Are Dream Team bosses making a mistake selecting the most-popular goalkeeper in the game?
But it's our duty to highlight any discrepancies worthy of discussion as the Gameweek 1 deadline draws near and so we feel compelled to discuss Caoimhin Kelleher (£3m).
As it stands, the Republic or Ireland international is set to start the 2025/26 season as the most popular goalkeeper in Dream Team.
MOST POPULAR GOALKEEPERS IN DREAM TEAM AHEAD OF GAMEWEEK 1 (% OWNERSHIP)
11.6% Caoimhin Kelleher
9.7% Robert Sanchez
9.2% Matz Sels
9% David Raya
8.7% Alisson
Before we get cynical, let's be clear that Kelleher is a very fine keeper.
Last season, he performed superbly for Liverpool while Alisson was sidelined with injury for a sustained period from mid-October until Christmas.
Most notably, he saved two penalties in the space of four days against Southampton and Real Madrid to grab the headlines.
During this time, Kelleher was something of a Dream Team cheat code as he was a cheap starter for the best team in the country and gaffers who took advantage of this situation were rewarded with plentiful points.
In fact, his average of 5.3 points-per-game was among the highest in his position for 2024/25.
This summer, the 26-year-old has transferred from Liverpool to Brentford in a move that will make him No1 for the first time in his career.
Kelleher's historical record and the promise of increased minutes are the reasons he's a popular choice among Dream Team bosses, not to mention his affordable price.
However, at the risk of coming across all doom and gloom, there are some issues to be addressed.
5
Firstly, a simple truth must be stated: Brentford are not Liverpool.
Clean sheets are the primary currency for keepers in Dream Team but it generally takes a team effort to repel the opposition.
You could have Lev Yashin, Gigi Buffon and Manuel Neuer all between the sticks at once but if they aren't given suitable protection then it is inevitable they will concede goals.
Last season, Brentford conceded 57 league goals, 16 more than champions Liverpool.
But even that doesn't tell the full story of the disparity between Kelleher's old club and his new employers.
The Bees conceded a whopping 646 shots in total, only Southampton gave up more opportunities.
5
The xG stats are kinder to the West London outfit, suggesting that six teams defended worse, but Dream Team managers should realise that clean sheets will be much harder for Kelleher to come by at the Gtech.
His predecessor, Mark Flekken, made more saves (159) than any other Dream Team goalkeeper last season, another indication of Brentford's defensive vulnerabilities.
Of course, racking up lots of saves is another way to earn points - perhaps Kelleher's best avenue going forward - but it's difficult to make waves without clean sheets and let's not forget that conceding goals can lead to minus points.
Another big concern is that Brentford might find life harder in the top flight this campaign.
They have lost Thomas Frank, Christian Norgaard and Bryan Mbeumo, with Yoane Wissa also linked to other clubs.
5
Keith Andrews has been appointed head coach and has a huge task ahead of him.
Pre-season predictions are often foolish in hindsight but many pundits are envisaging a taxing season for the Bees.
We're not saying that Kelleher is a horrible selection but, given all the factors, it seems unusual that he's more popular than all his rivals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
7 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Arne Slot provides Virgil van Dijk and Alisson updates as Liverpool stars miss friendlies
Both Virgil van Dijk and Alisson were absent as Liverpool faced Athletic Bilbao twice at Anfield on Monday, six days before the Community Shield against Crystal Palace Liverpool manager Arne Slot expects both Virgil van Dijk and Alisson to be available for the Community Shield after the duo missed the Reds' final pre-season friendlies. Van Dijk and Alisson were absent as Liverpool hosted Athletic Bilbao for two back-to-back games at Anfield on Monday. Slot confirmed pre-match that captain Van Dijk was ill. As for Alisson, the goalkeeper had been forced to leave the Reds' pre-season tour of Asia early for 'private reasons' and didn't return for the Anfield double-header. Liverpool won 4-1 and 3-2 respectively and now their focus turns to the Community Shield against Crystal Palace on Sunday. While fellow absentees Joe Gomez and Conor Bradley might not feature at Wembley, Slot revealed that Van Dijk and Alisson should be on the teamsheet. Asked if the quartet were at risk of missing the clash with Palace, the Reds boss replied: "Virgil normally not. Joe Gomez and Conor Bradley, it's going to be tight. Alisson will be back in time as well." Alisson's wife, Natalia, has seemingly confirmed that the reason he returned home from the Far East was because she'd had an operation. "Post op pic portrait of a real life," Natalia posted on Instagram. "Now I'm recovering at home. Thank God, to the wonderful team that served me and all the love I received, everything is evolving well. Thanks to all who sent messages." In good news on the pitch, Slot was pleased with his team's two performances against their opponents from La Liga - even if they weren't as clinical as he'd have liked. "I think in both games we created a lot of chances, scored seven goals - four in the first, three in the second - so that's very pleasing to see because we definitely didn't score every chance we had," the Liverpool manager said post-match. Where will Liverpool finish this season? Give us your prediction in the comments section. "Especially in the second game in the first half, I think we could have scored a few goals more than we did. So that pleased me most, the ability to create the chances and even to score seven goals over two games is also good." After making the trip to Wembley for a chance to win the first trophy of the new season, Liverpool will host Bournemouth on Friday, August 15 to begin their Premier League title defence. Following that, the Reds play Newcastle away and Arsenal at home prior to the international break.
BBC News
7 minutes ago
- BBC News
Fan reaction to Scottish Premiership's opening weekend
"Brutal", a "miserable victory", and no need for Scottish Premiership returned this weekend and brought with it drama and intrigue across the Russell Martin's scathing post-match comments to Falkirk's return to the top flight after 15 years, there were more storylines than you could shake an empty pie ashet the season, BBC Scotland will be asking you for your views on the action through our live pages. Here is a selection of what you made of the opening weekend's action. 'Brutal' Rangers draw with 'positive' Motherwell Rangers fans were left frustrated after their side conceded late on and only drew with Same old Rangers, can't close a game Pathetic performance, not enough skill in the team to play Russell Martin's way. Too laboured on the ball - too slow in thought and action. After this display and the coach's words I am really worried for this season. Top-six Poor show. I was not inspired by the choice of manager nor have I been impressed by the new signings. I wouldn't be surprised if we finish fourth, never mind second. Lack of determination to A new season and a new manager with new players, but the same old performance. Nothing new that wasn't there last season, poor passing, poor kick outs, and, considering the amount of corners, only one goal. Shocking. The same old excuses that we have heard before many It's very early, but I would be surprised if this Rangers team put in a challenge for the league title. Very Motherwell supporters were delighted with what they We are going to be a joy to watch this season! A superb second half saw us snatch a well deserved point. If we play like that all season we could be a real problem for other Superb. We fell away in the first half but the second half was tremendous. Like watching a new team. Effort and refusing to lie down, a new Delighted with our approach and mentality. Bravery and a will to try. Still plenty aspects to improve, but if we play like that every week, we will win more than we An inspiring start! Can totally see what Jens Berthel Askou is trying to do. A few nervous moments initially but once they settled down it went well. Struggle to recall a better opening Incredible performance from Motherwell and so unlucky not to win in the dying moments! We are going to be very fun to watch this season. Bring on St This was positive. Motherwell put Rangers on the back foot, which is not usual in these games. St Mirren 'dropped three points' against 'lethargic' Celtic Celtic fans were left with mixed emotions despite Luke McCowan's late goal earning them three points over St Mirren at Yet another miserable 1-0 victory in the final minutes. Can't disguise the deficiencies in the Celtic team – and in Brendan Rodgers' tactics. Negative, robotic football that will again result in several heavy defeats in St Mirren worked hard at their game plan and nearly got a point. Credit to the players for remaining calm and getting the reward for the perseverance. Onwards now for the Good performances across the park but found it difficult against a St Mirren team which has performed so well and competitively in the League Cup. Kieran Tierney was great, but needs to work on his fitness. All the pieces are there, we just need to find a way of fitting them Not the best performance but a win is a win. Fair play to St Mirren, they defended well. We need more attacking options. Adam Idah and Yang Hyun-jun aren't good enough. Says it all that only two of our six signings kicked a I am unsure if Celtic are lethargic or arrogant? Trying to walk the ball in with no real conviction. Fair play to St Mirren for not allowing the game to be dictated to them Brendan Rodgers has created a lot of negativity with that press conference the other day. He's a top coach but his ego is off the scale. I want us to sign players but he paid over £20m for Idah and Arne Engels, that's outrageous. Engels is like a fish up a Mirren fans were heartened by their performance against the This was a game played by two very good sides. I thought St Mirren at times rode their luck but they certainly deserved a point. Their defending was excellent and a work ethic to give the supporters a great deal of hope in the weeks to come. It was despairing to lose by a late deflected Three points dropped by St Mirren… They really should be doing better against poor opponents like A disciplined performance, we rode our luck for sure. Thought we were going to hold on. The Celtic subs made all the difference, I wish James Forrest would retire! 'Professional' Hearts 'outhustle' Aberdeen Hearts opened their league account with a 2-0 win over Aberdeen and supporters are optimistic about the season ahead under Derek Thoroughly professional performance, looked strong in every department and have a physicality to dig in when required. McInnes has been flawless since his Always good to start a new season with a win, especially at home. Much more incisive and quicker to move the ball forward than last season. Expect us to do even better once the new squad settles The most hungry, aggressive and solid as I've seen Hearts in a Hearts looked more hungry than Aberdeen. Every player worked for each another and looked like there was togetherness about the team. We need a creative midfielder to complement the eager workers. If Bloom can conjure up the final piece of the jigsaw, we could have an exciting supporters weren't impressed by the display at First half was awful from the Dons. Could see the difference in quality and also competitiveness in the Hearts team. Second half got a bit better, but Kusini Yengi has to score his chance. Nicolas Milanovic looked decent and was the only I think it's going to be a long season as I don't believe we have enough striking options to win crucial games like last Aberdeen were outhustled from the start. Hearts wanted it more and we looked off the pace and the need for a goal scorer is even more evident now - hopefully Yengi can get on the goal trail soon as this wasn't his finest Badly need a proven striker. Splash the cash and bring Bojan Miovski back. Sivert Nilsen should be nowhere near the team - Ante Palaversa is far better. Topi Keskinen still poor - Shayden Morris should be starting. Falkirk fans upbeat, United will 'struggle' for top six Falkirk earned a point against Dundee United on their return to the top-flight and fans were pleased with the Excellent performance by newcomers against the fourth-placed side last season. A couple of defensive errors proved costly. This performance augurs well for the season Well done the Bairns. If we can sort defence, we will be All in all a great advert for Scottish football, but from our perspective I thought we were the better team. Now it's time to work on the point gained, a more clinical edge in front of goal and maybe we could've gone back home with three Point was a fair result. Disappointed in the two goals we conceded but we kept going and played some decent stuff in what was a good game of fans singled out midfielder Panutche Camara for praise after the 2-2 Dundee United will struggle for a top-six finish with that defence and goalkeeper. Panutche Camara was brilliant to watch. Best player on the Three games in and we are sitting with two wins in Europe and an away draw in the league opener. Hardly a crisis!Kenny: Much better. Camara had a great game and we were unlucky not to pick up all three points. A good shift from the whole team and a definite step up in attitude and application. Two great goals! 'Relegation fodder' Dundee and steady Hibs Hibernian bounced back from their aggregate defeat by Midtjylland to beat Dundee Travelled to Dundee with my son, hoping that Hibs could start the league season strongly after the disappointment of Thursday. Great to see Hibs hit the ground running and could easily have scored four or five against a poor Dundee. Hopefully we can push on and get points on the board early. Very happy with the direction the club is Good win considering we went to extra-time on Thursday Don't need fireworks on day one, just three points. Dundee fans are fearful for the season ahead after another defeat under head coach Steven On the basis of the three Dundee games that I've watched, including today's, there is no doubt in my mind that we are already relegation fodder. We look weak all over the park, there is no fight in the team when Murray isn't playing, and we seem to be content playing for low-scoring defeats. This season has disaster written all over Hibs won in second gear. Pressley is deluded in his post-match comments. Nelms at the helm is destroying Dundee. As a so-called US "businessman", I would expect elements of success and improvement. Instead, we are rock bottom with the worst ground in the league. We deserve Dundee are awful. Relegated by February. No creativity at all. Couldn't even get the substitutes on I have supported Dundee for over 55 years and I can honestly say this is the worst set I have ever seen at this club and the future certainly doesn't look rosy. Time machine Killie, Livi 'should have won' Kilmarnock fans were left frustrated after their side let a two-goal lead slip against Livingston following George Stanger's red It was like going back in time to last season, come on Killie get it sorted out before it becomes normal to throw away points. It stops now, no more A good first half performance, but a disappointing second half. The red card and penalty made a big difference, however, Killie were on the back foot most of the second half. There are some positives, but the overarching feeling is that we still have work to do, and we need more cover defensively!James: Very disappointed to only draw the game. For all their possession Livi didn't create many chances. The game turns on the penalty. A very frustrating result but we did well in the first half and scored two good goals. I feel we need to beef up the central defence and New season, new manager, some new players in, yet once again it's the same as last season on too many occasions, another red the other hand, Livi supporters took positives from the We will surprise some people. A lot of fans of other sides have us finishing 12th. I think, or is it really hope, that we will get a top-six finish. That may very well be sixth, but I would love to see a top-five finish and a chance for Robbie Muirhead will be key for us this season up top but so will Jerome Prior at the other other end of the pitch along with Danny Wilson and Ryan McGowan but for me Graham Carey will be our surprise package this season, he's very A game Livi should have won, but Killie managed to score two quick goals.
Metro
10 minutes ago
- Metro
Arsenal scare off Porto with Jakub Kiwior transfer fee demand
Arsenal 'scared off' Porto by demanding a €30 million (£26m) transfer fee for Jakub Kiwior, according to reports in Portugal. Mikel Arteta's side signed the Poland international from Spezia in a deal worth £20m in January 2023. Kiwior started just 10 games in the Premier League last season and has struggled to secure regular playing time ahead of Arsenal's solid centre-back pairing of William Saliba and Gabriel Magalhaes. The 25-year-old has been linked with a move away this summer although Arteta is keen to keep the defender at Arsenal. A Bola reports that Porto made an approach to sign Kiwior earlier this summer but the Portuguese 'lost all hope' when Arsenal responded by asking for a €30m (£26m) fee. In The Mixer: Exclusive analysis, FPL tips and transfer talk sent straight to your inbox every week – click here and sign up before Friday to make sure you don't miss the first edition. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Porto did not follow up their interest in Kiwior and instead opted to sign Jan Bednarek in a €7.5m (£6.5m) deal from Southampton. More Trending Speaking in May, Arteta praised Kiwior for his performances while Gabriel was sidelined due to a hamstring injury. 'He deserves a lot of credit because he hasn't played too much throughout many months, and suddenly he's been thrown into the most difficult context, at the highest level, playing against the best opponents, when you haven't had the physical rhythm or the confidence to do it, and I think he's been exceptional,' Arteta said. Kiwior is in line to start alongside Saliba for Arsenal's Premier League opener against Manchester United on August 17 as Gabriel is yet to feature during the club's pre-season campaign this summer. MORE: Arsenal's Max Dowman sends two-word message to Liverpool wonderkid Rio Ngumoha MORE: Man Utd respond to offer to sign £66m former Arsenal and Chelsea transfer target MORE: Arne Slot provides Virgil van Dijk and Alisson Becker updates after missing Liverpool friendlies
