PH, PN leaders play down need for manifesto law
PETALING JAYA: Representatives from both the government and opposition showed little interest in enacting laws to hold political parties accountable for their election manifestos during a BBC debate programme last night.
PKR secretary-general Fuziah Salleh said her coalition, Pakatan Harapan (PH), has come to realise that governing is far more complex than being in opposition — and acknowledged that past manifestos may have overpromised.
"The perspective of how to run the country is different when you are in government as opposed to when you're in the opposition," said Fuziah, who is also deputy minister for domestic trade and cost of living.
"So, we will be more careful with manifestos this time," she added during the BBC's World Questions debate, held on Tuesday night.
The debate, part of the BBC World Service's World Questions series, featured four panellists, including Fuziah and former Bersatu Youth chief Wan Ahmad Fayhsal Wan Ahmad Kamal.
The proposal for a law compelling parties to fulfil their election pledges came from a member of the audience.
Responding to the idea, Wan Fayhsal said such a law was unnecessary, as voters already have the power to remove governments that fail to deliver.
"All political parties in Malaysia have had the experience of governing. We've learned not to overpromise on things we cannot deliver," he said.
Election manifestos in Malaysia are not legally binding.
The debate also touched on issues such as the rising cost of living, national identity and fundamental liberties.
It will be broadcast on the BBC World Service on Saturday, June 14.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
7 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
2% wealth tax would raise more than expanded SST, says ex-MP
Former Klang MP Charles Santiago argued that it is wrong to keep taxing consumption and not wealth, saying median wages barely keep up with inflation. PETALING JAYA : A 2% wealth tax would raise around 60% more than the RM5 billion in revenue the government hopes to obtain from its expansion of the sales and service tax (SST), says former Klang MP Charles Santiago. In a series of posts on X today, he commented on the assertion by deputy domestic trade and cost of living minister Fuziah Salleh that the government would become 'very unpopular' if it raised taxes on the top 10% of the nation's richest people and redistributed the wealth to the rest of the population. 'Malaysia's richest 50 hold US$90 billion (RM380.3 billion) in wealth, as per @Forbes. Why tax bananas and oil before mega mansions?' he said. Speaking at the BBC World Questions debate on Tuesday, Fuziah said that while the distribution of wealth should be more equitable and efficient, the government had to tread carefully in doing so. 'We already hear some noises when we talk about targeted petrol subsidies that may exclude the T20. 'Even the 2% dividend (tax) met some resistance,' Malay Mail reported her as saying, in reference to the introduction of a dividend tax on annual dividend incomes exceeding RM100,000 under the 2025 budget. Last year, finance minister II Amir Hamzah Azizan said the expansion of the SST was expected to generate RM51.7 billion in revenue in 2025, an additional revenue of RM5 billion over the previous SST collection forecast of RM46.7 billion. However, Santiago insisted that the matter ultimately boiled down to perspective and priorities. 'If you own RM100 million, a 2% wealth tax is RM2 million. That's one less Ferrari. Or less than your annual interest. But RM2 million could fund 500,000 school meals. This is about priorities,' he said. He also argued that it was wrong to keep taxing consumption and not wealth, saying median wages 'barely keep up with inflation'. '@UnicefMY shows low-income families spend 38% of their income on food. Inequality doesn't just grow, it erodes nations. Time to rebalance,' he said. He suggested that the increased revenue could be used, for example, to install solar panels for low-cost housing. 'This cuts electricity bills, creates income, and feeds clean energy into the grid,' he said.
New Straits Times
8 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Tengku Zafrul yet to decide next move after senatorship ends
KUALA LUMPUR: Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz said he wants to continue serving the country 'politically', with or without a government position, after his term as a senator ends in December. The Investment, Trade and Industry Minister, however, has yet to decide on his next course of action once his senatorship concludes. "I have not thought about it yet. Because there's so much (work) I need to focus on right now. "But my intention after December is to continue contributing in any way I can. "It doesn't have to be a position in government even. You can contribute to the government, and to the country in many ways. So to me, that's important. "But politically, I will want to continue to serve the country. And I've said it before that I've stated my intention to join PKR," he said during a press conference following the Regional Socialisation of the Asean Economic Community (AEC) Strategic Plan under the Asean Community Vision 2045. At the same time, he reaffirmed his commitment to focus on his current responsibilities at the ministry before completing his tenure as a senator, which is set to end in December. "My priority right now is to complete my term as a senator and to conclude various critical matters related to the country's investment and trade sectors, in line with my responsibilities at the ministry. "First and foremost, let me make it clear that I will focus on my current tasks. There is still a lot of work to be done at the ministry, as you are aware," he said. When asked about his position as minister after his senatorship ends, Tengku Zafrul said the matter would be entirely at Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's discretion. "I intend to continue contributing in my capacity at the ministry. However, whether I remain as minister after December depends on the prime minister's decision," he added. Tengku Zafrul reiterated that his decision to leave Umno and join PKR had nothing to do with wanting to take on another role in the government, whether as a minister or Menteri Besar. "I've said many times, even before I resigned from Umno, that I have no intention of contesting in any by-elections. "My decision to resign has nothing to do with wanting a government position, whether as a minister or Menteri Besar," he said. Tengku Zafrul on May 30 had announced his resignations from Umno. He had also announced his intention to join PKR.
Daily Express
9 hours ago
- Daily Express
2% wealth tax would raise more than expanded SST, says ex-MP
Published on: Thursday, June 12, 2025 Published on: Thu, Jun 12, 2025 By: FMT Reporters Text Size: Former Klang MP Charles Santiago argued that it is wrong to keep taxing consumption and not wealth, saying median wages barely keep up with inflation. PETALING JAYA: A 2% wealth tax would raise around 60% more than the RM5 billion in revenue the government hopes to obtain from its expansion of the sales and service tax (SST), says former Klang MP Charles Santiago. In a series of posts on X today, he commented on the assertion by deputy domestic trade and cost of living minister Fuziah Salleh that the government would become 'very unpopular' if it raised taxes on the top 10% of the nation's richest people and redistributed the wealth to the rest of the population. Advertisement 'Malaysia's richest 50 hold US$90 billion (RM380.3 billion) in wealth, as per @Forbes. Why tax bananas and oil before mega mansions?' he said. Speaking at the BBC World Questions debate on Tuesday, Fuziah said that while the distribution of wealth should be more equitable and efficient, the government had to tread carefully in doing so. 'We already hear some noises when we talk about targeted petrol subsidies that may exclude the T20. 'Even the 2% dividend (tax) met some resistance,' Malay Mail reported her as saying, in reference to the introduction of a dividend tax on annual dividend incomes exceeding RM100,000 under the 2025 budget. Last year, finance minister II Amir Hamzah Azizan said the expansion of the SST was expected to generate RM51.7 billion in revenue in 2025, an additional revenue of RM5 billion over the previous SST collection forecast of RM46.7 billion. However, Santiago insisted that the matter ultimately boiled down to perspective and priorities. 'If you own RM100 million, a 2% wealth tax is RM2 million. That's one less Ferrari. Or less than your annual interest. But RM2 million could fund 500,000 school meals. This is about priorities,' he said. He also argued that it was wrong to keep taxing consumption and not wealth, saying median wages 'barely keep up with inflation'. '@UnicefMY shows low-income families spend 38% of their income on food. Inequality doesn't just grow, it erodes nations. Time to rebalance,' he said. He suggested that the increased revenue could be used, for example, to install solar panels for low-cost housing. 'This cuts electricity bills, creates income, and feeds clean energy into the grid,' he said. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
