Hong Kong court postpones Jimmy Lai's trial to Monday (Aug 18) over heart condition
The Apple Daily founder's health condition was brought to the attention of West Kowloon Court on Friday, just as the three presiding High Court judges were about to hear closing speeches from prosecutors and defence lawyers in his case of conspiracies to publish seditious articles and collude with foreign forces.
Senior Counsel Robert Pang Yiu-hung revealed that Lai, 77, had recently experienced heart palpitations while in prison, adding that in one incident he felt he would 'collapse'.
The defence had earlier sought the court's permission for Lai's absence from the remainder of the trial, but the judges rejected the request.
Pang stressed his client did not want 'undue attention' on his health condition and that the defence was prepared to carry on with proceedings.
Prosecutor Anthony Chau Tin-hang said that while the prison service's medical team could provide Lai with necessary medication shortly, it was unable to immediately arrange for a Holter monitor, a portable device used to detect irregular heartbeats.
Chau added that a team of medical professionals were on standby outside the court in case of an emergency.
Madam Justice Esther Toh Lye-ping said she was 'a little concerned' and preferred that the hearing begin later to ensure it could proceed regularly. Mr Justice Alex Lee Wang-tang added that counsel should still be able to complete their oral arguments 'well before' the eight days previously scheduled.
The government, meanwhile, issued a statement on Friday night to 'strongly condemn the out-of-context and fact-twisting reports' by some foreign media outlets, including CNN, which it said had attempted to mislead the public into believing Lai did not receive the medical care he needed.
It said Lai's lawyers had also made it clear in court that correctional authorities had arranged daily medical check-ups for him and that he had no complaint regarding the medical services.
The statement noted that Lai was repeatedly confirmed to be physically and mentally fit for trial, and a visiting medical specialist from the Hospital Authority had found nothing unusual during a detailed examination on August 7 after the inmate complained of a heart condition.
It said Lai had initially refused the specialist's advice to put on a cardiac monitoring device before changing his mind on August 13 at another medical expert's recommendation.
Wearing a long-sleeved white top and a pair of khaki pants, Lai waved to supporters and family members and had a brief exchange with his lawyers before slowly walking away from the courtroom.
Lai, an outspoken critic of Beijing, has been remanded in custody for more than 1,700 days since he was first denied bail in December 2020. He faces life in prison if convicted.
His son, Sebastien Lai Sung-yan, has consistently raised concerns over his father's health and warned that the tabloid founder may die in prison if Western governments do not step in.
Robertsons, the law firm representing Lai, said in a statement last year that he had been receiving appropriate medical attention for his health conditions, including diabetes.
'He has access to daylight through the windows in the corridor outside his cell, albeit he cannot see the sky. He exercises for an hour every day in a secure area,' the statement added.
Mainland Chinese and overseas governments made their stances clear once again ahead of the trial's resumption, with US President Donald Trump renewing previous promises to secure Lai's release.
Trump said during last year's presidential election campaign that he would '100 per cent' get Lai out of the country, predicting that it would be 'easy'.
But in what appeared to be a toned-down version of his earlier pledge, Trump said on Thursday that he would 'do everything' he could to secure Lai's release, while acknowledging Chinese President Xi Jinping would not be 'thrilled' by the move.
'I'm going to do everything I can to save him,' Trump said in an interview with Fox News Radio. 'We'll see what we can do ... we're going to do everything we can.'
A Beijing spokesman in Washington slammed 'external forces' for smearing Hong Kong's rule of law and interfering in the nation's internal affairs. He also depicted Lai as 'a key orchestrator and participant in anti-China, destabilising activities in Hong Kong'. - SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
a day ago
- The Star
Hong Kong court postpones Jimmy Lai's trial to Monday (Aug 18) over heart condition
Former Hong Kong media boss Jimmy Lai Chee-ying's national security trial has been adjourned until Monday after judges expressed concerns about his heart issue that arose shortly before closing submission proceedings. The Apple Daily founder's health condition was brought to the attention of West Kowloon Court on Friday, just as the three presiding High Court judges were about to hear closing speeches from prosecutors and defence lawyers in his case of conspiracies to publish seditious articles and collude with foreign forces. Senior Counsel Robert Pang Yiu-hung revealed that Lai, 77, had recently experienced heart palpitations while in prison, adding that in one incident he felt he would 'collapse'. The defence had earlier sought the court's permission for Lai's absence from the remainder of the trial, but the judges rejected the request. Pang stressed his client did not want 'undue attention' on his health condition and that the defence was prepared to carry on with proceedings. Prosecutor Anthony Chau Tin-hang said that while the prison service's medical team could provide Lai with necessary medication shortly, it was unable to immediately arrange for a Holter monitor, a portable device used to detect irregular heartbeats. Chau added that a team of medical professionals were on standby outside the court in case of an emergency. Madam Justice Esther Toh Lye-ping said she was 'a little concerned' and preferred that the hearing begin later to ensure it could proceed regularly. Mr Justice Alex Lee Wang-tang added that counsel should still be able to complete their oral arguments 'well before' the eight days previously scheduled. The government, meanwhile, issued a statement on Friday night to 'strongly condemn the out-of-context and fact-twisting reports' by some foreign media outlets, including CNN, which it said had attempted to mislead the public into believing Lai did not receive the medical care he needed. It said Lai's lawyers had also made it clear in court that correctional authorities had arranged daily medical check-ups for him and that he had no complaint regarding the medical services. The statement noted that Lai was repeatedly confirmed to be physically and mentally fit for trial, and a visiting medical specialist from the Hospital Authority had found nothing unusual during a detailed examination on August 7 after the inmate complained of a heart condition. It said Lai had initially refused the specialist's advice to put on a cardiac monitoring device before changing his mind on August 13 at another medical expert's recommendation. Wearing a long-sleeved white top and a pair of khaki pants, Lai waved to supporters and family members and had a brief exchange with his lawyers before slowly walking away from the courtroom. Lai, an outspoken critic of Beijing, has been remanded in custody for more than 1,700 days since he was first denied bail in December 2020. He faces life in prison if convicted. His son, Sebastien Lai Sung-yan, has consistently raised concerns over his father's health and warned that the tabloid founder may die in prison if Western governments do not step in. Robertsons, the law firm representing Lai, said in a statement last year that he had been receiving appropriate medical attention for his health conditions, including diabetes. 'He has access to daylight through the windows in the corridor outside his cell, albeit he cannot see the sky. He exercises for an hour every day in a secure area,' the statement added. Mainland Chinese and overseas governments made their stances clear once again ahead of the trial's resumption, with US President Donald Trump renewing previous promises to secure Lai's release. Trump said during last year's presidential election campaign that he would '100 per cent' get Lai out of the country, predicting that it would be 'easy'. But in what appeared to be a toned-down version of his earlier pledge, Trump said on Thursday that he would 'do everything' he could to secure Lai's release, while acknowledging Chinese President Xi Jinping would not be 'thrilled' by the move. 'I'm going to do everything I can to save him,' Trump said in an interview with Fox News Radio. 'We'll see what we can do ... we're going to do everything we can.' A Beijing spokesman in Washington slammed 'external forces' for smearing Hong Kong's rule of law and interfering in the nation's internal affairs. He also depicted Lai as 'a key orchestrator and participant in anti-China, destabilising activities in Hong Kong'. - SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST
The Star
a day ago
- The Star
Jimmy Lai getting proper treatment while in detention: Hong Kong govt
In this Feb 28, 2020, file photo, Jimmy Lai Chee-ying (center) leaves the Kowloon City police station after being granted bail following his arrest earlier in the day. - Photo: China Daily HONG KONG: The Hong Kong Special Administrative Region government has strongly condemned what it termed 'out-of-context and fact-twisting reports' by some foreign media outlets, including the US-based Cable News Network (CNN), on the court hearing of the case of Jimmy Lai Chee-ying. In a statement issued on Friday (Aug 15) night, the government emphasised that Lai has been receiving appropriate treatment during his detention. Such reports attempt to mislead the public into believing that Lai did not receive the medical care he needed as a means to smear his case under the Hong Kong National Security Law (HKNSL), as well as his custodial arrangements and the medical care services provided to him, said the government said. Their aim to smear and undermine Hong Kong's rule of law is despicable and violates the professional conduct of journalists, it added. 'During today's open court hearing, senior counsel representing Lai Chee-ying clearly presented to the court that the correctional institutions arrange daily medical checkups for Lai and that there had been no complaints at all regarding the medical care he receives there,' said a spokesman for the HKSAR government. The court commended the Correctional Services Department (CSD) while the Department of Justice stated that the prosecution is equally concerned about Lai's health and well-being, which led the CSD to arrange for a professional medical team to be on standby on the spot, ready to respond to any emergency immediately if needed, said the spokesman. 'External forces and anti-China media chose to turn a blind eye to these facts, and continued to repeat lies and engage in despicable operations. We must sternly denounce their wrongdoings.' Before attending court, doctors certified that Lai was physically and mentally fit for court hearing, the government said. Following his claims of heart palpitations, a visiting specialist from the Hospital Authority conducted a detailed examination on him on Aug 7 and no abnormality was found. As a precaution, the specialist recommended prescribing medication to Lai to be taken as and when needed, and that he should wear a cardiac monitoring device, but Lai Chee-ying declined the advice of the specialist, according to the spokesman. On Aug 13, the CSD arranged for another detailed examination by a specialist from the Hospital Authority. The specialist again recommended that Lai wear a device to monitor his cardiac condition, which he finally accepted to do, and the Hospital Authority and the CSD immediately made arrangements for that within a short period of time, said the spokesman. The CSD is committed to ensuring that the custodial environment is secure, safe, humane, appropriate and healthy and has also put in place an established mechanism, including regular independent visitors, namely Justices of the Peace, who inspect the prisons to ensure the rights of persons in custody are protected, the spokesman said. 'The medical care received by Lai Chee-ying in custody is adequate and comprehensive. The CSD supports persons in custody with medical services provided by the Department of Health and the Hospital Authority.' Professional medical staff provide the most suitable medical services to patients as soon as possible, and persons in custody are treated equally, the spokesman said, pointing out that the authorities concerned adopt the proper arrangements while handling matters related to Lai, which are no different from those applicable to other persons in custody. - China Daily/ANN
New Straits Times
03-08-2025
- New Straits Times
Court awards RM4.1mil to teen disabled at birth by delayed C-section
JOHOR BARU: A teenager who suffered severe brain damage at birth due to a delayed caesarean procedure was awarded RM4.1 million in damages by the High Court here, which found a doctor and the owner of a private maternity home liable for medical negligence. Judge Nurulhuda Nuraini Nor ruled that the 16-year-old boy, who now suffers permanent disability and is fully dependent on his mother, had been deprived of timely medical intervention after the doctor failed to perform an urgent C-section promptly. The boy was awarded RM600,000 in general damages and RM3.5 million for future rehabilitation care, while his mother received RM80,000 for emotional distress and anxiety. The court also ordered the doctor and the maternity home owner to pay RM100,000 in costs. In her written judgment, Nurulhuda held the doctor personally liable for breaching his duty of care to both mother and child, and found the owner vicariously liable for the negligence that occurred on their premises. The mother filed the lawsuit in 2020 on behalf of her son, who was born on Sept 28, 2009, at the privately run maternity clinic in Johor Baru. According to court documents, she had sought help at the centre around 10am, where the doctor advised a C-section due to the umbilical cord being wrapped around the baby's neck. However, the surgery was not performed until 7pm, -a delay the court found inexcusable. The newborn was sent to the Sultanah Aminah Hospital at 5.30am on Oct 1, 2009, after he displayed signs of lethargy, poor sucking reflex, and breathing difficulty. He was diagnosed with severe hypoglycaemia and infection. Later assessments confirmed he had suffered irreversible brain damage. Despite temporary discharge, the baby's condition deteriorated and he was eventually referred to the Kuala Lumpur Hospital, where a consultant child neurologist confirmed the extent of the injury. The defendants represented by counsel B Thinesh and Raja Eileen Soraya Raja Aman, have since filed an appeal against the decision.
