Israel and Gaza: Is It Genocide?
Re 'I'm a Scholar of Genocide. I Know It When I See It,' by Omer Bartov (Opinion guest essay, July 20):
The charge of genocide against Israel is a deeply serious one — and, in my view, a misapplication of the term. Genocide, by definition, requires intent to destroy an ethnic or national group. Israel's stated and demonstrated intent is to dismantle Hamas, a terrorist organization that murdered about 1,200 people on Oct. 7, 2023, and continues to use civilians as shields.
Civilian casualties in Gaza are heartbreaking, and Israel must be held accountable for its conduct. But equating this war — however devastating — with genocide oversimplifies a tragic, complex conflict. Israel has issued warnings, created evacuation routes and urged civilians to flee. These are not the actions of a genocidal regime.
We can and must mourn innocent lives, advocate humanitarian aid and pursue peace. But we should also resist using terms that inflame rather than clarify. The world needs solutions rooted in truth, not accusations that blur moral and legal lines.
Seth EisenbergFort Lauderdale, Fla.
To the Editor:
I applaud Omer Bartov for having the courage to write his guest essay, making the case that what we are witnessing in Gaza is indeed genocide. While not an academic, I came to the same conclusion as Dr. Bartov but have been apprehensive about expressing my views publicly.
Having served with the United Nations in Cambodia, the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, I have seen ethnic cleansing and genocide firsthand on three continents. While the locales and situations are different, the hallmarks of these horrific acts are all the same. And what we are seeing in Gaza looks shockingly familiar to those who study this dark corner of history or who have witnessed it.
Like Dr. Bartov, based on my experience in United Nations peacekeeping missions around the world, I know genocide when I see it.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Mike Johnson says Ghislaine Maxwell pardon would give him ‘pause,' won't get ahead of Trump
House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-Louisiana, said he believes Ghislaine Maxwell, a key associate of Jeffrey Epstein currently serving 20 years in prison for conspiring to sexually abuse minors, should face "a life sentence." "If you're asking my opinion, I think 20 years was a pittance," Johnson told NBC's Kristen Welker on "Meet the Press" July 27. "I think she should have a life sentence, at least." His remarks to NBC come as many, including supporters of President Donald Trump, clamor for testimony from Maxwell. Some followers of the case have proposed a pardon in exchange, but Trump told reporters on July 25 he hadn't considered the move. "I'm allowed to do it, but it's something I have not thought about," the president said. Epstein was charged with sexually trafficking minors and died by suicide while in detention in 2019. Maxwell, his longtime girlfriend, has been accused of recruiting minors for the disgraced financier's predation. Maxwell maintains her innocence and is appealing her 2021 sex-trafficking conviction. Johnson in his interview with NBC reiterated that pardons aren't up to him, telling the outlet, "obviously that's a decision of the president." "I won't get in front of him," Johnson said. "That's not my lane." But, later in the interview he noted, "It's hard to put into words how evil this was, and that she orchestrated it and was a big part of it." "So, again, not my decision," he added, "but I have great pause about that, as any reasonable person would." The Trump administration for weeks has faced backlash over its handling of Epstein's case. Critics from Democratic lawmakers to prominent Republicans and slices of Trump's voter base accuse the president and other officials of not being transparent with the American people. The speaker has faced his own ongoing Epstein-related criticism, as some House Republicans have zeroed in on the Justice Department's recent review of Epstein's case and are calling for related documents to be released publicly. Democrats in Congress have piled on too. Reps. Ro Khanna, D-California, and Thomas Massie, R-Kentucky, introduced a bipartisan measure to force the Trump administration's hand in releasing the federal government's files. Also on "Meet The Press," the pair split on pardoning Maxwell. "That would be up to the president," Massie said. "But if she has information that could help us, then I think she should testify. Let's get that out there. And whatever they need to do to compel that testimony, as long as it's truthful, I would be in favor of." Khanna disagreed, saying Maxwell shouldn't receive a pardon. "Look, I agree with Congressman Massie that she should testify," the California Democrat said. "But she's been indicted twice on perjury. This is why we need the files. This is why we need independent evidence." Contributing: Bart Jansen and Aysha Bagchi, USA TODAY This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Mike Johnson reacts to possible pardon for Ghislaine Maxwell
The Hill
15 minutes ago
- The Hill
Trump insists Hamas is stealing food amid Gaza hunger crisis
President Trump on Sunday said Hamas is stealing food that was meant for people in Gaza, telling reporters multiple times that goods are being stolen when pressed on the hunger crisis in the region. The president, while sitting next to President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen in Turnberry, Scotland, was asked for his response to the images of starving children in Gaza. 'When I see the children and when I see, especially over the last couple of weeks people are stealing the food, they're stealing the money, they're stealing the money for the food. They're stealing weapons, they're stealing everything,' the president said. He added, 'It's a mess, that whole place is a mess. The Gaza strip, you know it was given many years ago so they could have peace. That didn't work out too well.' The Israeli military has reported that there is no proof that the Palestinian militant group had systematically stolen aid. Earlier on Sunday, Israel's military said it will start a 'tactical pause' in fighting in Gaza amid mass starvation concerns. Trump said he spoke recently with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, adding, 'I talked to him about a lot of things. I talked to him about Iran.' He said the U.S. would send more aid into Gaza and pressed other nations to contribute as well, suggesting that would be part of his conversation with der Leyen. And, he reiterated the claims about Hamas stealing food. 'It's not a U.S. problem, it's an international problem,' Trump said on Gaza. 'If we weren't there. I think people would have starved, frankly. They would have starved, and it's not like they're eating well, but a lot of that food is getting stolen by Hamas. They're stealing the food, they're stealing a lot of things. You ship it in and they steal it, then they sell it,' he said. House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) also insisted that Hamas has stolen the food on NBC's 'Meet the Press' on Sunday and noted that Yechiel Leiter, Israel's ambassador to the U.S., and other Israeli officials told him that Hamas has stolen 'a huge amount' of food since the start of the conflict on Oct. 7, 2023. Trump on Sunday said that the U.S. gave $60 million in aid for Gaza two weeks ago, but said that 'nobody even acknowledged it.' 'Nobody acknowledged it, nobody talks about it, and it makes you feel a little bad when you do that, and no other countries give anything,' he said. He said that Israel has to decide what happens next in the Israel-Hamas conflict in Gaza. 'What's going to happen? I don't know,' Trump said. 'Israel's going to have to make a decision. I know what I'd do but I don't think it's appropriate that I say.' The Trump administration last week said it was leaving Gaza ceasefire talks, blaming Hamas for failing to engage in good faith. Steve Witkoff, Trump's special envoy for peace missions, said the administration is considering alternative plans to secure the freedom of Israeli hostages held by Hamas and the future governance of the territory.
New York Post
15 minutes ago
- New York Post
Trump says ‘Israel is gonna have to make a decision' on Gaza — as he vows more aid
President Trump said that Israel is going to have to 'decide what to do' with the Gaza Strip now that ceasefire talks have collapsed and vowed to send more US aid to Palestinians in the war-torn enclave. 'When you get it down to a certain number, you're going to be able to make a deal with Hamas because once they give them up, then they feel that that's going to be the end of them,' Trump said, referring to hostage negotiations. 'They [Hamas] don't want to give [the hostages] back, and so Israel is going to have to make a decision.' Trump said Israel had to 'decide what to do' with Gaza after cease-fire talks collapsed once again. AFP via Getty Images He added: 'I know what I do, but I don't think it's appropriate that I say But Israel is going to make a decision.' Speaking to reporters ahead of his talks with European Union Commission President Ursula von der Leyen during his trip to the United Kingdom, Trump also complained that the US doesn't get credit for sending aid to the Gazans. 'If we weren't there. I think people would have starved frankly,' Trump said. They would have starved and it's not like they're eating well.' President Trump vowed to send more humanitarian aid to Gaza. AFP via Getty Images 'We sent $60 million 2 weeks for food, to Gaza,' Trump bemoaned at another point. 'And nobody acknowledged it, nobody talks about it. It makes you feel a little bad when you do that, and you have other countries not giving anything.' Trump claimed that he had backlash from some of his supporters but stressed he decided to send aid to Gaza anyway because there is 'a humanitarian reason for doing it.' 'Will I do more aid, yeah,' Trump replied when asked about sending additional resources to the beleaguered Gaza Strip. 'The US is going to do more aid for Gaza but we would like to have other countries participate.' The president did not specify how much more aid the US intends to send.
