BJP MPs protest parliament panel inviting Prakash Raj, Medha Patkar; meeting cancelled
The Standing Committee on Rural Development and Panchayati Raj, headed by Congress MP Saptagiri Sankar Ulaka, had called Patkar and Raj to hear her views on the implementation and effectiveness of the land acquisition law enacted by Parliament when the Congress-led UPA government was in power in 2013.
Patkar had led protests against raising the height of Sardar Sarovar Dam in Gujarat and is accused by the ruling party of working against the country's development interests in the name of public and environmental causes.
Former Union minister and BJP MP Parshottam Rupala was joined by other lawmakers from his party as they walked out of the meeting, with some dubbing Patkar as "anti-national". A BJP MP wondered if leaders from Pakistan could also be called to such a meeting, news agency PTI said,
Ulaka, the panel's chairperson, however, defended the decision, saying that it is standard practice for a parliamentary committee to hear civil society members and other stakeholders on various issues.
"We wanted to hear their views on the land acquisition law. We wanted an opinion from everyone, but they (BJP) didn't allow it," he told news agency PTI.
Out of the 29 members of the committee, 14 members, including the chairman, were present, and a majority of them were from the BJP and its allies.
The meeting's agenda was to hear from different stakeholders on the implementation and effectiveness of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, a UPA-era Act.
Representatives of the Department of Land Resources (Ministry of Rural Development), the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC), the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, non-government organisations (NGOs), experts, and other stakeholders were to speak before the panel.
Among those invited before the panel were officials from the Environment and Forest Ministry and activists, including Patkar and Prakash Raj, also an actor who has often criticised the BJP's politics.
Former prime minister HD Deve Gowda also attended the meeting, according to PTI.
A BJP MP said they were not told about the decision to ask Patkar to share her views with the committee. Generally, sources said, it is the chairman's prerogative to pick names, though members can make suggestions.
A BJP member said their primary objection was to calling Patkar, who was the face of the 'Narmada Bachao Andolan' protest against a determined push by the Gujarat government, headed then by Narendra Modi as chief minister, to raise the height of Sardar Sarovar Dam.
The state government's views finally prevailed, and Modi, who took over as prime minister in 2014, has often spoken about the efforts to stall the project since its foundation in the 1960s.
As the BJP MPs walked out, Ulaka said he decided to end the meeting due to a lack of quorum.
"As per rule, a quorum of 10 members is required. When the BJP MPs walked out, there was no quorum, and the meeting ended," he said.
BJP MPs objected to Patkar appearing before the panel, and called her 'anti-national,' according to sources quoted by news agency PTI. A miffed MP also wondered if the prime minister of Pakistan could be called for questioning by the panel, the news agency report said.
When the meeting started, opposition MPs were of the opinion that Patkar should be heard, to which the BJP MPs did not agree.
Asked about the incident, Patkar said she was invited to appear before the panel, and while she and others were waiting, they saw some MPs leave.
We wanted to hear their views on the land acquisition law. We wanted an opinion from everyone, but they (BJP) didn't allow it.
She added that later, they were informed that the meeting had ended. Patkar said she had also appeared before parliamentary committees earlier.
"I have never experienced anything like this before. It is important to talk about the land acquisition law," she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
23 minutes ago
- United News of India
Oppn delegation raises concerns over voter list revision, meets EC
New Delhi, July 2 (UNI) A joint delegation comprising 11 political parties of the Opposition met with the Election Commission on Wednesday to voice strong objections over the recently announced Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar. Addressing the media after the meeting, senior Congress leader Abhishek Manu Singhvi said, a delegation, comprising around 20 representatives, engaged in a detailed discussion with the Commission that lasted nearly three hours. However, Singhvi said that only two members from each party were allowed to attend the meeting, preventing many leaders from participating. The parties have formally lodged a complaint regarding this restriction. 'Since 2003, Bihar has witnessed at least five major elections over the past 22 years. If the current voter list process is being questioned, does that mean all previous elections were flawed?' he asked. 'Even if a revision was necessary, it could have been done after the elections, with proper preparation. When a similar process was conducted in 2003, the general elections were still a year away and the assembly polls two years later. This time, the time frame is extremely limited,' the Congress leader added. He also raised concerns over the new documentation requirements for voter eligibility. For the past decade, Aadhaar has been accepted as a valid proof for most government processes, but now the Commission is reportedly requiring a birth certificate. In certain categories, those born between 1987 and 2012 may even have to produce the birth certificates of their parents, he said. 'This is an impractical and unfair demand. Millions of poor citizens, especially in rural areas, will be forced to spend months collecting documents. Many legitimate voters could be excluded from the rolls altogether. This is a clear violation of the level playing field, which is fundamental to free and fair elections,' he said. The delegation also questioned the legal process behind the sudden change. He said, "Because until January, there was no such rule. You did not announce it; instead, you published an SSR (Summary Special Revision). In January 2025, there was no announcement of an SIR, nor was the term even mentioned. So how was this decision suddenly made at the end of June?" Citing various Supreme Court judgments, the delegation argued that excluding eligible citizens from the electoral roll amounts to severe disenfranchisement and violates constitutional rights. 'We reminded the Commission that the Supreme Court has repeatedly held that denying someone the right to vote through exclusion from the electoral roll is a grave injustice,' Singhvi said. UNI RBE RKM
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
Waste piles up in Mohali, triggers mudslinging
1 2 Mohali: Overflowing garbage and deteriorating sanitation across Mohali have sparked a full-blown political storm, with leaders from all major parties — Congress, AAP, BJP, and SAD — engaging in a blame game, staging protests, and issuing sharp statements as the city struggles under mounting waste and public frustration. The crisis at the resource management centre (RMC) has turned into a political battleground. AAP councillor Sarabjit Singh Samana, son of local MLA Kulwant Singh, led a protest outside the RMC with a broom in hand, joined by residents demanding immediate action. Protesters shouted slogans against Congress mayor Amarjit Singh Jeeti Sidhu, holding him responsible for the worsening condition of cleanliness across the city. "Garbage is piling up everywhere. The rains have only worsened the situation, and public health is at risk," Samana said. Mayor Jeeti Sidhu hit back, accusing AAP of hypocrisy. "The AAP government controls the local bodies department. If Sarabjit Samana is genuinely concerned, he should ask his own government why they are not clearing pending agendas or releasing funds," the mayor stated. He added that repeated requests for more sanitation staff and resources had been ignored by the AAP-led state government. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like From Missing Every Conversation To Hearing Every Whisper With This $140 Device Top Trending News Today Learn More Undo The BJP also entered the fray, with district president Sanjeev Vashisht visiting the protest site and criticising both the Congress-run corporation and the AAP government. "While the mayor is nowhere to be seen, the people of Mohali are suffering. Both Congress and AAP are playing politics while the city drowns in filth," Vashisht said. Former Congress cabinet minister Balbir Singh Sidhu also weighed in, launching a scathing attack on the AAP MLA Kulwant Singh. "The MLA belongs to the ruling party. If he cannot get basic civic issues resolved despite being in power, he should resign. The people of Mohali deserve better," he said. Meanwhile, angry residents, facing uncollected garbage, stagnant water, and foul odours, expressed their dismay at the political drama. "Politicians from every party come here, shout slogans, and then leave. But the garbage remains," said BS Chawla, a resident of Phase 5. "We are the ones who suffer, while they fight among themselves." With the threat of disease outbreaks looming large, citizens have now appealed directly to MLA Kulwant Singh, chief minister Bhagwant Mann, and senior municipal officials to inspect the worst-affected areas and urgently deploy additional sanitation staff to prevent a public health crisis. As garbage continues to pile up and the monsoon adds to the mess, Mohali residents are demanding action over optics — real solutions instead of political stunts.
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
Rashbehari-to-college campus rally takes up entire road flank
Kolkata: Hundreds of BJP supporters on Wednesday afternoon marched down a 3-km route from Rashbehari crossing to the law college where a first-year student was gang-raped a week ago. The rally took place after the organisers — Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha (BJYM), the youth wing of BJP – obtained permission from the Calcutta High Court to protest against the sexual assault. Considering the commuters' woes, the HC had asked the police to ensure that the breadth of rallies must be restricted to a third of the road. However, one flank of the Rashbehari connector was shut completely on Wednesday, which paralysed traffic movement on the stretch for close to two hour. BJYM state president Indranil Khan told TOI: "Despite the HC's green signal, cops were not allowing our party workers to put up a stage on the opposite flank of the college. After talking to the police, we decided that our rally would pass on one flank of the road while the other flank would remain open for traffic movement." You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata The protest march began around 3.10 pm, and it took nearly an hour for the protestors to reach the mancha where opposition leader Suvendu Adhikari addressed the public. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Most Women Have No Idea This Household Item Fades Dark Spots Overnight Undo by Taboola by Taboola Adhikari said: "The rally evinced our strong protest against the rape of a law student by a student union leader and his accomplices. We demand justice for this heinous crime, and our fight against this injustice will not stop." The BJP leader, while demanding CM Mamata Banerjee's resignation, also mentioned that there would be a march to Nabanna next week and that he would request RG Kar rape victim Abhaya's parents to join the rally. According to Adhikari, BJP will organize North Bengal Abhiyan on July 21 — the day Trinamool is scheduled to observe Martyrs' Day. While Adhikari said the number of protestors was around 3,000, Trinamool claimed the turnout was not more than 750. While the protests ended at 5 pm, the ripple effect lingered for another hour. Several commuters, office-goers, including school students, were caught in snarls. Sutapa Majhi, a resident of Baguiati who was stuck in a bus, said: "I want the rape accused to be punished. But I am doubtful how effective such rallies will be." Sayak Deb, a student, was spotted walking home as no vehicle was moving. "I boarded a bus but had to get down as it was stuck," said the boy. Suman Saha, a trader at Gariahat market, rued: "Since traffic movement was disrupted due to the rally, customers stayed away."
