logo
Buying a Prefab ADU Was Supposed to Be Easier Than This

Buying a Prefab ADU Was Supposed to Be Easier Than This

Business Mayor05-05-2025

A few months ago, Vanessa Gibbons contacted Meka Modular, a San Jose, California, prefab builder, only to discover that something seemed off. She and her dad were planning on having an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) built in Joshua Tree, and Meka's designs 'were simple and affordable, so I reached out,' she told us via email. But after an initial phone call with the business owner, Gibbons received 'an informal email saying he could have his accounting reach out for payment if I was ready to move forward. I replied asking for photos of projects built in the past year and have not received a response.'
Eventually, she did hear back. 'As we changed all our models last year with a new line up [sic] we have none installed yet. We have numerous under permit currently and they should be installed in the field in the next few month [sic],' he wrote. The company 'is not listed on the Better Business Bureau,' Gibbons says, and 'has no pictures of actual houses, just renderings.'
Reddit threads echo her bewildering experience, including this comment from 'jupiteroot' three years ago: 'I had my '15 minute' call with them 3 weeks ago and have not been able to get a single question answered since. My impression is that they will not go any further unless you pay the $2750 feasibility study fee.'
Over much of the last decade, ADU production has exploded, especially in California, in response to the housing crisis. (Dwell even built one of its own.) But with it has come countless ambitious small startups with big plans, many of which are exposing industry pitfalls that signal caution for consumers like Gibbons. As with Meka, which Dwell featured online in 2019, some provide eye-catching renderings that seemingly never materialize, while others have left a trail of unrefunded deposits on unproduced projects, financial falters, and even criminal fraud accusations. Sometimes, too, startups that belly up end up liquidating their assets or filing a type of bankruptcy that pays off investors first, leaving customers in the lurch.
Last year, for example, Multitaskr, an ADU builder formed in 2020 in Chula Vista, California, abruptly closed after its license was revoked and it was accused of bilking customers out of more than $15 million. Allegations posted on LinkedIn by a former employee, Anna Zúñiga, offer a rare glimpse into the company's operating conditions. 'Twenty 'active' projects had been stalled for over a year, with homeowners growing increasingly frustrated,' she wrote. 'The problems ran deep: thirty projects from early 2020 didn't have their plans submitted for permits within the originally provided timeline—a fact hidden from customers. Our construction team was too small to handle the workload, and cash flow problems prevented hiring additional staff.'
Connect Homes installs a home in Malibu after the Woolsey Fires.
Before the company liquidated, Connect Homes cofounder Jared Levy gave a revealing interview early last year with Builder commenting on the future of prefab: 'Right now, we are an industry that is uncomfortably stuck somewhere … between the construction process and an industrialized process,' he said. 'If we want prefab to skew more toward being an industrialized product … we won't get there through automation and robots. We will get there by changing the regulatory environment for building prefab homes. And when we do, someone can do their research, pick their manufacturer, order a house, and have it delivered the next week.' Venturing Too Far Too Fast?
But it's not that simple, yet. Permitting processes remain time-consuming, and can be especially challenging for ambitious new ADU builders. While venture capital can help get a company off the ground, many new prefab ADU builders borne by it are beholden to investors to scale up quickly to achieve returns, before they gain experience with the unique challenges of ADU development.
'Building the local relationships needed for efficient permitting and installation is critical,' says Noerena Limón, CEO of Casita Coalition, a California multisector nonprofit that works to advance middle housing. 'The successful prefab builders understand this part of the work and set realistic expectations with investors on timelines for returns and the need for factory capacity to keep pace with customer commitments.'
One cautionary tale from the mid-2010s is that of Kasita, an Austin, Texas, start-up founded by environmental science professor turned entrepreneur Jeff Wilson that courted venture capital, raising $11.5 million in the process to fund its idea for affordable plug-and-play micro-housing. The concept was widely celebrated by the design community, and many expected it to 'disrupt the urban landscape' and possibly revolutionize the housing industry. Eventually, Kasita was sold, and it never produced a single ADU.
Prefabricated and stackable, Kasita's units promised a solution to America's affordable housing crisis.
As Levy pointed out, the industry's inherent challenges are already considerable; and through their lack of experience, venture capital backed home building start-ups might not be the best way to deliver prefab homes at scale to consumers because of the vagaries of the industry itself. 'The idea of a construction company raising money from venture capital investors is relatively new,' says Liz Young, getting at the idea that this is still uncharted territory. Young is the founder of Realm, a, yes, venture-backed company, one that uses advanced technology and data analysis to help guide clients through construction processes, but does not build homes. Regardless, 'modular and prefab is extremely promising and is one of the most affordable housing options, but we still need to mature the ADU ecosystem,' adds Limón. Small Scale
Dan Fitzpatrick serves as president of the nonprofit Tiny Home Industry Association, whose members include owners of small traditional construction businesses in each state. The group advocates to legitimize tiny homes (which are sometimes prefab, and used as ADUs) as viable housing and promotes best practices. 'If we hear of issues with bad actors, we try to get the word out,' says Fitzpatrick. Read More Concept Sketching for Industrial Design, an Online Course
One notable 'bad actor' in Colorado, Holy Ground Tiny Homes shuttered after filing for bankruptcy in 2022, leaving almost 200 former customers on the hook for $6 million. The company, which enjoyed status as a Christian nonprofit, had convinced them '… to pay full or partial deposits for tiny homes, delayed building those homes for months or years, and refused to refund the deposits,' according to Business Den. 'Some Holy Ground victims, who are spread across the country, lost their life savings.'
You can almost hear Fitzpatrick shake his head over the phone.
In any case, he says more of his association members are getting into modular construction instead, '… for multiple reasons, including better acceptance of the product they're creating by local building officials, and more efficient use of labor. Also, more and more, the ability to re-use modules when deconstructing a home is a plus.'
'Modular and prefab is extremely promising and is one of the most affordable housing options, but we still need to mature the ADU ecosystem.'
—Noerena Limón, housing advocate
Like many of his peers, Fitzpatrick has noticed a proliferation of dubious online advertising through third-party vendors, including Amazon, hawking ADU and tiny house kits. For example, the Las Vegas, Nevada, company Boxabl advertises, solicits investment, and even promotes an 'affiliate program' that rewards online user engagement—all through social media platforms. Lauded by the likes of Elon Musk, who purchased one of its 'casitas' in 2022, the company has faced much scrutiny since first delivering 156 of its units to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in 2020. Last year, the SEC charged a former employee for fraudulently offering securities in the company. (Boxabl has not responded to a request for comment.)
'What consumers need to ascertain before they click the buy button is—are they getting a shed in a box or a unit that meets the building code requirements in their municipality?' says Fitzpatrick. That applies in the real world, too: 'They need to ask up front, to what standard are they being built and what independent firm is certifying it? That separates the wheat from the chaff.'
While navigating the ADU market may seem fraught with risk, prospective consumers can do much to educate and protect themselves. 'People should attend some sort of workshop to understand costs, contracts and timelines,' says Limón, of Casita Coalition. 'Vet builders carefully, make sure they have experience in your local jurisdiction; avoid all-in pricing before site evaluation; request to see local completed projects [as Vanessa Gibbons did]; read contracts thoroughly and look for clear scope milestones and refund policies; avoid large up-front payments.'
Vanessa Gibbons, who is interested in building an ADU, says Meka Modular wasn't able to provide any images of real projects, just renderings like this one.
As more cities and states look to leverage the success of ADUs to meet their housing challenges, it may also behoove those in the market to understand the industry's larger context and growth potential. After initially passing a landmark law to ease ADU zoning restrictions in 2017, California has enacted many more bills, including AB 1033, which provides jurisdictions the opportunity to opt in and allow homeowners to sell ADUs as condos. So far, the cities of San Jose, with one of the country's most expensive housing markets, and Santa Cruz have completed the opt-in process—and more are in progress. Due to their smaller square footage and lot sizes, ADU condos typically sell for less than single detached homes in the same neighborhoods. Communities that opt in will help fill an urgent need for attainable starter homes in the state.
'ADU adoption has been considered one of the most important housing reforms ever, certainly in California,' says Limón. 'When you think about the fact that we have the second lowest homeownership rate in the entire country and the most underproduced kind of unit is that starter home, this will become the only starter home supply in the state.' Tapping Potential
San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan recently penned an op-ed in the San Francisco Standard that proposed state housing officials negotiate the mass purchase of factory-made dwellings; the units would be used to create a kind of lease back program to enable lower-income homebuyers to make mortgage payments as they get ADU rental income. Mahan suggests the state could establish a 'buyer's club' as part of a 'program to negotiate the bulk purchase of up to one million factory-made backyard cottages,' and issue lease-revenue bonds to enable the purchase of 'deeply discounted ADUs.' As the piece explains, 'the state would pay the upfront cost of purchasing and installing the ADU in willing homeowners' backyards, then the homeowners would buy the unit via a small monthly payment, presumably using revenue they earn from renting it.'
Such an enterprise could demonstrate how to begin matching the housing shortage with a large-scale response designed to bring down ADU costs. It may also serve as impetus for scaling up installation partners on the ground, easing the way for more efficient ADU housing development in the future.
The enormous unrealized potential of ADUs is clearly not contained to California. At least seven states across the nation now have effective statewide ADU laws on the books, and a dozen more have developed promising laws for upping production. 'The momentum is growing, which is obviously exciting,' says Limón. 'That may also be tempting new builders to get into the game and serve everyone immediately.'
But just as permitting processes can take time, so does building an entire new industry—and, as many of these examples illustrate, there will be growing pains. For one, Vanessa Gibbons, the reader who prompted this article, is willing to face that reality. (The company she first contacted Dwell about, Meka Modular, replied for requests for comment but has not left one.) She and her dad are still exploring ADU options for their place in Joshua Tree, and have narrowed their search parameters to manufactured homes. 'For our budget of under $200K all in, including permits and getting utilities installed, it's the only available option we can find,' she says.
Illustration by Scott Wilson
Related Reading:
READ SOURCE

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Whole Foods food distributor hit by cyberattack - and it might leave grocery shelves empty
Whole Foods food distributor hit by cyberattack - and it might leave grocery shelves empty

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Whole Foods food distributor hit by cyberattack - and it might leave grocery shelves empty

United Natural Foods Inc., the primary food distributor for Whole Foods, was hit with a cyberattack that may leave some grocery store shelves empty. The food company said Monday it became aware of 'unauthorized activity' on some of its IT systems, prompting the supplier to take some services offline. With the systems down – and no immediate time for them to be back up and running – stock on Whole Foods' shelves may soon be sparse. The computer system was used to connect customers - such as Whole Foods - to the supplier and get deliveries of goods. A Whole Foods spokesperson told The Independent that they are 'working to restock our shelves as quickly as possible and apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused for customers.' In an SEC filing, the food company said it noticed the unusual activity last week and immediately implemented containment measures. The company said it notified law enforcement and is currently investigating the incident. 'We are assessing the unauthorized activity and working to restore our systems to safely bring them back online,' the company said in a statement. 'As we work through this issue, our customers, suppliers, and associates are our highest priority. We are working closely with them to minimize disruption as much as possible.' Last year, the food company and Whole Foods signed an eight-year extension of their deal to be the supermarket's primary distributor, according to Axios. Issues with deliveries from the supplier were detailed in a Reddit post. 'We got our Saturday truck at 2 a.m. Sunday morning, with no way to scan it in to the store receiving tool and none of the typical UNFI paperwork. They are saying no cycle counts or orders until further notice. This seems bad, to say the least,' the poster wrote. Someone claiming to be a food company employee commented that they 'literally cannot do anything network related.' 'At a complete standstill. This is catastrophic to the business. This is a company-wide issue that affects business at all levels. This is really some crazy s***,' the employee wrote. Another person claiming to work for United Natural Foods Inc. said work has been canceled the last two days. 'Apparently our whole system is down right now. We haven't been told everything, just that we can't come into work,' they wrote.

Toyota, Subaru Hit with Class-Action Lawsuit Over Claims of 12-Volt Batteries in EVs That Keep Dying
Toyota, Subaru Hit with Class-Action Lawsuit Over Claims of 12-Volt Batteries in EVs That Keep Dying

Yahoo

time4 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Toyota, Subaru Hit with Class-Action Lawsuit Over Claims of 12-Volt Batteries in EVs That Keep Dying

A new lawsuit filed against Subaru and Toyota claims that the two automakers' jointly developed electric vehicles, the Solterra and bZ4X, suffers from an issue that causes the 12-volt battery used for accessories to repeatedly fail, with the plaintiff filing the suit claiming his vehicle has gone through multiple batteries in 5000 miles. The class-action lawsuit, which was filed in the U.S. Eastern District Court of California, claims that Subaru and Toyota both knew about 12-volt battery problems before the the Bz4X or Solterra went on sale. Allegedly, these cars (from the 2023–2025 model years) drain and kill the 12-volt battery on a regular basis; despite that, the suit claims the two carmakers failed to warn customers or to fix the issues at hand. The filing mainly focuses on this single owner's account. "The 12-volt battery equipped in Plaintiff Wade's Class Vehicle has failed three times after only about 5000 miles of driving the vehicle. The 12-volt battery in Plaintiff Wade's vehicle has been replaced twice since March 2023,"says the filing, according to The owner claims that the first failure happened within weeks of ownership; then the battery died again when it had around 2000 miles on it, and yet again around the 5000-mile mark. Based on other accounts posted online, however, he's not alone when it comes to 12-volt battery issues. As one person with a 2024 example of the Solterra told the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration: "I have had the car since December of 2024, the car was a new lease. The battery has failed twice — once in January, and again last week. When I took it to the dealership, they said they replaced the battery, the new battery is now doing the same thing." On Reddit, customers have been complaining about similar situations since early 2023. "At 6 months had the 12 volt battery replaced, now after 3 weeks getting low battery again," said one commenter. Another made a post in January alleging that since picking up the car in April of 2024, they've had a dead 12-volt battery three different times. Interestingly, it doesn't appear as though the lawsuit in question defines what the central issue is between the 12-volt battery and the rest of the system. In other words, it doesn't define what the core defect, is aside from the 12-volt battery dying prematurely. Whether or not that factors into the suit's outcome is yet to be seen. The electric Toyobaru siblings are hardly the only EVs to suffer from issues and allegations of problems with their 12-volt batteries in recent years. Back in 2021, Ford issued a service bulletin regarding a software problem that caused the Mustang Mach-E's 12-volt to drain while the car's propulsion battery was being charged, while earlier this year, an owner took to Reddit to claim that his 2021 Mach-E's 12-volt lost power and trapped his child in the vehicle. Meanwhile, back in 2023, Hyundai found owners of the Ioniq 5 complaining about unexpected 12-volt battery death, eventually pinning the problem down as one related to third-party applications pinging the car too frequently via Bluetooth. You Might Also Like You Need a Torque Wrench in Your Toolbox Tested: Best Car Interior Cleaners The Man Who Signs Every Car Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Whole Foods' shelves could get bare as supplier shuts down deliveries after cyberattack
Whole Foods' shelves could get bare as supplier shuts down deliveries after cyberattack

New York Post

time5 hours ago

  • New York Post

Whole Foods' shelves could get bare as supplier shuts down deliveries after cyberattack

A major supplier to Whole Foods said it has shut down deliveries after it was hacked – leading to fears of empty store shelves. United Natural Foods, a $31 billion distributor of natural and organic products, said in a regulatory filing on Monday that it 'identified unauthorized activity in our systems' and has notified law enforcement while it conducts an investigation. The Rhode Island-based company, also known as UNFI, discovered the issue last week and took 'some systems offline while we investigate,' according to the filing. Advertisement 3 United Natural Foods is a major distributor of natural and organic grocery items. UNFI 'We are assessing the unauthorized activity and working to restore our systems to safely bring them back online.' The company reached out to its retail customers on Saturday and Sunday informing them that there will be no deliveries on Monday, adding that it did not know when the disruption would end, sources told The Post. Advertisement 'It's bringing the company to a standstill with no orders generated and no orders coming in,' said Steve Schwartz, director of sales for the Morton Williams grocery store chain in New York City. Among the items that Morton Williams' 20 stores receive from UNFI are frozen and dairy items, including Stoneyfield yogurts as well as Sanpellegrino and La Croix sparkling waters. 3 Whole Foods has not commented on how the UNFI outage will impact its stores. Christopher Sadowski The chain has already contacted other distributors to supply these and other items if the disruption is prolonged, Schwartz said. Advertisement But others were more immediately impacted. 'I work at a Diamond store in a scratch bakery and they aren't even sending us flour, cake blanks or brown butter cookies,' wrote one Reddit user on Sunday. 'We're trying to figure out if we need to call all our customers who have special orders in this week, because of course its graduation week too.' Another bakery business posted 'we're out of components to make the cakes and tarts so we'll have an empty case til we get our delivery. We sold out of a lot last night so today will be $0 cake sales 🙃Can't do much production. Basically will bake off what we have for the floor until something else comes in.' 3 UNFI is one of Whole Foods primary distributors. Christopher Sadowski Advertisement A person who identified as a UNFI employee posted, 'Our systems went down nationwide around 3:30 pm last Friday. At my location they have been calling us in every day since to come pick y'all's groceries in hopes that our systems come back on. So far that has not been the case. That's all we know, corporate isn't telling us s–t.' Whole Foods did not immediately comment. UNFI is scheduled to announce its third quarter results on June 10. Its shares are down 8.5% on Monday to about $25. 'It's a mystery as of yet what is going to happen and how long it's going to be until things are back to normal,' wrote another Reddit user who identified as a UNFI employee. 'Was told by the branch VP that even when they can start to get back on track it will have to be done in phases. So it's gonna be a while for things to be back on track fully.' Victoria's Secret delayed its earnings release last week after a cyber attack resulted in its website going dark for several days last month.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store