44-year-old man arrested for assaulting elderly Sikh in US

Hindustan Times

a day ago

A 44-year-old man has been arrested for assaulting an elderly Sikh man, the Los Angeles police department said in a statement on Tuesday. Advocacy group The Sikh Coalition said that while the suspect is in custody for the brutal assault on Singh, the police are not investigating the case as a hate crime.
The brutal assault left Harpal Singh, 70, with a skull fracture and potential brain trauma.
Singh was assaulted by an 'unhoused' man, Bo Richard Vitagliano, while he was taking his daily walk near the Sikh Gurdwara of Los Angeles on August 4.
The Los Angeles Police Department said in a statement Tuesday that Vitagliano, 44, was arrested on Monday for the 'brutal attack' against Singh.
Vitagliano has been booked for assault with a deadly weapon, and his bail was set for USD 1.1 million.
Advocacy group The Sikh Coalition said that while the suspect is in custody for the brutal assault on Singh, the police are not investigating the case as a hate crime.
It said Singh has sustained very serious injuries during the assault and remains in critical condition.
The police said that on August 4, law enforcement officials responded to a radio call of an 'assault with a deadly weapon investigation.' Preliminary investigation revealed there was a physical altercation between Singh and Vitagliano, who is an 'unhoused' individual.
Witnesses said while they did not see how the altercation began, they heard a loud commotion, then witnessed two men swinging metal objects at each other, the LAPD said. Both individuals were struck, and Vitagliano further assaulted Singh while he was reportedly on the ground. When witnesses intervened by yelling at Vitagliano, he rode away on his bicycle.
Los Angeles Fire Department paramedics responded and transported Singh to a nearby hospital, where he was admitted for a skull fracture and potential brain trauma. Singh continues to be under the care of a physician due to injuries suffered in the altercation.
Vitagliano has an extensive criminal record for narcotics, assault with a deadly weapon, and various weapons charges. Based upon the evidence in this matter, police believe the assault was not a hate crime, but instead motivated by a dispute over property belonging to the victim.
LAPD said local officers will be conducting extra patrols in the area following this incident and will continue engaging the community to discuss public safety and address any further concerns of the Sikh community.
The Sikh Coalition noted that it is 'impossible to completely rule out that this is a hate crime at this stage. The suspect has been in custody for less than 24 hours, and Harpal ji himself remains unconscious and has thus been unable to sit for a full police interview, with professional translation services, separate from a conversation immediately after the attack.' 'After such an interview happens, if the LAPD still believes this was not a hate crime, they must publicly clarify how they determined hate was not a factor in this assault,' it said.
Singh's brother, Dr Gurdial Singh Randhawa, said he is grateful that the police have arrested a suspect for the horrific assault, but 'we need to better understand this attack and why it is not being considered a hate crime.' 'Justice must be served, and our local Sikh community must know that the area around our gurdwara—where we gather to worship, learn, connect, eat, and serve others—is safe for all,' he added.
Akal Takht jathedar condemns assault, calls it hate crime
Amritsar Akal Takht officiating jathedar Giani Kuldip Singh Gargaj on Wednesday condemned the assault. In a statement here on Wednesday, jathedar Gargaj said it should be recorded as a hate crime and also said it is essential to understand the intent behind the attack.
Gargaj, while citing a 2024 hate crime report of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), said Sikhs remain the third most-targeted religious group, which is a grave concern.
'The FBI report records 153 hate crime incidents against Sikhs in 2024 alone,' he said, stressing the urgent need for collaborative efforts worldwide, including in the US, to raise awareness about Sikh identity in order to curb such attacks.
The jathedar asked Sikh organisations in the US to make special efforts to educate the American public about Sikh identity and, in case of difficulties, to seek the support of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC) and the Akal Takht.
He asked external affairs minister S Jaishankar to ensure through the Indian mission in the US that the assault is officially recorded as a hate crime and that strict action is taken against the perpetrator. Gargaj directed the SGPC to correspond with the ministry of external affairs to ensure stringent action against the accused.
DSGMC seeks justice