'Can you say it's criminal to love?': SC bats for distinction of rape from 'genuine' romance
A bench of Justices B V Nagarathna and R Mahadevan noted the existence of co-education institutions and universities and said, "Now, they develop feelings for each other. Can you say it is criminal to love? We have to keep a distinction between a criminal act like rape, etc., from this."
The observations came on a petition raising the question whether or not the age of consent, which is 18 years, should be reduced to 16 under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act.
"When there are genuine romantic cases, they like each other and they want to get married... Don't treat such cases the same as criminal cases," the bench said.
The bench went on, "You have to keep the reality of society in mind."
The top court referred to the trauma such couples face, generally owing to the male partner being sent to jail by the parents of the girl after filing a case under the POCSO Act.
"This is the harsh reality in society," the bench said, noting cases under the POCSO Act were also filed to cover up elopements.
Senior advocate H S Phoolka, appearing for the petitioner organisation, called for safeguards.
The bench observed that the police would look into the matters to ascertain whether it was a case of kidnapping, trafficking or whether it was a case of genuine love.
Phoolka said a similar issue concerning the age of consent was being considered by another bench of the apex court.
The bench posted the matter for August 26 after Phoolka said he would place on record some top court orders in the context of the prayers sought for in the petition.
Recently, the Centre defended in the apex court the statutory age of consent of 18 years, saying the decision was a "deliberate, well-considered, and coherent" policy choice aimed at shielding minors from sexual exploitation.
The Centre said diluting the age of consent or introducing exceptions under the guise of adolescent romance would be not only legally unsound but also dangerous.
The written submissions was filed in a separate case which raises the point of age in adolescent relationships.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
27 minutes ago
- Indian Express
A former prime minister of Mali is jailed on corruption allegations
A former prime minister of Mali was jailed Tuesday following allegations of corruption that he has denied, his lawyer told The Associated Press. Choguel Maïga, 67, led the civilian wing of the country's military junta until his November 2024 dismissal days after he criticized it for postponing elections. He has continued to publicly criticize it. His lawyer, Cheick Oumar Konaré, said the Supreme Court had notified the former prime minister of the charges filed against him by Mali's prosecutor general and ordered that he be placed in custody. The charges follow a report by the West African nation's auditor general on the management of public funds while Maïga was prime minister. No trial date has been set. Earlier this month, another former prime minister, Moussa Mara, was imprisoned after tweeting his support for jailed critics of the junta, which has ruled since coups in 2020 and the following year. In June, Gen. Assimi Goita was granted an additional five years in power despite the junta's earlier promises of a return to civilian rule by March 2024. The junta dissolved political parties in May.
News18
33 minutes ago
- News18
MEA Secy Kumaran to visit Colombia, Peru to boost bilateral ties
New Delhi [India], August 19 (ANI): Ministry of External Affairs' Secretary (East) P Kumaran will visit Colombia and Peru from August 21 to 26, 2025 to review various elements of growing bilateral relations.A MEA release said that during the visit, Secretary (East) is slated to meet with ministers and senior officials in the governments of Colombia and Peru and discuss areas of mutual interest, including in trade and commerce, mining, energy, health and pharmaceuticals, defence, infrastructure, cooperation in IT and digital sectors, apart from topics of mutual interest in the bilateral, regional and multilateral context. He would also be interacting with representatives of the business community and think release said that Colombia and Peru are India's important partners in the South American region with whom India has growing trade relations, with scope for diversification in trade, commerce and investment, including cooperation in energy, critical minerals and rare enjoys warm and friendly relations with both Colombia and Peru. The relationships are based on shared democratic values and growing cooperation in areas such as trade, energy, pharmaceuticals, IT, and capacity-building. The visit of Secretary (East) reflects India's continued commitment to enhancing its engagement with Latin America and the Caribbean region, the release said. (ANI)
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
With 32 Suicides In 31 Months Due To Online Gaming, Karnataka Faces Growing Crisis
On the surface, it begins with a phone game — just a few clicks on an app promising quick winnings. But online gambling in Karnataka today sits at the crossroads of law, livelihood, and loss. On one side are stories of ordinary families falling into debt traps so deep that lives are lost to shame and desperation. On another is the state govt, caught between public pressure to regulate and court battles over the limits of prohibition. Police records show 32 suicides linked to online gambling losses since 2023, nearly two-thirds of them in Bengaluru. Officers admit the number is likely far higher, hidden in missing-person cases and unreported deaths. Victims come from every walk of life: drivers, small businessmen, students, even salaried workers. Each case has the same cycle — borrowed money, mounting losses, shame, and no way out. While families crumble and psychiatrists warn of rising addiction among the young, who increasingly equate online identity with self-worth, the gaming industry is booming, its revenues set to double. At the heart of the debate is a question: has online gambling quietly grown into a social crisis? You Can Also Check: Bengaluru AQI | Weather in Bengaluru | Bank Holidays in Bengaluru | Public Holidays in Bengaluru | Gold Rates Today in Bengaluru | Silver Rates Today in Bengaluru Countless Lives Shattered The human toll is reflected in stark stories. In Feb this year, three members of a Mysuru family died within 24 hours. Joshi Antony recorded a video accusing his sister Sharmila and her husband Jobi of taking a loan of Rs 80 lakh in their widowed sister's name and losing it in online games. Hours after Joshi's suicide, the couple also ended their lives. In Jan, two men in Bengaluru, Mallikarjun, a lab technician, and Kumaraswamy, an auto driver, killed themselves after losing more than Rs 10 lakh each on rummy apps. Both had taken hand loans. Unable to face creditors, they gave up. In Aug 2024, Srinivas, a travel agent from Hassan, jumped with his wife and 11-year-old daughter into Hemavati canal. He had borrowed over Rs 15 lakh, lost it on online rummy, and could not repay. These are part of 32 gambling-linked suicides since 2023, 20 of which are in the state capital. Govt awaiting panel report Home minister G Parameshwara told the Legislative Assembly that the state is awaiting the recommendations of a committee headed by IPS officer Pronab Mohanty, expected in Sept, before deciding on regulation. Karnataka had earlier amended the Police Act in 2021 to ban online games, but the high court struck it down in 2022, calling the move unconstitutional and arbitrary. The state has challenged the order in the Supreme Court. "Online games are more dangerous than drugs," Parameshwara said, stressing the need to protect the youth. At the same time, IT-BT minister Priyank Kharge flagged the industry's growth potential. He said India's gaming business, valued at Rs 3.7 lakh-crore, could double to Rs 7.4 lakh-crore within three years, with 590 million gamers and 140 million paid users already active in 2024. Many cases not reported: Cops According to ADGP R Hitendra, the pattern is consistent: reckless play, mounting losses, deception at home, followed by overwhelming shame. "They lie to their families, borrow heavily, and when the truth comes out, they cannot face them," he said. A senior officer said the official count of 32 deaths is "far below reality." Many cases are hidden—either as missing persons or suicides where the gambling link is never established. Students, too, are being drawn in. "Show us one family that has benefited from online gambling. There are none," the officer added. Mental health impact Psychiatrist Shashidhar S Bilagi described how online gaming can progress from recreation to compulsion. "It begins as relaxation, but quickly becomes addictive," he said. Warning signs include irritability, anger when interrupted, poor academics, disrupted sleep cycles, and withdrawal from social life. Youngsters often justify their behaviour with distorted thoughts such as "worthless offline, important online." The result can be anxiety, depression, conduct disorders and, in some cases, suicidal tendencies. Bilagi stressed the need for "digital hygiene" — balancing online activity with real-world responsibilities. Nimhans runs a Service for Healthy Use of Technology (SHUT) clinic, and helplines like 14446 are available for those struggling. Industry Booming The India Gaming Report-2025 identifies Real Money Gaming (RMG) as the engine of growth, contributing 86% of industry revenue in 2024. Paying gamers grew at 18.5% annually between 2020 and 2024, and are expected to reach 292 million by 2029. RMG alone is projected to touch $7.3 billion by then. Of the $2.8 billion invested in Indian gaming firms since 2019, 90% has flowed into RMG. Analysts say the model has adapted swiftly to tax changes and is now entrenched as the backbone of the sector. WIDENING TRAP City/District 2023 2024 No. of suicides -2025 (Up to July 31) Total Bengaluru 4 9 7 20 Mangaluru 1 0 0 1 Kalaburagi 1 1 0 2 Hassan 0 1 1 2 Dharwad 1 0 1 2 Gadag 0 1 0 1 Davanagere 0 0 1 1 Uttara Kannada 2 0 0 2 Bidar 0 0 1 1 Total 9 12 11 32 Source: Karnataka state police Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
