe in black-letter law. The book has been edited and introduced by Gupta's daughter professor Shruti Bedi and is a personal and scholarly tribute to her father who is a noted jurist and mentor. His decades-long influence on judicial training, ethics and legal academia is palpable throughout the collection, which brings together contributions from judges, scholars and legal philosophers who have crossed paths with him or been shaped by him. Professor Bedi is a professor of law and director at the University Institute of Legal Studies, Panjab University. An internationally recognised legal scholar, she is an international fellow at the National Institute of Military Justice, Washington DC, and a visiting professor at Universitas Airlangga, Indonesia. She also serves as the director of the Centre for Constitution and Public Policy. 'From my formative years in Chandigarh, I know firsthand that almost everyone has a fond memory in connection with professor Gupta's articulation and depth of legal acumen,' said Justice Kant. 'Beyond the courtroom, professor Gupta's pivotal stint at both the National Judicial Academy and then at Chandigarh Judicial Academy, apart from his plethora of teaching roles, all cement his position as a human being in the legal and judicial landscape of India,' he said. Chief justice of Punjab and Haryana high court, Justice Sheel Nagu, and high court Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul were among the dignitaries present at the event.
Scroll.in
3 hours ago
- Scroll.in
West Bengal: Two persons arrested for assaulting Muslim men transporting cattle in Durgapur
Two persons were arrested for allegedly beating up, tying and forcing two Muslim men to do sit-ups in West Bengal's Durgapur on Thursday, while they were transporting cattle for farming purposes, police said. The attackers were allegedly linked to a Hindutva outfit and the Bharatiya Janata Party, The Indian Express reported. The incident took place near the Gammon Bridge under the Coke Oven police station limits, where a group of men stopped a pickup van carrying cattle and attacked its occupants, The Hindu reported. A purported video of the incident has been widely shared on social media. Commissioner of Police (Asansol-Durgapur) Sunil Kumar Chaudhary told The Hindu that the men were transporting cattle from the Asuria market in Bankura district. An FIR has been filed against a BJP youth wing leader who was allegedly seen in the video tying the victims' hands and forcing them to do sit-ups, the newspaper reported. Two persons belonging to the minority community, while carrying cattle for farming purpose, were detained and severely beaten up yesterday in Durgapur by some hooligans belonging to a particular political party. A case has been registered over the incident and two of the… — West Bengal Police (@WBPolice) August 1, 2025 Raids are underway to arrest all those involved in the incident, West Bengal Police said in a statement on social media. 'Nothing and no one will be allowed to dent our state's tradition of inclusivity and harmony,' the police said. 'We always have, and always will, demonstrate zero tolerance for religious bigotry of any kind.'
