Justin Baldoni's $400 million lawsuit against Blake Lively has been dismissed
Baldoni accused Lively of defaming him and seizing creative control of "This Ends With Us."
Baldoni can still allege Ryan Reynolds tried to get his agent to drop him.
It ends with a judge's 132-page opinion.
US District Judge Lewis Liman on Monday tossed the $400 million countersuit Justin Baldoni brought against Blake Lively and her husband, Ryan Reynolds.
Baldoni's lawsuit, filed in federal court in New York, accused Lively, who was his "This Ends with Us" costar, of taking over his movie and trying to destroy his reputation.
The lawsuit, which included his production company Wayfarer Studios and several publicists he worked with as plaintiffs, also alleged that Lively falsely accused him of sexual harassment to gain control over the film's creative direction and promotion.
The case was combined with a separate lawsuit against The New York Times and Leslie Sloane, Lively's public relations representative. Baldoni accused Sloane of planting false stories in publications about him, and The New York Times of acting as a "conduit" for Lively's allegations that he sexually harassed her on set.
Lively has alleged in a separate lawsuit and in a California Civil Rights Department complaint that Baldoni and his public relations representatives tried to smear her in the press.
US District Judge Lewis Liman's Monday decision weighed whether Baldoni's allegations — and the evidence his lawyers collected in court filings — sufficiently proved that the defendants defamed him, and that Lively extorted him by threatening to withhold publicity for "This Ends With Us" unless the movie was made under her own creative vision.
Over 132 pages, Liman wrote that Baldoni and his studio couldn't sufficiently prove their claims to bring the case to trial.
"The Wayfarer Parties cannot recover for Lively's alleged actions to steal creative control of the film from Baldoni and the Wayfarer Parties," he wrote. "Regardless of the propriety of these actions, they do not constitute civil extortion under California law."
Lively's allegations against Baldoni — accusing him of sexual harassment, and of his production company violating her employment contract for "This Ends With Us" — still remain alive. Liman is weighing whether to dismiss Lively's lawsuit against Baldoni or let it proceed to trial.
Monday's opinion did, however, leave a door open for Baldoni to renew allegations that Lively and Reynolds illegally tried to get WME — the talent agency that represents all three actors — to cut ties with him.
According to Baldoni's attorneys, Reynolds approached a WME executive during the premiere of "Deadpool and Wolverine" and told him that Baldoni was a "sexual predator." The agency dropped Baldoni as a client shortly after Lively's complaint against him.
A spokesperson for Baldoni didn't immediately return a request for comment from Business Insider.
Read the original article on Business Insider
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Joe Caroff, Designer of the James Bond 007 Logo, Dies at 103
Joe Caroff, the unheralded graphic designer whose iconic creations included James Bond's 007 gun logo, posters for West Side Story and A Hard Day's Night and typography for Last Tango in Paris, Manhattan and Rollerball, died Sunday. He was 103. Caroff died one day short of birthday No. 104 in hospice care at his home in Manhattan, his sons, Peter and Michael Caroff, told The New York Times. More from The Hollywood Reporter Terence Stamp, Brooding Legend of British Cinema, Dies at 87 Dan Tana, Former Owner of Namesake Hollywood Restaurant, Dies at 90 Michael Sloan, 'The Equalizer' Co-Creator, Dies at 78 Caroff also cooked up the opening title sequences for such films as Richard Attenborough's A Bridge Too Far (1977), Volker Schlöndorff's Death of a Salesman (1985), Gene Saks' Brighton Beach Memoirs (1986) and Martin Scorsese's The Last Temptation of Christ (1988), which pulled back to reveal a crown of thorns. His portfolio of posters included those for a dozen or so Woody Allen films plus Oh Dad, Poor Dad, Mamma's Hung You in the Closet and I'm Feelin' So Sad (1963), A Fistful of Dollars (1964), For a Few Dollars More (1965), Too Late the Hero (1970), Tell Me That You Love Me, Junie Moon (1970), Cabaret (1972), An Unmarried Woman (1978) and Gandhi (1982). Plus, Caroff designed the logo and title signature for Orion Pictures, several album covers for Decca Records and the logos for ABC's Olympic coverage (with the network's circular letters and five Olympic rings intertwined), ABC News and 20/20 (styled to resemble a pair of eyeglasses). The one quality he wanted his work to have was 'effervescence,' he said in the 2022 TCM documentary By Design: The Joe Caroff Story. 'I want it to have a life, it doesn't want to lie there flat.' For his first movie job — he would work on more than 300 campaigns during his career — United Artists executive David Chasman hired him to design the poster for West Side Story (1961), then asked him to come up with the letterhead for a publicity release tied to the first Bond film, Dr. No. (Chasman had designed the poster for the 1962 movie.) 'He said, 'I need a little decorative thing on top,'' Caroff recalled in 2021. 'I knew [Bond's] designation was 007, and when I wrote the stem of the seven, I thought, 'That looks like the handle of a gun to me.' It was very spontaneous, no effort, it was an instant piece of creativity.' Inspired by Ian Fleming's favorite gun, a Walther PPK, Caroff attached a barrel and trigger to the 007 and for his work received $300, the going rate for such an assignment, he said. Even though the logo, though altered in subtle ways, has been featured on every Bond film and on millions of pieces of merchandise, he received no credit, no residuals, no royalties. The logo did, however, bring him 'a lot of business,' he said. 'It was like a little publicity piece for me.' Joseph Caroff was born on Aug. 18, 1921, in Linden, New Jersey. He had four older sisters and a younger brother. His father, Julius, was a painter who 'could make a plaster wall look like a wood wall … it wasn't as if he just painted it, he rendered it,' he said. While attending Brooklyn's Pratt Institute, he assisted French graphic designer Jean Carlu on the making of the 1942 propaganda poster 'America's Answer! Production' for the U.S. Office of War Information. It featured a large, gloved hand on a wrench. (Carlu, whose right arm had been severed in a Paris trolley accident, had designed the poster for the 1921 Charlie Chaplin film The Kid). 'At Carlu there were no set times,' he told Thilo von Debschitz in a 2021 interview for Eye magazine. 'Sometimes he asked me to come at eight in the morning, sometimes not before 10 in the evening. I was able to take part in large design projects and learn a lot of different techniques from him.' Caroff graduated in 1942 after majoring in advertising design, being elected class president for three straight years and serving as art editor on the school yearbook, Prattonia. Five days after getting married, Caroff in 1943 headed overseas to serve in the U.S. Army, and he would load propaganda leaflets that he had worked on with Carlu months earlier into planes that would drop them all over Europe. Back home after 36 months away, Caroff landed a job at Alan Berni & Associates, then opened his own business designing book jackets. The first one he got paid for was for the cover of Norman Mailer's debut novel, The Naked and the Dead, first published in 1948. 'I loved doing that work,' he said in the TCM documentary, 'primarily because it was an opportunity to read a book, to interpret it and then come up with a cover design that I felt best expressed what was in that book.' Caroff got the idea for the West Side Story poster — it famously features textured letters that resemble bricks and the ballet-like outlines of lovers Maria and Tony on fire escapes — after seeing clips of the film. (He said it helped that he was a West Sider in real life.) One of his fun touches on the poster for The Beatles' A Hard Day's Night was putting a knot in a guitar handle. 'It frankly was just a whim,' he said. 'It doesn't do anything except to create a quirky note, nothing more.' After 18 years going it alone, he founded the agency J. Caroff Associates in 1965, and he and his 22-person staff, working out of offices on East 57th Street in Manhattan, often handled 10 film projects at a time. As von Debschitz related in an interview for Print, 'His poster for Tattoo — a [1981] erotic thriller produced by [frequent client] Joseph E. Levine — caused a scandal because it depicted a naked woman with bound feet. Feminists (and probably pubescent men) tore the posters down in the subway, which led to even more publicity. Levine told Caroff, 'You made out with your fucking poster better than I made out with my fucking movie.'' He invented an undulating typeface for Last Tango in Paris (1972) and came up with treatments that used roller skates and high rises to spell out Rollerball and Manhattan for those 1975 and '79 movies, respectively. He also fashioned a train out of the title for the poster for The Great Train Robbery (1978). He retired in 2006 at age 86 to concentrate on painting. In addition to his sons, survivors include his daughters-in-law, Ruth and Cynthia, and his granddaughter, Jennifer. His wife of 81 years, Phyllis, a longtime professor at the Hunter College School of Social Work whom he met at a New Year's Eve party, died in February, four days shy of 101. After decades of being ignored by Bond producers, Caroff received an Omega watch with an 007 engraving from Barbara Broccoli, Michael G. Wilson and EON Productions as a 100th birthday gift. Caroff was asked if he had saved any of his original renderings over the years. Think how much those would be worth! Alas, he had tossed pretty much everything. 'Probably not a smart thing to do, but I never attached what I was doing to any greatness,' he said. 'I was just working, period. I was just being an artist.' Best of The Hollywood Reporter The 25 Best U.S. Film Schools in 2025 The 40 Greatest Needle Drops in Film History The 40 Best Films About the Immigrant Experience Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Terence Stamp, Brooding Legend of British Cinema, Dies at 87
Terence Stamp, the strikingly handsome British actor who embodied the swinging sixties and whose versatility shone in Billy Budd, Superman and The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert, died Sunday, his family told The New York Times. He was 87. They did not specify where he died or the cause, the newspaper said. More from The Hollywood Reporter Netflix Unveils First Look at Louis Partridge, James Norton, Emily Fairn and Anthony Boyle in 'House of Guinness,' Sets September Launch Date Edgar Wright, Guy Pearce, Gale Anne Hurd, Stephen Elliott Pay Tribute to "Truly Iconic" Terence Stamp: "The Most Mesmerizing Eyes" Thelma Schoonmaker on Martin Scorsese's "Remarkable" Bond With Michael Powell and Using AI to Help Publish Her Late Husband's Diaries Stamp won the best actor award at the Cannes Film Festival for his terrifying performance as a psycho who holds a young woman (Samantha Eggar) hostage in William Wyler's The Collector (1965), then experienced a resurgence when he played the Kryptonian megalomaniac General Zod in Superman (1978) and Superman II (1980). Stamp had supporting roles in Legal Eagles (1986) and Wall Street (1988), then received critical praise for portraying a veteran English crook in the Steven Soderbergh crime drama The Limey (1999). Also that year, he gained Star Wars immortality by playing Chancellor Valorum in The Phantom Menace. In his youth, the blue-eyed Stamp was widely considered one of the most handsome men onscreen, and Italian director Pier Paolo Pasolini used that to peculiar effect in Teorema (1968), casting the actor as a nameless and wordless visitor who seduces an entire household. Pasolini made sure to include several close-up shots of Stamp's crotch in the film. As the cavalry sergeant in Far From the Madding Crowd (1967), he received equal top billing with Julie Christie despite the fact that Peter Finch and Alan Bates also played characters who romanced her flirtatious Bathsheba. 'That was my mum's favorite movie of mine,' he once said. 'She always thought I looked better [in it] than I looked in anything else.' The feature includes a memorable whirling montage of Stamp, who was naturally left-handed, showing off his swordsmanship to woo Christie on a hillside. Director John Schlesinger insisted that all cavalry men before 1860 were right-handed, and so Stamp obliged. Offscreen, he romanced Christie, and he claimed both were name-dropped in The Kinks' 1967 hit song 'Waterloo Sunset' — 'Terry meets Julie, Waterloo Station, every Friday night' — though the band's frontman, Ray Davies, denied that in his autobiography. Stamp also dated English supermodel Jean Shrimpton, and when that relationship ended, he began a round-the-world trip to make sense of it all, stopping first in Egypt and winding up in Bombay. It was there that he received a telegram addressed to 'Clarence Stamp,' inviting him to meet Superman director Richard Donner for a chance to star opposite Marlon Brando. 'Two actors of my generations were Brando and [James] Dean,' he told interviewer Michael Parkinson in 1988. 'They were the two idols. Dean was no longer with us and Brando was still around, so the idea of getting up on film with him, albeit brief, was irresistible.' However, working alongside the two-time Oscar winner was disappointing, he said. Brando, playing Superman's father, Jor-El, didn't bother to learn his lines, having his dialogue written in a large font on posters placed behind the set lights. 'How are you going to play King Lear and Macbeth if you can't learn a line?' Stamp asked. 'I've learned them already,' was Brando's dismissive retort. Stamp, then 24, received a supporting actor Oscar nomination in 1963 for his screen debut as the angelic and optimistic HMS Avenger crewman Billy Budd. His captain was played by Peter Ustinov, who directed, co-wrote and produced the film. Stamp's confidence in the screen test was shattered when he spied Ustinov looking out over the rooftops as he waited for him. 'He was so powerful that everything that I said seemed very thin. And I just stopped speaking,' he said. Ustinov hired him, though, as Stamp had unwittingly replicated Billy Budd's gormless behavior. 'This is Terence Stamp' the film's trailer screams, 'the young actor hailed by famed columnist Louella Parsons as the screen's outstanding new star discovery.' He received the most promising newcomer (male) award at the Golden Globes, and the film was voted one of the year's 10 best by the National Board of Review. In a career spanning six decades, perhaps his most challenging performance came after he was offered the role of Bernadette, a transgender woman who embarks on an Australian road trip with two drag queens, in The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert (1994). 'I thought it was a joke, but a woman friend of mine just happened to be present when I was getting calls from my agent about the script, and she pointed out to me in a very incisive way that my fear was out of all proportion to the possible consequences,' he told the British Film Institute. 'But it wasn't a fun thing, or anything I was looking forward to. It was, 'Fuck me, this is the last thing in the world I want to do: be in fucking Australia with paparazzi.' It was like a nightmare. But it was only when I got there, and got through the fear, that it became one of the great experiences of my whole career. It was probably the most fun thing I've ever done.' The film grossed more than $16 million at the Australian box office, screened at Cannes and won the Oscar for best costume design. 'At the beginning of the film, we're distracted by the unexpected sight of Terence Stamp in drag,' Roger Ebert wrote, 'but Stamp is able to bring a convincing humanity to the character.' Stamp was born on July 22, 1938, in Stepney, London, the oldest of five children. His father was a tugboat captain who was often away for long stretches. He won a scholarship to the Webber Douglas Academy of Dramatic Art and later shared a house in London with Michael Caine as the two began their movie careers. When Stamp turned down the film lead in Alfie despite playing the role on Broadway in 1964, Caine snapped it up. (The British acting legends acted on stage in The Long and the Short and the Tall yet never appeared together in a movie.) Stamp's spark for acting began, he said, when he saw Beau Geste (1939) in a movie theater. 'The empathy I felt from Gary Cooper was life-changing, and a secret dream was born in the darkened auditorium,' he wrote in his 2017 memoir, The Ocean Fell Into the Drop. His earlier memoirs were 1987's Stamp Album, 1988's Coming Attractions, 1989's Double Feature and 2011's Rare Stamps: Reflections on Living, Breathing and Acting. He wrote the 1993 fiction novel The Night and in 2001 co-authored with Elizabeth Buxton a healthy eating manual for those who are wheat and lactose-intolerant called The Stamp Collection Cookbook. His other films included the spy comedy Modesty Blaise (1966); Ken Loach's 1967 debut, Poor Cow; Frank Oz's Bowfinger (1999); and Bryan Singer's Valkyrie (2008). More recently, he appeared in Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children (2016), Viking Destiny (2018), Murder Mystery (2019) and Edgar Wright's Last Night in Soho (2021). For television, Stamp hosted the first season of the horror anthology series The Hunger, re-entered the Superman world by voicing Jor-El on Smallville and tried to solve the crime at the center of the 2017 Agatha Christie adaptation Crooked House. On New Year's Eve in 2002, Stamp, then 64, married 29-year-old pharmacologist Elizabeth O'Rourke, whom he had met in Bondi, Australia. They divorced in 2008. His late brother, Chris Stamp, was a co-manager and producer for The Who in the band's earlier days. In the DVD extras of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert, Stamp — in character as Bernadette — is asked, 'Why is Terence Stamp so attractive?' 'Well, he possesses the three things that any woman would want,' he says. 'He's funny, he's romantic, and he has wisdom.' Best of The Hollywood Reporter The 25 Best U.S. Film Schools in 2025 The 40 Greatest Needle Drops in Film History The 40 Best Films About the Immigrant Experience Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
‘It Ends With Us' Actress Isabela Ferrer Claims Justin Baldoni Is Harassing Her Over Subpoena in Blake Lively Legal Battle
Isabela Ferrer got a big break when she was cast as Young Lily in 'It Ends With Us,' playing the younger version of Blake Lively's character. But a year after her film debut, Ferrer finds herself trapped in a bitter legal feud between Lively and the film's director, Justin Baldoni, both of whom have subpoenaed her. More from Variety Blake Lively's Lawyers Seek Sanctions Against Justin Baldoni's Attorney Over Pre-Trial 'Press Tour' Blake Lively Subpoenas Her Online Critics - Is It Fact-Finding or Intimidation? Blake Lively Suffers Blow in 'Smear Campaign' Claim as Judge Dismisses Case Against Justin Baldoni's Social Media Guru Jed Wallace On Sunday, Ferrer's lawyer alleged that Baldoni is 'harassing' her and trying to use his financial leverage over her to control how she responds to Lively's subpoena — when what she really wants is not to be dragged further into the dispute. Lively is suing Baldoni for sexual harassment and alleges that Baldoni launched a secret campaign to smear her reputation after she complained. Her lawsuit includes an allegation that Baldoni added a scene to the film in which Young Lily loses her virginity. After the scene was filmed, she alleges that Baldoni approached the young actors and said, 'I know I'm not supposed to say this, but that was hot.' In response, Baldoni's lawyers released text messages from Ferrer in which she called him a 'great director' and said he was 'wonderful to work with.' His lawyers have argued that as the feud developed with Lively during the subsequent promotion of the film, Ferrer felt compelled to shun him. Lively's lawyers subpoenaed Ferrer in February, seeking any communications between her and the other parties in the case. That required Ferrer to hire a lawyer and to seek a guarantee that Baldoni's team, as her employer, would cover her legal bills. That, in turn, led to a protracted dispute. Ferrer's lawyer, Sanford Michelman, claimed that Baldoni was seeking to condition the financial guarantee on retaining control over Ferrer's response to the subpoena, or at least control over her legal representation. According to Michelman, the producers' lawyer cited a fake case, which he believed to be an AI hallucination, in support of the argument that the producers had such leverage. Michelman also alleged that Baldoni's team had contorted the facts surrounding Ferrer's involvement in the dispute. While an agreement was being worked out, Baldoni's team asked if Michelman would accept service of a subpoena on her behalf. He refused. Baldoni's lawyers want Ferrer to produce documents and messages. According to them, a process server has tried to catch her at addresses in Brooklyn and Sag Harbor, but has been unable to track her down. Baldoni's lawyers are asking a judge to approve 'alternative service,' essentially forcing Michelman to accept service of the subpoena on Ferrer's behalf. Michelman is opposed, arguing they have failed to show that Ferrer is ducking the subpoena. Ferrer's legal team says Baldoni's motion, as well as the dispute over the Lively subpoena, exhibits a 'broader pattern of conduct by Baldoni to bully Ms. Ferrer.' 'While Ms. Ferrer will faithfully comply with her legal obligations under any subpoena, summons or court order, she obviously will not be intimidated or extorted by any party to otherwise participate in the proceedings,' Michelman wrote. As part of the new filing, Ferrer asks the court to 'deny the Motion in its entirety and impose appropriate sanctions against Baldoni.' Baldoni's team declined Variety's request for comment. The trial is scheduled for March. Best of Variety New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week What's Coming to Disney+ in August 2025 What's Coming to Netflix in August 2025
