AI shifts from adviser to architect in enterprise decision-making
The research, titled "Winning with Intelligent Choice Architectures," examines the role of intelligent choice architectures (ICAs) - dynamic AI systems that collaborate closely with humans - to shape, refine, and optimise decision-making environments across six sectors: retail, manufacturing, banking and finance, life sciences, energy, and communications. The report highlights the strategies of companies such as Walmart, Mastercard, Meta, and Pernod Ricard as they adopt these advanced AI capabilities.
AI's evolving role
The core finding of the study is that the value of AI within organisations is shifting away from simply improving existing business processes to elevating the quality of available options, thereby enabling better, faster, and more accountable decisions. This change is particularly evident in large enterprises looking to differentiate themselves in complex, highly competitive markets. ICAs flip the script. They do not just learn from decisions - they learn how to improve the environment in which decisions are made. That's not analytics, that's architecture.
The research was conducted jointly over a year by academic and industry experts, drawing on experiences from a diverse range of global businesses. Michael Schrage, Research Fellow at MIT Sloan's Initiative on the Digital Economy and one of the coauthors of the report, emphasised the significance of this shift in approach.
Sector insights
In the retail sector, AI helps address challenges in staff turnover, customer personalisation, and supply chain logistics. Pernod Ricard, for instance, applies ICAs to test and personalise campaign content early in the development process, expediting refinement and adaptation. Similarly, Walmart's HR department leverages an ICA to pinpoint local store talent, widening the pool for internal development.
Hybrid decision-making supported by AI is also being implemented in manufacturing, improving product design and supply chain management. Cummins, for example, is exploring generative AI to simulate extreme scenarios in powertrain design, aimed at bolstering resilience and reducing time-to-market.
In the banking, financial services, and insurance sector, ICAs tackle areas such as risk management, regulatory compliance, personalised service, fraud prevention, and adaptation to market changes. Mastercard is integrating ICAs across departments to harness insights from onboarding, customer care, and sales, in order to improve operational efficiency. LibertyGPT, an AI tool at Liberty Mutual, reportedly saved employees more than 200,000 hours in 2024 by quickly answering queries and summarising large volumes of information.
Communications and technology companies are using ICAs to identify and act on valuable business opportunities. BT, the British telecommunications company, has developed Aimee, an AI assistant involved in 60,000 customer interactions each week, autonomously resolving around half of all product and billing enquiries while supporting advisers with the rest. Meta applies ICA frameworks to enable internal teams to make more informed product decisions, experiment with business models, and fine-tune user engagement strategies.
The healthcare sector is also experiencing transformation through ICAs, especially in areas like drug discovery and patient care. The study found that using ICAs with scientific teams can prioritise promising drug candidates, potentially reducing drug discovery times by up to 30% and associated costs by as much as 40%.
Defining accountability
Companies implementing ICAs report outcomes that are not only more efficient but also more transparent and accountable. The design of decision environments - where rights are allocated and options presented - is central to the increased effectiveness of both human and machine collaboration.
Ashok Krish, Head of AI Practise at TCS, outlined the impact of this new paradigm. "By augmenting human judgment with machine intelligence, ICAs shift AI from task automation to building superior decision environments for complex multi-factorial situations, enabling more trackable, traceable outcomes that ensure accountability. They help align talent development strategies with organisational goals, making it easier to identify and nurture high-potential employees in the AI-era. Ultimately, ICAs foster environments where human judgment and AI work together seamlessly to create connected organisation intelligence, where smarter and more informed decisions are made."
David Kiron, Editorial Director at MIT Sloan Management Review, stressed the collaborative nature of these advances. "This isn't AI as co-pilot. This is AI and humans working together as architects to redesign how people perceive, weigh, and act on choices."
The study also examines the importance of transparency in decision-making structures. Sankaranarayanan Viswanathan, Vice President and Head of Business Innovation Corporate Technology Office at TCS, stated, "The real challenge for enterprises isn't just making better decisions - it is recognising that decisions are merely the outcome of the choices they privilege or overlook. What we need are systems that foster intelligent choice architectures - enabling the organisation to see, understand, and act with awareness. Accountable AI demands clarity not only in outcomes, but in the choices considered, the priorities weighed, and the trade-offs accepted. Without this, intelligent systems will silently assume decision-making authority - often without oversight or recourse."
Broader implications
The joint research by TCS and MIT Sloan Management Review continues a longstanding relationship focused on understanding how enterprises can integrate and leverage new digital technologies effectively. The report provides sector-specific examples illustrating how organisations across diverse industries are configuring ICAs to optimise workflows, reassign decision rights, and enhance overall business performance.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Air New Zealand inks direct partnership with ChatGPT maker OpenAI, pair create virtual customers
As well as being OpenAI CFO, Friar is a long-time member of the board of Walmart. Before returning home to run Air New Zealand, Foran was in charge of the giant retailer's US operation. There have been several meetings between senior Air New Zealand and Open AI senior leaders over the past year 'and they saw that Air New Zealand could well be the petri dish for innovation in the critical infrastructure and aviation game', Ravishankar said. The airline's use of OpenAI's generative artificial intelligence (AI) has run from the mainstream – summarising complicated documents – to creating the aforementioned virtual focus group. OpenAI's Sarah Friar overlapped with Air NZ CEO Greg Foran at Walmart. Photo / Getty Images 'Our customer service teams have created customer personas by feeding them all the feedback and complaints we've got – to test service improvements before we introduce them to a focus group,' Ravishankar said. Ideas could be 'pre-tested' on and honed on the virtual personas, which were based on hundreds of thousands of pieces of customer comments, helping to fine-tune ideas from a much broader pool of perspectives, before putting them before a human focus group. 'AI allows you to do complex, integrated planning much more seamlessly,' Ravishankar said. 'We're starting to look at how we use AI to optimise our loyalty tier benefits, for example, and how we can optimise turnaround to improve on-time performance management.' What about customer-facing AI? Air New Zealand was an early adopter of Soul Machines' avatar technology, before the Kiwi firm flamed out, but switched from the homegrown solution to its inhouse-developed chatbot 'Oscar'. Is Oscar about to get an an AI makeover? 'As are a lot of organisations, we're doing a ton of work on whether generative AI is ready for prime time; ready to directly interface with customers to provide an, if you will, chatbot on steroids. We're doing a lot of testing, but we're just not fully satisfied it's there yet,' Ravishankar said. 'But it's maturing at a rate of knots. I'm a technologist by trade, and I've never seen anything move as quickly.' Behind the scenes, staff are using AI to help deliver more personalised service to customers, he said. All up, the airline is using 1500 CustomGPTs to introduce efficiencies to internal workflows. CustomGPTs are set to specific tasks and can be ring-fenced to access a company's own data – addressing the dangers of an AI hallucinating or breaching privacy or commercial confidentiality. How do you market to an AI concierge? OpenAI recently released a ChatGPT 'agent' that can carry out autonomous tasks, such as booking travel (or 'looking' at a photo of a meal you like on Instagram, then ordering the ingredients for you from an online supermarket). The initial release was restricted to those on US$200 ($330) per month pro plans, but it's being rolled out this month to those on cheaper Plus plans too. So far, many early testers have found the ChatGPT agent slow and clumsy, in part because human approval is needed at various steps – including credit card purchases – so you can't walk away from your device. 'Uncharted territory' But while the ChatGPT agent might be a while off for OpenAI's free tier, pundits see 'agentic AI' as the next big thing – and it's already starting to figure in the airline's thinking. 'We're starting to wonder what the role of a brand is when ... a customer's own concierge [AI] agent is deciding which product to put in front of the customer,' Ravishankar said. 'That's uncharted territory ... if anyone tells us they know exactly how that's going to play out, they're making it up. 'But we're paying close attention to it, and then we're seeing multiple models emerge. 'It could be we provide an Air New Zealand concierge, or our concierge interacts with a customer's own concierge. Or we just make our environment open to customers' own agents, being able to interact with us. 'It's too soon to say what pattern emerges. If I was a betting man, I'd say we'll probably see multiple models.' Direct collaboration As part of the collaboration, Air New Zealand will gain early access to OpenAI technologies to develop and apply use cases, and equip its people across corporate roles with secure, enterprise-grade AI tools, Ravishankar said. 'By working directly with OpenAI, we not only access leading-edge technology but we also shape how it's used in the real world.' 'Air New Zealand is taking meaningful steps to bring AI across key parts of its business using OpenAI's technology. We have been particularly impressed with how quickly they have built over 1500 CustomGPTs to introduce efficiencies to internal workflows,' OpenAI international managing director Oliver Jay said. 'Their focus on innovation and responsibility shows how the aviation sector can adopt advanced tools in practical ways that deliver value for both employees and customers.' POSTSCRIPT: Captain's chair? Foran resigned as CEO in May. He will depart the airline in October. The Australian recently reported that Ravishankar has the inside running to replace him. The Herald asked Ravishankar if he wanted to take the opportunity to rule himself in or out. 'That is definitely above my pay grade, and you probably want to speak to the board about that,' he replied. There was no immediate response from the board. Boards typically don't comment on potential candidates prior to an executive appointment. Chris Keall is an Auckland-based member of the Herald's business team. He joined the Herald in 2018 and is the technology editor and a senior business writer.
Otago Daily Times
6 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Credit card fee changes highlight unfair costs
New Zealanders continue to be ripped off by credit and debit card surcharges. The issue was noted in passing when Civis complained a fortnight ago about misleading price advertising. It's time this week for Civis to get to grips with the gripe about surcharges. Civis' indignation was spurred after being charged the equivalent of 3.94% for an online credit card fee. While the actual extra amount for the shuttle bus was only a little more than $2, unjustified charges can soon add up to hundreds of dollars a year. Reacting becomes a matter of principle. Businesses are making money not on goods or services provided, but via bonus income from their charging methods. That's not right. Many businesses ignored commission "guidance" after high bank "interchange" fees were capped in 2022. Businesses were being charged up to 2.25% on credit cards and up to 1.5% on online debit card transactions. These were slashed to 0.8% and 0.6% respectively. The fee for contactless debit cards remains capped at 0.2%. On Thursday, the commission cut the fees again on the dominant Visa and Mastercard credit card networks, from 0.8% to 0.3% for in-person transactions, and to 0.7% for online. Debit card fees didn't change. The interchange fee makes up about 60% of what businesses pay as merchant fees. Although the earlier caps should have saved consumers about $140million, the commission estimates businesses failed to pass on $45m to $60m in savings. The cuts announced this week should reduce business costs by another $90m. It's reasonable that sellers then pass on fees to customers if they choose. Although individual costs are small, they can quickly accumulate for businesses as well. Because eftpos doesn't attract direct costs, customers using that method need not, in effect, subsidise those paying with credit cards, contactless debit cards or Apple or Google Pay. Many businesses, including supermarkets, absorb the costs. It's often cost-effective and more convenient to accept electronic payments than cash. Customers must be informed of any surcharge before payment and be made aware of cheaper ways to pay, where available. This requirement is sometimes breached. "We expect sellers to offer at least one payment method that does not incur a surcharge," the commission's website also says. The shuttle bus company had an alternative, though less convenient, way of paying directly. Even that option carried a small fee. "We would expect any surcharges to be no more than 0.7% for contactless debit card payments or 1.5%-2% for credit card payments," the commission says. "Many merchants only have one rate, so we consider any surcharge above 2% is hard to justify." Thanks to Thursday's decision, one would expect that 1.5% to 2% to come down further. The commission said operating costs like staff, electricity and point-of-sale were general expenses and shouldn't be included in a surcharge. They were required regardless of the payment type. Because the commission's "expect" and "should not" guidance is so often ignored, it's time for compulsion. On Thursday, the commission itself said regulation might be needed and that it would be monitoring the situation. The banks and credit card companies were brought into line on interchange fees. Retailers must be, too. The commission received 571 inquiries about surcharging in the past 18 months. It said concerns were managed case by case. High interchange fees were an easy way for banks and credit card companies to make money, and they competed for customers through reward schemes. Many have been reviewed because excess profits were cut. Expect more to be ditched. ASB advises merchants how to calculate a fair surcharge. It also notes: "Some payment methods do not incur costs, such as eftpos or debit cards that are accepted via insert or swipe, and so payment with these methods should not have a surcharge applied." Amen to that. civis@
1News
18-07-2025
- 1News
Commerce Commission moves to lower debit and credit card surcharges
The Commerce Commission has moved to lower interchange fees paid by businesses to accept Visa and Mastercard payments. The regulator has issued a final decision, saying the cost was too high, and their decision would save businesses around $90 million a year. It said the average business would save around $500 each year in lower fees, but individual businesses could save more or less, depending on the mix of transactions they accept. The Commission put the overall cost of interchange fees at around $1 billion for businesses, which were often passed onto customers through surcharges and higher product costs. "This is an important step in our continued work to cut costs for businesses and consumers," Commerce Commission chair John Small said. "Our latest decision builds on the initial fee caps set in 2022, which led to $140 million in annual savings to New Zealand businesses." ADVERTISEMENT "This decision cuts the cost for businesses accepting payments made through credit cards and foreign-issued cards, which are often the most expensive for businesses to accept." The Commission said it would also explore what regulations may be needed to address excessive surcharging. The Commission expected payments providers to support businesses understand their costs to accept these payment types. It has also decided not to regulate fees for commercial credit card or prepaid debit card payments.
