Why your winter workouts might not have the benefits you'd think
However, new research has shed light on that old saying, revealing that it's not just any workout that benefits your mental health, but rather the context surrounding it.
It turns out, it's less about how hard you work up a sweat and more about why you're moving, who you're with, and how you feel about it.
In other words, that 6am jog around your local streets on a cold winter's morning might not actually be the best workout for your mind.
Context is king
The study from the University of Georgia found that where, how, and who with, makes all the difference when it comes to exercise and mental health.
'Historically, physical activity research has focused on how long someone exercises or how many calories were burned,' said Patrick O'Connor, co-author of the study.
'The 'dose' of exercise has been the main way researchers have tried to understand how physical activity might influence mental health, often ignoring whether those minutes were spent exercising with a friend or as part of a game.'
The study found that people who regularly exercise for leisure get improved mental health benefits, such as lower levels of depression and anxiety.
But if physical activity comes from chores like cleaning the house or mowing the lawn, it may not offer the same benefits.
Mr O'Connor also gave an example of a soccer player's mental state while playing a game, which can vary greatly depending on the outcome.
For instance, scoring the winning goal might boost confidence, but missing a shot and getting the blame might lead to negative feelings that counteract any mental health benefits you might have gotten from exercising.
Therefore, the context of an activity affects a person's emotional response, even if the actions are similar.
Other examples include walking to work on a hot day (which is not necessarily enjoyable) versus taking a group workout class where you really like the instructor's style (which is more likely to benefit your mental health).
So, why do these factors matter?
According to sports psychologist Dr Jo Lukins, who has spent decades uncovering what really keeps Aussies active, humans are 'continually seeking meaning'.
'Therefore, part of our decision-making in any area of our lives revolves around the motivations we have and the circumstances we face,' Dr Lukins tells news.com.au.
'Humans are deeply social beings, and often seek human contact through physical activity.'
Sometimes this contact is direct – for example, going for a walk with a friend – and other times it's indirect, such as walking along a waterfront where there are other people around.
Enjoyment is another crucial factor.
Research has shown that the main reason children stop participating in sport is a loss of joy.
So, Dr Lukins says it's no surprise that as adults, we also need a fun element in our exercise to stay interested and committed.
How to motivate yourself to exercise
With winter weather set in across the country, even thinking about exercise can feel like a challenge.
Dr Lukins' top tip is to ditch the rule book and find exercise that's actually fun, and do it with a friend if you can.
'Be curious and creative when making your decisions,' she advises.
'Maybe there's a dance class you've always wanted to try, or you could take a long walk in a museum or explore indoor spaces like a shopping centre.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Gut Instinct
Introduced by Australian Story presenter Leigh Sales. When Jane Dudley's partner Alex first suggested treating her crippling mental health disorder with faecal transplants, she was grossed out. Now she's a true believer and the medical world is taking notice. Airs Monday July 28, 8:00pm (AEST), on ABCTV and ABC iview.
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
BTN Newsbreak 25/07/2025
STEPS IN A DAY You might have heard some people say you need to walk 10,000 steps a day to stay healthy. But where did that number even come from? Now, a new study has suggested otherwise. As we all know, walking lots is really good for us. It keeps our hearts healthy, our bones strong, and our minds clear. And since the 1960's, 10,000 steps a day has been the gold standard. But apparently, there's no science behind that number. It's why Katherine and her team decided to do some research of their own. Right now, there's no exact number of steps kids should be doing daily, but the Department of Health suggests 60 minutes of exercise a day is optimal. STARLINK OUTAGE If you were using Elon Musk's Starlink internet service this morning, you might've found things were a bit slow. Mr Musk took to his platform X this morning to apologise, after the internet provider suffered a huge outage, with at least 60,000 people globally reporting internet issues. It's become a pretty important service for people in Australia's outback, where high-speed internet can be pretty patchy. Starlink says the outage was caused by a software services issue, and that things should now be back online. COMIC-CON Thousands of people from all over the world have travelled to San Diego for one of the world's most popular comic conventions, Comic-Con! When Super Mario characters, Batman, and a giant banana come together under the one roof, it can only mean one thing: it's time for Comic-Con! Comic-Con was started in San Diego back in the 1970s, by a small group of comic, movie and science fiction fans, and was a true comic book convention. Since then it has grown into a global phenomenon and has become more of an opportunity for fans to dress up like this. Comic-Con has also become an important place for actors and Hollywood producers to promote new projects, although they seem to be a little more absent from this years Comic-Con. Over the next couple of days more than 100,000 fans will be able to attend panels, workshops, meet artists and creators, and get unique merch and collectibles! BOW TIES FOR ANIMALS First up, to 18-year-old Darius in the US who has turned his passion for sewing into a business that helps save animals. He's raised more than 700 thousand bucks selling bow ties and donating them to shelters for animals to wear, which has helped them get adopted even faster. VULTURE PUPPETS Now to a zoo in Prague, where zookeepers have been using hand puppets to feed their new baby vultures. It might look a bit creepy, but they do it so that the birds don't get too close to humans, otherwise it might affect their ability to connect with other birds, and find a mate in the future. LEONARDO DA PINCHY And finally, to Leo the cat in New Zealand who's been wreaking havoc on his local community, stealing laundry from his neighbours' clotheslines and bringing his loot back home. He's earnt himself the nickname Leonardo Da Pinchy, and nothing is off the cards: undies, socks, even a 300 dollar cashmere jersey.
ABC News
7 hours ago
- ABC News
As South Australia deals with its algal bloom, California is dealing with another
A dead sea lion is discovered on one end of the coast, and not far away an entire pod of long-beaked common dolphins lay stranded. It is becoming a familiar scene for those living along the coast of Southern California. And much like in South Australia, where thousands of dead sea creatures have washed ashore since March, a harmful algal bloom is to blame. Warning: This story contains content that some readers may find distressing. In California, this is the fourth consecutive year of death and destruction along the coastline. There have been scores of marine mammals and sea birds injured and killed, with US rescuers dealing with "by far historically the largest mass stranding event" relating to algal blooms. In South Australia, the Karenia mikimotoi bloom, kills fish and other sea creatures by impacting their gills, causing them to drown. In the US, authorities have been dealing with different types of algae, including one that produces domoic acid which can cause mammals like sea lions to experience seizures, behave aggressively or die. The Pacific Marine Mammal Center (PMMC) said the harmful algal bloom on the Southern California coast had significantly impacted sea lion and common dolphin populations and had killed two humpback whales and a minke whale. "In 2025, we've experienced the worst domoic acid algae bloom that we've ever experienced in Southern California history," Alissa Deming, PMMC vice president of Conservation, Medicine and Science told ABC News. Dr Deming said the PMMC hospital had taken in hundreds of sick mammals, which had been "physically demanding and very emotionally taxing" on staff and volunteers trying to help while protecting the public from aggressive animals. "A number of the sea lions were also pregnant, and that resulted in reproductive losses of over 85 fetuses born and lost in our hospital as a result of this bloom," she said. The veterinarian said there were likely similar drivers for its bloom to the one happening in South Australia including increasing marine temperatures and more nutrients from cold water upwelling. "By combining the warm sea surface temperatures with increased nutrients, that has resulted in us having a bloom event every year since 2022, with them seemingly becoming larger, longer lasting and covering a lot larger geographic region," Dr Deming said. Investigations are underway if the destructive Los Angeles wildfires in January and the associated run-off have contributed to the bloom. The US National Office for Harmful Algal Blooms said a conservative estimated cost of harmful algal blooms for the the US was about $50 million, but experts say expenses are hard to quantify. A 2024 study estimated losses to tourism-related businesses during the 2018 Florida red tide bloom at $US2.7 billion. Dr Deming said the US government agencies continued to have monitoring and management practices in place to support the commercial seafood industry. "Being able to have good federal and state agencies that can do surveillance to test to ensure seafood is safe for the public, as well as trying to come up with preventative measures or best management practices to prevent blooms, … are really high priority items," she said. "We're happy we have some of those systems in place, but there's absolutely room for improvement I think all around the world to help prevent the conditions that support these really long lasting and devastating blooms." Other algal blooms have also wreaked havoc in other parts of the world. An algae surge choked to death an estimated 40,000 tonnes of salmon in Chile in 2016 while hundreds of elephant deaths in Botswana in 2020 were linked to cyanobacteria, often called blue-green algae in Australia. The scale of each harmful algal bloom event seems to be increasing, professor Gretta Pecl from the University of Tasmania's Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies told the ABC. "If there isn't something done to mitigate, to reduce climate emissions, warming will continue and these kinds of events will be more and more likely," she said. US research biologist at NOAA Fisheries Kathi Lefebvre, who has been studying harmful algal blooms for 25 years, said the blooms were getting worse and reaching areas "where we used to not have problems". "It is turning out to be a major impact of climate change." Authorities in South Australia have linked South Australia's algal bloom to climate change, and state and federal governments have pledged a collective $28 million for a suite of measures to tackle the algal bloom, including more funding for testing. Dr Lefebvre said authorities needed to take action now to mitigate the effects of future blooms. "What's going to happen if these blooms are going to be continuing is that there's going to need to be ways to test for toxins … to protect human health," Dr Lefebvre said. "The more information we have, the better decisions we can make.
