logo
New Tax Bill may allow late ITR refunds, protect NGO income from heavy tax

New Tax Bill may allow late ITR refunds, protect NGO income from heavy tax

In a key move that could impact millions of taxpayers and not-for-profit organisations (NPOs), a Parliamentary Select Committee led by BJP MP Baijayant Panda has recommended critical changes to the draft Income Tax Bill, 2025, which seeks to replace the six-decade-old Income Tax Act, 1961. The panel's 4,575-page report, tabled in the Lok Sabha on Monday, focuses on simplifying the tax code while safeguarding key exemptions for religious-charitable institutions and easing compliance for small taxpayers.
Relief for Religious-cum-Charitable Trusts
One of the most significant recommendations is to retain the existing tax exemption on anonymous donations made to religious-cum-charitable trusts. Clause 337 of the new Bill had proposed a flat 30% tax on all anonymous donations, except for those made to purely religious trusts. This marked a sharp departure from current law, under which religious and charitable trusts receive broader exemptions unless the donations are specifically earmarked for hospitals or educational institutions they run.
The Committee flagged this as a "critical omission" and urged the reintroduction of a provision similar to Section 115BBC of the current Act to prevent adverse consequences for religious-charitable trusts. 'The proposed clause could significantly disrupt the NPO ecosystem,' the report warned.
Tax Only 'Income', Not 'Receipts'
Another major concern addressed is the proposed shift from taxing 'income' to 'receipts' of NPOs. The Committee strongly opposed this move, arguing it goes against the principle of real income taxation. Taxing gross receipts would unfairly include capital recoveries and inflows that do not represent actual earnings, it said.
Instead, the Committee recommended a return to net income-based taxation, urging a rewrite of Clause 335 to ensure only surplus income is taxed, not donations or reimbursements.
TDS Refunds Without ITR Filing
In a taxpayer-friendly move, the Committee also proposed allowing TDS refunds without mandatory ITR filing. The current draft Bill requires individuals to file a return within the due date to claim a TDS refund — even if their total income is below the taxable limit.'This may inadvertently criminalise small taxpayers who are otherwise non-filers,' the report cautioned. The Committee has therefore suggested removal of Sub-clause (1)(ix) from Clause 263, which mandates return filing for refund claims.
Shift to 'Tax Year' Welcomed
The Committee has also welcomed the government's decision to replace the concepts of 'previous year' and 'assessment year' with a unified 'tax year'. This move is expected to streamline tax references, reduce confusion, and improve accessibility of the law to non-specialists.
Additional Recommendations
According to experts, the Committee has made over 566 suggestions aimed at refining the draft Bill. These include:
Modernising definitions such as "capital asset" and "infrastructure capital company"
Clarifying property-related deductions
Re-emphasising the "actual payment" rule for claiming business expense deductions
Making penalties for non-maintenance of books discretionary
Creating procedural safeguards to prevent excessive penalisation of honest taxpayers
Nangia Andersen LLP, M&A Tax Partner, Sandeep Jhunjhunwala said the Committee has suggested modernising definitions such as "capital asset" and "infrastructure capital company", clarifying property-related deductions, and reinforcing the "actual payment" rule for business expenses. It has also recommended procedural safeguards such as making penalties for non-maintenance of books discretionary and permitting refund claims even where returns are not filed on time.
According to Amit Baid, Head of tax at BTG Advaya:
1) Reintroducing Nil withholding certificates helps prevent refund backlogs for genuine zero-tax cases — including non-residents entitled to treaty relief on cross-border transactions.
(2) Disallowing all deductions just because a return was late would have punished lakhs of genuine taxpayers. The Committee's fix restores sanity by limiting this to only certain income-linked deductions.
(3) Without the phrase 'in the circumstances of the case', GAAR could have become a tax sledgehammer - treating even bona fide restructurings as abuse. The Committee's intervention restores balance and guards against overreach on honest transactions.
(4) Many legacy trusts were staring at disqualification under vague definitions. By recommending clarity on 'wholly for charitable or religious purpose', the Committee saves hundreds of older institutions from legal limbo.
Chance missed
The Committee missed the chance to resolve the double taxation risk in holding company structures. Denying inter-corporate dividend deduction under the 22% concessional regime not only breaks with past policy logic, but could make this regime unattractive for investment vehicles and cross-border structures.
Tax-neutral treatment for fast-track demergers could be challenging. By not addressing this, the Committee has left a key gap that may discourage intra-group restructurings."
As the Monsoon Session of Parliament begins on July 21, the debate on the Committee's recommendations will shape the final contours of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, before it replaces one of India's longest-standing laws.
"The report provides clause by clause evaluation of the Bill with total 566 observations / recommendations for change. This is a mammoth task performed in a record time with precise and relevant recommendations. Now the Lok Sabha has to debate the recommendations and identify the changes that are required in the current Bill to make it futuristic and relevant for common tax-payers. It is highly desirable to defunct the old law and bring a new law which is transparent, easy to comprehend, in line with current business requirements and help to reduce tax disputes," said Preeti Sharma, Partner, Tax and Regulatory Services, BDO India.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Cooperative dept role key in implementation
Cooperative dept role key in implementation

Hans India

time16 minutes ago

  • Hans India

Cooperative dept role key in implementation

Rajamahendravaram: The Cooperative Department has a crucial role to play in effectively implementing the Right to Information (RTI) Act, said East Godavari District Cooperative Officer M Venkataramana. Addressing a district-level awareness programme on the RTI Act, organised at the Aryapuram Urban Cooperative Bank's conference hall, he noted the significance of cooperative societies as grassroots institutions that work closely with the public. Venkataramana urged Public Information Officers (PIOs) to be fully aware of key provisions such as Section 7, which mandates timely responses to RTI applications, and Section 19, which deals with the appeal process. He warned that delays or denial of information could lead to penalties and disciplinary action under Section 20. District Cooperative Audit Officer M Jagannatha Reddy stressed the importance of a transparent and timely information system and said staff should be well-versed with the Act to serve the public more efficiently. Divisional Cooperative Officer M Kanakadurgareddy explained the exemptions under Section 8 of the RTI Act, which prohibit the disclosure of information related to national security, strategic interests, trade secrets, or personal privacy. Ramadas Cooperative Training College Principal Srinivas explained that as per Section 20, officials could be fined ₹250 per day for delays in providing information, with a maximum penalty of ₹25,000. He also underlined the mandatory disclosure of information related to corruption and human rights violations. The awareness session was attended by PIOs, appellate officers, and supporting staff from various cooperative institutions across the district.

AP Chambers conducts awareness session on ELI scheme
AP Chambers conducts awareness session on ELI scheme

Hans India

time16 minutes ago

  • Hans India

AP Chambers conducts awareness session on ELI scheme

Vijayawada: The AP Chambers of Commerce and Industry Federation (AP Chambers) conducted an awareness session at its premises here on Thursday on the Employment Linked Incentive (ELI) scheme and TDS/TCS provisions and compliances. The session brought together senior officials from the Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and the Income Tax Department. Officials from EPFO provided a comprehensive overview of the ELI scheme, a landmark initiative announced in the Union Budget 2024–25 and approved by the Union Cabinet under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The scheme's primary goal is to generate over 3.5 crore new jobs and integrate 1.92 crore first-time employees into the formal workforce by incentivising employers who hire additional workers. The ELI scheme offers financial incentives to both employers and first-time employees, aiming to boost job creation and EPFO registration, particularly within the manufacturing sector. Key features highlighted during the session included wage-based incentives, mandatory EPFO registration, Aadhaar-based Direct Benefit Transfers (DBT), and extended incentives specifically for the manufacturing sector. The officials emphasised how the ELI Scheme will accelerate formal job creation and significantly improve social security coverage. P Veerabhadra Swamy, Additional Central PF Commissioner, Hemong Venkatesh, Regional PF Commissioner–I, Prabhudatta Prushty, Regional PF Commissioner–I and Abdul Khader, Regional PF Commissioner–II participated. Following the EPFO session, P Anil Kumar, officer from the Income Tax Department (TDS), here delivered a focused presentation on TDS/TCS provisions and compliances. His session covered the latest updates, essential compliance timelines, and practical guidance for businesses to prevent penalties and ensure accurate tax deduction and reporting. The programme was spearheaded by Potluri Bhaskara Rao, president of AP Chambers, B Raja Sekhar, General Secretary and Akkaiah Naidu, Treasurer. The session saw enthusiastic participation from approximately 100 representatives from diverse sectors, including MSMEs, manufacturing, services, trading, and professional firms. Attendees found the session highly informative and timely, widely appreciating AP Chambers' initiative for raising awareness on these crucial reforms and helping industry members stay informed and compliant.

From The Hindu, July 25, 1975: Water allowance for ICF staff suggested
From The Hindu, July 25, 1975: Water allowance for ICF staff suggested

The Hindu

timean hour ago

  • The Hindu

From The Hindu, July 25, 1975: Water allowance for ICF staff suggested

New Delhi, July 24: The Committee on petitions of the Rajya Sabha has suggested grant of 'water allowance' to the employees of the Integral Coach Factory (ICF), Madras, in view of the expenses they had to incur in procuring water for their daily use. In its 48th report presented to the House to-day, the Committee said the quantum of water allowance to be granted might be decided by the Government in a 'sympathetic and realistic manner.' The Committee also recommended that the Government should ensure that adequate water supply was maintained in the factory area where employees had to work for long hours. The Government should take some long-term measures in the light of the present experience to ensure that the hardship caused by water scarcity in future might be minimised to the extent possible, the Committee said. A petition signed by more than 2,000 ICF employees was presented to the Rajya Sabha on May 9 by Mr. Subramanian Swamy (JS) requesting that in view of the drought conditions prevailing in Tamil Nadu and lack of drinking water, an interest-free loan of Rs. 1,000 be granted to each employee so that new wells were dug and the existing ones deepened.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store