
Premier League refereeing errors fall to all-time LOW as worst-hit team revealed – and it's not Arsenal
UNDER REVIEW Premier League refereeing errors fall to all-time LOW as worst-hit team revealed – and it's not Arsenal
REFEREEING errors fell to an all-time low in the Premier League last season - despite a series of controversies.
According to the Prem's 'Key Match Incident Panel' - made up of former players, managers and refs - there were just 18 VAR errors over the 380 matches of the 2024-25 campaign.
6
Bruno Fernandes was wrongly sent off for a foul on James Maddison
Credit: Getty
6
The Panel admitted it was incorrect to send off Myles Lewis-Skelly against Wolves
Credit: PA
6
West Ham's last-gasp penalty against Man Utd was another mistake
Credit: Alamy
That was a 42 per cent drop on the 31 errors in 2023-24 and further down on the 35 mistakes assessed in the previous campaign.
The panel looks at every major decision on goals, penalties and red cards, determining if the call by the onfield officials or the VAR was correct or flawed.
SunSport understands the reduction was largely down to fewer missed VAR interventions on subjective decisions, although there were occasions in which Stockley Park wrongly recommended a change of call.
Missed interventions included the red cards for Manchester United skipper Bruno Fernandes against Spurs, Arsenal left-back Myles Lewis-Skelly's dismissal at Wolves and the last minute penalty winner for West Ham that spelled the end for Old Trafford boss Erik ten Hag.
READ MORE IN FOOTBALL
GROUND BREAKING Premier League club set to get green light for £130m stadium expansion
The KMI ruled that the VAR should have stepped in to recommend red cards for Brighton's Joao Pedro against Brentford and Everton's James Tarkowski in the final Goodison Merseyside derby.
Brentford were the biggest sufferers, with three mistakes which should have been changed in their favour, with Everton the beneficiaries of three errors.
There were a number of occasions in which the KMI Panel agreed that the on-field decision was wrong but did not meet the threshold for a VAR intervention.
The numbers will doubtless be met with disbelief from Arsenal fans who remain insistent that PGMOL have an agenda against them.
JOIN SUN VEGAS: GET £50 BONUS
But the costly second yellow cards for Declan Rice and Leandro Trossard against Brighton and Manchester City respectively did not come under the scrutiny of the Panel.
Changes to time-keeping last season saw an average of nine minutes and 45 seconds of stoppage time per game, down 108 seconds from the previous season.
The campaign saw 105 added time goals across the 380 matches, 40 fewer than in 2023-24.
But VAR checks were significantly speeded up, with the average delay per match due to VAR down to 39 seconds from 64 seconds in the previous season.
6
VAR should have sent off Joao Pedro for his elbow
Credit: Reuters
6
Arsenal were not on the wrong end of the most wrong decisions
Credit: Getty

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
32 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Forgotten Celtic flop seals bumper transfer 18 months on from horror Parkhead stint as he ends nine-year spell with club
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THE 2023/24 season was one that brought a league and cup double to Celtic. But while there was widespread success in Brendan Rodgers' first season back, not everything went exactly to plan. Sign up for the Celtic newsletter Sign up 3 Nat Phillips endured a tricky time of things at Celtic Credit: Kenny Ramsay 3 Phillips had been with Liverpool since 2016 Credit: Getty Despite Celtic's impressive campaign, many of the players signed ahead of the season haven't gone on to hit the heights that might've been expected. Luis Palma, Gustaf Lagerbielke and Odin Thiago Holm were among the big summer recruits. They'd enjoy more success in the January window with Nicolas Kuhn and Adam Idah the two big name arrivals. One player who left the Celts that month was Nat Phillips. The big defender's departure brought an end to a torrid loan spell from Liverpool. A defensive injury crisis towards the end of the summer transfer window saw Rodgers enter the market for centre-back cover. And on deadline day, Phillips arrived on a short-term loan deal from Liverpool. But Phillips, 28, would go on to endure a tough time of things at Celtic Park. His five-month stint ended with Phillips having made just eight appearances for the Hoops in all competitions. Phillips' last appearance was a particularly torrid one, as he netted an own goal in a 2-1 defeat to Kilmarnock at Rugby Park in a game where he struggled badly. Celtic icon Peter Grant lifts the lid on former teammate Mo Johnston's shocking move to Rangers and reveals whether he's forgiven him for it Having made his senior debut for Liverpool in 2019, Phillips had failed to enjoy a regular run of first team football during his career. A defensive crisis at Anfield saw him play 20 times in the 2020/21 campaign, but he'd feature just a further eight times in all competitions for the club. He had short loan spells at Stuttgart and Bournemouth before moving on another loan to Cardiff immediately after his Celtic exit. Last season, Phillips finally enjoyed a campaign of regular action. That was during a season-long loan at Derby County, where he played 33 times to help the Rams maintain their Championship status. Now, he's on the move again and this time it's permanent. 3 Phillips has sealed a £3million move to West Brom on a three-year deal. The Baggies will be hoping to mount a promotion challenge under new boss Ryan Mason this coming season. They've been out of the top tier since being relegated in 2021. Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page


BBC News
38 minutes ago
- BBC News
Man Utd make improved £60m bid for Spurs target Mbeumo
Manchester United have submitted an improved bid of more than £60m for Brentford striker Bryan Tottenham boss Thomas Frank was keen to be reunited with Mbeumo, while there has also been interest in the forward from other Champions League this month, United had an offer of £45m, plus up to £10m in add-ons, rejected for the have suggested Brentford would want at least the £62.5m fee Wolves received for Matheus Cunha before they agree to the sale of a player who still has a year left on his contract.


Daily Mail
43 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Mark Clattenburg names 'nasty' Real Madrid star as his favourite defender of all time
Podcast All episodes Veteran Premier League referee Mark Clattenburg named a crafty Real Madrid legend as his favourite defender of all time on the latest episode of Whistleblowers. Whistleblowers is football's most original new podcast, hosted by Mark Clattenburg alongside Mail Sport Football Editor Ian Ladyman and broadcaster Gordon Smart. Debating which centre back was the greatest of all time, Clattenburg championed 'nasty' Portuguese defender Pepe. Over his 229 appearances for Real Madrid, Pepe won 15 major trophies but developed a notorious reputation with officials for his feisty tackling and behaviour. 'The best centre half I ever saw, even though he could be quite nasty, was Pepe,' the former official revealed. 'I watched him at Euro 2024, the last international tournament he played in, and he was incredible for his age at 41. 'What I liked about him was that he was an incredible pro – he achieved an awful lot. It was like the ball was glued to him, every ball that went in, he was at the other end of. Football's most original new podcast: Whistleblowers Hosted by Gordon Smart, with ex-referee Mark Clattenburg and Mail journalist Ian Ladyman, this isn't another safe roundtable of punditry. It's football told differently - with insight, authority, and plenty of laughs. Listen wherever you get your podcasts now. 'As a referee, I had run-ins with him. In the Champions League final in particular – but he was just an incredible centre half.' Pepe returned from a thigh injury to deliver a man-of-the-match performance in Portugal's Euro 2016 final victory over France, a match Clattenburg refereed. Clattenburg also officiated the defender during Real Madrid's 2016 Champions League final victory over Atlético Madrid. He controversially awarded a dubious penalty against Pepe for a tackle on former Liverpool forward Fernando Torres – which Atlético scored to level the match. When asked who he would pair with Pepe for the ultimate defensive partnership, Clattenburg suggested Vincent Kompany, arguing that the Belgian's ball-playing ability would complement the Portuguese defender's tenacity. 'I would want a shot stopper and a ball player', Clattenburg explained. 'I like Vincent Kompany alongside Pepe. Kompany had a great attitude, very different to Pepe.' While Clattenburg favoured more recent defenders, co-host Ian Ladyman delved further back in football history for his best defender, naming Liverpool stalwart Alan Hansen. Hansen won eight league titles, three European Cups, two FA Cups, and four League Cups during his decade-plus spell at Liverpool, establishing himself as one of the most decorated centre-backs in English football history. Ladyman explained: 'You can't look past Alan Hansen. Literally, you couldn't get past him. 'What a footballer: wonderful reader of the game. He was brave, athletic, probably could have played in about seven positions. 'A great passer of the ball, a leader. He would always look pristine after a game because he would never have to go to ground – he was that good.' Alongside Hansen, Ladyman named a controversial Liverpool-Manchester United defensive pairing, choosing Nemanja Vidić for his physicality. Ladyman argued: 'If you have a stylish distributor of the ball, you need someone next to him who can scare the life out of people. 'I would go with Vidic – he could head the ball; he was a monster in the tackle.' To hear more debates like this one, including which single player had the greatest impact on football, search for the latest episode of Whistleblowers now – available wherever you get your podcasts.