PH, PN leaders play down need for manifesto law
PKR secretary-general Fuziah Salleh said her coalition, Pakatan Harapan (PH), has come to realise that governing is far more complex than being in opposition — and acknowledged that past manifestos may have overpromised.
"The perspective of how to run the country is different when you are in government as opposed to when you're in the opposition," said Fuziah, who is also deputy minister for domestic trade and cost of living.
"So, we will be more careful with manifestos this time," she added during the BBC's World Questions debate, held on Tuesday night.
The debate, part of the BBC World Service's World Questions series, featured four panellists, including Fuziah and former Bersatu Youth chief Wan Ahmad Fayhsal Wan Ahmad Kamal.
The proposal for a law compelling parties to fulfil their election pledges came from a member of the audience.
Responding to the idea, Wan Fayhsal said such a law was unnecessary, as voters already have the power to remove governments that fail to deliver.
"All political parties in Malaysia have had the experience of governing. We've learned not to overpromise on things we cannot deliver," he said.
Election manifestos in Malaysia are not legally binding.
The debate also touched on issues such as the rising cost of living, national identity and fundamental liberties.
It will be broadcast on the BBC World Service on Saturday, June 14.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
17 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Life goes on: Rafizi vows to continue duties despite threats, attack on family
KUALA LUMPUR: Former economy minister Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli said he will carry on with his duties despite receiving threats and the recent attack on his family, stressing that stopping his work would mean giving in to those trying to silence him. He said he is not prioritising politics in the current situation but believes the threats were aimed at forcing him to give up and remain silent. "Some have suggested that I take a short break, but life and responsibilities must go on. "It is not that I am heartless or prioritising politics under the current situation, but the aim of the threats against my family is to make me give up and stay silent. "If I do not continue my routine and duties as usual, then their objective would be achieved," he said in a Facebook post today. As such, Rafizi said he will proceed with the Yang Berhenti Menteri podcast tonight, joined by Ampang member of parliament Rodziah Ismail and education activist Victor. Topics on the podcast will include the recent attack on his family, the threat posed by a bullying culture, and other issues. He also said he will go ahead tomorrow with the mobile counter at the Pasar Pagi Taman Muda and meet Pandan residents as planned. Police are tracking down two individuals Police are tracking down two individuals believed to have assaulted the son of the former PKR deputy president at a shopping mall in Putrajaya on Wednesday. Rafizi had said his son was attacked and injected with a syringe, and he believes the injection may have contained one of three possible substances: drugs, a virus, or simply water. investigation into the incident will be carried out.
Free Malaysia Today
a day ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Screen teachers, staff before hiring them, says MP
PKR backbencher Bakhtiar Wan Chik said screening teachers and staff in schools for criminal records would provide a key layer of prevention to ensure the safety of children. KUALA LUMPUR : A PKR backbencher has called for all teachers and staff in schools and childcare centres to be screened for criminal records to curb unwanted incidents after a rise in cases related to abuse. Bakhtiar Wan Chik (PH-Balik Pulau) told the Dewan Rakyat such checks should be made a condition before teachers, wardens, and support staff begin work. He said the measure, which is also used in Australia to block those with criminal records from working with children, would send a strong signal that 'safety is a shared duty and non-negotiable'. 'It will not solve all issues, but it can be a key layer of prevention,' he said. 'This step will not only protect our children from potential harm, but also build parents' confidence that schools and preschools are a safe place for their children. 'Our greatest investment should not just be in school infrastructure or classroom technology, but in ensuring that every child who goes to school returns home safely every day,' he said when debating the 13th Malaysia Plan. Last year, police rescued over 400 children from 20 welfare homes in Selangor and Negeri Sembilan linked to Global Ikhwan Services & Business Holdings, with some staff and religious teachers among the 171 arrested for alleged sexual abuse, neglect and exploitation. Other cases include a teacher in Ipoh arrested last year for hugging, kissing and sending indecent photos to a 12-year-old student, and another facing trial this year for allegedly touching a female student with sexual intent. Earlier today, the Muar sessions court ordered a teacher to enter his defence on charges of sexually assaulting a nine-year-old boy in a Tangkak school library six years ago.
Free Malaysia Today
a day ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Rodziah pleads against early sacrifice of Ampang seat
Rodziah Ismail won the Ampang parliamentary seat in the 2022 general election, defeating former PKR vice-president Zuraida Kamaruddin and eight other candidates. KUALA LUMPUR : Ampang MP Rodziah Ismail hopes to serve out her current term but is prepared to make way for another PKR candidate in the 16th general election (GE16). The former Selangor executive councillor's remarks follow confirmation that investment, trade and industry minister Tengku Zafrul Aziz has joined PKR's Ampang division. He quit Umno on May 30. Rodziah, the PKR welfare bureau chief, said the development had fuelled speculation of 'certain agendas', including questions about the Ampang parliamentary seat and the two state seats under it. Ampang PKR chief Syed Ahmad Abdul Rahman Alhadad holds the Lembah Jaya state seat while Selangor deputy speaker Kamri Kamaruddin has the Bukit Antarabangsa seat. 'Whatever the decision may be, let's wait until the end of the current term. Don't turn Ampang into a sacrificial seat. 'If the sole purpose is to create space and pave the way early by asking any MP or assemblyman to step aside, I think that is unreasonable,' said Rodziah, who won the Ampang seat in the 2022 general election (GE15). She won with a 29,681-vote majority, defeating former PKR vice-president Zuraida Kamaruddin and eight other candidates. Rodziah was moved from the Batu Tiga state seat in the Shah Alam parliamentary constituency to reclaim Ampang from Zuraida, who won it under the Pakatan Harapan (PH) banner before joining Bersatu and later Parti Bangsa Malaysia (PBM). In February, FMT quoted sources as saying that Tengku Zafrul was expected to contest a Selangor seat in the next general election, with Ampang being his top choice, and Petaling Jaya and Pandan as other possibilities. Speaking to FMT in an interview at Parliament, Rodziah said she would abide by the party's decision on GE16 candidates, for both state and parliamentary seats. 'If my services are needed, I will continue. If the decision is otherwise, I will accept it because over the past few years, I have seen where my path may lead,' said Rodziah, who lost the contest for the PKR women's chief in May. Last week, PKR secretary-general Fuziah Salleh confirmed that Tengku Zafrul's application to join PKR's Ampang division had been approved by the party's central leadership council at its July 26 meeting. The senator had resigned as an Umno Supreme Council member and Kota Raja division chief. Tengku Zafrul, who joined Umno in 1997, was seen as a technocrat when appointed as finance minister in Muhyiddin Yassin's Cabinet in March 2020, a role he retained in Ismail Sabri Yaakob's administration. His Umno membership only became publicly known ahead of GE15 when he was named Barisan Nasional's candidate for Kuala Selangor, a seat he failed to win. In April 2024, Tengku Zafrul quit as Selangor Umno treasurer, citing a lack of serious effort to revive the party in the state after its poor showing in the state polls, fuelling speculation – first emerging in December – that he was leaving Umno.
