Department for Education stifling efforts to boost skills, warns Andy Burnham
The mayor of Greater Manchester told MPs his counterparts in other parts of the country share his view that local efforts to improve technical education and boost the workforce are being stifled by the department, which he said is 'wasting time' over a crucial way to boost economic growth.
During an appearance before the Commons Business and Trade Committee, Mr Burnham was asked what had been his 'biggest frustrations' during his term as mayor.
He said the 'evidence is clear' that the current model of devolution in Greater Manchester is the right one and delivers economic growth.
But Mr Burnham added: 'The frustration, to answer your question: the biggest is the Department for Education, without a shadow of doubt.
'Why are we remaking the case for devolution to this department now? I've been doing it for eight years.
'It stands to reason that you can create stronger technical education pathways when you can work with actual employers in your city region who will be employing the young people, or the older workers, who will come through.
'We are the only ones who can create that pathway. We are the only ones that could commission our colleges for the actual sectoral strengths of our economy, and yet it still seems that is resisted.
'I think the kind of position of the Department for Education on this issue risks becoming an anti-growth policy. It risk pulling back the growth that we've got.'
Greater Manchester Combined Authority, currently has full control of an apprenticeships and adult skills budget, but is yet to secure devolution of 16-19 education spending.
Mr Burnham has created the 'Greater Manchester Baccalaureate', which he describes as an 'equal alternative to the university route', but he was clearly frustrated at perceived resistance to his plans in Whitehall.
The latest official figures show that 11.2% of young people in the North West of England are not in education, employment or training.
Mr Burnham added: 'We know our employers. I'm convening our employers to get those work placements, to really create those extra pathways for our young people, and to fell now that we are still having to argue for that and get permission to do that just seems to me to be wasting time.'
Greater Manchester Combined Authority has created an online portal called Beeline, which enables users to search for training and educational routes to certain jobs in the region.
Mr Burnham said the portal currently shows about 450 vacancies for software developers.
He added it would not be a surprise if the high level of young people missing out on job opportunities continues if a 'top-down' approach without local flexibilities continues.
Mr Burnham conceded that the department had 'moved a bit… down the path with us' and he welcomed the potential of Skills England, which will work with combined authorities, businesses and training providers to boost jobs when it is launched this year.
'But I just want to leave the committee in no doubt, the reason there's urgency in my voice is we're growing fast, but we could quickly have a vacancy problem that turns investors away. That is why it is mission-critical for this Government,' he added.
The Department for Education has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
8 hours ago
- The Guardian
Ministers aim to export London's academic success to England's struggling schools
Ministers plan to turbocharge their school improvement programme to tackle regional inequalities, aiming to export the success of London's high-achieving pupils to England's most struggling schools. Bridget Phillipson, the education secretary, said her school improvement plan was 'taking the best' of the previous Labour government's successful London Challenge, which revolutionised the city's school system, and applying the techniques to flagging schools throughout England. This week's A-level results raised alarm at the widening gap between results in London and regions outside the south-east of England, particularly in the Midlands and the north-east, where improvements in top grades have been stagnant. The Department for Education is to double the number of schools being supported by its regional improvement for standards and excellence (Rise) programme, which identifies 'stuck schools' with repeated poor inspection reports, and aim to transform them through expert assistance from experienced school leaders and partnerships, as well as up to £200,000 over two years in extra funding. Phillipson said: 'This week's exam results were a time for celebration, but they also laid bare the yawning attainment gaps at A-level that continue to cast a shadow over so many areas of the country. 'It's appalling that young people across the north-east, the East Midlands and West Midlands continue to be held back compared to their peers in London. 'That's why, as part of our plan for change, we are putting a laser focus on those areas of the country, and those schools where performance is weakest, with our new school improvement teams – taking the best of the renowned London Challenge and applying it to areas like the north-east, to make sure that every single child, wherever they grow up, has the life chances they deserve.' The rollout of the Rise programme is backed by the former education secretary David Blunkett and Sir Kevan Collins, the government's school improvement tsar, who were involved in the London Challenge after it was launched in 2003. Lord Blunkett applauded the early intervention in schools through the Rise teams, saying the policy would 'narrow the gap and create a more equal start in life, so crucial to releasing the talent, creativity and self-reliance of young people'. In London, the government used data to identify schools with the most glaring problems, and then worked with local authorities to overhaul each school's leadership and culture, while also working with parents and wider communities to tackle specific issues in boroughs such as Tower Hamlets, where Collins was a senior leader. By 2010, London had a higher proportion of schools rated as good or outstanding by Ofsted than any other area of England. The initial phase of Rise began earlier this year, after 600 schools were identified as urgently needing support. More than 200 were matched with advisers and partners, and must create an approved plan for transformation before receiving up to £200,000 in extra funding spread over two years. The DfE said a further 200 schools would be added 'very quickly' in the autumn, when the new school year commences, as a sign of the government's recognition of the urgency. Collins said: 'The emphasis [of Rise] is all about pace, because the one thing about schools that start to decline, the slide becomes embedded. They can't recruit great staff, people start leaving, attitudes become habitual. You need to be radical to turn that around, and the longer you leave it, the harder it is. This is what is so shameful about these schools being left like this for so long.' He added: 'One of the things about the London Challenge was that it was very high-profile and with a sense of endeavour – everyone was leaning into it, it had massive national leadership. There was a big effort, a clear effort, and that is what we are trying to replicate with Rise.' Jon Coles, the director of the London Challenge when it launched under the leadership of Tim Brighouse, and who is now the chief executive of the United Learning academy trust, said: 'The history of the London Challenge shows that you can make a big difference, that these things are not inevitable. 'Twenty years ago, inner London performed less well than every region in the country. And now the only place that outperforms inner London is outer London. 'So things can change. But it requires people to decide they are going to work together, have a great strategy, take tough decisions, collaborate beyond boundaries, in order to make things better for children.' Thursday's A-level results showed the gap between the best- and worst-performing regions widened again this year, with 32% of entries in London gaining the top A* or A grades, compared with fewer than 23% in north-east England. Young people in the north-east of England are also less likely to take A-levels than their peers in London and the south-east. Research published by the DfE in July showed that more than half of children in inner London eligible for free school meals at the age of 15 went on to higher education by the age of 19, compared with 22% in the north-east and the east Midlands.
The Herald Scotland
15 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Builder wins ‘significant' slice of £980m homes contract
Hamilton-based Procast Group has been awarded Lot 13 on the Greater Manchester Combined Authority Net Zero Housing Retrofit Framework Agreement. The contract is for a national framework, covering all nine regions of England, not just Greater Manchester. However, it is geared towards supporting Greater Manchester's Net Zero target of 2038 – 12 years ahead of the overall UK Government target. The work will see Procast Group carry out an end-to-end solution from surveying to handover, with significant opportunities across England's housing stock and access to various government grant funding schemes. Procast Group - who are leading innovators in the retrofit and renewables sector - will also provide expertise in project management, customer support, and quality assurance. The framework is available to all public sector, housing associations, and third sector organisations. Derek Innes, owner and managing director of Procast Group, said: 'We are delighted to have been awarded this lot, which we feel really positions Procast as national player in the retrofit market. 'We are pleased to be playing our part in supporting UK Government's net zero targets, alongside trying to tackle fuel poverty nationwide. 'This award demonstrates our capability to deliver complex, compliance-driven projects and provides a significant growth opportunity in the expanding retrofit sector.' Procast Group, which currently employs more than 130 staff, is a market leader in retrofitting work and innovative multi-trade contracting projects across Scotland and the North of England. The group also operates bases in Aberdeen, Dumfries and Forfar. Nick Nairn: 'Hospitality industry has been hung out to dry' Nick Nairn has spoken of fears that Scotland's hospitality industry has been "hung out to dry" amid increasingly challenging conditions. Following the closure of Nairn's in Bridge of Allan last year, the celebrity chef has shifted his focus back towards the Port of Menteith cook school, restaurant, and lifestyle store, which he operates in partnership with his wife, Julia. It has been a successful summer for the duo as they build on a venture that "ticks every box" for their shared creative passions and celebrate 25 years since the first series of Cook School demonstrations took place. Despite this, Nairn remains vocal regarding the unrelenting pressures on hospitality businesses across Scotland and warns of the impact this could have on a nationwide scale. AROUND THE GREENS ⛳ Owner gets into business for the love of the game This article appears as part of Kristy Dorsey's Around the Greens series The popularity of golf simulators has surged in recent years, transforming the way many people experience the game and how new players come into the sport.
Telegraph
20 hours ago
- Telegraph
Top A-level grades are worth £15,000 a year
Achieving top grades at A-level could add £15,000 to a graduate's earning potential, new figures have shown. Those who clinched 360 points in their exams – equivalent to three top grades – earned £44,200 on average five years after graduating university, according to data from the 2022-23 tax year. Pupils who got fewer than 180 points (or three Ds) earned £29,200, meaning the high achieving students were paid 50pc more. In cash terms, this intellectual premium has never been higher, according to the latest outcomes data from the Department for Education. It comes as a record 28.3pc of all A-levels were marked A or A* in the 2025 exam session. Students who failed to achieve more than three Ds found themselves barely earning more than the £26,000 median income for non-graduates in their twenties at the time. Those who completed a BTEC qualification instead of A-levels, typically costing between £2,000 and £8,000 for a two-year course, were found to be earning an average of £27,000 when assessed at the same point. With university entrants this autumn forced to stomach yet another tuition fee rise, with the cap rising 3.1pc to £9,535 a year, non-academic avenues may yield a better financial payoff. While the academically gifted may simply tend to target subjects or careers with higher earnings potential, and may rise through their employers' ranks faster, the real difference is most likely the universities to which their impressive scorecards give them access. The graduate earnings spread between institutions offering the same subject can be enormous – averaging just under £30,000 across all 35 broad subject areas. Nowhere is the difference between the best- and worst-paid alumni greater than for business and management students. University of Oxford graduates in the field were found to be on the cusp of six-figures after just five years, earning £93,800. Their counterparts from Wrexham University (called Glyndŵr University at the time), meanwhile, were making £23,700 – just under four times less. While the academic requirements to the former's economics and management degree are a stiff A*AA (including a top grade in maths), you can be considered for the Welsh establishment's business and management course with three Cs. The same data shows those having achieved 360 points in their A-levels are far more likely to go after masters degrees or PhDs. Of the smartest in the class, 16pc were still studying five years after graduation, compared to 9pc for those who took home fewer than 180 points. Low-scoring graduates were also more often out of work or education, at 6.4pc compared to 4.3pc for high achievers. Tom Allingham, from money advice website Save the Student, said: 'This confirms what I'm sure many people already believed – that those who achieve higher grades will likely go on to earn higher salaries. 'That said, there is more to this than initially meets the eye. While those who achieved three or four A/A* grades have a notable earnings premium over their peers, the difference between all other groups is fairly small – albeit still with a positive correlation. 'In other words, when it comes to your future salary, the difference between, for example, a B and a C at A-levels may not be all that significant.' Rose Stephenson, Director of Policy and Advocacy at the Higher Education Policy Institute, said: 'The gap in earnings between graduates with high and low A-level results has never been greater – it is now the widest gap on record. 'While university is a great investment for many, these figures are a stark reminder that effort at school and college continues to pay dividends long after leaving the classroom. 'The imperative remains to tackle entrenched inequalities described by the Secretary of State for Education today. It should be your intellect alone that determines your grade results, not your background or wealth. 'These figures show the stark impact achieving lower grades can have on earning potential, and the cycle of disadvantage that can be perpetuated as a result.'
