&w=3840&q=100)
Rahul Gandhi agrees with Trump calling India 'dead economy'; allies differ
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has sparked a political row by echoing US President Donald Trump's controversial remark calling the Indian economy 'dead' -- a statement that has drawn disapproval not just from the ruling BJP, but also from his own party colleagues and opposition allies.
However, his remarks have seemingly not gone down well within the Congress party or the broader opposition coalition, the INDIA bloc, where several leaders have distanced themselves from both Trump's claim and Gandhi's statement.
Congress' Rajeev Shukla rebukes Trump
Senior Congress MP Rajeev Shukla dismissed Trump's comments outright, defending India's economic trajectory over the decades. 'Trump saying that the economies of India and Russia are dead is wrong. The Indian economy is not dead,' Shukla said, crediting a series of governments—from Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh to Atal Bihari Vajpayee -- for laying the foundation of India's economic reforms. 'Our economic condition is not at all weak,' he added.
Shukla also criticised Trump's trade policies, saying, 'Every nation has the right to trade with whom it wants. Restricting them and attacking Brics is not right. Trump is living in a delusion.'
Similarly, Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Priyanka Chaturvedi, a key INDIA bloc leader, took to social media to counter the 'dead economy' label. 'Not that one needs to say it -- there's enough legitimate data to know that the Indian economy is in the top 5 of the world and one of the fastest growing economies,' she wrote. 'Calling it a dead economy can only come from a position of arrogance or ignorance.'
Trump's outburst triggers diplomatic, political fallout
Trump's attack came as part of a broader criticism of India's defence and energy ties with Russia. 'India has always bought a vast majority of their military equipment from Russia,' he said, accusing New Delhi of maintaining some of the 'highest tariffs in the world' and 'obnoxious' trade barriers.
He also announced a sharp 25 per cent tariff on Indian imports to the US, which the Indian government said it is 'studying carefully'. The Commerce Ministry, in a statement, said India remains committed to negotiating a fair and balanced trade deal, and will take all necessary steps to protect its farmers, entrepreneurs, and MSMEs.
India's economic numbers tell a different story
Despite the political heat, data points to a very different picture than Trump's claim. As of 2025, India has overtaken Japan to become the world's fourth-largest economy with a GDP of $4.19 trillion. It is projected to be the third-largest by 2030.
Even trade with Russia, which Trump criticised, has grown significantly -- from $10.1 billion pre-pandemic to $68.7 billion in FY25, largely due to crude oil, fertilisers, and metal imports.
However, brokerage firms like Nomura and Barclays warn that Trump's new tariffs could shave off 20–30 basis points from India's GDP growth in 2025–26.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
2 minutes ago
- Hans India
Owaisi says fresh US tariffs on India will hurt Indian exporters, deter FDI, hit jobs hard
Hyderabad: AIMIM president Asaduddin Owaisi on Thursday said US President Donald Trump's decision to impose 50 per cent tariff on Indian goods will hurt Indian exporters, MSMEs, manufacturers and will disrupt supply chains, deter FDI, and hit jobs hard. A day after Trump imposed a penalty of another 25 per cent on India for buying Russian oil, Owaisi said Trump just slapped another 25 per cent tariff on India, taking it to 50 per cent, because 'we bought oil from Russia'. In a post on X, the Hyderabad MP said 'This isn't diplomacy, it's bullying by the buffoon-in-chief who clearly doesn't understand how global trade works". These tariffs will hurt Indian exporters, MSMEs, and manufacturers. It'll disrupt supply chains, deter FDI, and hit jobs hard. But why will Narendra Modi care? Where are those BJP muscle-flexers now?" the AIMIM chief asked. "Last time I'd asked if Modi ji would show his 56-inch chest when Trump imposed 56% tariffs. Trump stopped at 50%. Maybe he's scared of our non-biological PM? Was selling out our strategic autonomy worth filling your friends' billionaire coffers?" he further said. Trump on Wednesday slapped an additional 25 per cent tariff on goods coming from India as penalty for New Delhi's continued purchase of Russian oil, a move that is likely to hit sectors such as textiles, marine and leather exports hard. Trump signed an executive order - Addressing Threats to the US by the Government of the Russian Federation - imposing the additional tariff over and above the 25 per cent levy, which comes into effect from August 7. After this order, the total tariff on Indian goods, barring a small exemption list, will be 50 per cent.
Hans India
2 minutes ago
- Hans India
Sensex and Nifty Rebound After Sharp Fall on Hopes of India-US Trade Talks
On Thursday, the Indian stock market went down in the morning, with both the Sensex and the Nifty nosediving. Sensex fell by more than 700 points but later went up and closed at 80,623. Nifty also went down by over 200 points but ended above 24,500. Experts say the market improved because people are hopeful that India and the US will have trade talks soon.
Hans India
2 minutes ago
- Hans India
Initiatives like IMEC needed especially in times of volatility, uncertainty: Italy's envoy Talo'
New Delhi: The ambitious India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor project was started with a "lot of hope" and such initiatives are needed especially in times of volatility and uncertainty driven by global security challenges, Italy's envoy for IMEC, Francesco Talo' said. In an exclusive interview to PTI Videos at the Italian Embassy here on Wednesday, he also said that less than a month after its launch in New Delhi in 2023, there was a "terrible attack" against Israel on October 7, and this impacted the project. "Therefore, things were slipping, frozen. But, now there is a renewed interest," the envoy said. The Israel-Hamas conflict still goes on, and the Middle East (or West Asia) region has seen wide-scale volatility and uncertainty over the last two years, including the recent twelve-day military confrontation between Israel and Iran in June. "I would say that especially in times of volatility or uncertainty, we need projects like this (IMEC). We need to have a differentiation. We need to be ready to play on different grounds. So, not to be conditioned only by one route, by one interlocutor," Talo' told PTI in the interview. Cautioning that in times of great inter-dependence today, he underlined that one needs to be on one hand "not too dependent" on any one option, and on the other hand, need to live in a system of inter-dependence. Talo', a seasoned diplomat, visited India earlier this week to take part in a meeting of representatives of countries which are partners in the IMEC initiative. He also met India's deputy National Security Advisor. "I have had meetings with part of the administration, especially with people in the National Security Council and the external affairs ministry. And I'm planning to meet other people today (Wednesday) in order to better understand the importance of our partner India," he added. So it's good that in this very city, the "first meeting" among the special envoys of IMEC was held, the diplomat said. "I was here when the initiative was launched in September 2023. I was with my Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. And, we had a clear vision of a great opportunity for our countries, for our shared interests," Talo' said, adding, IMEC was started with a "lot of hope" and it was very much linked to the idea of having important political and economic results. And, this is the moment really to have a "transition" from a phase of conferences, interviews, and some public events to a "more concrete phase of action", he asserted. Billed as a pathbreaking initiative, the IMEC envisages a vast road, railroad and shipping networks among Saudi Arabia, India, the US and Europe with an aim to ensure integration among Asia, Middle East and the West. The IMEC initiative was firmed up on the sidelines of the G20 Summit in Delhi in September 2023. An agreement was signed by India, Saudi Arabia, the European Union, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), the US and some other G20 partners for the corridor. EU signatories Italy, France, and Germany are partners in this transnational connectivity project. Many strategic affairs watchers have described the IMEC as perhaps an answer to China's massive Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), a mega infrastructure and connectivity project that will involve a large number of countries. Asked about his views on BRI, Talo' described it as "another project" and different from IMEC. "They are different by nature. Their members are different. So, I don't want to.. I don't like the idea of presenting IMEC as something against them. It's something for us, for our partners, for our peoples. And, then there can be other initiatives," he said. Italy had joined BRI in 2019. According to international reports, it had announced its withdrawal from it, four years later. Talo' emphasised that when it comes to realising the IMEC vision, there are financial challenges and practical infrastructure challenges. "It involves several countries. We all know that it's not going to be simple," he said. "But it could be a great opportunity, because we see great prospects of growth for all of us," the envoy said. Talo' underlined that one cannot have real security and peace "when only one nation is rich". There is need for entire region to grow, and of course innovation can somehow be the lead for these changes for the better. "We are already seeing this in India," he said. The Gulf countries are also important protagonists, actors in innovation. "We can do it all together, and this will also benefit countries which have more problems," the envoy said, adding, this can somehow also "contribute to the peace process". During the interaction, he also shared the reasons for Italy pitching its coastal city of Trieste as a "possible principal hub" in this corridor. Also, India, the Middle East, and at least Italy and the Mediterranean countries in the same region, which "I like to call the Indo-Mediterranean region, we have a common interest that is an area of growing prosperity where, for instance, navigation and trade is free and open", Talo' said. Italy, along with three other IMEC partner countries are also part of the powerful G7. "Of course, the G7 countries can offer a contribution... Furthermore, I think it's important to take into account the role of the European Union with its Global Gateway initiative. So, the idea is that IMEC can be put under the umbrella of the Global Gateway," he said. In November 2024, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, in his address, on the occasion of inauguration of the new Chancery of the Embassy of India in Rome, had referred to the proposed India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor (IMEC). The minister had said that this connectivity corridor, which was agreed to in principle during India's presidency of the G20, will be a game changer between Europe and Asia.
