Caste census: Pasmanda Muslims may be counted as OBCs
'Pasmanda Muslims will be given their due share in the national caste census,' said a senior BJP leader. Leaders of the BJP Minority Morcha and OBC Morcha confirmed the same.
'As per the Mandal Commission recommendations, some groups among Muslims are included in the state and Central list of Backward Classes. These Muslims will be enumerated as such in the caste census (among OBCs),' K Laxman, the national president of the BJP's OBC Morcha, told The Indian Express.
The national president of the BJP Minority Morcha, Jamal Siddiqui, said: 'Pasmanda Muslims too are citizens of this country. So they will be enumerated as per their backwardness in the caste census.'
So far, all Census undertaken by the government, including the last one in 2011, included Muslims as a separate, single bloc. The move is significant as the BJP, which is accused of being anti-minority, has been wooing Pasmanda Muslims, with Prime Minister Narendra Modi leading the way. Enumerating them as OBCs, entitles them to the quota for OBCs.
'Pasmanda', a Persian word, means the 'ones left behind', and is used to describe depressed classes among the Muslims. The Sachar Committee in its report put the number of OBC and SC/ST Muslims at 40% (all India 2004-05). But Pasmanda activists and scholars say that the Pasmandas make up 80-85% of the total Muslim population in India.
This broadly tallies with the 1871 Census that said only 19% of Muslims in India were upper caste, while 81% were made up of the lower castes.
While confirming that Pasmandas may be counted as OBCs in the caste census, Laxman made a distinction between the surveys conducted by Bihar and Telangana, both of which counted Pasmanda Muslims among backward classes.
The national enumeration cannot be 'as haphazard as was done in the Telangana caste survey', he said. In Telangana, where the Congress government of Revanth Reddy carried out the caste survey, 81% of the Muslims were found to be Pasmanda. According to Laxman, 'In Telangana, the government was trying to appease Muslims and included almost all of them under the Pasmanda Muslim category. Muslims were once rulers of Hyderabad. How can rulers be OBCs?'
The Bihar caste survey, which put Pasmandas at 73% of the Muslim population, was more of 'an example to emulate', Laxman said. While the Mahagathbandhan government including the Congress and RJD was in power when the Bihar caste survey was carried out, the Chief Minister then was Nitish Kumar, who is now a BJP ally.
Incidentally, at his press conference Wednesday after the government's caste census announcement, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi had urged it to emulate the Telangana survey.
Another leader of the BJP Minority Morcha said that Pasmanda Muslims are already included in some state lists for reservation. 'For instance, Mapila is an OBC in Kerala. But among the Muslim population in Kerala, we don't have figures on the number of Mapilas as Muslims have been considered a single backward bloc,' the leader said.
Supporting such a distinction for Pasmanda Muslims, a Pasmanda Muslim activist said the Ashraf Muslims (who are seen as the 'elite'), and Pasmanda Muslims, including the Ajiafs (Backward Muslims) and Arzals (Dalit Muslims), cannot be considered as a single bloc.
'The caste census will help bring out the difference. Pasmanda is a term which in India has largely stood for Backward Class Muslims, who are marginalised due to their socio-economic backgrounds,' he said.
However, Ali Anwar Ansari, seen as among the foremost Pasmanda Muslim leaders, told The Indian Express, 'What is the point of just enumerating Pasmanda Muslims in a separate category? Some state lists of OBCs already do this. The Central government should ideally look for socio-economic upliftment of Pasmanda Muslims, by including Dalit Muslims in the Scheduled Caste list, for example. They are not ready to do this.'
IUML MP Haris Beeran said the inclusion of Pasmanda Muslims among OBCs would be another bid to bring 'some kind of a division within the community'. 'When the Supreme Court itself has said that Muslims as a group are backward, what is the rationale for subdividing them without giving any inkling of uplifting the community?'
It was from Telangana that the BJP's Pasmanda outreach incidentally began. In 2022, addressing a BJP National Executive in Hyderabad, PM Modi urged party leaders to reach out to marginalised Muslims.
During the Lok Sabha campaign last year, while speaking in Aligarh, Modi accused the Congress and ally Samajwadi Party (SP) of 'marginalising Pasmanda Muslims' and said the community 'must be given opportunities'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scroll.in
11 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
In May crackdown on ‘foreigners', only Bengali-origin Muslims sent to Assam detention centre
On May 24, the Matia detention centre began to fill up as the Assam police launched a drive to round up alleged illegal immigrants in the state. Over the next few days, reports appeared of Bengali-origin Muslims held at the centre being taken to India's border with Bangladesh and being forced to cross over at gunpoint. Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma told the Assembly that 303 'foreigners' had been pushed into Bangladesh. But he did not disclose their identities. Scroll filed a Right to Information query with the office of the Inspector-General of Prisons, Assam, asking for information on the number of detainees at the Matia centre, details of their cases, and when they were admitted inside. We also asked for detailed information on those who had been released, deported or 'pushed' into Bangladesh since April 2025. The Assam government's reply to our questions was incomplete. It did not share any information about those forced to cross the border into Bangladesh. However, it gave us a list of those detained at the Matia detention centre between May 27 and July 8. All 53 of them are Muslims. The RTI response Most of those rounded up in that crackdown were declared foreigners like the 51-year-old teacher from Morigaon, Khairul Islam, who was arrested and then forced out of Indian territory. Declared foreigners are typically long-term residents with families and properties in Assam, who have failed to prove that they are Indian citizens before the state's foreigners tribunals. Islam was forced out even though his case, challenging the foreigners tribunal order, was pending in the Supreme Court. Similarly, Shona Bhanu, a 59-year-old resident of Barpeta, was expelled from Indian territory. Both had told Scroll that they were first kept at the Matia camp before being taken to the no man's land between India and Bangladesh. However, the Assam government does not seem to have acknowledged these arrests, let alone their being expelled from India. The Assam prisons department informed Scroll that 53 declared foreigners were arrested and admitted in the camp on May 27, 28 and 29and July 8, all of them Muslims. However, the RTI reply has no record of Islam and Bhanu being admitted to the camp in May. Moreover, when Scroll put together an Assam government affidavit in the Supreme Court and the information from the RTI response, it became clear – in the last nearly 12 months, only Muslim declared foreigners have faced arrest and incarceration in Assam. The CAA model Foreigner tribunals are quasi-judicial bodies unique to Assam, which rule on citizenship cases. They have been accused of arbitrariness and bias, and declaring people foreigners on the basis of minor spelling mistakes, a lack of documents or lapses in memory. Many of the appeals to FT orders are pending in the higher courts. In the last five decades, Assam's foreigners tribunals have declared 1.6 lakh people as non-citizens, of whom 69,559 are Hindus. In recent years, several declared foreigners had been released from imprisonment after the Supreme Court and the Gauhati High Court ruled against their prolonged incarceration. But that changed in August 2024. The Assam government began a renewed crackdown on declared foreigners, who were arrested and sent to the Matia detention centre. By September 2024, the number of detained declared foreigners at Matia, the largest detention centre in India, had increased by four times to 72. However, all the newly arrested declared foreigners, who were sent to the detention centre in August, were Muslims, according to the Assam government affidavit filed before the Supreme Court on February 3 this year. The admission list at the Matia centre, which is maintained by the camp authorities and was seen by Scroll, also showed that only Muslim declared foreigners were admitted following the crackdown. As is evident from the RTI response from the Assam prisons headquarters, the May crackdown leading to 'pushbacks' followed the same pattern. The decision to spare Hindu declared foreigners is in line with the Assam government's implementation of the contentious Citizenship Amendment Act, which had triggered fierce protests from Assamese nationalists in 2019 . For instance, in July 2024, the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party government asked the state's border police not to forward cases of non-Muslims who had entered India illegally before 2014 to foreigners tribunals. As Scroll had reported, this was a clear sign of the Assam government putting in place a citizenship regime that excludes Muslims. Last month, too, the Assam Government asked district authorities and members of the foreigners tribunals to drop cases against the members of six non-Muslim communities who are granted amnesty under CAA. While Assamese nationalists were opposed to all immigrants, whether Hindu or Muslim, Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma has raised the alarm against 'Muslim infiltration'. 'In Assam, we are fearlessly resisting the ongoing, unchecked Muslim infiltration from across the border, which has already caused an alarming demographic shift. In several districts, Hindus are now on the verge of becoming a minority in their own land.' No Rohingyas In May, Scroll had reported that all the Rohingya detainees had been expelled from the detention centre even though their cases were pending in the courts. The Assam prison headquarters' reply confirms that there are no Rohingya inmates at Matia. As of July 23, of the 110 inmates at Matia, three are 'convicted foreigners', 80 declared foreigners and 27 Chin refugees. But on April 24 this year, there were 103 Rohingya refugees – 37 of them children – at the Matia camp, according to the lists maintained by the detention centre, which were accessed by Scroll. The department said there is 'no record available pertaining' to whether the refugees were deported or pushed across into Bangladesh. Scroll had reported that they were expelled from the detention centre without following due process. Sarma had announced that several inmates of the Matia detention centre in Assam, including Rohingya refugees, were 'pushed back' into Bangladesh as part of a countrywide 'operation' by the Indian government.
Hindustan Times
11 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Haryana: Khattar defends electoral roll revision, accuses Cong of protecting fake voters
Union power minister Manohar Lal Khattar on Sunday slammed the Congress for their campaign against the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, accusing them of protecting their 'vote bank of illegal infiltration and intruders.' Union power minister Manohar Lal Khattar (HT File) Addressing media in Karnal, Khattar said that the Election Commission of India had launched a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) drive to remove the names of fake and deceased persons from the voter rolls. 'The Congress party is protesting against this move in Bihar as they were getting fake votes. It seems that Congress has believed in getting fake votes, but now the public is aware of their tactics,' he added. The former chief minister also stated that the law and order situation is under control in the state and that the police are working to arrest the attackers of Manisha, who was found dead in Bhiwani district. Refuting Khattar's allegations, Rohtak MP and Congress leader Deepender Hooda said that the SIR in Bihar is an institutionalised theft of votes and that the same process was implemented in the Haryana and Maharashtra elections. 'The ECI and other bodies are working as partners of the ruling BJP. We are also examining the list of voters in Haryana and evidence of vote theft will be brought before the public soon. The SIR's objective is to take away the voting rights of the poor, but the BJP's theft has been exposed,' Hooda added.
Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
New Uttarakhand Bill to do away with Madrasa Board, extend minority education benefits beyond Muslims
The Uttarakhand Cabinet has approved a decision to introduce the Uttarakhand Minority Educational Institutions Bill, 2025, which, among other aspects, will repeal the Madrasa Board and the rules governing the minority-run institutions in the state. According to an official communication, the proposed Bill aims to extend the benefits of Minority Educational Institutions status to the minority communities other than Muslims. This has sparked concern among Muslim groups that the proposed law might result in erosion of their rights under Articles 26 and 30 of the Constitution that provide rights to run educational institutions and manage religious affairs. The proposed Bill, if enacted, will also permit the study of Gurmukhi and Pali in recognised minority educational institutions from July 1 next year and will also lead to the dissolution of the Uttarakhand Madrasa Education Board Act, 2016, and the Uttarakhand Non-Government Arabic and Persian Madrasa Recognition Rules, 2019. The rules empower the Madrasa Board to chart the syllabus, set guidelines, conduct examinations, and inspect madrasas to ensure they fulfil eligibility criteria. At present, the board has a Recognition Committee that deals with granting recognition to madrasas. 'The committee shall have a member nominated by the 13-member board, an 'academician-rank' member, the deputy registrar, and a 'headmaster-rank' member,' the rules of the board state. The proposed Bill is likely to make recognition of the institution null and void as it allows Sikhs, Jains, Christians, Buddhists and Parsis to run minority educational institutions as against the current provision only for Muslims. At present, 452 'recognised' madrasas operate across the state. It also mandates educational institutions to obtain recognition from the 'concerned authority' to qualify as minority educational institutions. It also requires the educational institution to be registered under the Societies Act, Trust Act, or Companies Act while ownership of land, bank accounts and other assets to be in the institution's name. 'Recognition can be withdrawn in cases of financial mismanagement, lack of transparency, or activities against religious and social harmony,' the communication read. The Dhami government's move to introduce the Bill comes six months after it started a madrasa-sealing drive to shut institutions not recognised by the board or the education department. The Recognition Committee, which had not met since 2020, convened a meeting on February 27, a day before the drive began, leading to 'unrecognised' madrasas being shut. Expressing concern, Jamiat Ulema-i-Hind's state secretary Khurshid Ahmed said, 'Initially, the Uniform Civil Code curbed the right to practice the religion, the anti-conversion Act will further depreciate the situation. With the madrasa board being nullified, religious education will be hampered. The (Pushkar Singh Dhami) government has been implementing policies to erode the rights that the Constitution guarantees under Articles 25 to 30. We will analyse the Bill once it is introduced and assess if it needs to be legally challenged.' The state government, however, claims that the Bill is aimed at 'establishing a transparent process for granting recognition to educational institutions set up by minority communities in the state, while ensuring quality and excellence in education'. State BJP chief Mahendra Bhatt said the legislation mirrors the BJP's motto of 'sabka saath, sabka vikas (everyone together, development for all)' and will 'safeguard the Constitutional rights of minorities'. 'Until now, only Muslims reaped the benefits of minority educational institutions. The proposed Bill will ensure that other minority communities also benefit. The Bill is important as several irregularities and scams with regard to educational institutions have come to light in the recent past,' he said. Terming the move 'unfortunate' and 'politically motivated', former Uttarakhand CM and senior Congress leader Harish Rawat called for modernisation of the madrasa board. 'Madrasas are supplementary to our education system. Just like Sanskrit schools, where scholars are made, madrasas give birth to scholars of religious philosophy. If the board has shortcomings, rectify it. The Bill is being tabled as the BJP is upset with its performance in the recent panchayat polls,' he said.
