logo
Trump's Fed attacks puncture veneer of central bank independence: McGeever

Trump's Fed attacks puncture veneer of central bank independence: McGeever

Zawyaa day ago
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist for Reuters.)
ORLANDO, Florida - If U.S. President Donald Trump's public attacks on Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell have achieved one thing, it has been to thrust the issue of central bank independence firmly into the spotlight. But this raises the question, what does 'independence' really mean?
Central bank independence is widely considered a bedrock of modern-day financial markets. Economists, investors and policymakers almost universally agree that monetary policy should be set for the long-term good and stability of the economy, free from short-term and capricious political influence.
But maintaining that theoretical separation between policymakers and politicians is very challenging in practice.
Ultimately, central banks are creations of – and, to varying degrees, extensions of – their national governments. The legislatures determine their statutes, parameters, goals, and key policymaking personnel.
One need only look at the intertwined and often coordinated responses of countries' central banks and governments to the global financial crisis and pandemic for evidence that complete independence doesn't actually exist.
DE FACTO OR DE JURE
'Independence' has two primary meanings in studies of monetary policy.
Academic studies often refer to 'de jure' independence, essentially legal or institutional independence, and 'de facto' or operational independence. Importantly, de jure independence is no guarantee of de facto independence or vice versa.
Perhaps surprisingly, the U.S. scores pretty low on a de jure basis, mainly because the Fed's statutes have barely changed since it was created over a century ago in 1913.
Davide Romelli, associate professor at Trinity College Dublin, has updated a central bank independence index created by Alex Cukierman, Steven Webb, and Bilin Neyapti in the 1990s. The index, in which 0 is no independence and 1 is total independence, shows the US scoring 0.61. That suggests the Fed is a less institutionally independent body than the European Central Bank, which scored 0.90, and even the People's Bank of China, which scored 0.66.
But on a de facto basis, the Fed would almost certainly rank as higher than the PBOC, given its design, transparency, and accountability mechanisms such as the chair's regular press conferences and appearances before Congress.
And look at how the Fed resisted the clamor to raise interest rates when inflation first exploded after the pandemic as well as its patience in lowering them now given the uncertainty surrounding the U.S. trade agenda. You can argue the wisdom or folly of the Fed's actions in either case, but both episodes put its operational independence on full display.
'BANANA REPUBLIC'
When experts talk about threats to central bank independence, they are usually referring to concerns about de facto independence.
Indeed, this is why Fed-watchers have grown increasingly troubled by Trump's excoriating verbal attacks on Powell over the last six months for not cutting interest rates. If there is a line demarcating political interference, however amorphous, Trump has crossed it.
"The words that Trump uttered are the ones one expects from the head of a banana republic that is about to start printing money to fund fiscal deficits," former Fed Chair and U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen told The New Yorker earlier this month.
Of course, even if Trump were to replace Powell with a more amenable chair, this would not completely eliminate Fed independence. The Fed chair does not single-handedly set interest rates and represents only one of 12 votes at each policy meeting.
But in many ways he or she is the first among equals, as University of Maryland's Thomas Drechsel shows in a recent working paper.
Analyzing over 800 personal interactions between Fed officials and each U.S. president from Franklin D. Roosevelt to Barack Obama in 2016, Drechsel found that 92% were with the Fed chair. President Richard Nixon interacted with Fed officials 160 times, reflecting his infamous efforts to influence then chair Arthur Burns, while only six interactions took place during Bill Clinton's two terms.
To be sure, not all meetings or telephone calls involve political pressure, and for purely logistical reasons, it makes sense that the president would prioritize speaking with the head of the monetary policy body as opposed to all its members.
As such, appointing the governor is a key area where a central bank's independence can be damaged. In a 2022 academic paper titled "(In)dependent Central Banks" revised in February analyzing 317 governor appointments in 57 countries between January 1985 and January 2020, the authors noted that as central banks' powers – and perceived independence – have expanded, political incentives to control them have intensified, "especially in an era of growing global populism."
Thus, in many cases, the more power a central bank has to ignore political pressure, the more motivated government leaders are to apply it. If that is a global trend, Trump appears to be at the vanguard.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist for Reuters.)
(By Jamie McGeever. Editing by Mark Potter)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Moment Trump aide is confronted with photos of Gaza's starving children
Moment Trump aide is confronted with photos of Gaza's starving children

The National

time2 hours ago

  • The National

Moment Trump aide is confronted with photos of Gaza's starving children

An aide to Donald Trump was confronted with photos of starving children in Gaza during a meeting with Tunisia's President Kais Saied. Mr Saied told US envoy Massad Boulos, who is also the father-in-law of the US President's daughter Tiffany Trump, that 'it is time for humanity to wake up and put an end to these crimes against the Palestinian people'. 'I believe you know these images well,' Mr Saied was seen telling the envoy in footage released by the Tunisian presidency. He described one of the photos as showing 'a child crying, eating sand in occupied Palestine'. Mr Boulos stood silently, occasionally nodding, as Mr Saied called events in Gaza 'a crime against all of humanity' and 'absolutely unacceptable'. Lebanese-born Mr Boulos is a senior adviser to Mr Trump on Arab, Middle East and African affairs. His son, Michael Boulos, married Tiffany Trump in 2022. The US is Israel's main political and military backer and has vetoed UN resolutions calling for an end to the war in Gaza. However, Mr Trump has shown signs of thinning patience with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as the toll of the 21-month war mounts. Some of Israel's usual allies, including Britain and France, issued stark criticism this week of what they called the 'drip feeding of aid', as starvation takes hold in Gaza. The head of its largest hospital said on Tuesday that 21 children had died from malnutrition and starvation in the previous three days. More than 100 aid organisations warned on Wednesday that 'mass starvation' was spreading across Gaza and that their own colleagues were suffering acutely from the shortages. Israel says some humanitarian supplies are being allowed into Gaza and accuses Hamas of stealing aid.

Stock markets rally after Japan-US trade deal
Stock markets rally after Japan-US trade deal

Al Etihad

time4 hours ago

  • Al Etihad

Stock markets rally after Japan-US trade deal

23 July 2025 16:31 LONDON (AFP)Stock markets rose on Wednesday after Japan and the United States hammered out a trade deal to slash Donald Trump's tariffs, including those on the crucial car were also cheered by news that Washington had reached agreements with Indonesia and the Philippines, stoking optimism that other countries will also follow suit before Trump's August 1 FTSE 100 was up 0.5 percent, after hitting another record high at the piled on one percent and Frankfurt also advanced, tracking gains in surged over three percent after the US president announced a deal lowering tariffs on some Japanese goods to 15 percent, down from the threatened 25 deal will also reduce tolls on autos -- an accounting sector for eight percent of Japanese jobs -- to 15 percent, compared, with 25 percent for other countries. In return, Japan pledged to invest $550 billion in the United States, Trump said on social in carmaker Toyota rocketed higher by more than 14 percent, Mitsubishi 13 percent and Nissan eight carmakers also rallied, with Porsche rising over seven percent, while Volkswagen and BMW were up around six percent in Paris, Stellantis topped the gainers on the CAC 40, advancing close to seven also hailed an agreement with Manila to lower levies on Philippine goods by one percentage point to 19 percent, while tariffs on Indonesia were slashed from 32 percent to 19 in Manila and Jakarta announcements boosted hopes of other deals before next Friday's deadline, though talks with the European Union and South Korea remain 10-year government bond yield soared to the highest since 2008. Elsewhere in Asia, Hong Kong hit its highest level since late 2021, while Shanghai was advances came after a broadly positive day on Wall Street where the S&P 500 hit another peak but the Nasdaq snapped a six-day streak of records. Eyes are also on the release of earnings from Google parent Alphabet and tech giants, including Tesla and Intel.

Central Bank Launches AI Venture with Presight
Central Bank Launches AI Venture with Presight

TECHx

time4 hours ago

  • TECHx

Central Bank Launches AI Venture with Presight

Home » Emerging technologies » Fintech » Central Bank Launches AI Venture with Presight The Central Bank of the United Arab Emirates (CBUAE) and Presight, AI and big data analytics company, have announced the launch of a joint venture. The initiative supports the CBUAE's Financial Infrastructure Transformation Programme (FIT). This strategic partnership marks a major milestone in the UAE's efforts to enhance resilience and integrate artificial intelligence across the financial ecosystem. The signing ceremony was witnessed by key officials, including: H.E. Khaled Mohamed Balama, Governor of the CBUAE H.E. Mansoor Ibrahim Al Mansoori, Vice Chairman of Presight H.E. Saif Humaid Al Dhaheri, Assistant Governor for Banking Operations and Support Services The agreement was signed by H.E. Ebrahim Obaid Al Zaabi, Assistant Governor for Monetary Policy and Financial Stability at CBUAE, and Mr. Thomas Pramotedham, CEO of Presight. The joint venture will deliver sovereign, AI-powered platforms and services to strengthen the UAE's financial market infrastructure. It will support critical systems such as: Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) Instant Payments Platform (Aani) Domestic Card Scheme (Jaywan) National Card Switch Real-Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) system Open Finance initiative (Nebras) H.E. Ebrahim Obaid Al Zaabi stated that the venture reinforces the UAE's commitment to building a secure, efficient, and future-ready financial system. He noted that combining the CBUAE's infrastructure strategy with Presight's technology will enhance the UAE's position as a global financial hub. Mr. Thomas Pramotedham added that the venture will apply advanced AI to key financial systems. He emphasized that this sovereign finance technology initiative is designed to accelerate innovation, resilience, and operational security.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store