War of words: In targeting Jaishankar, is Rahul Gandhi tripping on Js?
At a time when Congress leaders and MPs are on foreign soil as part of multi-party delegations explaining the government's position on Pakistan and terrorism emanating from the neighbouring country, Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition (LoP) Rahul Gandhi on Friday posed a fresh set of questions to External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar and claimed 'India's foreign policy has collapsed'.
Gandhi's use of the initials 'JJ', which he did not clarify, caused consternation in sections of the party. His post also drew a sharp rebuttal from the BJP, which criticised his 'immature and irresponsible comments' that were 'miles from the truth' and said he was deserving of 'Nishan-e-Pakistan (Pakistan's highest civilian honour)'.
Sharing a clip of Jaishankar's interview with Dutch broadcaster NOS, Gandhi wrote on X, 'Will JJ explain: Why has India been hyphenated with Pakistan? Why didn't a single country back us in condemning Pakistan? Who asked Trump to 'mediate' between India & Pakistan?'
Congress media department head Pawan Khera and social media chief Supriya Shrinate refused to comment on what Gandhi meant by 'JJ'. Two senior leaders said it was obvious that while one J stood for Jaishankar, the other was open to interpretation. 'It could be Joker or jhoota (liar). It could be Jaichand or Mir Jafar, who are both considered traitors,' said a leader. The other party functionary said, 'It is up to the people to interpret what the J stands for.'
Another senior Congress functionary said the party 'should not play such games' with a Union Minister. 'There has to be a better way to ask questions from the government and the EAM. I know the BJP has made personal attacks on the Congress and Rahul Gandhi. But there has to be a difference between us and them,' he added.
A leader who is part of one of the all-party delegations said, 'He is the LoP. He has certain responsibilities to ask questions of the government on behalf of the people. But such posts on social media. I don't understand them. You can have your spokespersons and leaders do such things. Why do it yourself from your official social media account?'
This is not the first time the Congress and Gandhi have targeted Jaishankar this week. On Monday, the LoP asked the minister to clarify whether the government had 'informed' Pakistan before targeting the terrorist infrastructure on its soil and what it meant in terms of aircraft 'lost' by India. Khera repeated the allegations at a media briefing the same day, adding that Jaishankar's remarks may have helped terrorists 'escape'. Khera even called the minister a 'mukhbir (informant)' – something that didn't go down well with a section of Congress leaders, who said that it was taking things 'too far'.
The Ministry of External Affairs clarified that Jaishankar's remarks were being 'falsely represented' and added, 'This utter misrepresentation of facts is being called out.'
The BJP hit back at Gandhi's 'undignified words', saying his comments were playing into Pakistan's hands. Underlining the significance of the LoP's office, BJP national spokesperson Gaurav Bhatia said, 'You can have a difference of opinion with the Prime Minister, this can happen in a democracy but using undignified words against him, your statements being seconded by Pakistan and their being played in their Senate, being used by Pakistan to defame India and your staying quiet is worrying.'
Asking him to 'choose sides' once and for all, Bhatia said Gandhi needed to decide if he was 'the Leader of the Opposition of India or Pakistan's Nishan-e-Pakistan'.
'When Operation Sindoor is still on, what kind of irresponsible statements are being made by Rahul Gandhi ji? 'Please tell me how many of the India Air Force's jets have been downed?'… This is when today, Pakistan's senior political leader Maryam Nawaz said that Pakistan had to suffer a lot of losses during the nights of May 6, 7, and 9 because of Indian retaliation,' he said.
'Pakistan is admitting that our forces destroyed nine terror launchpads, destroyed 11 Pakistani airbases. Maryam Nawaz is admitting that Pakistan has got such a jolt that it is crumbling. What is LoP, Nishan-e-Pakistan doing now? … Rahul Gandhi ji, your core character of being anti-India, against the morale of the country's armed forces (has been exposed) … why did you start hating the 140 crore people of the country while hating PM Narendra Modi?' he asked.
Earlier in the day, before Gandhi's social media post, BJP MP Nishikant Dubey alleged that in 1991 India and Pakistan had signed an agreement to exchange information 'about any attack or army movement'. This, he added, was signed with the support of the Congress.
'Is this agreement treason? Congress is hand in glove with Pakistani vote bank, does it suit you to make objectionable comments on Foreign Minister S Jaishankar,' Dubey wrote on X.
After Khera pointed out that the Congress had withdrawn support to the Chandra Shekhar government in February 1991, Dubey responded by saying the Congress had 'stopped reading'. 'According to article 14 of this agreement, this agreement was ratified in a meeting held in Delhi on 19 August 1992, which is written on page number 2 of my tweet. Was there a Congress government in 1992 or not?' he asked.
The 'Agreement between India and Pakistan on advance notice on military exercises, manoeuvres and troop movements' was signed on April 6, 1991. The Chandra Shekhar government lasted a total of seven months from November 10, 1990, to June 21, 1991, continuing for a few months after the Congress withdrew support on March 6. In the elections that followed, the Congress returned to power under the leadership of P V Narasimha Rao.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
42 minutes ago
- The Hindu
CPI(M-L) likely to contest around 45 seats in Bihar Assembly election
The Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist), an ally of the Opposition Mahagathbandhan (grand alliance) in Bihar, is planning to contest around 45 seats of the total 243 in the Assembly election due later this year. The CPI(M-L) will also launch a campaign, 'Badlo Sarkar-Badlo Bihar' (change the government, change Bihar)', across the State soon. Addressing mediapersons in Patna on Tuesday (June 10, 2025), CPI(M-L) national general secretary Dipankar Bhattacharya said: 'Our party has been making preparations to contest 40-45 Assembly seats in the upcoming election. In the coming days, there would be talks on seat sharing and the agendas on which the Mahagathbandhan would contest the poll.' Won 12 in 2020 election In the last 2020 Assembly election, the party won 12 seats out of 19 it contested. The CPI(M-L), the Communist Party of India (CPI) and the Communist Party of India (Marxist) together won 16 out of the total 29 seats in the election. The CPI had contested six seats, while the CPI(M) fought on four seats. Both won two seats each. In the 2024 Lok Sabha election, the CPI(M-L) won two seats of Ara and Karakat of the total 40 seats. 'No governance' The CPI(M-L) slammed the NDA governments led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the Centre and Chief Minister Nitish Kumar in the State on national security and law and order issues. 'Today there is no government as such in the State. Law and order has collapsed and the people of the State are caught between crime and corruption,' Mr. Bhattacharya alleged. 'Cases of rape have become common, and feudal atrocities have increased in the name of development and good governance in the State. People of the State now are trying to get rid of this oppressive government,' he said. The party leader said the CPI(M-L) would run the Badlo Sarkar-Badlo Bihar campaign from June 18 to June 27, especially in the four regions of Shahabad, Saran-Champaran, Magadh, and Muzaffarpur to Darbhanga. Calls for special session The CPI(M-L) leader criticised the Modi-led government over its foreign policy too. 'The Modi government had sent seven delegations to 32 countries (following Operation Sindoor), but India's international isolation continues. They [the Central government] should call a special session of Parliament to discuss the Pahalgam terrorist incident and the situation thereafter,' he said. 'The BJP-led NDA government has weakened the country on every front, especially on issues related with national security and foreign policy,' he said. On the ongoing (anti-Maoist) 'Operation Kagar' in Chhattisgarh, Mr. Bhattacharya said: 'It's all state- sponsored violence. The five Left parties of the country have written a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi on June 9 demanding an immediate stay on the ongoing operation.' Polit Bureau member Dhirendra Jha, party legislators Gopal Ravidas and Sandeep Saurabh, party MLC Sashi Yadav, and senior State leaders K.D. Yadav and Umesh Singh were present on the occasion.
The Hindu
42 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Nitish Kumar has performed the last rites for law and order in Bihar: Lalu Prasad
Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) Chief Lalu Prasad on Tuesday (June 10, 2025) criticised Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar over the alleged deterioration of law and order in the State. In a post on X, Mr. Prasad accused Mr. Kumar of not only ruining the State's law and order but also performing its last rites. This comes after Mr. Prasad's son, Tejashwi Yadav, Leader of Opposition in the Bihar Legislative Assembly, lashed out at Mr. Kumar over the issue of a double murder in Patna, where a mother and daughter were shot dead by three unidentified criminals. 'Nitish, tell us, how many murders are happening before 5 p.m.?' Mr. Prasad asked. Stating that he was sharing official figures, Mr. Prasad said that under Mr. Kumar's tenure, Bihar had witnessed 65,000 murders. 'Nitish-BJP have not only ruined law and order but also performed its last rites. Never, ever has there been such a corrupt, negligent, and lazy police force in Bihar,' Mr. Prasad said in the post. Leaders of the ruling Janata Dal (United) and the Bharatiya Janata Party hit back at Mr. Prasad asking him not to give a sermon on law and order. Bihar's JD(U) President, Umesh Singh Kushwaha, countered the RJD supremo's statement and said that those who gave protection to criminals for political gains were now preaching on law. 'Before raising questions on law and order, the RJD supremo should consult his conscience and question himself. At the same time, he should publicly apologise for bringing Jungle Raj in Bihar. The law-and-order situation was so pathetic during the Lalu-Rabri regime that most of the criminal incidents were not even registered, because the criminals had the open protection of the government,' Mr. Kushwaha said in a press statement. BJP leader and Deputy Chief Minister Samrat Choudhary too attacked Mr. Prasad, saying that during his rule, crime was committed under the protection of power, whereas, today, under Nitish Kumar's good governance, there was no organised crime and criminals were not let go on the basis of caste or religion. 'Action is taken within 48 to 72 hours of the incident. No one can escape after committing a big crime. RJD leaders do politics by exaggerating some incidents of murder in family feuds or land disputes and defaming Bihar,' Mr. Choudhary said, while speaking to the media in Patna. To a question on the murder statistics shared by Mr. Prasad on 'X', Mr. Choudhary said, 'He should also post the figures of kidnapping, murder and massacre that took place during his 15 years of rule. People have not forgotten the fear and anarchy that was created during his rule. Its impact is still there, that is why investors hesitate to invest in Bihar.' He pointed out that Mr. Prasad was unable to see the rapid infrastructural development that had been done in Bihar in 11 years by the double engine government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chief Minister Nitish Kumar. Mr. Choudhary added that Mr. Prasad had been a powerful Minister in the UPA Government at the Centre, but Bihar did not get even ₹2 lakh crore in aid during his 10 years. 'However, the Modi government had invested ₹14 lakh crore in the State for the development of roads, bridges, electricity and airports,' he said.
Time of India
42 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Like cat guarding milk': Rajnath Singh slams UNSC for naming Pakistan in anti-terror panel; says PoK will join 'Bharat' soon
Defence minister Rajnath Singh addresses a gathering during a dialogue on the topic 'National Security & Terrorism', in Dehradun. (PTI) NEW DELHI: Defence minister Rajnath Singh on Tuesday criticised the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) for appointing Pakistan as the vice-chair of its counter-terrorism panel. Singh said this decision is similar to "making the cat guard the milk" as Pakistan has a known history of protecting and supporting terrorists. "What is astonishing is that this Counter-Terrorism panel, was formed after the 9/11 terror attacks. Pakistan had sheltered the mastermind of the 9/11 attacks. This (decision) is akin to cat guarding the milk," Singh said. At an event in Dehradun, Singh said Pakistan has supported terrorism for many years and described Operation Sindoor, which was carried out in response to the Pahalgam attack, as the "biggest action" against terrorism in India's history. Singh pointed out that both India and Pakistan became independent at the same time, but while India is now seen as the "mother of democracy", Pakistan has gained the label of "father of global terrorism". He said this comparison should be kept in mind. Singh also said Pakistan is "stubborn" and needs to be dealt with using "strategic, diplomatic and economic pressure" from the global community to stop terrorism from its land. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 3.5, 4.5 BHK Homes starting at ₹4.89 Cr.* Hero Homes Learn More Undo "Pakistan has always given shelter to terrorists, trained them on its soil and helped them. Pahalgam (attack) was just an example, but I want to tell you that list of Pakistan-aided terrorists is very long. And, Pakistan always tries to justify terrorism. So, it is important that we eliminate not just these terrorists but the entire terror infrastructure that aids them," he said. He added that Pakistan has not been able to stop development in Kashmir despite efforts. "Udhampur-Srinagar-Baramulla railway link is a shining example of the government's relentless pursuit of progress in Jammu & Kashmir. Soon, PoK will join us and say 'I, too, am Bharat'," he said. Shashi Tharoor, Priyanka Chaturvedi Share Key Insights After Meeting PM Modi At His Residence Calling terrorism a problem for humanity and a global issue, Singh said that no society should accept it. He also mentioned that some people glorify terrorists as "freedom fighters" and said, "no revolution is born out of the womb of terrorism, it only engenders destruction and hatred". Singh further stated that "No religious, ideological or political reason can justify terrorism. No human objective can ever be achieved through bloodshed and violence." He said Pakistan supports terrorism and a large portion of its foreign aid is used to fund this support. "Funding Pakistan means funding the infrastructure of terrorism. Pakistan is a nursery of terrorism. It should not be nourished," he said, asking other countries to stop giving money to Pakistan. Singh said that Pakistan's land has been a shelter for global terror groups. He named terrorists like Hafiz Saeed and Masood Azhar who move freely there, and added that even senior officers of the Pakistan Army have attended terrorists' funerals. "Now, the same country is expected to lead the global community against terrorism. This raises serious questions on the intentions and policies of the international system," he said. Singh urged the international community and organisations like the UN to take the issue of terrorism seriously. He said, "Only when we are free from terrorism, will we be able to move towards the goal of global peace, progress and prosperity."
