I pressured my mother to confess a scandalous family secret on her deathbed - now I'm worried I ruined her final moments
A woman has described their torment after pressuring their mother to confess a family secret while on her deathbed.
Posting on the thread r/AmITheA**hole, the user, believed to be based in the US, revealed how they found out at a young age that her baby brother's biological father was not the man who had brought him up.
Allen, the poster's younger brother whose name has been changed for privacy, lived the majority of his life believing that George, the man who raised him from a baby, was his biological father - even after he had died.
In 2023, Allen and his wife began discussing the fact that he didn't look much like George, and even began to wonder if he was his real father.
The Reddit user recalled their distress when they realised their mother 'didn't have much time left' but was the 'only one who had the answer'.
As I result, they 'pressured her, got loud with her' and finally got her to admit the truth to Allen, giving enough information for them to eventually track down his real father.
However, the Reddit user revealed they felt guilty for forcing out the information, writing: 'AITA for pressing my mom in her final weeks? I felt like it caused Allen to be stand offish and he rarely came by to check on her after that.'
They added: 'The reason I think I might be the a**hole is one for pressing her while she's on her deathbed and causing her discomfort but also the fact that my brother kind of abandoned her at that point and yelling came to visit her one time after that and at that point she was incoherent basically in a coma and I feel like maybe I robbed her of her final moments with her family.'
But taking to the comments, most agreed that they'd done the right thing - and felt sorry for Allen, having been kept in the dark for so long.
One commenter wrote: 'Why on earth was she still lying about it? Did the guy turn out to be scary or something?'
The sister of Allen responded and confirmed that this was not the case at all. She wrote: 'No. He actually turned out to be a really good guy. Feel like she was embarrassed and wasn't really thinking about how it is going to affect him not knowing.'
Other readers of the story questioned why the poster's mother and aunty were discussing the topic so openly at the dinner table when she was present as a child.
One person wrote: 'What kind of sick family discusses this at the dining table in front of the other kids? Either they thought it was no biggie or they did it on purpose so someone would overhear and they wouldn't be to blame that it all came out. Either way, they suck and I'm sorry for the original poster and their brother.'
Many people supported the poster's decision to pressure their mother into telling the truth.
Another person wrote: 'You not only helped Allen find his bio-dad but also helped preserve a modicum of decency for your mother right before her death, even though she doesn't have much decency to begin with.'
A second said: 'Your brother should have been told a LONG time ago. He had every right to know who his birth father was so he could decide whether to have a relationship then or not. It was wrong for your mother to keep that from him. You did the right thing.'
Posting on the thread r/AmITheA**hole , they revealed how they found out at a young age that her baby brother's biological father was not the man who had brought him up
Others were not as supportive of the decision and argued that the daughter had 'ruined' her brother's final chance to make 'fond memories.'
They wrote: 'The last time with your mom should have been where you could make some fond memories or have nice talks together. You ruined that for your brother, so congratulations.'
Explaining how the poster came to to learn the information, they wrote: 'When I was young I discovered the secret while at the dining table when my aunt and grandmother were having a conversation.
'My aunt spilled the beans that my stepdad was not my youngest brother's real father.'
However, some time after the initial reveal worlds nearly collided, the poster wrote: 'Years later me and my mother were out having a few drinks just enjoying each other's company and she said oh my God that's Allen's real dad.
'We didn't speak to him and I wasn't exactly sure which guy she was talking about.'
Despite George taking the secret to his grave Allen had discussed with his wife how he felt that he 'looked nothing like' who he thought his father was and had question if he was 'his real dad.'
When Allen opened up to his older sister about how he was feeling she 'told him he'd have to talk to Mom,' and that she did not know much about the situation.
However, timing was not on the daughter's side as their mother 'didn't have much time left but was the only one that had the answer.'
The poster admitted that due to their mother's ill health she 'felt bad springing it' on her but thought that her brother deserved answers.
She wrote: 'Everybody else who was privy to it was dead by this point and my brother wanted to find who is real dad was so he can know his family history, family medical history, if he has other siblings out there you know that kind of stuff.'
However, when the siblings approached the topic with their mother she 'tried to deny it,' triggering the daughter to get 'loud with her.'
Recalling the altercation and her own behaviour in particular she wrote: 'I'm not proud of it.'
Although it was a challenge the truth finally came out. The daughter wrote: 'But she finally admitted to Allen, and what little information she could remember, or was willing to release, was just enough that with a little searching we were able to find him.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
43 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
MAGA supporters mourn passing of former Trump official
Trump world is mourning the loss of the former NYPD commissioner who led the city through the aftermath of 9/11. Bernard Kerik (pictured) died on Thursday at the age of 69, after being hospitalized for cardiac disease, the New York Post reports. He was surrounded by friends and family at the time of his death at NewYork-Presbyterian hospital. Kerik - who served a stint in prison for fraud - was a presence at Trump's Mar-a-Lago resort and a steadfast advisor to the president. Many in MAGA world shared their memories and condolences, as word spread of Kerik's untimely death. 'I'm heartbroken to hear of the passing of Bernard Kerik,' wrote Camryn Kinsey, who was previously appointed to serve as an 'external-relations director' under Trump. 'He was one of the first people I met when I moved to DC , and quickly became a mentor and a friend,' she recounted. 'He didn't owe me anything, but took the time to guide me, support me and share the kind of wisdom only someone who had lived through history could offer.' Kinsey (pictured) went on to say he 'carried the weight' of the September 11 attacks on the World Trade Center 'with honor,' and noted that Kerik helped her as she pursued her master's degree in national security. 'His stories, his strength and his love for this country shaped me more than he probably knew,' Kinsey wrote. 'He was a true American patriot. I will miss him deeply.' Kerik was born in Newark, New Jersey on September 4, 1955. He never finished high school, but earned his General Educational Development certificate before he headed off to serve in the US Army, Fox News reports. From there, Kerik worked for a time for the Passaic County Sheriff in New Jersey - and joined the ranks of the NYPD in 1968. He briefly left the force in 1994, when he joined the Department of Corrections. After just four years at the department, then-NYC Mayor Rudy Giuliani appointed him commissioner of the agency. Over the course of his two years in that position, Kerik curbed guards' sick time abuse and reduced inmate violence. But Kerik really shot to prominence after he was appointed New York City's police commissioner in 2000, and presided over a 63 percent drop in violent crime. He then oversaw the NYPD's response, rescue and recovery efforts during the September 11 attacks. Reflecting on his work at the NYPD, Giuliani told the Post that Kerik was a 'true patriot' and 'one of the bravest men I've ever seen. 'He became police commissioner when they thought crime couldn't be reduced any further, yet he reduced it further,' the former mayor said. 'His work helped New York become the safest big city in America and a shining example of urban renaissance. Then he faced the worst foreign attack since the War of 1812 on American soil - September 11. He was at my side within 20 minutes of the attack and never left.' Yet Kerik did step away from his role as the head of the NYPD just a few months later. By 2003, following the US's invasion of Iraq, then-President George W. Bush named Kerik to head up a provisional police force in the nation. There, he recruited thousands of police officers and assembled a SWAT team to pursue kidnappers and insurgents. Around the same time, Kerik also founded Kerik Group - a private crisis and risk management consulting firm whose clients over the years include King Abdullah II of Jordan and the ruling family of the United Arab Emirates. Apparently impressed by his work, Bush sought to nominate Kerik to head the newly-established Department of Homeland Security in 2004. 'Bernie Kerik understands the duties that came to America on September the 11th. The resolve he felt that morning will guide him every day on his job,' Bush said at the time. But Kerik's nomination was short-lived as he withdrew himself from consideration just a few days after, when he admitted to employing an illegal immigrant as a nanny. The admission sparked a probe into other aspects of Kerik's life - and it was soon revealed that while he was married with two children, he rented an apartment in Lower Manhattan to conduct an extramarital affair with Judith Regan - who published his best-selling memoir. The apartment had originally been donated by a developer for use by rescue workers at Ground Zero, the Times reports. By 2006, Kerik pleaded guilty in the New York State Supreme Court to two misdemeanors involving renovations to his Bronx apartment by a New Jersey construction firm with suspected links to organized crime - and he was $221,000. Three years later, Kerik also pleaded guilty to eight federal felonies - including charges he evaded taxes on a $225,000 gift for home repairs and made false statements to federal officials when he was being considered for the Homeland Security post. The former cop - who had once been hailed as 'America's Cop' - then saw his name removed from the Manhattan jail complex that had been rebranded in his honor, and went on to serve four years behind bars before he was pardoned by Trump in 2020. In the aftermath, Kerik became a vocal critic of the criminal justice system and a staunch Trump ally. He spread the conspiracy theory that the 2020 presidential election was stolen, and even worked with Giuliani to investigate the claims. As a result, Kerik was recently grilled by Congress in hearings related to the January 6 Capitol riots, and was subpoenaed to disclose privileged Trump administration documents reportedly linked to the investigation. Meanwhile, Kerik wound up serving as a surrogate for the Trump administration on national security issues last year. He is now being remembered for his accomplishments and patriotism, which earned him an NYPD Medal for Valor, 29 NYPD medals for excellence and meritorious service, a Presidential Commendation from former President Ronald Reagan, two Distinguished Service Awards from the Department of Homeland Security and even an appointment as a Commander of the British Empire by Queen Elizabeth II. In a tribute online, FBI Director Kash Patel said Kerik was a 'warrior, a patriot and one of the most courageous public servants this country has ever known. 'He was decorated more than 100 times for bravery, valor and service, having rescued victims from burning buildings, survived assassination attempts and brought some of the world's most dangerous criminals to justice,' Patel wrote on X. 'His legacy is not just in the medals of the titles, but in the lives he saved, the city he helped rebuild and the country he served with honor.' Former Trump attorney Alina Habba echoed that sentiment by calling Kerik was a 'true patriot, fearless leader and devoted friend. 'Bernard Kerik embodied strength, loyalty and courage every single day,' she wrote. 'I'm honored to have known him.' Trump adviser Roger Stone, meanwhile, called the former cop a 'great man,' while FBI former Trump campaign adviser George Papadopoulos shared how Kerik offered him support during a difficult time for him and his family. 'The encouragement and positivity he gave us when we had only briefly met before would lead to an indelible memory and life long respect,' Papadopoulos wrote.
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Jakob Ingebrigtsen: ‘I'm embarrassed to be victim of domestic violence'
Act now to keep your subscription We've tried to contact you several times as we haven't been able to take payment. You must update your payment details via My Account or by clicking update payment details to keep your subscription.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
The REAL reason Trump is cracking down on Harvard... and it's nothing to do with ultra-woke students and staff
It is America's oldest college, is often ranked the best university on the planet, boasts 57 miles of bookcases in its biggest library, and is sheltered by a colossal $53 billion endowment. But Harvard University faces perhaps the greatest threat in its 389-year history, with a US president who's cutting funding and student visas to pressure professors to change their ' woke ' ways. President Donald Trump has frozen some $2.6 billion in federal funding, revoked the visas of foreign students, and is poised to axe Harvard's tax-free perks. The Ivy League school in Cambridge is getting its 'ass kicked,' the Republican says. Trump says the college's liberal leaders must stop antisemitism on campus, halt their diversity equity and inclusion schemes, and admit more US-born students. He increasingly appears alarmed by Harvard's opaque links to America's main competitor, China, and a web of financial, scholarly and military work that ultimately connects to its communist leaders. Under the radar, Harvard has trained members of a Chinese paramilitary group, partnered with its military universities, and maybe even helped a forced organ harvesting program, House Republicans say. On Wednesday, Trump urged the school to cut its population of foreign students — a fifth of whom are Chinese — from nearly 30 percent to 15 percent. Then, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the administration would 'aggressively revoke' the visas of Chinese students with links to its communist government at all US colleges. 'For too long, Harvard has let the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) exploit it,' a White House official told Reuters The school has 'turned a blind eye to vigilante CCP-directed harassment on-campus,' they added. Harvard did not answer our request for comment. The school says it will 'stand firm' against pressure from the administration. China's embassy in Washington said educational cooperation was 'mutually beneficial and should not be stigmatized.' Experts say the administration is undermining the research that makes America a world leader. Here, the Daily Mail takes a look at the ties to China that have hurt Harvard's reputation. JUNKETS FOR KILLERS Perhaps the most shocking of Harvard's ties to China are its links to a state-run paramilitary group that's rounded up Uyghurs and other minorities and caged them in China's forced labor camps. Officials from the Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps (XPCC), have since 2020 attended training sessions on public health run by Harvard's China Health Partnership. The XPCC was that year slapped with US sanctions for its role in alleged human rights abuses against Uyghurs and other Muslim ethnic groups in Xinjiang. Still, Harvard kept holding workshops until last year, says the Department of Homeland Security. Elise Stefanik and other Trump loyalists on the Hill this month launched a probe into Harvard's support for the XPCC and other schemes, and detailed their findings in a 14-page letter demanding answers from Harvard. The training sessions 'could have been deployed by XPCC to further repress the Uyghur people,' Stefanik and her colleagues on a House committee wrote. China denies claims of wrongdoing in Xinjiang, but both the Trump and Biden administrations have described Beijing's policies in the western province as 'genocide.' The lawmakers also queried Harvard's links to organ harvesting in China, where religious minorities have allegedly been executed on a massive scale to collect body parts for transplant. They highlight seven research projects between 2022 and 2024 when Harvard and Chinese researchers cooperated on studies about transplanting kidneys, livers, hearts and other organs. This is worrying, they wrote, because of Beijing's alarming 'record of human rights abuses in harvesting organs from religious and ethnic minorities.' Experts have since 2014 warned of large numbers of jailed dissidents, particularly Muslim Uyghurs, Falun Gong members, and Christians, being executed for their body parts. There are even reports that some victims are alive when their organs are removed. ARMING THE ENEMY Harvard also finds itself in the middle of an arms race between two of the world's biggest military powers. The college has taken funding from the Pentagon and spent it on research projects with China-based academics who could well be stealing America's military secrets, the lawmakers wrote. Harvard scholars have teamed up with Tsinghua University, Zhejiang University, and Huazhong University — which all undertake defense work for China's military, says the letter. Projects have covered materials for artificial intelligence (AI), polymers and alloys used in warplanes, and microelectronics — which could all benefit China's armed forces, it adds. 'Harvard researchers should not be contributing to the military capabilities of a potential adversary, says the letter from the House Select Committee on China. ROGUE SCHOLARS Shady dealings between Harvard scholars and Beijing were spotlighted by the case of Charles Lieber, who previously led its department of chemistry and chemical biology. Lieber was in 2021 convicted of lying to federal investigators about his ties to a Chinese-run science recruitment program and dodging taxes on his payouts from a Chinese university. Lieber, an expert in nanotechnology, in April started a cushy job at the state-funded Tsinghua University in Shenzhen. He praised his host city's 'dynamism and innovative spirit.' His conviction was part of a crackdown under the first Trump administration of intellectual property theft by China. The prosecutions were later halted under the Biden administration. Critics said they had led to racial profiling and a culture of fear that chilled scientific collaboration. MUZZLED SPEECH In its pressure campaign against Harvard, the Trump administration asked the school to provide details about its foreign students. When Harvard refused, the Department of Homeland Security revoked its ability to enroll international students. This follows mounting concerns over which Chinese students Harvard is helping admit into the US, and whether they have ties to the communist party. Harvard was rattled in April 2024, when a student activist there was physically ejected from an event by a Chinese exchange student — not a member of college security — when she heckled a speech by a visiting Chinese diplomat. A video of the event shows the Chinese exchange student dragging the heckler out of the room. Harvard disciplined the student protestor, but not the student who dragged her out of the room. John Moolenaar, the Republican chair of the House Select Committee on the CCP, at the time slammed 'another example of Harvard's appallingly unequal treatment of protestors based on the speech they support.' 'Harvard is punishing brave students who spoke out against the CCP's human rights abuses while not only letting the student who assaulted them off scot-free but also handing him an apology,' he added.
