From JD to BJP and out: It's Dhankhar's turn
Jagdeep Dhankhar
is only the latest case of a bunch of political travellers -- with roots in the perennially bickering erstwhile
Janata Dal
(JD) mob -- who had travelled into the
BJP
, to bag prized posts in the
Narendra Modi
establishment only to be ejected at the sight of crossing the line or error of judgement.
Ex-JD-Congressman Dhankhar, who progressed from the West Bengal Raj Bhavan to the Vice-President's office, shares the same zig-zag journey of fellow 'Jat farmer leader'
Satyapal Malik
, a former JD leader who moved to the BJP and held gubernatorial offices in Bihar, J&K, Odisha, Goa and Meghalaya during the Modi regime only to end up with a bitter and noisy parting. Many in the Opposition are now watching whether Dhankhar too will make noises or opt to play it safe.
It was often said that in the post-2014 BJP surge propelled by the Modi effect, the premium was on ideological alignment and Sangh Parivar grooming, from ABVP-Yuva Morcha upwards, to be considered for key posts in the Centre, and flourish -- with a few exceptions for technocrats with ministerial briefs. Yet, some political aberrations became notable for the way they flourished in the BJP, mostly from the JD background, and some converts from the Congress. Yet, many of them eventually got grounded mostly for apparently failing to master the temperament and instincts of 'the homegrown'.
However, a colleague of Dhankhar and Mallik in the Janata Dal platform, who too later moved to the BJP ecosystem, is
Arif Mohd Khan
, who is going steady in the Modi regime as a rare governor, who got a second posting -- that too in poll-bound Bihar -- after completing a full-term in Kerala. In between, the Modi regime also entered into an ambitious ruling coalition experiment in J&K with yet another Congressman turned Janata Dal-turned PDP leader Mufti Mohd Sayed, who was also with Khan in the VP Singh-floated Jan Morch (of Congress rebels) against Rajiv Gandhi regime, but that coalition in Srinagar unravelled due to in-built contradictions after Mehbooba Mufti became CM after her father's untimely death.
Yet another JD-pedigreed man who found short-term luck as CM of Karnataka was Basavraj Bommai, son of former JD national president SR Bommai, who led the BJP to defeat. Incidentally, a BJP leader, who had held key ministerial posts in the Vajpayee regime and who later made a lot of noise when a 'marg darshak mandal' was created for 75+ old BJP leaders post-2014, was Yashwant Sinha, who too had travelled into the BJP from Janata Dal (from its Chandra Shekhar faction). It was from the Janata Dal camp that Maneka Gandhi (along with her son Varun) joined the BJP with much fanfare as the 'other half of the Gandhi family' during the Vajpayee-Advani era and flourished long before they were denied election tickets and grounded recently.
Live Events
Among the Congress converts to the BJP post-2014, Himanta Biswa Sarma is perceived to be the most flourishing one so far, as the party's CM of Assam and a pointsman for the Northeast. Many others, including original Team Rahul members Jyotiraditya Scindia, Jatin Prasada and RPN Singh, thrive in the Modi establishment as ministers and legislators.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
7 minutes ago
- NDTV
Even Tech Giants Can Be Non-State Actors: RSS's Ram Madhav On New World Order
New Delhi: The world in 21st Century will be multipolar instead of bipolar and would come with a new set of global institutions, non-state actors and challengers, said Ram Madhav - ideologue of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the BJP's ideological mentor, in his new book - "The New World: 21st Century Global Order and India". "The world we are entering into will be very different from what we have lived in for last seven decades," Ram Madhav told NDTV in an exclusive interview, pointing out that while many are saying so, no one has yet defined it. "I proposed in this book that we must understand that the world in 21st century will not be bipolar. It will be multipolar and it will be heteropolar. Heteropolar in the sense that while countries will rise as important poles -- we have risen as an important pole. World recognizes that. So is Russia today. So is Turkey today," he said. The first very important change, he said, will be the rise of China "and at the same time, a decline in influence of the western powers especially America". "When I say decline, I am not at all saying that probably America will disappear or it will no longer be there as a power," he added. There are other nations that are rising as well, including India, and as long as they do not come into their own, there could be a cold war between these two power centres. What would eventually emerge is a multipolar world, where nations would play a key role in their immediate and extended neighbouhood, he said. In this multilateral world, global bodies too, would be multilateral, he said. Pointing out that China has recently announced a new arbitration arrangement for nations with Hong Kong as headquarters, he said, "What will happen to International Court of Justice in The Hague? Because now countries if they prefer, they simply can go to Hong Kong and China will mediate and solve your problems. New institutions are coming up". The new world order would also come with its own set of non-state actors and challengers -- including religious, media, big tech organizations that will become big enough players to affect sovereign nations, Ram Madhav said. "Beyond multipolarity is heteropolarity. In multipolarity you have multiple countries as rising as middle powers... In heteropolarity, non-state players of different natures will rise," he said, giving examples of Syria and Afghanistan where those called terrorists till recently are ruling. "You know, in India also, some of our people in my movement call George Soros a danger to India. Ford Foundation a threat to India. They are posing certain challenges. I don't deny that. But are they countries? Do they have armies to pose challenges? They are just NGOs," he said. But for some, even someone like George Soros could be a challenge, he said, recalling his visit to Hungary, where Prime Minister Viktor Orban had counted the billionaire investor as a "biggest threat" his country faces. "We are seeing in Elon Musk what he is doing, the challenge he is throwing to a person like Trump. This is the kind of world we are entering into where tech giants can be important players. They can challenge your sovereignty," he said. To survive in this new world order, India, he said, has to eschew romanticism and be pragmatic, break new grounds in education, research and development and hone talent.. "The government understands it. That's why government has introduced certain very pragmatic measures. I talked about, you know, strategic autonomy policy of the government. It's a very important policy at a time when the world is transitioning," he said. Today, between expectation from America and China also that India should join them, India under Prime Minister Narendra Modi has taken a principled stand of strategic autonomy.
The Hindu
7 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Female trainee constables protest at U.P.'s Gorakhpur centre over basic amenities, abusive language, cameras
Fresh batch of women constable recruits at Gorakhpur's 26 Battalion Provincial Armed Constabulary (PAC) campus of U.P. Police on Wednesday (July 23, 2025) protested and raised slogans alleging lack of basic facilities like drinking water, electricity, abusive language of trainers and even claimed that they were being forced to bathe in the open and cameras in bathroom corridors. In the viral videos, which were shared widely the new recruits could be heard saying, 'If they (authorities) could not make arrangements, why were we called here, there was shortage of everything from electricity to drinking water, our privacy was compromised, there were of lack of private bathing areas,". Another recruit added, "one Reverse Osmosis (RO) set was given for around 600 students, for 30 girls four fans were functional, even the fans were not in proper working condition,". Some protesting recruits question the high number of appointed women called at once for training while a few claimed presences of CCTV cameras in bathroom corridors, terming it as a breach of privacy. While administrative officers dispersed the protestors who were blocking the road and directed them back inside the centre, the recruits protested outside the administrative building, demanding addressing of their basic demands. Amid the protest senior officials including senior PAC officer Akhil Kumar and district police officials rushed to the spot and initiated an inquiry. "Officials took serious note of the issues raised by the women recruits of 26 Battalion PAC, Gorakhpur and a detailed inquiry was initiated. It was found that due to a 'technical fault' electricity shortage happened which led to a temporary water scarcity, the issue has been promptly resolved. Following the preliminary enquiry, Physical Training Instructor (PTI), who used abusive language with women recruits was suspended. The claim of camera in bathroom is completely wrong, the U.P. police give highest priority to women security and respect," reads an official statement issued by Additional Director General (ADG) PAC, Uttar Pradesh. Opposition parties hit out at the State government over the mismanagement accusation adding for the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) women worship is only a slogan. "Unfortunate news is coming from Gorakhpur about the mismanagement of the training centre for women police recruits. There is no electricity, no water, no dignified bathroom. When this is the condition of the main city then what can one say about the rest. Women worship is a slogan of the BJP," wrote the Samajwadi Party (SP) president Akhilesh Yadav, on X. The 26th Battalion PAC centre, which serves as a police training school, recently seen induction of 598 women constable recruits from various districts of Uttar Pradesh as part of the 2023 batch.
The Hindu
7 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Modi begins U.K. visit, trade deal to be inked today
Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrived in the U.K. on Wednesday- (July 23, 2025) evening, kicking off the first leg of his two-nation tour, as India and the U.K. prepare to sign a 'free trade' agreement (FTA) on Thursday (July 24, 2025). During the visit, Mr. Modi and U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer are expected to review ties, with the sides discussing technology, investment, climate, defence, trade, and migration. The Prime Minister is also scheduled to meet Britain's monarch, King Charles III. The Prime Minister's visit is fleeting — less than 24 hours long — with Mr. Modi set to fly to the Maldives on Thursday evening to celebrate the country's 60th anniversary of Independence from Britain and the 60th anniversary of diplomatic ties between New Delhi and Male. 'During my meeting with Prime Minister Rt Hon Sir Keir Starmer, we will have the opportunity to further enhance our economic partnership, aimed at fostering prosperity, growth and jobs creation in both countries. I also look forward to calling on His Majesty King Charles III during the visit,' Mr. Modi said in a pre-departure statement. The so-called 'Comprehensive Strategic Partnership' with the U.K. had made 'significant progress' in recent years, Mr. Modi said. The meeting comes exactly a year since the two countries signed a technology cooperation framework — the Technology and Security Initiative (TSI). A new bilateral investment treaty is also currently under discussion and a defence industrial cooperation framework was announced earlier this year. Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal, who is accompanying Mr. Modi on the trip, and his British counterpart, Business and Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, will sign the trade agreement on behalf of the two governments. However, the impact of the trade deal with India is expected to be about 0.1% of GDP (or £4.8 billion annually) in the long run, for Britain, as per U.K. government estimates. Britain's economy is struggling and that a trade deal was signed is itself significant for Mr. Starmer. The British Prime Minister faces strong political headwinds from the right over immigration, and from his own Labour party, over attempts to cut spending on welfare. One area Mr. Starmer has been polling ahead of Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch and Reform UK leader Nigel Farage is on the issue of who is most prime ministerial, Anand Menon, a political scientist at King's College, London, told The Hindu. '… Burnishing that brand — one way to do that is to be seen with other world leaders,' he said. The world is unstable and uncertain for both India and the U.K. and forging closer ties with allies is a way of hedging, according to Mr. Menon. 'For neither side does it mean there's some deep ideological or any other affinity,' he said. Following his meetings with the Prime Minister and the king, Mr. Modi will fly to Male. 'I look forward to my meetings with President [Mohamed] Muizzu and other political leadership, to advance our joint vision of a Comprehensive Economic and Maritime Security Partnership, and to strengthen our cooperation for peace, prosperity and stability in the Indian Ocean Region,' Mr. Modi said about the Maldives leg of his trip. 'I am confident that the visit will yield tangible outcomes, benefiting our people and advancing our Neighbourhood First Policy,' he added.
